If Li Mu replaced Lian Po as the commander in the Battle of Changping, would Zhao Guo win?

Updated on history 2024-03-02
6 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    During the Warring States Period, Qin and Zhao were both great powers, Qin became very powerful through the Shang Dynasty reform, and Zhao became very strong through Zhao Wuling King Hu Fu Cavalry and Archery, and both countries could eventually dominate the world. Both Zhao and Qin invested a lot of troops in the Battle of Changping, and supported the war with the strength of the whole country, and the king of Zhao fell into a divisive plan and replaced Lian Po with Zhao Kuo, as a result, the Zhao army was defeated, and it was only a matter of time before Qin unified the world. So if Li Mu replaced Lian Po as the commander in the Battle of Changping, would Zhao Guo win?

    Personally, I think that Zhao Guoguo won, Li Mu's military command ability and Bai Qi are not up and down, Li Mu is more assertive, he is very stable in fighting, and he will not fall into the Qin State's strategy, resulting in the army being surrounded.

    1. Li Mu's military command ability is very strong, and he will not commit strategic problems.

    Li Mu and Bai Qi are both famous generals of the Warring States, Li Mu dealt with the Xiongnu on the border of Zhao, and the Xiongnu were so strong that Li Mu did not dare to invade Zhao. If Li Mu replaces Lian Po as the commander, he will definitely not send troops easily, he pays attention to spying on the enemy's situation, judging the situation and taking the opportunity to send troops, so after Li Mu arrives in Changping, he will not rush to send troops to fight, he will definitely analyze the pros and cons of all parties and fight selectively. <>

    Second, Li Mu is quite assertive, he will not change his strategy because of the urging of the monarch, and he will not be easily deceived.

    Li Mu is quite assertive, he doesn't like to be interfered with in the war, once the king of Zhao wanted him to lead the army to resist the Xiongnu, but Li Mu did not agree, and later the king of Zhao promised him that he had the right to command, so he went to war. If he replaces Lian Po, Li Mu will not be in a hurry to fight the Qin army because of the shortage of domestic logistics and supplies, and will analyze the specific situation more specifically. After Li Mu led his troops into battle, he would not be like Zhao Kuo, who fell for the Qin army's strategy of luring the enemy, resulting in the army being surrounded.

    Third, Li Mu is steady and steady, and it will be difficult for Qin and Zhao to carry it after a long time, so the two sides are likely to negotiate peace.

    Li Mu replacing Lian Po will be more flexible than Lian Po and have more actual combat experience than Zhao Kuo, and at the same time, he can calm down and make his own decisions on how to fight. If it goes on for a long time, the Qin army's labor expedition will definitely not be able to stand it, and it will be difficult to maintain the exhaustion of Zhao's national strength, and the two sides are likely to shake hands and make peace in the end, and find a way to negotiate peace. If Zhao Guo can hold Changping, it will be considered a victory.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Yes, Li Mu is also a general who is good at defense, and he will still adopt a stubborn policy of Lian Po, and the Qin State will not be victorious.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Zhao Guo will not win, at most he can reduce some losses.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    At least you won't lose, you won't win, and a draw is possible. Li Mu's art of war inherited Lian Po, and the way of using troops was close to Lian Po, but it was a pity that the upper echelons of Zhao did not like him.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Because he is a capable person, although he has never fought a war, he is a person with ideas and brains, he has made outstanding contributions to the development of society, and has helped many people to provide strategic ideas.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Because this person knows this place well and has a good ability to lead troops, he will use this person.

Related questions
14 answers2024-03-02

The Changping battle between Qin and Zhao was more likely to win in any way, and Lian Po adopted a defensive policy, which was indeed a good method when Qin was strong and Zhao was weak, but it was not a long-term solution; Since the Shang Dynasty changed the law, the Qin State rewarded cultivation and warfare, and both the quality of soldiers and grain and grass reserves far surpassed that of Zhao. In this war, both sides invested a lot of troops, and after the end of the war, the number of soldiers killed by Zhao alone reached 400,000, and the daily consumption of these 400,000 people was not a small amount. Lian Po has adhered to the defensive policy for more than a year, and Zhao can be said to have tightened his belt to live, Zhao is not as good as Qin, and its geographical location itself is not rich in food, and it is very likely that Zhao will be consumed to death first in a defensive war. >>>More

5 answers2024-03-02

The main reason is that Zhao Kuo talks about the army on paper and has no experience, in addition, the victory of Qin and the defeat of Zhao are also historical inevitability.

2 answers2024-03-02

The Battle of the Long Spoon took place in 683 BC during the Spring and Autumn Period. The two vassal states of Qi and Lu fought at Changsco (now Miaoshan Town, Laiwu, Shandong, north of Qufu), and finally ended with the defeat of Lu and Qi. >>>More