Does Jin Yong like Song Jiang on the surface, but he supports Fang La in private?

Yes, Jin Yong felt that Song Jiang was too hypocritical, and he didn't like Song Jiang's character.

Yes, because he thinks Song Jiang is too hypocritical, I have harmed 107 generals for my own selfish desires, trouble, for the well-being of the people in the world, to rebel against the imperial court.

No, Mr. Jin Yong didn't have too much to say about "Water Margin", and he didn't belittle anyone who supported anyone.

In fact, whether it is from the point of view of influence, from the territory at that time, or the reason for their uprising, Fang La must be more powerful than Song Jiang. Many people are more familiar with Song Jiang, and that is because of "Water Margin", but most of the content in this book is actually fictional, not in real history, in real history, the rebel army led by Song Jiang and the Qi army led by Fang La cannot be compared at all, because they are not on the same level at all.

In real history, Fang La's power was greater than that of Song Jiang. The Fangla Rebellion was quite prestigious in the south, and his territory was much larger than Liangshan in the Song River.

Fang La's power is great. Song Jiang is just a first-class Kou, although he has fought in many places, there is no deep-rooted base area, and the extermination of Song Jiang is just a state of troops. And Fang La occupies 52 counties in six states, with hundreds of thousands of soldiers and horses, and the imperial court exterminated Fang La with the strength of the whole country.

Fang La's generals counted millions of residents in the jurisdiction, on the other hand, Song Jiang only had Shuibo Liangshan and 108 heroes, and the two were not of the same level. Therefore, Fang La's power is greater.

In history, Fang La's power was greater than Song Jiang's, which is why so many heroes died at his hands.

2.Fang La was suppressed by Tong Guan, and there was no so-called Wu Song who captured Fang La with one arm.

3.If there is. Song Jiang and Fang La still have the strength to cut off the drama, but it is basically impossible to overthrow the Song Dynasty. Because the country's strength was still there at that time, several famous generals of the military who had been on the battlefield for a long time were still alive, and these generals had not been framed by corrupt officials at that time.

4.The fall of the Song Dynasty had a certain relationship with the Fangla Uprising, but the main reason was the internal troubles (peasant uprisings, natural disasters) and external troubles (Jin soldiers) and the surrender policy and wrong strategic policy of the six thieves of the Northern Song Dynasty that led to the demise of the Northern Song Dynasty.

5.If Song Jiang Fangla joins forces to overthrow the Song Dynasty, it may not be able to stand on its feet, because Song Jiang Fangla will also lose his troops when he conquers the country, and at that time, the Jin State has risen and is invincible, and it is a matter of time before he dominates the Central Plains.

The prototype of Song Jiang is from our county, in fact, there are only 36 people in total, and they run away after the case, known as "thirty-six when they come, eighteen pairs when they go", and finally they were exterminated by the prefect, which is recorded in the county annals. A prefect is enough to deal with him, and the change of dynasty can be described as a fantasy.

According to the combined military strength of Fang La and Song Jiang at that time and the military strength of the Song Dynasty, the former may be relatively strong; However, their organizational structure is too simple, all rely on brothers to easily maintain, and may not get the support of the masses, if they join forces against the Song Dynasty, maybe Tian Hu in Hebei and Wang Qing in Huaixi will also rebel, and they all want to get a piece of the pie, and then as long as the Song Dynasty is in chaos, the world may really change.

Song Jiang is too weak. Fang La would not join forces with him. Even if they join forces, they can't overthrow the Song Dynasty.

There is no such possibility, and this is also a banditry, or a blatant rebellion, Song Jiang will not do it.

Although Song Jiang also went to Liangshan, he became the leader of those heroes. But in Song Jiang's heart, he still hopes to return to the embrace of the Song Dynasty, after all, Song Jiang has always had a heart of glory and wealth. He didn't want to be a bandit leader all the time, Song Jiang wanted to glorify his ancestors, so as long as he had the opportunity, Song Jiang would return to the arms of the Song Dynasty.

In fact, Song Jiang wanted to surrender to the Song Dynasty when he first went to Liangshan, but at that time Song Jiang himself was not of value.

Song Jiang is also a smart person, he knows that he will be recruited by the Song Dynasty only if he has value, so Song Jiang has been accumulating his own strength to enhance his value. In the end, Liangshan led by Song Jiang became a first-class bandit nest of the Song Dynasty at that time, and at this time, Song Jiang himself had a certain value, and there was the possibility of being recruited by the Song Dynasty. Therefore, once the Song Dynasty showed that meaning, Song Jiang would naturally surrender to the Song Dynasty.

Song Jiang: From the beginning to the end, he didn't want to be a bandit leader.

Although Song Jiang had an average level of education, he still received a certain education. Song Jiang, who grew up under ancient education, was deeply influenced by the ideas of feudal society, and he always wanted to become a high-ranking official and nobleman, so as to glorify his ancestors. This was Song Jiang's idea, in fact, it was also the idea of the vast majority of people at that time, and many people didn't want to be bandits.

They were just forced to do so, and now that they have a better choice, they will definitely accept the court's recruitment. And those people on Liangshan who didn't want to accept Zhao'an were because they had a certain grudge with the imperial court at that time, which was the reason for their refusal.

In fact, they themselves also wanted to live in peace, and they didn't want to be a bandit leader or a bandit, so they were only forced to do so when they were helpless and desperate. Now that there are better options, they definitely choose better ones, and no one wants to be bandits. But then again, Song Jiang is not a good person, he sold his life for his own glory and wealth.

He also did not care about how his brothers who had grievances with the court would deal with those grievances.

Song Jiang has been recruited, and he is already an official! Ideologically, he is at odds with Fang La.