Is Song Jiang s recruitment right, and what will happen to him if he doesn t recruit security

From the current point of view, he should not be recruited, if he does not recruit An, he will be an emperor, his power at that time was greater than that of the court at that time, but Song Jiang's loyalty to the monarch is very heavy, as if only Zhao'an is the right way.

According to what is reflected in the book, Zhao'an is unavoidable for Song Jiang's background and values! If you think about it from the perspective of his thinking, he thinks that his move is completely correct, and his purpose in recruiting An is to hope that the people who follow him will not be infamous as traitors in the future, even if they are used! But if you think about it from the perspective of a modern person, he must be wrong because you can't make life decisions for others!

In the process of seeking recruitment, Song Jiang was too selfish and unscrupulous!

It can be seen from Wu Yong that Wu Yong supported Song Jiang before Zhao'an, but after Zhao'an finished Song Jiang's official uniform, J made Zhi faint. Wu Yong began to regret it. During the battle, Wu Yong saw his brothers fall one by one, sighed again and again, and was already disheartened by the title of knight.

Song Jiang did not have the slightest remorse, and he did not hesitate to sacrifice everything.

Later, after drinking poisonous wine, he tricked Li Kui into drinking it together, mainly because he was worried that Li Kui would rebel and ruin the identity and reputation that he had worked so hard to win and fall short.

It is impossible to recruit peace, and then die in the country, this is the limitation of the times, in that era, this is the best destination, and the grass and the like are not done by the big husband. And the Water Margin is written about robbers**, only tragedy can be sublimated, so they must die, although they can play freely, but after all, they can't tamper with history, they can't shake the Great Song Dynasty, and they don't fall into the grass for life (recorded) Only in this way can they make **famous all over the world.

There will be two scenarios:1Overthrow of the regime, 2was wiped out.

Zhao'an is the best way out for Liangshan Group in Song Jiang's heart, but it is not the best choice for the fate of the Liangshan brothers!

One:Song Jiang himself was born in a ** institution, and he is a local big landowner, regardless of his position, he has been familiar with sages since he was a child, and he still can't escape the eight words of filial piety, loyalty, courtesy, righteousness and shame in his heart. Note that "loyalty" is second only to filial piety.

In the eyes of the rulers, in fact, "loyalty" is only ranked behind filial piety, before the imperial examination, civilians want to be officials, can only "raise filial piety", unfilial piety is definitely disloyal!

Later, he had to kill people and enter Liangshan, and after Chao Gai died, he changed the "Juyi Hall" to "Zhongyi Hall". Loyalty to the Orthodox dynasty is far greater than righteousness among brothers!

"Cultivate literature and martial arts, and sell them to the emperor's family".For scholars, the orthodoxy of the court is the real dream. Song Jiang is like this, Wu Yong is also like this, and most of the brothers in the 108 generals are from ** institutions, and even more so!

Second:If the entire Liangshan Group looks at the entire Song Dynasty and the current situation at that time, then the ending of Liangshan Juyi is actually doomed to failure. This point can be seen clearly by Song Jiang, who was born in a family, and Wu Yong, who is extremely smart.

The confrontation between Liangshan and the imperial court, on the surface, is to win more and lose less, but most of them rely on the terrain advantage of the home field, in addition, the opponent is too weak, and a person like Gao Yu who plays football can win, that is wonderful! What's more, Tong Guan in history is not a weak chicken, although he is a eunuch, he is very capable of fighting.

It must be known that the Song Dynasty implemented a forbidden army system at that time, which was the main force of Gongwei Imperial Capital. Economically, the imperial court was far more so. Fang La's nationwide uprising was wiped out, not to mention a small Shuibo Liangshan?

Liangshan was not destroyed, there is only one reason, Liangshan is weak and cannot constitute a threat to the imperial court, there is Liaojin in the north of the imperial court, and there is Fang La in the south, so I don't have the time to take care of you! Once the effort is freed, the fate of Liang Shan can be imagined.

Looking at the current situation, the Song Dynasty at that time was already crumbling, not far from the change of Jingkang, even if it could be in a safe corner, it would not last for ten years! Under the nest, Ann has finished eggs?

So as long as Liangshan continues to gather righteousness, after all, he can't escape the end of the downfall, the best way is to break up, and the brothers are not cats and dogs, they all have the ability to survive. Of course, if you break up at that, there will be nothing to write about.

To sum up, Song Jiang, Wu Yong and others believe that Zhao'an is the best ending.

It's a pity that they are not characters who can change the current situation, after all, they are just the current situation, the waves in politics, but these waves want to be benevolent and sad.

is inevitable, if you don't accept Zhao'an, you can only set yourself up as a king, and Song Jiang doesn't have this ability, even if he becomes an emperor, he will not be promising.

Song Jiang Zhao'an is inevitable. Song Jiang himself is a relatively traditional person, and he had to force Liangshan to do it as a last resort. And his heart is still very eager for the approval of the imperial court.

He thinks that being a bandit on Liangshan is an act of shamelessness in the face of his parents. If he doesn't recruit An, he may always feel guilty and end up separating from the heroes of Liangshan.

In fact, it's not inevitable, if you don't recruit An, maybe your own development is also very good.

Die faster. Many heroes in "Water Margin" died very unjustly, and many people felt that their tragedy was caused by Song Jiang.

In fact, "Water Margin" itself is a myth** Different from TV series, there are a lot of strange forces in it. At the beginning of the story, Taiwei Hong inadvertently let go of the 108 "Demon Lords", that is, the later Liangshan One Hundred and Eight Generals. And in the middle of the story, Jiutian Niangniang also granted Song Jiang three volumes of the Book of Heaven, asking him to do the right thing for heaven, be loyal to righteousness, assist the country and the people, and change the evil and return to the right.

And told Song Jiang that the Jade Emperor was originally because the 108 "Star Lords" had not broken their demonic nature, so he temporarily punished them in the lower realm, and after they succeeded, they could return to heaven, otherwise they would go to hell. Therefore, Song Jiang must take everyone to accept Zhao'an and assist the Great Song Dynasty, otherwise they will not only not be able to return to Heaven to resume their duties after their deaths, but they will also have to go to hell. And the end of ** also wrote, "Tiangang is all returned to the heavenly realm, and the earth should also enter the earth."

For thousands of years, the gods are all temples, and the heroes are sown in the history of thousands of years", which shows that they have all been reinstated in the upper realm, and they have also left their names in the lower realm.

To sum up, if Song Jiang does not Zhao'an, then according to the trend of history, even if he is not defeated by Zhang Shuye of the Great Song Dynasty, he will be exterminated by the later Dajin, even if they can finally seize the Great Song Dynasty, kill Cai Jing Gao Yu and others, wipe out the Sankou, and fight against Dajin to dominate the world, all heroes can have a good death, then they will all go to hell after death.