Why did Liu Bei fail to continue the Han Dynasty?

At present, there are only the Western Han Dynasty and the Eastern Han Dynasty in the official history, and the Eastern Han Dynasty was built by Liu Xiu, a relative of the Han family, and later unified the world, and continued the 200-year national fortune of the Han Dynasty, but I think again, if Liu Xiu did not dominate the world, but only divided one-third of China, and then established the country as Han, and then existed for 50 or 100 years and was destroyed, then he can still be recognized by history as the Han Dynasty? I think it shouldn't be, just like Liu Bei, who is also a relative of the Han family, and is also a member of the Kuang Fu Han family, but because it is a secession party, the established Han is not recognized by history, and the official history believes that the end of the Han Dynasty was the abdication of Liu Xie, not the demise of Shu Han.

Not counting the Three Kingdoms, the destruction of the Eastern Han Dynasty and the Han Dynasty will be over, and to put it bluntly, the Shu Han is likely to be an impostor. Liu Xiu's bloodline with Han Yuanzong and Emperor Gengshi is actually quite estranged, and they have not been related for several lifetimes, just like the relationship between Liu Bei and Emperor Xian of Han; Before Liu Xiu and Liu Bei started their troops, their families were not wealthy......

However, both Liu were committed to restoring the Han Dynasty founded by Liu Bang, and Liu Xiu fought against Wang Mang's new dynasty, and finally replaced the first emperor and became the Han Emperor; Liu Bei hoped to support the Han dynasty and be called Emperor Han after Emperor Xian was deposed. Erliu has a lot in common, they all dominate one side first, then seize the world, and revive the Han Dynasty, but one succeeds and the other fails......Emperor Xian of the Han Dynasty and Liu Bei are not relatives within three generations, and the two cannot talk about continuation, <>

The Shu Han founded by Liu Bei is located in a corner and cannot be regarded as an orthodox dynasty in history. Therefore, it cannot be said that it can be regarded as a continuation of the two Han Dynasty. However, some historians regard the Western Han Dynasty as the former Han Dynasty, the Eastern Han Dynasty as the Later Han Dynasty, and the Shu Han Dynasty as the Ji Han Dynasty, which can be regarded as a continuation of the Han Dynasty.

The relationship with Liu Beimao is only surnamed Liu.

Shu is a small place, and the national strength is not good.

has the intention to kill the enemy, but has no power to return to the sky.

If Liu Bei. Unify the world and rejuvenate the Han Dynasty, so how long will the Han Dynasty last? From the perspective of ancient history, the Han Dynasty was the Chinese nation.

The proudest dynasty, so far, countless people feel sorry for Liu Bei for the Han Dynasty. Due to Liu Bei's failure, Hannah was unable to continue. Due to Liu Bei's defeat, the dynasty has been changing since then, giving rise to orders for the rise and fall of 300 years.

So, if Liu Bei won the world, would it still be the Han Dynasty now?

Qin Shi Huang. began to unify the world, thought of the ten thousand lineage, defeated the descendants of the surname, and became the son of heaven forever, but did not expect that the second generation was about to perish. In this regard, Han Gaozu Liu Bang.

After the establishment of the Han Dynasty, it began to deliberately guide the continuation of the Han Dynasty, so the White Horse Alliance was formed. That is, not the king of husbands. After stipulating the world, Meteor can only become an emperor and become a king.

If a rational man wants to be king, that is, rebel, all the people under heaven will punish him. This was actually the fundamental system for establishing the Han Dynasty Long Live University, and this policy had a far-reaching impact and aroused the consciousness of the time, that is, the meteor world. Therefore, until Wang Mang.

After usurping politics, the world was shrouded in wolf smoke, and all of them rose up to resist, and finally only supported a few warlords who were meteors, and many warlords even changed their surnames to dare to claim the king.

So Liu Xiu. Continuing to use the Han Dynasty after winning the world means that the Han Dynasty continues, which is actually trampling on Han Gaozu's White Horse Alliance with actions. This is also the reason why the Han Dynasty lasted for 400 years.

At the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty, the world was in turmoil, and Liu Bei was reckless, but the most fundamental reason why he could quickly concentrate his forces to capture the city was the people's hearts at that time. That is, to restore the Han Dynasty. Therefore, but it was all because Liu Bei was not angry, failed to recover the country, and lost to Cao Cao.

Lost to Sun Quan.

Broken country. Even the comfortable corner of the later Shu Han existed for decades, but later generations still relied on orthodoxy and did not recognize the Wei state.

Even the state of Qin. Therefore, it is foreseeable that if Liu Bei won at that time and restored the Han dynasty like Liu Xiu, the Han dynasty would continue from then on.

And the so-called repeated, Liu Bei, if you take the world, it will be to restore the Han Dynasty three times. This will definitely take shape in the hearts of the people. The Han Dynasty will be a profound thought that will never perish.

In addition, if Liu Bei takes the world, he will inevitably continue Liu Bang's guidance, continue to consolidate Liu Cheng's national status, and even respect him as the eternal emperor. Therefore, if Liu Bei takes the world, even if there is turmoil in the later dynasties, it will eventually return to the Han Dynasty to restore and restore the track of the Liu family's world. This is very likely to shape the royal family for China forever and establish the tradition of ten thousand lineages forever.

Once this tradition persists, and so far probably the Han Dynasty, the only change is that the rulers have changed. If Liu Bei won the world, would he also become the world of the Han Dynasty now?

However, the biggest uncontrollable danger here is that in the Liu Cheng royal family, future generations can continue to produce eloquent talents. That is, when the country is in chaos, it is possible to reverse the madness, regather forces, and restore the capabilities of the Han Dynasty. Once there is a fault, there is no guarantee for the country!

If Liu Bei unified the world and revived the Han dynasty, then the dynasty established by Liu Bei could not be the Eastern Han Dynasty, and Liu Bei would become the emperor of the new dynasty, not Emperor Xian of the Han Dynasty. The national glory of the Han Dynasty ended with the Eastern Han Dynasty's dedication to the emperor.

How long a dynasty can rule depends on whether its system is perfect and whether it has a Ming monarch. If Liu Chan's generation can still sit on the country, but three generations later, I won't know.

It will last for a very long time, because Liu Bei has always been relatively good at managing the country and has his own understanding.

Liu Bei could not return to Han because the enemy country was too strong, and his own strength was too weak, and Liu Bang occupied Hanzhong and could compete for the world because his own strength was strong and had the opportunity to develop and grow, and there were many talents.

Liu Bei is the peak of strength after seizing Hanzhong, at this time Liu Bei still has half of Jingzhou, and his subordinates have accumulated troops in the past, and at the same time there are some people and horses obtained from Xichuan and Hanzhong, but after the battle of Yiling, Liu Bei's power is not as good as before, because Guan Yu was defeated in Jingzhou before, coupled with the defeat of the Battle of Yiling, a large number of elite troops under Liu Bei were lost, and his own subordinates also died in the past few years, and Shu Han entered the stage of green and yellow. And his opponent Cao Cao occupies the richest place in the whole territory, although the battle of Chibi and the battle of Hanzhong have losses, but it is not unacceptable, and Sun Quan has been steadily developed for many years, and has obtained half of Jingzhou, the national strength of the two countries is stronger than Shu, and then the three kingdoms entered a period of peaceful development, and the gap between Wei and Shu is naturally getting bigger and bigger, and under various predicaments, Liu Bei has not succeeded.

Liu Bang also occupied Hanzhong, but Liu Bei's situation was different. Liu Bei's opponents were Wei and Wu, two countries with very large land areas, and their strength was above Liu Bei. And among Liu Bang's opponents, only Xiang Yu is stronger than him, and when Liu Bang and Xiang Yu compete for dominance in the world, there are other princes at the same time, some of these princes are united and some are hostile, this is Liu Bang's opportunity, he exterminated other small princes step by step, and united some princes to attack Xiang Yu, the strength continued to grow during this period, and Liu Bei did not have such an opportunity, when he established the foundation of Shu, Wu and Wei had already established the basic plate, and when many princes fought in the past, Liu Bei's power is still very weak, and after Liu Bei lost Jingzhou, he could only occupy Hanzhong to develop, and he could not compare with Liu Bang.

Liu Bang's subordinates also have more talents than Liu Bei, and Liu Bang's subordinates are full of talents, which is enough to compete with Xiang Yu. And Liu Bei's subordinates also had a lot of talents in the past, but after Liu Bei established the Shu State, many of Liu Bei's subordinates have grown old, and most of his subordinates have died, in the battle of Yiling, Liu Bei focused on cultivating a large number of talents who died in the battle of Yiling, such as Ma Liang, the battle of Yiling, the blow to Liu Bei's forces is not only in terms of troops, if there are so many talents in the late Shu Han Dynasty, maybe it will not be so easy to be seconds, after all, there is no general in Shu, and Chunyuan Sui Liao turned into a vanguard. Liu Bang has Xiao He, Zhang Liang, Han Xin and other talents, plus Liu Bang also has the emperor's tolerance and ambition, and he was repeatedly defeated in the battle with Xiang Yu, and finally won the world.

He told Jian because Liu Bei's ability was not very strong, and he began to slump after experiencing the failure of the Northern Expedition, but Liu Bang thought that victory and defeat were a common thing in soldiers.

Because Liu Bei was hindered by Sun Quan and Cao Cao at that time, Liu Bang was the only one in his time, and Xiang Yu was a fool.

At the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty, a three-legged Huaijian situation was formed, and the reason why Liu Bei failed was because of the situation. And the reason why Liu Bang was able to establish the Han Dynasty was because Liu Bang had a unique talent to know and dislike.

As far as I know, this has only happened in one country, and that is Japan. From Emperor Jimmu more than 2,000 years ago in Japan to the present, the members of the imperial family are all bloodline. After reading it, don't you think it's amazing?

In China, however, this is not possible. I'll give you an analysis of why it is not possible :

History, from the time when the Xia Dynasty changed course and changed hands to Yin Shang, the change of dynasties was destined to be imprinted in the minds of the Chinese nation. Shang was destroyed by Zhou, although there was a so-called orthodox era in the world for nearly 700 years, but after the Spring and Autumn Period and the Warring States Rebellion, it was finally destroyed by Qin. As for the uprising of Chen Sheng and Wu Guang, it conveyed the belief that "the prince will have a kind of Xiangning" to the hearts of every Han people.

Since then, Chu and Han have competed for hegemony, Empress Lu has usurped power, Wang Mang has reformed, and all kinds of things have made the people of the Han Dynasty clearly recognize: the world is inherently the master, and the virtuous can get it. After so many turmoil and turmoil, I think there are not a few people in the world who have the idea of overthrowing the monarch.

external environment. The reason why I am telling you is that the kind of situation you mentioned has only happened in one country in Japan, as far as I know. Japan is an island country, and there is no harm from Yidi in the north and no threat of barbarism in the south.

In addition to the external factors such as the ** volcano, it can be said to be unique. This external environment has created a stable internal political environment. Imagine if the Han Dynasty lasted until the Wei and Jin dynasties, wouldn't it be wiped out by the Wuhu?

If it barely lasted until the Sui and Tang dynasties, wouldn't it be wiped out by the Turks? If it was reluctant and continued until the Song Dynasty, wouldn't it be destroyed by Jin Yuan? If it was not destroyed by the Jin Yuan, wouldn't it be destroyed by the Qing Dynasty?

All these things doom that the mainland will not be a land of peace, and the Central Plains will not be a land of eternal gold.

To sum up, no matter what happened, the Han Dynasty could never last, neither could the Wei and Jin dynasties, the Sui and Tang dynasties impossible, the Song and Yuan dynasties even more impossible, and the Ming and Qing dynasties were the most unlikely. As for me, I want to say two words, hehe.

Orthodoxy is all lip service The world is fought by fists In history, there are many people who have been scolded for Xiang but succeeded in usurping the throne and have the last laugh The emperor is the emperor in ancient sayings, and the virtuous live in it To put it bluntly, it is who is the emperor and the opposition is invalid.

No, because it is the trend of historical development, so the Han Dynasty will definitely change, and we can't be sure that all the emperors after the Han Dynasty will be good at governing the country. Therefore, we will definitely follow the trend of historical development, learn from the countries that have developed into capitalism, and eventually form an independent style

Unless each of his descendants is a Ming Jun,

Still, but history will say: Later Han.

One man's history, one family's words.

Definitely! Liu Bei will not give up the good orthodox successor, and he will not restore the reputation of Zhongxing!

If Liu Bei completes the unification, he will definitely not be called Shu Han, and the name is suspected of being a local government.

Therefore, it will definitely change.

Looking at Liu Beidingdu**, is it Chang'an or Luoyang?

History books like to name the capital after where it is located.

But the East and West Han will not be called anymore!

Another ancient man liked to name after the place of birth.

Liu Bei is a native of Zhuo County, Youzhou, maybe the name of the Northern Han Dynasty will be advanced.

It's hard to say, but presumably for the sake of the stability of the people in the world, he should call the court he established the Han Dynasty, and falsely claim that it is the continuation of Liu Xiu's Eastern Han Dynasty, because she has also become an emperor, and she is also a member of the Liu family, and she can call any country name.

does not belong, because Liu Bei is not orthodox in the Han family, he is just a side branch.

Yes, in ancient times, bloodline was very important, Liu Bei has always emphasized his identity as a relative of the Han family, if Liu Bei unified China, whether he supported the emperor or continued to call himself emperor, he could claim to be orthodox in the Han family.