Zhuge Liang s empty city plan, did Sima Yi really not see it?

I didn't dare to enter when I saw it. wiped out Zhuge Liang, and the next one to be destroyed was Sima Yi himself. The reason why Sima Yi was activated was because no one could resist Zhuge Liang's attack. The truth of the cunning rabbit's dead lackey cooking, Sima Yi will not understand.

Sima Yi saw Zhuge Liang's empty city plan, but he still chose to withdraw his troops just in case.

No, because Zhuge Liang is cautious and does not take risks easily, Sima Yi thinks that there must be ambushes.

No, if he defeats Zhuge Liang at this time, then the emperor will not reuse him, it will be no good for him, and since Zhuge Liang dares to open the door, it means that Zhuge Liang has made all preparations.

In reality, it is not so terrible, because there is no need, so I don't want to inquire about the news, and it is also for self-protection, so I didn't choose to send someone to find out the news.

No. Sima Yi knew at the time that it was a plan, and his troops at that time had been seriously damaged, so he could only plan and pretend to be fooled.

Zhuge Liang's empty city plan is particularly terrifying. Sima Yi knew that if he wanted to gain a firm foothold in the court, Zhuge Liang had to be there, so he didn't send someone to inquire about the situation, but also gave himself a step.

According to expert analysis, it is unanimously believed that Sima Yi deliberately released Zhuge Liang in the empty city plan.

The story of the empty city plan is taken from "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", a story adapted by the author based on Pei Songzhi's note "Guo Chong's Three Things" in the Three Kingdoms. Later, it was used in the Thirty-six Strategies, which means that the virtual and the real are real, and the army is impermanent. The tactic of showing hypocrisy is a kind of psychological warfare in which suspicion arises from suspicion, and is mostly used in situations where the enemy is weak and the enemy is strong.

There are indeed some successful examples of using this strategy in history, such as Zhang Shougui Shouguazhou and so on.

In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, it is written that Wei sent Sima Yi to attack the Shuguo Street Pavilion, and Zhuge Liang sent Ma Jian to garrison it and failed. Sima Yi led his troops to take advantage of the victory and approached Xicheng, Zhuge Liang had no soldiers to meet the enemy, but he was calm and calm, opened the city gate, and played the piano and sang music on the city tower. Sima Yi suspected an ambush and led his troops to retreat.

In fact, this is just a small story made up by Guo Chong in the commentary, Sima Yiyuan was in Luoyang during the Battle of Jieting, and returned to Wancheng after conquering Mengda, thousands of miles away from the place of occurrence, and Zhuge Liang fought against Zhang He, Kong Ming saw the defeat of Jieting, and quickly withdrew to Hanzhong. So, the event itself is fictional.

Of course, this is just a phenomenon, but the biggest reason is that Sima Yi is also more afraid of Zhuge Liang, because Zhuge Liang's use of soldiers is really very weird, and then he knows that Zhuge Liang is usually not in danger, so at this time, we must pay attention to the fact that Zhuge Liang may have some ambushes in some places.

So at this time, he was afraid that if he failed again, he would be punished again when he went back, so Sima Yi had more places to be afraid of, so in the end, it led to the success of an empty city plan.

The empty city plan is seen in Pei Songzhi's "Notes on the Romance of the Three Kingdoms" quoted by Guo Chongwen, and Pei thought it was not credible, so whether this matter existed or not is a question.

There is no such thing as an "empty city plan" in the official history, it was made up by Luo Guanzhong himself!

Maybe, if Sima Yi defeats Zhuge Liang, he will not be reused.

Historically, Zhuge Liang did not engage in empty city plans.

Sima Yi is most afraid of Zhuge Liang in his life, because Mr. Zhuge Liang is stronger than Sima Yi in everything, can Sima Yi not doubt it in the face of the empty city plan? Besides, Sima Yi is too afraid of Zhuge and it's too late to run, how dare he break into the empty city!

Hello landlord, Zhuge Liang did not use the empty city plan in real history, but if you use the thinking of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms to analyze this matter, I think it is. Why didn't Sima Yi enter the empty city and let Zhuge Liang's empty city plan succeed, the real reason was not that Sima Yi was suspicious and did not dare to rush into the army, but because he could not annihilate Zhuge Liang at once, at that time he was jealous and excluded by many people in the Wei Group, and everyone wanted to bomb him **, because his power was too high, as the saying goes, the gun shot the first bird.

How could Sima Yi establish his majesty in the Wei State and make himself useful so that he would not be attacked by those who were eyeing him in the Wei State all the time? He can only let Zhuge Liang have a certain military strength, so that every time Zhuge Liang conquers him, Sima Yi will be useful, those evil forces in Wei clearly see this, and of course they will not attack Sima Yi, but Sima Yi can't make Zhuge Liang particularly strong, because it will be related to the life and death of Wei.

Therefore, Sima Yi is in a relatively embarrassing environment, and he must not let Zhuge Liang not have any strength at all, but he must not let Zhuge Liang's military strength be particularly strong, so this is the real reason why Sima Yi forced Zhuge Liang to the empty city, but to everyone's surprise, he did not enter the empty city.

Sima Yi is a person who grew up slowly in the cracks of history, he can be called a hero, he is much stronger than Zhuge Liang in history, Sima Yi often said: "The soldier who surrenders without a fight, the good is also good." ”

If there is an empty city plan in history, it is impossible for Sima Yi's talent to not see through it, and Sima Yi is worried about the birds and hiding the bow.

There is no understanding in the romance. Sima led the army to come, and saw Zhuge Liang sitting at the head of the city, playing the piano leisurely, and was cautious after suspecting Zhuge in his life, there must be an ambush in the city. So I quit the army, but there is no such thing as this history in the canonical history. It is fictionalized by the author of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms.

In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, it is said that Sima Yan did not see through his empty city plan.

It depends on what kind of drama you watch, according to the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, I didn't see through it, and according to the New Three Kingdoms, half and half, I personally think I didn't see through it, the reason is that what is the difference between Sima Yi catching Zhuge Liang and Zhuge Liang's death, if you let Zhuge Liang go, you can catch Zhuge Liang alive and you have to die, and Zhuge Liang has not seen Sima Yi die for ten years after his death. Some people say that letting go of Zhuge Liang and Huarong Dao is a reason and impossible, Huarong Dao letting go of Cao Cao is Liu Bei's strength is too poor, Cao Cao is let go of the north and chaos, Liu Bei has no meaning for Sun Quan, and the world may fall into the hands of Sun Quan. And even if Zhuge Liang is arrested, Shu Wei claims to be the best and Zhuge Liang is captured or dies, and he will not be destroyed immediately, and he can unite Sun Quan to fight against Cao Wei.

If you watch the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, you won't feel that the empty city plan has been recognized. The name of the original work is Romance of the Three Kingdoms, not the New Three Kingdoms.

The following is my personal thoughts, Sima Yi knows that the main reason why he can hold military power is because Zhuge Liang is a great threat to Wei. If he really killed Zhuge Liang, it won't be long before his military power will be taken back by the Emperor of Wei, and even the lives of his family are quite worried. The reason why Sima Yi withdrew from the army was not because he failed to see through Zhuge Liang's empty city plan, but because he wanted to continue to control the military power of Wei, this is the truth of the matter, and Sima Yi is so smart.

And why didn't you shoot Zhuge Liang to death with one arrow, why didn't you surround the city and wait for Zhuge Liang to finish eating the food, and wait for them to slowly starve to death. This is my personal opinion, don't spray if you don't like it.