Guan Yu and Lu Bu are more powerful in kung fu

Lu Bu was the first fierce general of the Three Kingdoms. The three British battles against Lu Bushang are tied! Guan Yu is also very powerful, but compared to Lu Bu, he is still inferior!

Half a catty to eight taels. I'm the best.

a) From the point of view of personal force value:

Lu Bu should be greater than (at least greater than or equal to) Guan Yu (Zhang Fei), after all, "Three Heroes Battle Lu Bu", Liu Guanzhang and three people can barely defeat Lu Bu. This is the story of the fifth episode of ** "Romance of the Three Kingdoms".

What's more, Lu Bu also has the miracle of "shooting halberds at the gate" (in the 16th chapter of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", in the official history "Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Wei Shuqi. There are records in the Biography of Lu Bu), ancient archery techniques account for a large proportion of personal force value, such as the ancient martial arts examination, one of the main subjects is archery.

In terms of archery, neither Guan Yu nor Zhang Fei has a clear record. On the contrary, Guan Yu was often shot by cold arrows and suffered a lot.

The only thing that is in doubt is that the generals have a single challenge.

Lu Bu's single-handedly canonical historical record seems to be out of reach: in "Three Kingdoms. Wei Shuqi. In the Biography of Lu Bu, Lu Bu only had a one-on-one confrontation with Guo Yan (Guo is not a famous general) and stabbed Guo Yan with a spear (failed to kill).

Although Guan Yu's single challenge achievements are also very few, he can kill the famous Hebei general Yan Liang ("Three Kingdoms. Book VI of Shu. Guan Zhang Ma Huang Zhao Biography records: Yu Wang saw Liang Lu Gai, spurred the horse to spur Liang in the crowd, beheaded it, and Shao Zhu could not be the one).

Although the performance of the single challenge is doubtful, the official history "Three Kingdoms" recorded the folk song at that time: "There is Lu Bu among the people, and there is a red rabbit among the horses." It can be seen from this side that people at that time still recognized Lu Bu's personal force as the highest.

2) From the point of view of the military command level of the leader:

Guan Yu is significantly higher than Lu Bu in this regard. Lu Bu has always been brave and unscrupulous in his life, and the war only relies on personal force to solve the problem, so the battles he commands are always partially advantageous, but the whole has been defeated repeatedly, and finally Baimenlou was killed by his own family.

And Guan Yu's military level is recognized as enough to serve as a party leader. He commanded the partial division to defend Jingzhou, and he could fight the record of flooding the Seventh Army and shocking Huaxia (forcing Cao Cao to even have the fear of moving the capital), although he was defeated and killed in the end, it was only because of the Eastern Wu behind, not defeated on the frontal battlefield.

So on the whole (whether it is romance or official history): personal force is Lu Bu is better than Guan Yu; But in terms of overall military level, Guan Yu far surpassed Lu Bu.

Guan Yu must be powerful in the official history, Guan Yu is the first military general of the Three Kingdoms in the official history. Lu Bu is even more powerful in Romance.

Can't simply say who is better than whom, of course, judging from the three Ying battles against Lu Bu, it should be that Lu Bu is a little more powerful than Guan Yu After all, it is a dozen three.

Lu Bu is even more powerful.

Lu Bu's experience in the official history is actually not much different from that in the Romance, but in terms of force alone, Lu Bu is not as strong as in the Romance! In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Lu Bu defeated the princes and generals in the Battle of Tiger Pass, even if Zhang Fei and Guan Yu went into battle, they were not Lu Bu's opponents! In the end, it was Liu Bei who personally went into battle and staged a three-English battle against Lu Bu with Guan Yu and Zhang Fei, and finally defeated Lu Bu.

In the subsequent battle of Puyang, Cao Wei's fierce general Xu Chu also singled out Lu Bu, but in only twenty rounds, Cao Cao discovered that something was wrong, shouted out Lu Bu's words that he could win alone, and ordered his six generals to besiege Lu Bu together, and finally defeated Lu Bu! It can be seen that no one can defeat Lu Bu alone in Romance, and if you want to defeat Lu Bu, you must use siege tactics!

In terms of the two of them's bright martial arts, Lu Bu is even more powerful.

According to the records in the history books, the two fought directly twice, and the two battles were won by Lu Bu.

During the first battle of Guan Yuzhen's defense of Xiapi, Lü Bu attacked Xiapi and won; In the second battle, when the three brothers of Liu Guan and Zhang were stationed in Pei County together, Lü Bu only sent the general Gao Shun to lead his troops to attack Xiapi, and as a result, he won. From this point of view, it seems that the overall situation can be inferred with a number of battles, and the overall situation is that Lu Bu did win Guan Yu, and Guan Yu didn't seem to be able to defeat Lu Bu at all.

An extension is made from **, that is, the famous Three Heroes Battle Lu Bu.

Although there are some exaggerations and some fictional history, fiction is not fiction, and it is still continued along the previous historical framework. The two brothers Guan Yu and Zhang Fei were barely able to have a draw with Lu Bu or were able to suppress Lu Bu slightly, but when Liu Bei also came to fight Lu Bu together, they couldn't beat Lu Bu, so that Lu Li Jian Tuanbu took the opportunity to escape.

This is enough to see that Guan Yu really wants to lose to Lu Bu.

Lu Bu is resourceful:

In terms of intelligence, Lu Bu is also stronger than Guan Yu.

In 194 AD, Lu Bu and Liu Bei had a contradiction, Yuan Shu took advantage of the gap to send troops to attack Liu Bei, and his subordinates persuaded him to take advantage of the gap to destroy Liu Bei, but Lu Bu said: Otherwise, if the technique is broken, then the generals of Taishan in the north, I have to save it in the siege. can grasp the core of the contradiction in the chaos, which shows that Lu Bu is very strategic.

Earlier, around 200 AD, Guan Yu had been stationed in Xiapi, on behalf of Xuzhou Tai Shou, originally intended to let him hold this base, but Guan Yu was defeated and captured under Cao Cao, in 219 AD, Liu Bei was called the king of Hanzhong, let Guan Yu take charge of Jingzhou, and gave him enough power and trust.

After taking over, Sun Quan wanted to marry him, Guan Yu not only did not agree, but also scolded, so there was a gap with Eastern Wu, which completely destroyed Liu Bei's strategy of uniting Wu to resist Cao, resulting in the union of Sun Quan and Cao Cao, causing Guan Yu to lose Jingzhou and lose his life.