Song Jiang finally chose to accept Zhao an, did he really do something wrong?

Yes, because Song Jiang's decision directly led to the death of many heroes in Liangshan, it was wrong.

really did something wrong, because with Song Jiang's strength, he can completely compete with the imperial court, and he can establish his own power, and there is no need to go to Zhao'an.

Yes, because in some way, he hurt 108 good men, but instead made all of them end up more tragic.

No, this decision was made because of the pressure of society at that time, and it was not my original intention, so people can understand it.

Yes, he was very wrong in doing so, leading his brothers directly on the path to perdition, with unpredictable results.

Liangshan Zhao'an is the result of the will of the majority. Li Kui's opposition to Zhao'an was idealistic and directly rebelled. Lu Zhishen and Wu Song opposed Zhao'an, there was no ideal, but there was a stable place to drink wine and eat meat.

The rest of the people did not support Li Kui, nor did they support Lu Zhishen and Wu Song, but they agreed with Zhao'an, and in the end, there was only Zhao'an. Look at Song Jiang's method, follow the path of the famous prostitute Li Shishi, in the eyes of Huizong, Liangshan's one hundred singles, eight generals and 100,000 military horses are not as good as Li Shishi's smile, tea, song and chess, this is an insult to the surrendering faction, and the so-called Liangshan heroes are not self-reflective. For the surrender faction, Huizong will not pay attention to it.

Then Liangshan won the battle to promote surrender, and the imperial court came to levy four thieves, and the thieves were destroyed, and everything was over.

If there is no description of Zhao'an, the Water Margin will never become one of the four famous novels. As for the rights and wrongs of Zhao'an, it's really hard to say, because of 108 people, everyone's ideas are different, and even the original intention of Shangliangshan is different. Hu Yanzhuo, Lu Junyi, Guan Sheng, Sun Li, and others only went up the mountain because of Song Jiang's promise to recruit An, Lin Chong, Chao Gai, and the seven brothers were forced to go to Liangshan, and most of the others relied on Song Jiang to go to Liangshan in name.

Among them, the seven Chao Gai brothers, Lin Chong, Wu Song, Lu Zhishen, Li Kui, Li Jun, etc. are all against Zhao'an, Yang Zhi, Guan Sheng, Hu Yanzhuo, Lu Junyi, etc. are eager to recruit An, and the others are all joining in the fun, and whether they recruit or not Zhao'an has no impact on them. Song Jiang once said to Chao Gai: "As the so-called goose has left a voice, people have left a name, the eldest brother has to think about the fate of the brothers, does the elder brother want their children and grandchildren to bear the infamy of a thief for generations?"

The ancients attached great importance to fame, so Song Jiang's original intention was right, so when conquest of Fang La, although many people were reluctant to go, they still went in terms of brotherhood, especially Wu Song's words made people cry: "If you leave your brother halfway, it seems that Wu Song is a person who is unkind, and now Jiangnan is determined, and my brother is finally full of merit, and when he returns to Beijing to make a book, he will not write the name of his younger brother."

Although the end of the heroes of Liangshan was tragic, Jiuquan finally had an explanation to his ancestors and descendants, some people said that Song Jiang gave his brother's life for fame and fortune, but when he drank the known poisonous wine, everything was clear. Zhao'an is the best way out, although the ending is a little tragic, but it is these tragedies that make a classic masterpiece. If the Water Margin is just a simple ** of heroes robbing houses, it definitely does not have today's height, and the Water Margin is wonderful because of Zhao'an.

Song Jiang Niu Dan.

Unfit to be a commander!! A person whose hobbies (needs) are too "persistent" is easy to be emotional (Song Jiangye!). ）

"Single-minded" on the wrong path

Even if you send someone to assassinate Gao Yu and Taishi. Is it difficult?!! The palace is easy to enter! Besides, I've also caught Gao Yu.

is still so "wishful thinking", you are "playing" with your brother's life

The original idea was good, taking into account the overall situation, but the result was miserable, negligent villain!!

Right or wrong is not a good evaluation, the following is my personal opinion:

Most of the ancients paid attention to loyalty and righteousness, leaving a good reputation for future generations to transmit, for example, although Lin Chong is the head of the forbidden army, dare to ask Lin Chong how many grades of the official are, how many people remember after death, and what if his wife was robbed? There are so many wrongs in ancient times, I believe that future generations will still not remember, and Liangshan fell into the grass as a robber of Kou Dang, and it will not be remembered by future generations. Liang Shanbo has been completed, and the way these people can be remembered by future generations is either to succeed in rebellion or to recruit peace.

It is impossible to succeed in the rebellion, (if you want to refute the Qing Dynasty and look at history first) 108 heroes, what Du Qian, Yum, An Daoquan, these people abound, timid and afraid of things without force, Fang La was the largest rebel army at that time, and was finally exterminated by 100,000 elite soldiers in the south of the Yangtze River gathered by the imperial court. Let's talk about Zhao'an, and then for the national construction work, whitewash the identity. (Shi Naixian only dared to write Liang Shanbo after Zhao'an) Only in this way can he be called a hero.

When I was a child, I never remembered that there was a story about Liang Shanbo in the history books, and the stories were written in language books. The propaganda of Liangshan's heroes relies on **, and Song Jiang will not be written in ** if he does not recruit An, so I think Song Jiang will not be famous if he does not recruit An. The mind is a little confused, you will see.

On the Double Ninth Festival after Liang Shanbo arranged the seats, Song Jiang made a big party with the theme of "Chrysanthemum Meeting", and on the body, Song Jiang filled in a poem "Man Jianghong" to dissect himself, and there were two sentences like this:

The center is willing to calm the captives and protect the people and the country. The sun and the moon are often loyal and fierce, but the wind and dust obstacles are treacherous. 」

Although Song Jiang is a small official in Yuncheng, he is also a Shandong native who grew up reading sage books. The so-called governing the country and leveling the world, there are only two ways to go, one is to kill the white snake uprising like Liu Bang, and the other is to learn literary and martial arts and sell them to the emperor's family.

The real Song Jiang in history rebelled, and the ending was unsuccessful. Song Jiang in "Water Margin" was recruited, and then recruited Fang La, so he finally achieved Song Jiang's wish to protect the country and the people.

In fact, rationally speaking, Song Jiang's "Zhao'an Road" for the leaders of Liangshan Bo is the best way to wash white.

After becoming bigger, it becomes a big problem for the imperial court, and the imperial court has to suppress it, and if it can't be suppressed, it will naturally have to talk about it, and what to talk about is to ask for officials to give officials, and to ask for money to give money. The so-called murder and arson are also recruited.

In Chinese history, there is no shortage of people who follow the routine of Song Jiang to do things, such as Li Zicheng, the general of the rebel army at the end of the Ming Dynasty, who was constantly recruited and recruited. With such a strong military strength as Li Zicheng, and still regards Zhao'an as a good way out, how can Song Jiang, a small Liangshan cottage owner, be? Is there really a rebellion?

Throughout the ages, there have been many rebels, and how many have really succeeded? The era in which Song Jiang lived, from the perspective of later generations, was decadent and gray, but in the eyes of the people at that time, it was actually a great rule and prosperity.

Rebellion in troubled times is still a thing with a very low success rate, and rebellion in the ruling world is not even more a big death?

If you are Song Jiang, you are a Song Jiang who has studied history since childhood and has the power to scheming, what do you want? Are you willing to be only a small official in Yuncheng and work all your life? You don't want to! Song Jiang didn't want to either!

If you are Song Jiang, you don't want to spend your life in the world, but you were stabbed with Jiangzhou, and you accidentally mentioned anti-poems, and you have to fall into the grass as a last resort, what will you do? Do you really want to stain the Xunyang River estuary with blood? Do you really want to laugh at Huang Chao's husband?

It's okay to talk about it when you're drunk, but can you still say such meat words when you wake up?

Rebel? It's easy to say, but it's really hard to do. Rebellion is not a dinner party, not a fuss, not a painting and embroidery, not so elegant, so calm and polite, so gentle and courteous. But Zhao'an can!

Therefore, if you are Song Jiang, you really have the power to scheming, and Zhao'an is the best way out!

Because "Water Margin" was deleted and changed Song Jiang's "motive", as well as Song Jiang's true identity, Song Jiang is Song Huizong's younger brother!

Because "Water Margin" was deleted and changed Song Jiang's "motive", as well as Song Jiang's true identity, Song Jiang is Song Huizong's younger brother!

There may be the following reasons why Song Jiang has to recruit An:1. One is that Song Jiang himself is a person who pays a lot of attention to fame, so the matter of loyalty and patriotism is very important to Song Jiang, 2. The second is that Song Jiang likes to help the world and save the people, and does not like to fight and kill. Yangsan is in danger.

3. After Liangshan became bigger, the heart of the imperial court to destroy Liangshan has not ended, and has sent people to exterminate Liangshan many times, although Liangshan has repeatedly defeated the imperial army with the help of geographical advantages, but the imperial court sent not its elite army, and Liangshan did not cause heavy damage to the imperial army, the imperial court can organize an army to attack Liangshan at any time, on the contrary, Liangshan does not have enough soldiers to supplement, according to this trend, sooner or later it will be defeated by the imperial army, once Liangshan fails, they will be wiped out.

4. Liangshan lacks the economy of Qingjing. Liangshan does not have a stable economy**, and their income** mainly depends on robbery and donations from wealthy families in Liangshan, but this is not a long-term solution, not enough to support Liangshan's growth, or long-term development, and often go down the mountain to rob, which will lead to public resentment, and there will be more and more people who hate them, and the imperial court will also increase their conquest, and Liangshan's situation will be more dangerous. Therefore, Song Jiang needed to think about the future of his brothers.