In Water Margin , should Song Jiang recruit An?

For the environment in which it was at the time. He should be recruited. But!

For "Water Margin" and Song Jiang, but should still accept the imperial court's recruitment, first of all, before the Liangshan brothers were recruited, although the righteousness between them was important and they were righteous people, but in the final analysis, they were still grass cowards, they rebelled against the imperial court, in other words, the Liangshan brothers were a group of disloyal and rebellious grass coars. And "Water Margin" not only embodies a righteous word, but also focuses on a loyalty, if they only have the righteousness of brothers and do not care about the country, and are not loyal to the country, this does not reflect the main talk of "Water Margin".

Song Jiang led Zhao'an, so that the Liangshan brothers became loyal to the imperial court, and this also fulfilled the name of Liangshan's loyaltyAlthough Liangshan suffered heavy losses later, it was because of Liangshan's loyalty that they were deeply loved by readers, and I said on the other hand, if Liangshan did not accept Zhao'an, then what is the difference between them and Wang Qing, Fang La and others?

Secondly, we take Song Jiang as an example, although he was a small official before going to Liangshan, he himself was very loyal, even if he later went to Liangshan, he still did not change his original intention, and still wanted to serve the imperial court. And Song Jiang went to Liangshan was also forced by the situation, after he went to Liangshan, what he wanted was to use it as a basis, and then look for an opportunity to recruit An, ready to serve the country again, so, in Song Jiang's heart is loyal to the imperial court, he hopes that he can be recruited, even if he gets a tragic ending in the end, he has never regretted it, so for Song Jiang, he should still go to Zhao'an.

Finally, in terms of strength, Liangshan should also accept Zhao'an, although Liangshan has defeated the imperial court's conquest army several times, but Liangshan's strength is limited after all, the reason why they were able to defeat the imperial court officials and army,It is also because of the topography of Yangsan. But the Song Dynasty was different, although the Song Dynasty experienced several failures in the conquest of Liangshan, but for the Song Dynasty, it did not hurt the vitality, so they could continue to mobilize troops and horses to attack Liangshan. In this way, if Liangshan does not recruit An, it will be difficult to avoid the continuous conquest army sent by the imperial court

How to say it, Song Jiang recruits an or not, it is a dead end, so there is no difference between choosing to accept or refuse, don't worry about whether he should recruit an or not, since the left is also dead and the right is dead, there is no difference, and there is nothing to worry about.

1. Song Jiang will die regardless of whether he chooses Zhao'an or not, so it doesn't matter how he chooses. The reason why Song Jiang was targeted by the imperial court and handed over to Zhao'an was mainly because the people on Liangshan were basically fugitives who had violated the law, and more importantly, they were all capable people with unique skillsAt first, the imperial court didn't pay attention to it, but seeing that their team was expanding too quickly, they began to be afraid, so they proposed to recruit An.

But from the very beginning, the imperial court was not really recruiting peace, if they did not agree, the imperial court would directly send troops to kill them, if they agreed, then solve the troubles of the province in batches, even if they had special skills, but after all, they were all fugitivesIf the imperial court reuses them, how will they manage others in the future, so it makes no difference if Song Jiangtong disagrees.

Second, for Song Jiang, Zhao'an is a good way out, he has a dream of being an official, so he wants to fight. In fact, for Song Jiang, he had no choice, he clearly knew the purpose of the imperial court's recruitment, but he still wanted to fight, relying on the brothers who could command in his hands to gamble on the imperial court and not dare to do anything to themIn other words, even if the court kills some people, some people will be able to take this opportunity to become new people, which can be regarded as finding a good way out for them.

But Song Jiang didn't expect the court to be ruthless, whether it was a mistake or a mistake, as long as it was all on Liangshan, he would kill it, It is estimated that Song Jiang didn't expect this kind of result, if they weren't so ostentatious, maybe they would live in the ravines and ravines for a lifetime, why bother to walk on this road of no return and die.

Finally: Actually, I personally hate Song Jiang, and he can't be a very insidious person, which is really unlikeable!

It should not be put that Song Jiang led Zhao'an, so that the Liangshan brothers became loyal to the court, and this also fulfilled the name of Liangshan's loyalty.

Song Jiang has been a member of the imperial court from the beginning, and it is impossible for him not to accept Zhao'an. Even though he knew it was a trap, he would jump into it.

I think it was necessary to recruit An, because the result of that environment at that time was inevitable.

Under the circumstances and background at that time, it was still necessary to recruit An.

I don't think so, to go all the way to the dark is the real hero, to go your own way.

In the context of that time, Song Jiang would be surrounded and suppressed by the imperial court if he did not recruit An, so the final result was the same.

I think this is still the way it should be, mainly because they really can't develop further.

This is a must, no matter what, the ending of the heroes on the beam is the same.

Whether they recruit or not, they will end up like this.

"Water Margin".Song Jiang Zhao'an was wrong. Song Jiang's fault for Zhao'an was after Zhao'an, he was in the Northern Song Dynasty.

Officialdom was targeted everywhere, after Song Jiang accepted Zhao'an, he did not have a good understanding of the situation in the imperial court, he thought that the emperor at that time still had real power, so he desperately tried to please the emperor, but the imperial court at that time had been Cai Jing and Gao Yu.

controlled, Song Jiang had no good impression of these two people, and many people on Liangshan had a deep hatred for these two people.

Song Jiang's character characteristics

Song Jiang is a person with multiple personalities. First of all, it is to squander wealth and fight righteousness, help the weak and help the poor, filial piety and respect for relatives and friends, which is the gentle and generous side of his character. secondly, he was filial to the emperor and emphasized righteousness, which was the orthodox side of his character; Again, he does things for everyone in the open and makes friends with thieves in the dark, which is the hypocritical and cunning side of his character; In the end, he gathered people to oppose the country and wrote poems, which was the rebellious side of his character.

Song Jiang should accept Zhao'an. The reason why Song Jiang was able to beat Chao Gai.

The main reason for coming to power is that his idea of recruiting peace is supported by the majority of people. There are many people with strong martial arts who were in the imperial court at the beginning, or were lured by Song Jiang or captured in battle. They are not willing to live in Liangshan for the rest of their lives.

There are also some intellectuals and technical talents, and their skills can be eaten in the first place, so why not be reused by the emperor and be a pillar of the country.

Synopsis. "Water Margin".

It is the end of the Yuan Dynasty and the beginning of the Ming Dynasty.

Most of the signatures of the existing journals are Shi Nai'an and Luo Guanzhong.

One of the two, or both of them have a long chapter**.

The whole book describes the heroes of Liangshan.

Resist oppression, water and Liangshan.

The grand story of the growth and recruitment of the Song Dynasty, and the conquest for the Song Dynasty after being recruited and the eventual demise, artistically reflects the Songjiang Uprising in Chinese history.

The whole process from its occurrence, development to defeat profoundly reveals the social roots of the uprising, enthusiastically praises the resistance struggle and their social ideals of the heroes of Mind, and concretely reveals the internal historical reasons for the failure of the uprising.

Should. In "Water Margin", Song Jiang should recruit An. From the book, it can be seen that a large part of Liangshan's rolling jujube is the original imperial court officers, and many of the small soldiers are sergeants from all over the world.

Therefore, returning to the imperial court is also the hope of most people in Liangshan. Therefore, the long-term plan is to close the auspicious and closed to recruit an banquet and dismantle.

According to the plot in the story, the three heroes of the Ruan family should be supportive, as well as his military advisor Wu Yong. and Yang Zhi, who used to be an official, is also very supportive.

There are the third-ranked Shangying Tianji Star Wu Yong, Tianqiao Star Yanqing, Tianwei Star Hu Yanzhuo, and "Thunderbolt Fire" Tianxing Qin Ming.

Zhao'an was the best way out for the Liangshan group in Song Jiang's mind, but it was not the best choice for the fate of the Liangshan brothers, which was also the limitation of the peasant class.

Song Jiang, whose name is Gongming, nicknamed Hu Baoyi, Timely Rain, and Xiaoyi Hei Saburo, is a character in Shi Nai'an's classic ** "Water Margin", one of the one hundred and eight generals, ranking first. Song Jiang was originally the director of Yuncheng County, Shandong, and his correspondence with Chao Gai was discovered by Yan Poxi, so he killed Yan Poxi in anger and fled home to hide. Later, he took refuge in Hua Rong, but was framed and imprisoned by Liu Gao's wife when he was watching the lanterns in Qingfeng Village.

Song Jiang's eyes are like a phoenix, and his eyebrows are like lying silkworms. Dripping and slippery ears hanging beads, bright eyes painted. The lips are square, and the mustache is light; The forehead is wide and the top is flat, and the skin and flesh are full.

When he sits like a tiger, he walks like a wolf. years and thirty years, there is a measure of giving to all people; The body is six feet, and he has the heart to sweep away the four seas. Ambitious and beautiful-minded.

The knife and pen dare to bully Xiao Xiangguo, and his reputation does not allow Meng Weijun.

There are two completely different genetic bloodlines in Song Jiang's body. One is to find the image of Song Jiang in various texts before the book was written in "Water Margin", and compare the deeds of Guo Xie in "Historical Records" with the deeds of Song Jiang in "Water Margin", and sort out the bloodline of Song Jiang from the original simple "brave man" to the "godfather of rivers and lakes" in "Water Margin". The other is the temple bloodline.

Without Song Jiang's leadership, the heroes of Liangshan might not be able to unite and form a united front against **. Without the cohesion and organization provided by Song Jiang, the outlaws would probably be more easily defeated by the ** army.

In addition, without Song Jiang's leadership, the heroes of Liangshan may not be able to achieve success and fame in **. The story revolves around a group of outlaws who, under the leadership of Song Jiang, become a formidable force to challenge the corrupt ** and ultimately win the emperor's pardon.

It is worth noting that the story of "Water Margin" is a fictional work and is not based on real historical events. So if the story goes in a different direction, there's no way to ** what will happen.

In the end, it will perish in the internal fighting, because many people were forced to go to Liangshan by Song Jiang and others.

I think that in the end, they will be wiped out, and the Song Dynasty will send people to exterminate them, and their force value is not enough, so they will be exterminated in the end.

felt that he was wiped out by a net, and the Song Dynasty sent people to exterminate it but the force was not enough, so it was later exterminated.

I think in the end he should be a very powerful person, and he will become more and more influential.