If Liu Bei is dead, will Guan Yu really surrender to Cao Cao?

Not necessarily, Guan Yu has always been loyal, if Liu Bei died at that time, I think Guan Yu would find out who killed Liu Bei and cut himself after avenging Liu Bei.

If Liu Bei died, Guan Yu would not really surrender to Cao Cao, because Liu Bei was very important to him, and he might retaliate against Cao Cao.

Guan Yu will not really surrender to Cao; Guan Yu himself was the embodiment of righteousness, and he was righteous with Liu Bei Taoyuan at that time; Cao Cao just used money and beauty to tie Guan Yu up;

No. Guan Yu is Liu Bei's sworn brother, and he will not betray even if his eldest brother dies. In ancient times, this kind of righteousness was very important, so it was impossible for Guan Yu to surrender to Cao Cao.

I don't think Guan Yu will really surrender to Cao Cao. Because Guan Yu is a loyal and righteous person, he will definitely not lower his dignity to surrender to Cao Cao.

No, it won't. Guan Yu is a loyal and brave person, and people in ancient times paid great attention to integrity, not to mention that Guan Yu's character would not surrender.

Because he and Cao Cao's early encounter with each other, he was forced to surrender to Cao Cao when he was Sun Que, and he did not really surrender to Cao Cao, so he rebelled against Cao Cao in the later period.

Mainly driven by interests, he can be reused by Liu Bang's side and can have more power.

At that time, Liu Bei's army was defeated, and the three brothers Liu Guan and Zhang were separated. Guan Yu protected Liu Bei's two wives, the second lady of Gan Mi. At that time, Guan Yu was surrounded by Cao Cao, and with his martial arts, he might be able to kill it by himself, even if he couldn't kill it, it would be a big deal to die.

But he couldn't do that, because if he escaped or he died, the two sisters-in-law would not end well. So in order to take care of the overall situation, he temporarily surrendered to Cao Cao. And to make it clear:

Only the Han is lowered, not the Cao. And as long as there is information about Liu Bei, he will leave. At the same time, in order to repay Cao Cao for not killing, he was willing to set up a big attack for Cao Cao before leaving.

So after beheading Yan Liang and Wen Chou, there was the story of Guan Yu traveling thousands of miles and looking for Liu Bei.

At the same time, there is also a saying among the people that "the body is in Cao Ying, and the heart is in Han", which shows Guan Yu's loyalty.

was once caught by Cao Cao, but Guan Yu and Liu Bei had a deep brotherly relationship, and swore that he and Liu Bei were friends of life and death, so Guan Yu killed Yan Liang and repaid Cao Cao and left the Wei State, Cao Cao deliberately let Guan Yu go, because Cao Cao had long thought that Guan Yu would leave and rewarded Guan Yu.

surrendered, but he still went to Liu Bei.

Liu Bei's army was defeated, and Guan Yu protected Liu Bei's wife and was besieged by Cao Cao in Tu Mountain, and Cao Cao wanted to persuade Guan Yu to surrender and let Zhang Liao be a lobbyist. Zhang Liao said: "Today, there are Cao Gong's soldiers on all sides, if my brother does not surrender, he will die; It is useless to die in vain, if you surrender to Cao Gong; But he inquired about Liu Yuanjun's message, and if he knew where, he would go to it.

One can protect the second wife, the other does not betray the covenant of Taoyuan, and the third can leave a useful body: with these three stools, the brother should be detailed. "Guan Yu said three conditions, one, I swore with the emperor's uncle to support the Han family, I will only descend to the Han Emperor today, not to Cao Cao; Both, the second sister-in-law asked for support for the emperor's uncle, and everyone was not allowed to come to the door; The three, but knowing the whereabouts of Uncle Liu Huang, no matter how many miles away, he should resign:

If one of the three is missing, it will not be surrendered. "

Therefore, Guan Yu surrendered to Emperor Xian of the Han Dynasty, and the reason for surrender was that he didn't want to die, wanted to protect Liu Bei's wife, and had the opportunity to assist Liu Bei again.

Extension: Guan Yu (?) 220), Ziyunchang, a native of Xie Liang in Hedong (now Yuncheng, Shanxi), a famous general in the late Eastern Han Dynasty, followed Liu Bei to various places in the early days, was captured by Cao Cao, and killed Yuan Shao's general Yan Liang in Baimapo, and was known as the enemy of 10,000 people together with Zhang Fei.

After the Battle of Chibi, Liu Bei assisted Zhou Yu of Eastern Wu to attack Cao Ren of Nanjun, and did not send Guan Yu to the north to block Cao Cao's reinforcements. Liu Bei entered Yizhou, and Guan Yu stayed in Jingzhou.

In the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an, Guan Yu surrounded Xiangfan, Cao Cao sent Yu Ban to come to reinforcements, Guan Yu captured Yu Ban, killed Pang De, and shocked Huaxia, Cao Cao had wanted to move the capital to avoid its sharpness. Later, Cao Cao sent Xu Huang to reinforcements, and Lü Meng of Eastern Wu attacked Jingzhou again, and Guan Yu was defeated and killed.

After Guan Yu died, he was gradually deified and revered by the people as "Guan Gong", also known as the beautiful bearded man. The Qing Dynasty was enshrined as "the Emperor of Loyalty, Righteousness, Martial Spirit, Benevolence, Courage and Might", and was worshiped as the "Martial Saint", which was as famous as the "Literary Sage" Confucius. "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" respects him as the head of the "Five Tiger Generals" of Shu State, and Mao Zonggang calls it the "righteousness" of the "Three Uniques" of "Romance".

Chen Shuang said confidently. Ann, I think you misunderstood, I just ......Angel suddenly stopped in the middle of speaking, changed his tone and said: If there is a real conflict, what will you do? ”

Any video data related to the basement shall be kept, and no information about the basement shall be disseminated to anyone, and violators shall ......Kill! Angel, how did you choose to live here? After finding a slot, An Quan asked.

Angel, what are you looking for me? Angel? "Sister Angel, you're kidding us.

Alas! An Quan sighed, and said secretly in his heart: It's over, it seems that I will continue to live in this colorful world in the future.

Now that he was annoyed, on a whim, did you think that with the way you are now, you can protect Phyllis? After a pause, Gurion urgently said: Phyllis, come out, I have no ill intentions, there is no treasure in this room

Guan Yu and the two imperial sisters-in-law were besieged by Cao Bing, and Guan Yu was forced to surrender to Cao Cao in order to save the lives of the two imperial sisters-in-law.

thought that Liu Bei was dead, and he had to take the responsibility of protecting his sister-in-law.

Cao Cao. Don't kill Guan Yu.

There are several reasons for this:

1, Cao Cao wanted to influence Guan Yu. Guan Yu is a tiger general, Wen Jiu beheaded Huaxiong and killed Yan Liang.

Wen Chou, among the ten thousand armies, is like a tiger entering the flock, bravely covering the world. Cao Cao has always attached importance to talents, hoping to influence Guan Yu by treating him well, and finally let him defect to his command. 2. Cao Cao wanted to take the initiative morally.

Guan Yu is a loyal and righteous person, who is righteous and righteous, and will repay his kindness. Guan Yu surrendered to Cao Cao, feeling that Cao Cao treated him well, and left him only after making great contributions for Cao Cao. For Liu Bei.

Guan Yu never forgot it. Cao Cao gave Guan Yu a new robe, but Guan Yu wore it inside the old robe, because the old robe was given by Liu Bei, Guan Yu said that the old robe was worn outside, and seeing it was like seeing Liu Bei himself. Cao Cao gave Guan Yu a thousand miles of red rabbit horses.

Guan Yu thanked him again and again, saying that if he knew Liu Bei's whereabouts and rode a thousand-mile horse, he would be able to see Liu Bei within a day. Cao Cao said with deep feelings: "The owner does not forget his roots, and he is a righteous man in the world!"

In addition, when Guan Yu surrendered to Cao Cao, there were "three covenants", one of which was that if he knew Liu Bei's whereabouts, Guan Yu would go after him, and Cao Cao agreed.

3, Cao Cao wanted to educate the soldiers around him. To educate the soldiers around him, Guan Yu is a living textbook. I heard that Guan Yu hung the seal and sealed the gold, and walked out of the city gate, Cai Yang, the general under Cao Cao.

I want to lead the troops to capture Guan Yu back. Cao Cao stopped him and said to the soldiers who followed him: "Guan Yu does not forget his old master, he understands when he comes, and understands when he goes, what a big husband!"

Learn from him." Cao Cao was a good person to the end, and simply brought dozens of people to see off Guan Yu. Cao.

Guan Yu arrived in Liu Bei's arms, and Cao Cao did not kill him because Cao Cao was a person who cherished heroes very much, and he felt that Guan Yu was very appreciated by him, so he couldn't bear it. For this reason, the measure of killing Guan Yu and Cao Cao is not so small.

Liu Bei once defected to Cao Cao, Cao Cao's adviser Cheng Yu once persuaded Cao Cao to kill Liu Bei, Cao Cao's other adviser Guo Jia thought that Liu Bei was a popular hero, and took the initiative to defect to Cao Cao, killing Liu Bei would hinder the world's heroes from obeying Cao Cao's heart, Cao Cao and Guo Jia had the same opinion, so they did not kill Liu Bei.

In 198 AD, Lu Bu sent troops to attack Liu Bei, Liu Bei defected to Cao Cao after the defeat, since ancient heroes know heroes, Cao Cao has long seen that Liu Bei is a rare hero, knowing that he will not live under the people for a long time, on the issue of whether to kill Liu Bei, Cao Cao's advisers have different views, Cheng Yu believes that Liu Bei is an ambitious person, will never sincerely return to Cao Cao, leave Liu Bei by his side, sooner or later will cause trouble, it is better to kill to avoid future troubles. However, Guo Jia believes that Cao Cao's great cause has not been accomplished, and there is still the strongest opponent in the north, Yuan Shao, who needs to win the hearts of heroes in the world, and Liu Bei has a high prestige among the people and princes. Because before that, Cao Cao learned a lesson and thought that Guo Jia was right, so he kept Liu Bei by his side and treated him generously, neither reusing him nor killing him. Hope!

It's useless to kill him, and letting him go will also show his bearing and love for talent. And Liu Bei's power was very small at that time, and he was attached to Yuan Shao, so Cao Cao didn't take Liu Bei seriously, and even if he let Guan Yu go back, it couldn't affect his own interests.

Because Cao Cao cherishes talents very much, and Guan Yu is such a talent, Cao Cao cherishes talents, and also hopes that his policy of recruiting talents can make Guan Yu heartfelt to himself, he is indeed very good to Guan Yu, but in the end Guan Yu still chose Liu Bei.

Because Cao Cao cherishes talents, Guan Yu is a big hero, and Cao Cao is reluctant to kill.

Cao Cao respects him as a man, and the feeling that heroes cherish heroes.

Because he is both civil and military, Cao Cao still wants to use him as a talent.

This is a story in the romance, it is said that when Liu Bei and Cao Cao fought, Guan Yu was left to guard the house, and then he didn't fight, Liu Bei ran away by himself, Cao Cao led people to surround Guan Yu and Liu Bei's wife and children, Guan Yu surrendered to Cao Cao for the safety of Liu Bei's wife and children, but made an agreement, to the effect that he would not fight with Liu Bei, and then Liu Bei had the right to change jobs at any time as long as he needed.

Later, when Cao Cao and Yuan Shao were fighting, Guan Yu beheaded Yan Liang and helped Cao Cao relieve the siege of the White Horse, and then left in order to find Liu Bei, this sentence is a praise for Guan Yu.

But don't take the story of Romance seriously, except for Guan Erye, who did surrender in the official history, it is all made up. Yan Liang, Hua Xiong and Guan Yu have nothing to do with each other.

1. Guan Yu temporarily surrendered in order to protect Liu Bei's wife.

2, Guan Yu descended to Han and did not descend to Cao and fiercely.

3, Guan Yu and Cao Cao made an appointment to make friends, and once they knew Liu Bei's whereabouts, they would never tell Cao Cao to leave Cao Cao.