Dream of Red Mansions The Jia family went from decline to copying, was someone designed?

Updated on culture 2024-04-24
11 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    In the Dream of Red Mansions, the Jia family went from decline to copying, which can be said to be very embarrassingBut this is definitely not by design. There is no one in Jiafu who can carry the hope of the family in the future, and there is no successor, so it is impossible to maintain the continued progress of a big family, and the people of the Jia family are too much to pursue a luxurious life and are greedy for pleasure, which is also a major reason for the decline of Jiafu. <>

    Although Jiafu has a large family and a prosperous population, there is no male in Jiafu who has the ability to gain fame through the imperial examination. Even Jia Baoyu is just a little clever and witty, but Jia Baoyu himself doesn't like to be an official, and his talent is far from enough to be famous. Therefore, the future of Jiafu can be said to be bleak, no one can maintain the prosperity of the family, no one can be an official in the court, and no matter how big the family business is, it will be ruined.

    Moreover, the people of Jiafu are generally very extravagant, and they like to live a life of luxury and waste. Just one of Qin Keqing's funerals, they were held very grandly, which can be said to far exceed the specifications of ordinary families, and it was this extravagant atmosphere that also led to the decline of Jiafu. After all, they only know how to overdraft their family's property infinitely, and only know how to spend money, but few people can win benefits and honor for their family.

    This kind of luxury that does not know how to control is also the root cause of everyone's mind to be more content with pleasure and unable to forge ahead. <>

    And there are some other reasons why Cao Xueqin did not write it, after all, even if the people in Jiafu are officials in the imperial court, they are very powerless, and it can be said that there is no threat to the imperial court. Therefore, as long as anyone in the court has an opinion about Jiafu, they can be eradicated by stratagem at any time. Therefore, there is no capable person in Jiafu in the imperial court, although Jiafu is big, but there is no person who can straighten his waist in the imperial court.

    Therefore, the once prosperous Jia Mansion was destroyed in one fell swoop, and the destruction of such a large family was really shocking and sad.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    The Jia family from the decline to the copying of the family is indeed a design, and the person who designed the Jia family is the emperor and other royal families, because the Jia family belongs to the Rongguo Mansion, and they have glory and power at that time, so the royal family intends to weaken the power of the Jia family.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    In "Dream of Red Mansions", the Jia family went from decline to raiding the family, which was framed and designed by someone. The mastermind behind the scenes is Dai Quan. Dai Quan is the emperor's person again. Emperor Taishang is only superficially favored by the Jia family.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    In Dream of Red Mansions, the Jia family went from decay to raiding, and there is no obvious evidence in the book that it was designed by others. The so-called "prosperity must decline", the Jia family will be decadent sooner or later.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Yes, the reason why the Jia family was raided is by no means as frivolous as the popular version of "Dream of Red Mansions" says. Since "the vast white land is really clean", it shows that all the children of the Ningrong Mansion of the Jia family have lost everything, and the trees have fallen and scattered.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    As the saying goes, if a tree is big, it will decline. At that time, the four major families could be described as very beautiful, but this would also make other families jealous. Because the Zhen Mansion harbored criminals, there were ** slanderous rumors in front of the emperor, which affected the Jia Mansion.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Dream of Red Mansions: If Jia's family is not raided, can there be fewer tragedies? If nothing happens, they may be able to cut back on their expenses year by year, but at least there is no such tragedy. In fact, being raided was not the reason for the final ending, but because of the incompetence of these men, which led to a tragic situation in this family.

    If they don't raid their homes, they can indeed ensure that life is not so much tribulation, but in fact, if these men do something, there will be no tragedy in the end.

    If there had not been a major change, perhaps there would have been fewer tragedies

    In Dream of Red Mansions, the Jia family is a very wealthy family, and if their family had not been raided in the end, perhaps there would have been less tragedy. For example, if you do something like raiding your family, you will contribute all your property to the country, so they will have nothing in their family, how can they make a fortune? If there is no such thing as raiding the house, maybe they will slowly reduce the number of people who open the hall to balance the difficulties, and it can only be said that they can't afford to support too many people, but such a tragedy will not happen.

    Being raided is not the end, mainly because of the incompetence of the men

    Whether the Jia family can avoid the final ending, in fact, I think that the reason for being raided is not the main reason, but because they have a fatal mistake. If it weren't for this, maybe they would still have a situation where they would be lucky not to be raided, that is, the men of the Jia family have a little ability. But what is the end result?

    None of them were capable, so it was the situation that led to the eventual tragedy.

    If the men had done something, perhaps there would have been no tragedy

    All of these men in Jia Block's house are like girls, and no girl even has the idea of pretending, and after raiding the house, they live in Qiansan. The most painful thing about this family is that if their man could have been a little more capable, maybe there would not have been a tragedy. If they don't raid their homes, they can at least live an ordinary life, and at least they can keep their families.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    From the perspective of sympathy for Jia Baoyu and the twelve hairpins of Jinling, the Jia family does not raid the house, which can indeed ensure that everyone's lives are not so bad.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    The direct reason for the fall of the Jia family in "Dream of Red Mansions" was to raid the family, and the raid was also because their family guessed that the royal cherry blossoms were extravagant and spikes were wasted on money, and there was no successor to the descendants. In our modern family, we should pay attention to the fact that money is not exposed

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    The ending of Jiafu being raided in "Dream of Red Mansions" is hinted at at the beginning. Jiafu has been going downhill, drunk on life, politically forming parties for personal gain, children and grandchildren are not successful, and it is only a matter of time before they eat their old books and raid their homes.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    The reason is that Jia Fu has no real backer in the palace, and Jia Yuanchun is dead.

Related questions
8 answers2024-04-24

The people of Ning Guofu, Jia Zhen's son, and Qin Keqing's master, have an improper relationship with Wang Xifeng, but he should call Wang Xifeng his aunt.

3 answers2024-04-24

"Dream of Red Mansions" Jia Jing and Jia Zheng and Jia Yu are cousins, Jia Zheng and Jia Yu are brothers, Jia Jing gave birth to Jia Zhen, and Jia Yu gave birth to Jia Lian. >>>More

21 answers2024-04-24

Jia Yucun has nothing to do with the Jia family, Yucun is from Huzhou, Zhejiang, and the Jia family is from Jinling, not the same clan. It was only because Yucun wanted to use the power of Jiafu to be an official that he climbed a relative of Jia Zheng's nephew, which shows that Jia Yucun is a very realistic person. >>>More

4 answers2024-04-24

Twelve golden hairpins: Lin Daiyu, Xue Baochai, Jia Yuanchun, Jia Yingchun, Jia Tanchun, Jia Xichun, Li Kun, Miaoyu, Shi Xiangyun, Wang Xifeng, Jia Qiaojie, Qin Keqing. >>>More

7 answers2024-04-24

Speaking of "Dream of Red Mansions".

hates Lin Daiyu the most. >>>More