Why do you say that Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang are the culprits behind Zhang Fei s assassination? What

Credentials are talking nonsense with their eyes openZhang Fei's death was self-inflicted, Liu Bei was at most lax in discipline, and Zhuge Liang took the blame out of thin air.

Zhang Fei, whose name is Yide, was born in the late Eastern Han Dynasty, one of the five tiger generals of Shu Han during the Three Kingdoms period, and was regarded as a brother by Liu Bei, the lord of Shu, together with Guan Yu. Zhang Fei was originally a private entrepreneur with superior family conditions, and because he was moved by Liu Bei's righteousness, he resolutely gave up Wanguan furniture and raised troops with Liu BeiIt can be said that Liu Bei's first pot of gold was obtained from Zhang Fei。So no matter from which point of view, Liu Bei should be grateful to Zhang Fei.

Zhang Fei is short-tempered, although he is a general, he does not know how to sympathize with soldiers。loves to drink, drink more, drink more, and go crazy when you drink more, especially like to whip your subordinates for fun, so Zhang Fei has no cronies around him, and everyone is respectful and afraid of Zhang Fei. Because of this problem, Zhang once gave up the Xuzhou City that Liu Bei had finally gotten to Lu Bu, and Liu Bei also reminded Zhang Fei more than once that he must control himself and not delay the big thing, but the nature of the country is easy to change, although Zhang Fei verbally agreed, but he never took action, Liu Bei because of the relationship with Zhang Fei, it is not easy to go deeper, so he can only let Zhang Fei continue to let himself fly.

Although Zhuge Liang is Liu Bei's military advisor, his theoretical power is greater than Zhang Fei's, but in his heart, Zhang Fei never took Zhuge Liang in his eyes. In Zhang Fei's eyes, only the eldest brother Liu Bei can order himself, and as for Zhuge Liang, he is just working for Liu Bei. Zhuge Liang himself is well aware of this, therefore,Except for official business, Zhuge Liang will never interfere in Guan Yu and Zhang Fei's private life

And Zhuge Liang, who has always put the overall situation first, naturally knows the importance of Zhang Fei to the Shuhan Group, so no matter what he thinks, Zhuge Liang will not secretly plot to kill Zhang Fei, after all, this is a matter of cutting off his arm.

After Guan Yu carelessly lost Jingzhou, Zhang Fei drank more violently, and his subordinates beat him harder. Finally,Zhang Fei's two little-known generals couldn't bear it anymore, so taking advantage of Zhang Fei's hangover and not waking up, he sneaked into Zhang Fei's sleeping tent and stabbed Zhang Fei to death with a short knife.

Although Zhang Fei has the courage to be unstoppable, his character shortcomings are too obviousZhang Fei also died of his violent temper

Because Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang opposed to taking Eastern Wu, Zhang Fei was depressed and asked to wear linen and filial piety, and he was even more brutal to the sergeants.

Because Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang were actually able to consider that it was completely impossible to prepare so many things in a short period of time. If you have to force your subordinates to do this, you will only force them to rebel. But they didn't stop Zhang Fei.

This claim is baseless. Zhang Fei is the general of Shu Han, what good is it for Zhuge Liang and Liu Bei to harm him, there is no basis for saying that Zhang Fei was harmed by them.

"Romance of the Three Kingdoms" Kong Ming saw through Liu Bei after Zhang Fei's death.

After receiving the news of Guan Yu's death, Liu Bei's first reaction was to lead his troops back to Jingzhou to avenge Guan Yu. Zhang Fei is also the same as the honor, and he wants to follow Liu Bei to investigate and reform the expedition and avenge the second brother. But Zhang Fei, who borrowed wine to drown his sorrows, was killed by the soldiers and cut off his head because he whipped the soldiers to vent his hatred.

And when Liu Bei learned the news of Zhang Fei's killing, he just whispered 4 words: I know. Then he continued to lead the army forward.

After Liu Bei suffered a big defeat in Yiling, hundreds of thousands of elites were burned clean by Lu Xun. Liu Bei himself was almost killed in the fire, but fortunately, the guards desperately protected him and fled back to White Emperor City.

After Zhuge Liang learned the details of the matter, he finally saw that Liu Bei's true face was clear. It turned out that Liu Bei had been pretending all along, his brotherly concept was not so important, and his expedition this time was just to take back Jingzhou, not revenge.

Zhuge Liang's real disappointment:

Liu Bei's series of behaviors, although they did not make Zhuge Liang completely cold, but in the end, Zhuge Liang was disappointed in him. This disappointment really turned into a chill after Zhang Fei's death.

Zhang Fei's death starts with Guan Yu's death. Guan Yu guarded Jingzhou, but was attacked by Eastern Wu, and finally lost his life, and Shu lost the treasure land of Jingzhou. When Liu Bei heard the news, he was very angry, and even personally led an army to conquer Sun Quan.

In the eyes of everyone, Liu Bei's personal revenge for Dongwu was to avenge Guan Yu and attach importance to the brotherhood between him and Guan Yu.

But if you think about it carefully, if Guan Yu didn't lose Jingzhou. Jingzhou was the base that Liu Bei took after a long period of hard work, but it was captured by Eastern Wu when Guan Yu was stationed, and Liu Bei must be unwilling. In addition, the relationship between Shu and Wu was rigid at that time, and a legitimate reason was needed to tear up the alliance and declare war.

And Guan Yu's death is just an opportunity.

Zhang Fei was killed by Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang, this incident is naturally fake, and it can't be true.

Zhang Fei is a famous general of Shu State, one of the five tiger generals in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, and Liu Bei Taoyuan is a friend of eight worships. Whether it is from the ** of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms or the historical records of the Three Kingdoms, Zhang Fei died of an accidental assassination, not a murder by Liu Bei or Zhuge Liang.

If Liu Bei wants to murder Zhang Fei, he needs a motive, and Liu Bei has no motive to murder Zhang Fei. At that time, Guan Yu, the general of Shu, had just been defeated and killed in Jingzhou, and Shu lost his troops and lost his territory, and Liu Bei, after being proclaimed emperor, was ready to send the battle of Dongyiling to recover the lost territory, and mobilized Zhang Fei's army to intend to go out together. At this point in time, it was when Liu Bei was preparing to send troops to Eastern Wu, even if Liu Bei was dissatisfied with Zhang Fei and wanted to deal with Zhang Fei, he should not choose this juncture, the army did not move before the general, which was an extremely unlucky thing in ancient times.

And take 10,000 steps back and say, if Liu Bei really wants to murder Zhang Fei, with his position in Shu, does he need to go to Zhuge Liang to conspire? Is this looking down on Liu Bei too much, and Zhuge Liang too much. Then some people may say, what if Zhuge Liang wants to murder Liu Bei who Zhang Fei came to find?

What is the reason why Zhuge Liang wants to kill Zhang Fei, if the reason is justified and bright, then it is not a murder, but to expose the crime of another general in front of the monarch, it is not a murder, and if the reason is not enough for outsiders, then what kind of reason can make Liu Bei abandon a general who will never abandon him from the beginning to his birth and death.

Zhang Fei's death was due to assassination, which is clearly recorded in both the Romance of the Three Kingdoms ** and the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. But Zhang Fei is the world's general, the world's recognized enemy of 10,000 people, if you want to assassinate Zhang Fei, you need to take a great risk, assuming that Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang really want to murder Zhang Fei, with the status of these two people in Shu, coupled with Zhuge Liang's strategy, how can they not use such a risky method of assassination, such as poisoning is much safer. Another point is that after Zhang Fei was killed, the person who assassinated Zhang Fei was holding Zhang Fei's head and running to Dongwu, which doesn't make sense, if it was arranged by Liu Bei or Zhuge Liang, then after the assassin succeeded, shouldn't he take Zhang Fei's head to Liu Bei to take the credit, what did he do with it?

Could it be that Liu Bei wanted to find an excuse to attack Eastern Wu, Liu Bei killed one of his tiger generals in order to find an excuse, this logic doesn't make sense, let's not talk about it first, the problem is that Liu Bei had already decided to send troops when Zhang Fei died, and he asked Zhang Fei to bring troops to converge, which shows that Liu Bei had a reason to send troops to Eastern Wu.

Zhang Fei's death was completely an accident, in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, it was Zhang Fei who asked his subordinates to make white helmets and white armor to cause the disaster, and in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Zhang Fei was forcibly killed by his subordinates, no matter which is to say that Zhang Fei was assassinated, and the assassin took Zhang Fei's head to Soochow. Therefore, whether it was Liu Bei or Zhuge Liang, there was no reason to kill Zhang Fei, and Zhang Fei did not die from their murder.

I don't think so. After all, Zhang Fei is Liu Bei's good brother and a fierce general under Liu Bei, and Liu Bei should not harm him with Zhuge Liang.

No. This matter is not true, because Zhang Fei's relationship with Zhuge Liang and Liu Bei is very good, so it is impossible for them to kill Zhang Fei.

This matter should not be true, mainly because Zhang Fei's death actually has little to do with Zhuge Liang and Liu Bei. It can be said that it is indirectly killed.

Zhang Fei's death in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" has always been a very tragic episode, Zhang Fei has a straightforward personality, a hot temper, is brave and good at fighting, and Liu Bei and Guan Yu have become brothers of the opposite sex. Since then, he has been following Liu Bei, making great contributions to Liu Bei's cause of reviving the Han Dynasty, and saving Liu Bei's name several times. Such a fierce general was betrayed and killed by his own men.

However, regarding Zhang Fei's death, some scholars pointed out that it was a conspiracy between Zhuge Liang and Liu Bei. There are several reasons for this. First, Zhang Fei did not have a clear political position, and he initially joined the army only to make heroes from all walks of life, which was different from Liu Bei and Guan Yu.

The second is that after Liu Bei restored the Han dynasty and unified the world, he did not want to share the world with his former brothers of the opposite sex. Therefore, Liu Bei allowed Zhuge Liang to give full play to Zhang Fei's courage and strategy, so that the means calculated Zhang Fei, but he did not listen to the advice, began to drink indulgently, and whipped the soldiers after drinking. and let the two dangerous soldiers be by Zhang Fei's side without admonishing them, and finally made these two murder Zhang Fei.

In my opinion, these reasons are a bit nitpicky, maliciously scandalizing the image of Liu Bei Zhuge Liang。Not to mention the previous relationship between Liu Bei and Zhang Fei, even Zhuge Liang and Zhang Fei were very good friends, and Zhang Fei treated him as a brother. In the official history, Zhuge Liang later wanted Zhang Fei's two daughters to be queens.

Moreover, Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang are both righteous people, Liu Bei will not want to lose this fierce general and delay the great cause of reviving the Han Dynasty.

Zhang Fei's death was caused by his mistreatment of the soldiers, and he did not conspire with Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang to frame Zhang Fei at all, and Liu Bei had reminded Zhang Fei many times a long time ago that he must treat his soldiers well.

Because Zhuge Liang and Liu Bei felt that Zhang Fei was too reckless, and if he was kept, he might even harm his own big things, so the two of them teamed up to harm Zhang Fei.

Sending Zhang Fei to send troops in this battle was simply impossible to defeat, but Liu Bei didn't say that Zhuge Liang arranged it like this.

Because Zhang Fei wanted to avenge Guan Yu, but the situation at that time was not suitable for sending troops, Zhang Fei forcibly sent troops and was then killed, so some people say that Zhuge Liang and Liu Bei killed Zhang Fei.

After Zhang Fei's death, Liu Bei only said one sentence. Hey, he's dead. Zhuge Liang understood that Liu Bei's heart was an indifferent and ruthless person, so Zhuge Liang saw through Liu Bei and no longer served Liu Bei sincerely.

Moreover, Zhang Fei's death was expected by Liu Bei, after Guan Yu's death, Zhang Fei's temperament became more violent, and he often beat and scolded his subordinates, which was not good for the ruler, and he could not stabilize the morale of the army, and if the morale of the army was weak, he could not better lead the troops to fight. But Zhang Fei, as Liu Bei's brother-in-law, has no way to explain directly, but he has already guessed Zhang Fei's ending.

1. After Guan Yu's death, Liu Bei vowed to avenge Guan Yu. When Guan Yu died on the battlefield, Liu Bei regretted it very much and vowed to avenge Guan Yu. It's like his own brother is dead, and Zhang Fei expressed his determination and vowed to avenge Guan Yu, which made Zhang Fei and his generals excited, and felt that Liu Bei was a person who valued love and righteousness, so they all followed Liu Bei, and Liu Bei also gained a large number of little fans.

Second, after Zhang Fei died, Liu Bei sighed lightly, he died. Compared with Guan Yu's death, Zhang Fei's death seems to be just a small minion to Liu Bei. is also Liu Bei's sworn brother, why is there such a big difference, in fact, it is not difficult to understand.

Guan Yu has always been a loyal, courageous, brave and resourceful character, but Zhang Fei is a straight person, Liu Bei originally liked Guan Yu a little more. Therefore, Liu Bei felt different about the deaths of these two brothers.

Third, after the death of Zhang Fei and Guan Yu, Liu Bei did not have to hide it. Liu Bei is a person who likes power, for Liu Bei, nothing has a status is more important, Liu Bei still looked hypocritical at the beginning, this is to gain everyone's support, but with the increase of his rights, Guan Yu is dead, Zhang Fei is dead again, his rights are at his fingertips, for him, everything that happens is for the imperial power, so this kind of behavior makes Zhuge Liang feel terrible.

He said the words "I know" and said it calmly as before, only to realize that he was too calm, and began to pretend to cry bitterly.

After Zhang Fei's death, Liu Bei said, "Alas, he died." was very indifferent, allowing Zhuge Liang to see Liu Bei's true face of Lushan.