Why did Zhuge Liang have to give Liu Bei the death of his son Liu Feng? What is Zhuge Liang s real p

Updated on history 2024-03-07
26 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Zhuge Liang wanted Liu Bei to give his son Liu Feng death, and his purpose was not to want Liu Feng to succeed him. Liu Feng is Liu Bei's righteous son, his original surname is Kou, and he later changed his surname to Liu, and his military exploits are remarkable. And Liu Bei's biological eldest son, Liu Chan, because of the age difference, his qualifications are mediocre and his prestige is not enough.

    Zhuge Liang was worried that Liu Feng would become the crown prince, so he found a reason to give him death.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Zhuge Liang must Liu Bei die, the reason is that Liu Feng is the righteous son that Liu Bei said, and Liu Bei has his own son named Liu Chan in his later years. In order to further consolidate Liu Chan's position, giving Liu Feng to death can stabilize Liu Chan's status.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Zhuge asked Liu Bei to kill Liu Feng, and the reason for supporting Adou was very simple: orthodoxy. Because Adou is Liu Bei's flesh and blood relative, he is an orthodox descendant of the Han family.

    And Liu Feng is not Liu Bei's biological son, but was adopted by Liu Bei. Liu Bei's adopted son Liu Feng, when he was 20 years old, he was able to follow Zhao Yun and Zhang Fei to attack Yizhou, and later won Shangyong with Meng Da, which can be described as quite talented.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    Zhuge Liang believed that it was because of Liu Feng that he was killed, but his real purpose was to hope that Liu Chan would succeed to the throne smoothly and eliminate the threat of Liu Feng.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Feng is fierce and fierce, after changing the world, it will be difficult to control in the end, Zhuge Liang's words directly beat Liu Feng into the abyss, Liu Bei is still struggling with his own son, after all, Liu Chan is too young, Zhuge Liang's words directly made Liu Bei make up his mind. Why did Zhuge Liang have to let Liu Feng die? Most of them are still his own selfishness, Liu Bei already has a biological son, but he is very young, and Liu Feng is strong and healthy, if Liu Bei dies, it is very likely that there will be an internal struggle, which will weaken his own strength, and he can only give up one, Liu Feng has grown up, which means that Zhuge Liang's rights will definitely be subject to Liu Feng, so only if Liu Feng is dead, can he control Liu Chan, can he have more rights, and he will not be restricted.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    This is called crossing the river and demolishing the bridge, unloading the mill and killing the donkey. I think that Liu Bei fought in the east and west, and ran into walls everywhere. The person is middle-aged, and the son is only a few months old.

    In the war years, it is uncertain whether they will survive or not. Liu Bei saw that Liu Feng was young and handsome, martial arts and strong, and he was accustomed to fighting. So he rushed to recognize someone else as a son.

    Later, Liu Bei got the territory, and his son grew up. He also thought that Liu Feng was his son's biggest threat, so he used the excuse to kill Liu Feng. What is the sin that you really want to add?

    Even if Guan Yu doesn't die, Liu Bei will still kill Liu Feng sooner or later.

  7. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Because Liu Feng was only Liu Bei's adopted son, but he wanted to seize the throne of Shu Han, and refused to send troops when Guan Yu was on the northern expedition to Cao Wei, which led to the failure of the Northern Expedition. So Zhuge Liang had to kill him.

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Zhuge Liang asked Liu Bei to kill. dropped Liu Feng and supported Adou for a very simple reason: orthodoxy.

    Because Adou is Liu Bei's blood relative, he is an orthodox descendant of the Han nationality. However, Liu Feng was not Liu Bei's biological son, but Liu Bei adopted him. He came from a humble background, and during the Three Kingdoms period, which emphasized birth and bloodline, they were not qualified to control power.

    <> Zhuge Liang supported Liu Bei because he was an orthodox descendant of the Han Dynasty. With this status, Liu Bei could earn the high respect of other princes and attract many capable people to serve him. Adou's name is Liu Chan, and he is Liu Bei's biological son, and his bloodline has naturally been corrected, so he can obtain Zhuge Lianghe.

    The loyalty of others.

    On the other hand, Liu Feng is Liu Bei's adopted son, and when he was 20 years old, he was able to fight Yizhou with Zhao Yun and Zhang Fei. Later, he also won the battle of "Yongzheng" with Meng Da and was quite talented. But, Liu.

    Feng and Meng Da did not save Liu Bei's sworn brother Guan Yu when Guan Yu lost Jingzhou and went to Maicheng, which made Liu Bei very cold to Liu Feng. After Liu Bei occupied Hanzhong, he sent Liu Feng to assist Meng Da and forced Shangyong County Governor Shen Tu and his younger brother Shen Yi to surrender, thus occupying the three counties of Shangyong. Guan Yu captured Yu Ban, beheaded Pang De, attacked Cao Ren, flooded the Seventh Army, and shocked China and foreign countries.

    Even Cao Cao was conquered, and the capital was discussed to be moved to avoid his edge. However, when Guan Yu besieged Xiangfan, he asked Liu Feng and Meng Da to send troops to assist him. However, they believed that Shang had just occupied Jingzhou and could not easily send troops.

    Lü Mengqi attacked Jingzhou, and Guan Yu returned defeated.

    Do a detailed explanation of the problem for a detailed interpretation of the problem, I hope it will help you, if you have any questions, you can leave me a message in the comment area, you can comment with me more, if there is something wrong, you can also interact with me more, if you like the author, you can also follow me,..The likes are the biggest help to me, thank you.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    This is because Zhuge Liang wants to protect Liu Bei in this way, minimize the risks faced by Liu Bei, and also make the Shu Han regime more stable.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    Because this son is not Liu Bei's biological son, and this son's ability is very strong, in order to let Liu Bei's biological son succeed to the throne, he has to give this son to death. Zhuge Liang's real purpose is to support Liu Chan to ascend to the throne.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    Because Liu Bei's son may threaten Zhuge Liang's power, and it may also affect Liu Bei's power, he made such a decision. The main purpose is to ensure that there is no civil strife in Shu and to allow Liu Chan to inherit the position.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    Because Liu Feng is the oldest of his sons, Liu Bei cultivates the other party as his successor, after Liu Chan was born, he wanted Liu Chan to inherit the throne, considering the feelings of the whole Jingzhou Group, Liu Feng has an unruly personality and a particularly strong comprehensive ability, so it is a particularly big threat.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    Because Liu Feng has the right to compete for the position with Liu Chan, and his strength is very strong, his real purpose is to make Liu Chan the heir, and this is also to promote national unity.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    Because Liu Feng's ambition is relatively large, and he is not Liu Bei's biological son, it is very likely that he will usurp the throne after Liu Bei's death, and the most real purpose is to protect Liu Chan.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    This is because Zhuge Liang is also thinking about Liu Bei, and then also for the sake of Jiangshan Sheji, afraid that there will be a crisis of seizing the throne in the future.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    In the book "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", there was a plot where Zhuge Liang asked Liu Bei to kill his son Liu Feng, many netizens did not understand why Zhuge Liang had to kill Liu Bei's son Liu Feng, and what his purpose was.

    1. Liu Feng. <>

    When Liu Feng had not yet followed Liu Bei, Liu Bei had no heirs, so he adopted Liu Feng as his adopted son, and Liu Bei's expectations for this adopted son were very high. Fortunately, Liu Feng did not live up to Liu Bei's expectations of him, Liu Feng's ability is very strong, and many netizens said that if Liu Bei did not have his own biological son Liu Chan in the end, then the future heir of Shu Han must be Liu Feng, and if Zhuge Liang did not let Liu Bei kill Liu Feng at that time, he was very strong in the post-Three Kingdoms era, but history has no if, Liu Bei has his own son Liu Chan, and Liu Feng was also given to die, many reasons are still because of Liu Chan, And when Zhuge Liang investigated the cause of Guan Yu's death, he found that Liu Feng also indirectly caused Guan Yu's death, and after seeing Liu Feng's ambition, Zhuge Liang realized that Liu Feng couldn't stay.

    Second, Zhuge Liang's purpose.

    According to historical records, Zhuge Liang's purpose of persuading Liu Bei to kill Liu Feng is actually very simple, and it is also very logical, on the road of Liu Feng's death, Zhuge Liang just made a push, although he intended to get rid of Liu Feng, but it cannot be proved that Liu Bei had no intention of getting rid of Liu Feng, otherwise Liu Feng, as Liu Bei's adopted son, has always been loyal, and Liu Bei will not kill him because of Zhuge Liang's few words of persuasion. In fact, the biggest reason for killing Liu Bei and killing Liu Feng is politics, Liu Bei at that time already had his own biological son Liu Chan, and Liu Feng has grown up to be a person who is difficult to restrain him, in order to pave the way for Liu Chan, so Liu Feng must be killed. And Zhuge Liang's purpose is to protect Liu Bei, he wants to be this sinner, even if someone accuses him in the history books in the future, he will not accuse Liu Bei of injustice and accuse Zhuge Liang.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    I think this is done to set an example, because Liu Feng not only invaded the Montana Mausoleum, but also chose to stand by when Guan Yu was in trouble.

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-20

    Because he knew that Liu Bei's son was very scheming, and if he was not executed, he would definitely leave a relatively big disaster in the future, so he had to get rid of it.

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-19

    Because Liu Feng is Liu Bei's adopted son, his existence will have some status to Liu Chan. Therefore, Zhuge Liang must Liu Bei execute Liu Feng.

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-18

    Because Liu Feng is Liu Bei's adopted son, there will be some positions to Liu Chan. Therefore, Zhuge Liang must ask Liu Bei to execute Liu Feng.

  21. Anonymous users2024-01-17

    When Guan Yu was defeated and left Maicheng, Guan Yu actually asked Liu Feng for help, but Liu Feng did not lend a hand, which also made Liu Bei feel particularly chilled. Liu Feng disregarded the overall situation for his own personal interests, which eventually led to the killing of Guan Yu and the loss of Jingzhou. This is actually a capital crime in the eyes of Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang, so it is not surprising that Zhuge Liang suggested that Liu Bei give Liu Feng death.

    When he won the mediocrity, Liu Feng was actually quite powerful, and it was precisely because of this that Liu Bei asked him to guard the mediocrity, which was actually a kind of trust and reward for him. But after coming to Shangyong, Liu Feng was proud of his achievements, and always quarreled with Meng Da over some trivial matters, and the final result was that Meng Da took refuge in Cao Cao. The most critical point is that Liu Feng did not keep Shangyong, so Liu Bei was also very angry, after all, the three counties of Shangyong are very important cities, and this alone is enough to sentence him to death.

    Zhuge Liang's prestige in the army is actually relatively high, so he also established a lot of military regulations, and it is precisely because of this that the discipline of the Shu Han army at that time was relatively strict. And Liu Feng did violate the military order at that time, for example, he did not rescue Guan Yu, and lost Shangyong, and there were generals in his army who rebelled, if Zhuge Liang did not kill Liu Feng, then there would be no way to restrain his subordinates in the future, and it was precisely because of this that he suggested that Liu Bei kill Liu Feng. <>

    This should actually be the most important reason, because Liu Feng is indeed a very brave person. If Zhuge Liang and Liu Bei were both alive, Liu Feng might not dare to act rashly, but once these two people left, then Liu Chan would definitely not be his opponent. Therefore, in order to ensure Liu Chan's status, Zhuge Liang also suggested that Liu Bei strike first.

  22. Anonymous users2024-01-16

    Liu Feng is not Liu Bei's own son, just a righteous son, at that time Liu Feng refused to rescue Guan Yu This matter made Zhuge Liang very angry, at that time he obviously had the ability to rescue Guan Yu, but Liu Feng did not do so, so he was killed by Liu Bei.

  23. Anonymous users2024-01-15

    Liu Feng is not Liu Bei's own son, but his ability is particularly strong, Zhuge Liang will give Liu Feng death in order to let Liu Bei's own son succeed to the throne.

  24. Anonymous users2024-01-14

    His son Liu Feng was very ambitious at that time, and his existence was a threat to the Han family. Zhuge Liang must die in order to fulfill his promise and protect the Han family.

  25. Anonymous users2024-01-13

    This is because his son is not a particularly capable person, and he also places Liu Bei's throne, so Zhuge Liang asked Liu Bei to make such a choice. is worried that Liu Bei's son will betray his country, and the interests of the country can do anything for the sake of power.

  26. Anonymous users2024-01-12

    Why did Zhuge Liang suggest killing Liu Feng? Xiuyuan believes that there are three reasons!

    First, blood relationship. You must know that Liu Feng is Liu Bei's adopted son rather than Liu Bei's own son, and you must know that that the era at that time was an era that attached great importance to blood relations. Do you still remember the green forest and red eyebrows, how powerful they were at that time, but they still have to set up a person surnamed Liu to stabilize the morale of the army, why is this, it is because of that era, the grandson is the right, and the concubine is the second, let alone the righteous son!

    Regarding his move, some people say that it was because Liu Bei had no heirs at that time, so he got a son to prepare first. There is also a saying that Liu Chan was already born at that time, so the relevant public strongly opposed this matter, "Brother has a son, why use a moth?" Then there will be chaos.

    In any case, Liu Feng is not Liu Bei's flesh and blood, and it stands to reason that there should be no issue of inheritance, unless Liu Bei really can't give birth to a son.

    Clause. Second, the future Shu Han or for the future. You must know that Liu Feng's prestige is higher than Liu Chan's, whether it is in the army or among officers, the two are like the sun and the moon!

    It is because of this that Zhuge Liang is worried. You must know that it is very common for sons who have rights to move to the throne since ancient times, and Zhuge Liang is to prevent this, because he knows that Liu Feng has a violent temper, and if there is a little unstable factor in the future, he will definitely be unstable. And Zhuge Liang chose to get rid of him because he saw this, one for the future of Shu Han, and the other for his own hard work!

    Clause. 3. Feelings. You must know that the year Liu Chan was born was the time when Zhuge Liang was invited out by Liu Bei Sangu Thatched House.

    At that time, Zhuge Liang and Liu Bei were "like fish in water, sleeping at the same table, and waking up and collapsing together" and Liu Chan? Maybe it's around, if that's the case, Liu Chan is Zhuge Liang who grew up, can he be so emotionless? There is another aspect that shows the relationship between Liu Chan and Zhuge Liang!

    Do you still remember Liu Bei, Emperor Baidi, and the city of Tuogu? What did he say? He said that he asked Liu Chan to treat Zhuge Liang as his father, and this point, coupled with the above point, is enough to prove that Zhuge Liang's feelings for Liu Chan are greater than Liu Feng's, so Zhuge Liang is biased towards Liu Chan in the face of Liu Chan and Liu Fengfeng.

Related questions
13 answers2024-03-07

First, those who have seen the Three Kingdoms know that guarding the street pavilion is the most important part of the success of the First Northern Expedition, because the front of the Northern Expedition is too long, and the first thing to solve is the problem of food and grass for the soldiers. >>>More

15 answers2024-03-07

It is indeed Xu Shu's recommendation, and it is also because of Sima Decao's recommendation, Pei Songzhi's note)!! >>>More

21 answers2024-03-07

After Liu Bei's death, the national strength of Shu began to weaken, and the time was also lucky, the national fortune began to decline, and Zhuge Liang led his troops to fight also showed a trend of decline, and he never won any battles again, which is related to several reasons. The time and place are favorable, sometimes the influence of fortune is great, when the good fortune passes, it gradually shows a trend of decadence, and Zhuge Liang has never fought a beautiful battle again. >>>More

28 answers2024-03-07

Everyone knows Guan Yu, when he was still selling dates, he met Liu Bei and Zhang Fei, and the three of them didn't know each other, so they became brothers. Later, through their own efforts, the three of them made a career, but they were defeated and died when they were in full swing, and the strange thing is that Zhuge Liang was not sad at all when he learned that Guan Yu died because of the battle. Things have to start when Guan Yu was guarding Jingzhou. >>>More

17 answers2024-03-07

Cao Wei actually has no one to hold the post of prime minister anymore. After all, as the head of a hundred officials, the prime minister's power is too great, and if it is not restricted, it will inevitably conflict with the emperor's power.