What do you think of Zhao Kuo? How did Zhao Kuo die

Zhao Kuo's ability is unquestionable. Especially a young man, commanding a 40w+ army, the whole army can still maintain order in the case of cutting off supplies - being able to do this shows that Zhao Kuo's leadership ability is far beyond ordinary people. Zhao Kuo took the initiative to attack, and there were originally a lot of helplessness - the failure of Zhao's diplomacy led to the refusal of Qi and other major powers to provide food aid to Zhao at a critical moment, causing King Zhao to have to make up his mind to gamble to the death.

In terms of national strength, Lian Po's strategy is no longer suitable for Zhao, especially considering the background that Qi does not send food (aid to Zhao) and Wei Chu does not send troops (attack Qin). Zhao held out alone in Changping for 2 years, and Lian Po's tactics seemed invincible, but in fact they came at the cost of consuming a lot of food and money (repairing fortifications). Persisting like this, Zhao Guo really couldn't hold on, and before the Qin army broke through Changping, Zhao Guo himself would finish the calf first.

Therefore, King Zhao must use a young and promising general like Zhao Kuo to make a big gamble on national fortune. Both horizontal and vertical are defeated, and a big gamble may be able to save Zhao Guo. As for the anti-intrigues.

It's good to listen to it, modern people always think of the ancients as stupid, but they don't know who is the real ignorance and who is the one who will make future generations mourn.

Zhao Kuo is familiar with the art of war, but he has no real combat experience, so he is a soldier on paper. Judging from Zhao Kuo's deeds, all theories must be combined with reality and proceed from practice in order to play the greatest role.

Talking on paper, there is no real talent and real learning, the descendants of the generals, and the celebrity effect kills a group of people.

The typical one talked about on paper is very knowledgeable but I don't know how to use it.

The talk we see on paper is a fragment of Zhao Kuo, and it does not represent the whole story.

Zhao Kuo has been learning the art of war since he was a child, commenting on military affairs, thinking that there is no comparable to him in the world. once commented on military affairs with his father Zhao Hao, but Zhao Hao couldn't refute him, but he didn't praise him. Zhao Kuo's mother asked Zhao Hao the reason for this, and Zhao Hao said, "War is a dangerous occasion, and Zhao Kuo discusses it too easily.

If King Zhao doesn't let him be a general, if he must be made a general, the person who makes Zhao Jun fail must be Zhao Kuo himself. ”

After Zhao Kuo replaced Lian Po, he completely changed the original discipline and regulations and replaced the original officers. When Bai Qi, the general of the Qin State, heard about it, he dispatched unpredictable troops, pretending to be defeated by Zhao Kuo and retreating, while La Xizhi cut off the grain route of the Zhao army and divided the Zhao army into two, and the morale of the Zhao army could not be unified. Trapped for more than 40 days, the Zhao army was very hungry, Zhao Kuo personally led Lu Min's elite soldiers to fight, and the Qin army killed Zhao Kuo with an arrow.

Zhao Kuo's troops were defeated, and more than 400,000 Zhao troops were surrendered by the Qin State, and the Qin State buried all of them alive.

Zhao Kuo was shot and killed by the Qin army during the breakout of the Battle of Changping. Zhao Kuo was a native of Zhao during the Warring States Period, in 260 BC, the Qin army and the Zhao army confronted each other in Changping, the Qin army repeatedly challenged, and King Zhao Xiaocheng was anxious to win, and replaced the veteran Lian Po with Zhao Kuo. Zhao Kuoyi reversed Lian Po's defensive strategy and changed defense to offense.

The Qin general Bai Qi divided his troops into two routes to implement a counter-encirclement, so that the Zhao army's grain route was cut off and trapped in Changping. In the end, the Zhao army could not eat for 46 days, and Zhao Kuo personally led the warriors to break through the siege and was shot to death by the Qin army.

For a long time, the Qin state adopted a policy of "distant friendship and close attack", and when they started another war against Korea, Han decided to send Shangdang to Qin. At that time, the Taishou of the Shangdang thought that even if he got the Shangdang Qin, he would not stop like this. Therefore, he suggested that all 17 cities in the Shangdang region should be given to Zhao to provoke a dispute between the two countries, because the Shangdang region could be condescending and directly threaten Handan of Zhao.

In the seventh year of King Zhao Xiaocheng (260 BC), the Qin army and the Zhao army confronted each other in Changping, when Zhao Kuo's father Zhao Hao had died, Zhao Xianglin Xiangru was also seriously ill, Zhao Xiaocheng Wang sent Lian Po to lead troops to attack the Qin army, the Qin army defeated the Zhao army several times, and the Zhao army held the camp and did not fight. The spy of the Qin State said: "The most taboo and feared thing in the Qin army is that Zhao Kuo, the son of Ma Fujun Zhao Hao, is the general of the Zhao army.

Therefore, King Zhao Xiaocheng made Zhao Kuo a general to replace Lian Po.

Lin Xiangru said: "The king appointed Zhao Kuo only on the basis of a false name, which is like sticking the tuning column to death with glue and then playing the serpent. Zhao Kuo can only read the military books left by his father, and he does not know how to be flexible. King Zhao Xiaocheng didn't listen, and still ordered Zhao Kuo to be the main general.

Zhao Kuo has been learning the art of war since he was a child, arguing about war and strategy, thinking that no one in the world can compare with him. As soon as Zhao Kuo obtained the power of Lian Po, he immediately changed the laws and regulations and transferred officials. Bai Qi, the general of the Qin State, received the information and used the tricks to pretend to be defeated and retreated, but he attacked the baggage and supply routes of the Zhao army from behind, cutting the Zhao army's army into two parts, and the Zhao army's heart fluctuated.

After more than 40 days, the Zhao army was hungry, and Zhao Kuo sent elite soldiers to break through in person, and the four breakthroughs failed, and Zhao Kuo was shot dead in the breakthrough.

There are two Zhao Kuo in history. One is the son of Zhao Hao, a person who can only talk on paper. He was familiar with military books, but he did not know how to use them.

In the later stage of the Battle of Changping, he replaced Lian Po as the commander of the Zhao army, but due to a command error, the entire Zhao army was annihilated, and he himself was killed in battle, and all 400,000 people of the Zhao army were buried alive by the Qin general. Another Zhao Kuo was Zhao Kuo, a doctor of the Jin Kingdom, who participated in the battle between Jin and Chu during the reign of Jin Jinggong, during which he had a gap with Zhao Yingqi. Zhao Shuo, the son of Zhao Dun, married Zhuang Ji, the daughter of the Jin State, and after Zhao Shuo's death, Zhuang Ji and Zhao Yingqi committed adultery, and Zhao Tong and Zhao Kuo banished Zhao Yingqi to the Qi State.

Zhuang Ji held a grudge, so he falsely accused Zhao Tong and Zhao Kuo. In 583 BC, Zhao Tong, Zhao Kuo and others were destroyed by Jin Jinggong.

A tragic person fought with a famous general like Bai Qi in the first war. Like Ma Yan, he faced Sima Yi for the first time. In addition to being depressed, it is still depressed.

Zhao Kuo is a theoretical giant with 0 practical experience. In the end, the Battle of Changping was Zhao Kuo's paper talk, and he was destroyed by General Qin Bai Qi!

People who can only talk on paper and don't have any actual combat experience.

On paper, that's what he said.

The allusion is more seriously derogatory In the official history, Zhao Kuo is an expert in rectifying military discipline, Lian Po has always been ignorant of governing the army, not good at leading the army, and the army is disheartened, and the reason for the change of generals is this. The Changping Zhao army was defeated, defeated in the disparity in strength, the Qin and Zhao combat effectiveness ratio was 5:1, and Bai Qi used soldiers like a god, unexpectedly, as the so-called Romance of the Three Kingdoms in both Shengyu He Shengliang, the Zhao Kuo was unlucky, in other words, Lian Po is also a dead word there.

After the war, Bai Qi saw King Qin Zhao and talked about Zhao Kuo. Bai Qi said, I surrounded Zhao Kuo's 200,000 army with 500,000 people, and it took more than half of the ** to completely annihilate this army, which is something I have never done since I used the army. There is no food in the belly, and the fighting spirit is unremitting to satisfy people's hunger, which is Zhao Kuo's ability.

In the Battle of Changping, the elite of the Qin army lost more than half, and the outstanding generals suffered countless casualties, but in fact, the Qin army was not victorious, and the Zhao army was not defeated. The only difference is that Zhao Kuo is dead, and I am still alive. King Qin Zhao said that in the great battle of Changping, Qin lost 600,000 and Zhao lost 700,000, and Qin could be described as a small victory.

And Zhao Kuo died, and Wu An Juncun survived, which can be described as a big victory. Afterwards, Fan Ju was called King Zhao of Qin, and it was King Qin who won the great battle of Changping. King Qin smiled but did not answer.

Three years later, in the fiftieth year of King Zhao of Qin (257 BC), King Zhao killed Bai Qi. Qin surrendered Zheng Anping to Zhao, and the party returned to Zhao.

At that time, the Qin state had a population of only a few million ......Although Qin's war potential is better than Zhao, but if Zhao sticks to it, it should be said that it is an unequal war of attrition, and don't forget politics and diplomacy, Zhao has led most of the Qin army, and the other six countries can take the opportunity to attack Qin, the longer the time, the more obvious, just like the Vietnam War, speaking of Zhao Kuo, I personally think he is indeed a person who talks on paper, but it is not that he has no real talent and learning, I think he is still very strategic, military talent is born with endowment, if he can be modest, exercise under Lian Po for a few years, I'm afraid it's a rare handsome talent, I'm afraid it's not under Li Mu, of course, it's just a personal opinion.

The traditional saying is that Zhao Kuo will only talk on paper, which eventually leads to the annihilation of 400,000 Zhao troops.

But now there are also those who overturn the case for Zhao Kuo, thinking that it is understandable that Zhao Kuo "only" can recite the military book proficiently, because he has never had the opportunity to lead the army to fight before this; Secondly, the so-called "King Zhao Xiaocheng listened to the 'words of discord of the Qin State' and thought that the Qin people were afraid of Zhao Kuo, so they replaced Lian Po with Zhao Kuo", underestimating the wisdom of the king, the truth should be that Zhao Kuo had a certain prestige in the Zhao State, and in the case that Lian Po's troops could not win the battle, the King of Zhao used Zhao Kuo, which should be accepted by the people; Again, Zhao Kuo's mother met with King Zhao and said that Zhao Kuo would only talk on paper and could not be a big job. Try to stand in the perspective of King Xiaocheng, the general has just been appointed, will the will be revoked because of a few "words of advice" from a woman? Later generations thought that King Xiaocheng should listen to Zhao Kuo's mother's advice, but in fact, it was all an afterthought; Finally, the traditional view is most important to the results of Changping:

The so-called Zhao army was trapped for 46 days, the food was exhausted, Zhao Kuo was shot dead in the breakthrough, 400,000 Zhao troops were killed, and only 240 underage men escaped. Let's take these numbers as real. It can be concluded that

Although Zhao Kuo is not a top military strategist, he can also be called a reliable marshal. Trapped for 46 days, the Zhao army could still keep 400,000 main troops, and in the final breakthrough, Zhao Kuo still "took the lead" and finally died heroically.

These are two points of view, I hope it helps you.

Those who talk on paper, just give you an article. Zhao Kuo has studied the art of war since he was a child, talked about military affairs, and thought that there was nothing comparable to him in the world. once talked about military affairs with his father Zhao Hao, but Zhao Hao couldn't beat him, but he didn't praise him.

Zhao Kuo's mother asked Zhao Hao the reason, and Zhao Hao said, "War is a matter of life and death, and Zhao Kuo is too rash to discuss it. If King Zhao doesn't let him be a general, if he must be a general, the person who makes Zhao Jun fail must be Zhao Kuo himself. After Zhao Kuo replaced Lian Po, he completely changed the original discipline and regulations, and appointed officers rashly.

After hearing this, Bai Qi, the general of the Qin State, dispatched an unpredictable army, pretending to defeat the retreat, and cut off the grain route of the Zhao army, dividing the Zhao army into two, and the morale of the Zhao army could not be unified. Trapped for more than 40 days, the Zhao army was very hungry, Zhao Kuo personally commanded the elite soldiers to fight, and the Qin army shot Zhao Kuo to death with arrows. Zhao Kuo's army was defeated, and hundreds of thousands of Zhao troops surrendered to Qin, and Qin buried them all alive.

If you have heard the story of talking about soldiers on paper, you should know one of his characteristics, that is, in military affairs, he can only talk about it, and he will not use it flexibly! But since he can memorize these soldiers' books, it shows that he is still very smart Moreover, his mother once persuaded King Zhao that you must not use my son, he is not as good as his father, he is not benevolent, he is a person, this is his own mother! Not to mention more, these alone are enough to reflect his character

The first floor Historical figures can not be determined by documents, otherwise what would those professors and experts do?

I agree with the second point of view on the third floor.