If the heroes of Liangshan crossed over to the Three Kingdoms, would 108 be able to form a force?

Updated on history 2024-04-25
16 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    Yes, you can occupy the mountains as kings and be a group of mountain kings, but you can't be a big force like Cao Sun Liu who divides the world, even if you occupy some cities and become kings, it won't last long. Because they have no money, no people, and no identity. Although the people of Liangshan in the Water Margin robbed and destroyed many big families that had been inherited for a hundred years, and it seemed that they had robbed a large amount of gold, silver and jewelry, and there were really big families like Lu Junyi to join, but having this money could only be regarded as a rich man, and they could not rise to the height of feeding an army, and their money could not even be as much as the money of a famous family in Jiangnan.

    There are also people in Liangshan, there are one hundred and eight generals, and there are 100,000 soldiers. However, this one hundred and eight generals can be taken by the first few people, and the ten outside are all over the Three Kingdoms, and the weakened version of Guan Yu like Guan Sheng is the second strongest existence among the people in Liangshan, so it can be seen that Guan Yu alone can crush the entire Liangshan One Hundred and Eight Generals. And 100,000 soldiers, facing real armies like Cao Cao, Sun Quan, and Liu Bei, and a group of tigers and wolves who fought in the south and north, can only be regarded as a group of little sheep.

    The people of Liangshan are also fighting in the south and the north, but their battles are basically solved by a few high-end generals and strategies, and there are very few battles that are really completed by the soldiers below, that is to say, these 100,000 soldiers can only be counted as spectators, not soldiers who really kill the enemy.

    It's even more important in terms of identity. Cao Cao in order to have a legitimate identity, he did not dare to kill the emperor, he could only "coerce the Son of Heaven to order the princes", Sun Quan itself is a national family, although Liu Bei's family declined, but he was able to have a relationship with the royal family, which also made his background the most noble one. It is precisely because the status behind the three parties is so high that some people follow them, and only local rich people give money for them to fight.

    And what about the people of Liangshan? When it comes to the Three Kingdoms, it is at best just a group of hooligan bandits.

    On the whole, when the people of Liangshan arrived in the Three Kingdoms, it was more likely that they would go to the east and west to seek a future, and the possibility of claiming to be a force was too small, and their strength did not allow them to become big warlords.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    No. During the Three Kingdoms period, the Gatelord Clan held a lot of money and manpower, and without their support, it was impossible to dominate one side.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    No, because there are not many strong generals among the 108 generals, and they can't beat the fierce generals in the Three Kingdoms at all.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    No, because they are rogues and are not recognized by the world, which is why Liu Bei has to pretend to be an Uncle Liu.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    There will be no achievements, just crossing into the Three Kingdoms will be regarded as annexed by either party, or eliminated, the Water Margin is just a **, in history there is indeed Shuibo Liangshan, the existence of which cannot be denied,But they were quickly recruited by the Great Song Dynasty, not as powerful as ** said in the **, if it is really the Shuibo Liangshan in history, appearing in the Three Kingdoms era, they can be regarded as a grass coward in the Wuthering Mountains and Forests.

    Just like the general of the navy under Sun Quan, Gan Ning, Gan Ning has a nickname called Jinfan Thief, that is because Gan Ming was a pirate when he was not under Sun Quan's account, if the heroes of Shuibo Liangshan reach the Three Kingdoms era, they will either be wiped out by these three forces, Either he was surrendered by one of the forces, or if he was surrendered by the people of Eastern Wu, then it is likely that life will be very hard, because there is already a general like Gan Ning, and there is no need for water talents like Shuibo Liangshan.

    However, if Liu Beifa searches for traces after missing his brother, it will be even more troublesome, among the three brothers Liu Guan and Zhang, Guan Yu is particularly proud and arrogant and looks down on the characters who have been water thieves and heroes in the green forest, we must know that even the veteran Guan Yu like Huang Zhong looks down on the heroes who returned to Boliang Mountain, will Guan Yu afford it? If you can't get an infighting, the heroes of Shuibo Liangshan will finish playing directly, what will be the achievement? There won't be any achievements, don't think about it, this is simply an impossible task, of course, for the heroes of Shuibo Liangshan.

    Cao Cao, what will happen if Cao Cao takes away the power of Shuibo Liangshan? Cao Cao will be the first to kill Song Jiang, Song Jiang is an unstable factor, only by killing him will the heroes of Shuipo Liangshan be able to be honest and obedient, and then kill other disobedient people, In the end, the water poured on Liangshan, this force will become a team under Cao Cao, but it will not be heavy by Cao Cao, so what achievements can be achieved, nothing can be achieved, just eat and wait for death.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    I don't think the Liangshan forces will achieve much if they cross over to the Three Kingdoms, because the army of the Liangshan forces is just a rabble, and it will be very difficult to sue the chain to conquer the party, let alone face the three forces of Wei, Shu and Wu, who are good at conquest.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    If the Liangshan forces in the Water Margin cross over to the Three Kingdoms, Wu Yong and Song Jiang will probably die without a place to be buried.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Then they will also become the overlord of the hegemonic side, and compete for the world with Liu Bei, Cao Cao, and Sun Quan, and they will also be a very powerful force.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    If the 108 heroes of Liangshan Songxun travel to Shu during the Three Kingdoms period and serve Shu to feast, then Shu cannot unify the Three Kingdoms. Because there is still a gap between the strength of Liangshan Haochun Yingyin and the fierce general.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    I think Shu can unify the three kingdoms, because if these heroes all cross over to Shu, Shu is very strong.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    No, because these 108 heroes are not all strong in martial arts.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    I don't think I can help Liu Bei unify the world. Because Liu Lu's strength at that time was not as strong as Wei's, even if he added 108 generals, it would be impossible to complete the task of unifying the world and attacking Zen Li.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    It is estimated that it will not work, because Cao Cao's forces are more than one hundred and eight, and the overall strength is the strongest at that time.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    I don't think I can help Liu Bei dominate the world and complete the hegemony. Although the one hundred and eight generals of Liangshan are all powerful, they lack discipline.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    It's all because the world is hot and cold, and it's hard to be a good person, so I can't go to that place where I don't care.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    Forced by the government, you can see the Water Margin.

Related questions
9 answers2024-04-25

As the most outstanding historical interpretation of ancient times, "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" not only reflects the history of the Three Kingdoms period more truthfully with the creative principle of "seven realities and three voids", but also plays a role in spreading history to a certain extent, and more importantly, ** through the interpretation of this history, it profoundly reflects the traditional consciousness and concepts of the ancient Chinese, brings together the wisdom and strength of the Han people, and becomes a big book that accumulates ancient Chinese culture. Tan Banghe said: "The Romance of the Three Kingdoms belongs to the kind of work that concentrates on the overall achievements and characteristics of national history and culture, and then participates in the shaping of national character, the construction of national psychology, and the stereotyping of national culture, and continues to play a role in the process of national cultural development and evolution." >>>More

25 answers2024-04-25

If Cao Wei's national strength is 100 points, then I think the score of Eastern Wu should be around 50 points, and the score of Shu Han should be around 40 points.

12 answers2024-04-25

Right! If Guan Yu didn't die, Zhang Fei wouldn't be angry, he would fight soldiers every day, and he would be killed by his generals in the end, and Liu Bei wouldn't beat Wu, so Shu wouldn't have perished too early, all of this was caused by Wu.

15 answers2024-04-25

I don't know what the ending will be, there are too many variables, but what is certain is that he will fight alone, Zhao Yun can't beat Lu Bu, Zhao Yun and Lu Bu have never fought each other, and they can't be conclusive. "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" and "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" are simply two stories, and the conclusions drawn must also be different. As far as "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is concerned, there is no doubt that Lu Bu will rank first, although Zhao Yun's strength should not be underestimated, but when he met Lu Bu, the two tried their best, so the conclusion must be that Zhao Yun is more than lucky. >>>More

20 answers2024-04-25

Hello, the Three Kingdoms Killing enthusiast will answer for you. >>>More