How do you evaluate The Alliance of Military Divisions of Sima Yi ?

In this drama, you can often see the living scenes that blend with the landscape, or the bamboo house by the water, or the boat in the lake, and the ubiquitous perspective and frame scene integrate people, buildings, and landscapes very harmoniously, which makes people often feel like a picture scroll, indifferent and lofty. What's more worth mentioning is that the landscape in the play is actually beautiful today, and it looks similar to Fuchun Mountain, Qiandao Lake, and Taizhou Immortal Residence in Zhejiang, but the landscapes in front of the ancients and in the pen are actually mostly of this kind, and the scenery is not magnificent but it is not beautiful, and the lofty artistic conception and feelings are more emphasized than the magnificent scene, which is also a major feature of traditional Chinese aesthetics. On the contrary, if the scenery of this play is as magnificent as in the hero of Lao Mouzi, it will not be harmonious.

Most of the negative evaluations focus on discrepancies with historical facts, or inconsistencies with the preconceived plot of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, or dislike to wash the Sima family. However, at the beginning of the plot, the dialogue between Yang Xiu and Zhong Da has already been said, wouldn't the sage be wrong? It's good to talk about the later innovation in the romance.

The lines are exquisite, well-made, and quite good-looking compared with the same dramas. ps: Teacher Yu, who is free to switch between Emperor Uncle Aman, is a good actor, and he will play the little overlord of Jiangdong in the next play!

In the play, in order to elevate Sima Yi, from Cao Cao to Guo Jia, Xun Yu, and Yang Xiu, all of them boast about how Zhongda is a genius, extremely smart, and good at hiding. In the troubled times, life is like duckweed, with the flood of the times, fighting hard in the surging waves. Perhaps the heaven and earth will borrow their strength to turn the tide and turn the tide by turning the tide.

Or maybe the hero is not free, he will be captured, sit and wait to be killed, at most he will use his mantis arm as a car and fight for his life. The so-called strategic planning is nothing more than an exaggeration.

Other costume dramas can also often see very beautiful scenes, but they are more or less out of touch with the productivity of the times. In fact, in ancient times, especially in the turbulent autumn of the Eastern Han Dynasty, private gardening was only a very rare phenomenon. In the play, there is no garden at all for a gate valve like the Sima family, and it can even be said to be very simple, and the whole play sees 30 episodes that only the Cao family has high-end goods like Taihu Stone.

However, the wonderful thing is that some seemingly ordinary layouts are used in the play, which just creates a very simple and elegant environment, which is very consistent with the aesthetic taste of traditional literati and enhances the style of the whole play.

watched a seven-minute film, the overall feeling is very much looking forward to it, when I watched the new "Three Kingdoms", I wrote a drama review every two episodes, mainly the comparison between history, romance and the screenwriter in the play, and the evaluation in Tianya was not bad at that time. But after seeing it, because I was about to suffocate my internal injuries, I couldn't watch it anymore when I was in more than 60 episodes, so I broke off, and it's a pity to think about it now. However, for big dramas with the theme of the Three Kingdoms, I think that the standards are still very tolerant and diverse, except for Lu Bu and Diao Chan, which are really unacceptable, I basically think that there is better than nothing.

First of all, the filming period of domestic TV dramas is generally completed within three months. And this "Military Division Alliance" was filmed for a full 333 days (not counting the post-production, just the filming period), nearly a year. The production is excellent, and the intentions can be seen.

Nowadays, it is rare for domestic dramas to invest so much and make well-made. I sincerely hope that everyone will support this rare masterpiece of conscience!

Extraction code: G39i "The Alliance of Military Divisions of Sima Yi" is directed by Zhang Yongxin and co-starred by Wu Xiubo, Li Chen, Liu Tao, Yu Hewei, Zhang Junning, Tang Yixin, Zhai Tianlin, Zhang Zhixi, Zhang He, Wang Jinsong, Wang Dong, Tan Jianci, Xiao Shunyao, Lu Siyu, Lai Xi [54] and other co-starring historical dramas. The play cuts from a new perspective of Cao Wei, depicts the ups and downs of the legendary life of Sima Yi, the military master of the Wei State, and shows the magnificent post-Three Kingdoms era.

The TV series "The Alliance of Military Divisions of Sima Yi" is very well-made, the texture is also very good, the actors' acting skills are also very good, and the storyline is also very exciting, this is what makes the TV series good.

Some people may say that this TV series does not conform to the history of the Three Kingdoms, but the TV series itself has some drama, and it can't be required that TV is completely written in accordance with history, so what is the meaning of TV. Before watching this TV series, everyone may only know actors Wu Xiubo, Liu Tao, Yu Hewei, Li Chen, etc., but after watching the TV series, the audience will remember historical figures such as Sima Yi, Zhang Chunhua, Cao Cao, and Cao Pi.

This drama is a meticulous interpretation of the actors who have been filming for more than a year, and each actor's acting skills are very perfect and exquisite, and it can even be said to be textbook-level, which brought a great surprise to the audience. The storyline is also exciting, Cao Cao played by Yu Hewei is domineering and treacherous, and Sima Yi played by Wu Xiubo is also full of charm, especially Xun Yu with Wang Jinsong's own style makes people feel awe-inspired.

Although there are many movies and TV series with the theme of the Three Kingdoms, most of them are set with Shu Han as the protagonist, Dongwu as the supporting role, and Cao Wei as the villain. Guo Jia, Xun Yu, Cui Yan and other heroes and heroes ended with deep touching. Before watching this drama, you may only know Zhuge Kongming, the Five Tiger Generals.

This TV series is as well-made as possible within the scope of cost control. Although it has changed a lot compared to history, the TV series is interpretation in the final analysis, as long as the story is wonderful and the actors' acting skills are very good, this drama is a success.

The TV series "Military Division Alliance" is very exciting first of all, and it has achieved a better interpretation of the history of the Three Kingdoms, and at the same time, the actors' acting skills are the key to making this drama so popular, and it is precisely because of the wonderful performances of the actors that this drama is so popular.

The best thing to see is the resourcefulness and ingenuity of the great military division, as well as some ways and methods and skills in using soldiers, which makes people like it very much.

Most of the previous Three Kingdoms were written from the perspective of the Shu Kingdom. "The Alliance of Military Divisions of Sima Yi" can be said to be innovative, and it has written about the Three Kingdoms from the perspective of Wei, which can be said to give the audience a new experience, so it looks novel and unique.

There are differences in subject matter,"New Three Kingdoms".Under the guise of the famous book History, it is mixed with private goods

Because the gap between some settings and history in the New Three Kingdoms is very large, many characters are weakened, some characters are overly powerful, and there are some exaggerations. "The Great Military Division" is a drama that interprets the historical context of Cao Weifang from Sima Yi's personal perspective, in addition to novelty, it is more about the display of details, as well as the detailed portrayal of each character, the personal images of Zhuge Liang and Cao Cao in the play are more real than any previous TV series, which is the credit of the screenwriter and director.

Because the audience and environment are different.

When the new Three Kingdoms was first filmed, although it was known from the name that it was not completely referring to the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, the publicity was still promoted according to the name of the remake of the four famous novels, so while the audience **, it would undoubtedly be compared with the old version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms.

The old version of the Three Uniques has no one to surpass, and the highlights of the new version are not on Cao Guan Zhuge at all, Lu Yi's acting skills are the weakest in the entire crew, Cao Cao's plot is extremely fine, and Guan Yu is a soy sauce.

The real highlight of the New Three Kingdoms is in Sun Quan's addition of the Jiangdong Four Heroes, as well as Liu Bei, Cao Pi, Cao Zhi, these relatively marginal supporting roles, especially those in Jiangdong, I think they are not inferior or even better than the old version, even if there is Zhou Yu of Hong Universe first, but in terms of conforming to history, it is still Huang Weide's Zhou Yu who is more similar to the comment of "Gongjin is majestic", as for the rest of Jiangdong who were infinitely weakened by the old version, Lu Su, Lu Meng, Lu Xun and others, they also have their own highlights and good performances in the New Three Kingdoms, which is higher and which is lower.

Of course, the New Three Kingdoms was not wronged, the director was very mediocre and flawless, the only thing that was satisfactory was the simple tones and more textured costumes, the screenwriter's brain was open, the logic was touching, and there was a lot of hard wounds, and there was no way out for a drama to rely on the actors.

But when is the drama of the Military Division Alliance, after all the audience have gone through the baptism of lonely fang, splendid Weiyang, and three lives and three worlds and ten miles of peach blossoms, seeing such a drama that seems to have no traffic stars and is not a romance drama, do you suddenly feel very conscientious?

However, the drama of the Military Division Alliance, even if it is supported by Yu Hewei and Wang Jinsong, is not half of the average acting skills of the actors in the New Three Kingdoms. Why do many people react that Cao Cao of the Military Division Alliance is not good-looking as soon as he dies? Because Cao Cao's acting skills are too prominent, but Yu Hewei, whose acting skills can only be said to be equal to everyone in the New Three Kingdoms, instantly stood out in this play, which shows the average level of acting skills in this play.

Not to mention that it is because of the problem that Liu Bei's character design of the New Three Kingdoms is not good and affects the performance, he is aiming at this drama to make Cao Cao into Dong Zhuo's posture, and the character design is not much better than that of the New Three Kingdoms.

However, the military division alliance appeared at this time, and the social aesthetic level has been brushed too many times, and occasionally a drama that is not too exaggerated can be praised to the sky, which can only be said to be good for peers.

The New Three Kingdoms is very careless in terms of director and screenwriting, I don't know if it's a lack of funds or what, many big events can be saved, Cao Wei's generals except Xu Chu or Xu Chu, it seems that they can't find the shadow of other generals, a dragon set of brothers is used over and over again, although the whole drama costs a lot, but rough omissions abound.

"The Great Military Division" is a drama that interprets the historical context of Cao Weifang from Sima Yi's personal perspective, in addition to novelty, it is more about the display of details, as well as the detailed portrayal of each character, the personal images of Zhuge Liang and Cao Cao in the play are more real than any previous TV series, which is the credit of the screenwriter and director. The performance of restoring the customs is also excellent, and there are a large number of life scenes of the high-ranking families in the society at that time in the play, full of fireworks, and the scenes with large costs such as cooking and eating in the play are shown many times, and they are all real meals, making the audience feel as if they are in Luoyang, an ancient metropolis.

First of all, there are differences in the subject matter, the military division alliance is a drama that focuses on playing Sima Yi alone, and the new Three Kingdoms is a group drama! Each character can be highlighted as the protagonist at a specific time! Therefore, everyone is benchmarking the new Three Kingdoms with the old Three Kingdoms, and it doesn't make much sense to compare the Military Division Alliance with the Old Three Kingdoms.

The second is the plot, the Alliance of Military Divisions, as long as you make it up reasonably, set off the protagonist Sima Yi well, so that the story does not violate common sense and common sense, and it is basically okay to go on normally. What is the plot and lines of the new Three Kingdoms?

I will give one of the passages as an example, Guan Yu and Liu Bei mentioned Zhuge Liang's Wolong, saying that the dragon is a symbol of the emperor, which means that Zhuge Liang has ambitions to become the emperor sooner or later!

According to the screenwriter, Guan Yunchang uses the Qinglong Yanyue Knife, the dragon is the symbol of the emperor, do you Guan Yu have to kill the eldest brother sooner or later to stand on his own?

Zhao Yun, the word dragon, the dragon is the symbol of the emperor, are you Zhao Yun going to rebel sooner or later? There is also Pang Tong's phoenix chick, is he planning to be the queen? It's really outrageous, the problem is that it's not one or two, and the example I gave is just the tip of the iceberg in the outrageous whole play, which shows how ridiculous the plot and lines of the New Three Kingdoms are.

Sima Yi has almost no protagonists, and combines some wild histories and legends about the Three Kingdoms, and there is no discomfort when it looks fresh. The difference between the new Three Kingdoms and the old Three Kingdoms is that the actors' performances are on the one hand, and the point of inadaptability in the screenwriter may lie in the different emphasis.

The characteristics of the old Three Kingdoms are a lot of personal wisdom, so when each main character has a highlight, as soon as it comes out, he will point out who the country is, and the others are all supporting roles in the play, in fact, it is similar to a cool drama, everyone likes to watch the cow and the hero.

The characteristics of the new Three Kingdoms are a lot of manifestations of political conspiracy, such as Cao Cao's temptation and test of his son, such as Niu Cha and Zhuge Liang have to engage in internal unity with Guan Zhang first, Sun Quan used Lu Meng's use and death to deter Lu Xun to take back his rights, and Liu Bei's benevolence is obviously just a tool to win over people's hearts, and no one is the pride of the sky. It looks very much like a historical drama, and it's not so cool or even a little verbose.

Because "The Great Military Division" is neither history nor **, as an eight-point apocryphal "personal drama", it does not advertise itself as "historical history", and will not cause opposition from the historical party and the ** faction, which is enough to meet the needs and imagination of most audiences.

The old version of the Three Kingdoms is obviously adapted and filmed on the basis of ** "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", and it is also clearly a remake of the history ** "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", which is a thorough "group drama", with traditional culture as the connotation and the national humanistic spirit as the embodiment. Through the ** TV series, the audience can truly reflect on the past and present society, and can gain some benefits to human feelings and physics.

However, in the name of "official history" and relying on "**", the New Three Kingdoms played all kinds of conspiracy theories, and it really did not see any benefit to the construction of social harmony.