Some people say that Xiang Yu is brave and unscrupulous, what do you think?

A typical tragic hero, but to say that he is brave and unscrupulous, this evaluation is a bit unfair. If he really has no strategy, how can he become the overlord of Western Chu, it can only be said that Xiang Yu has a very obvious character flaw. He attaches too much importance to emotions and cannot fully analyze the problem, which is the real reason for his failure.

In the Battle of Julu and the Battle of Pengcheng, Xiang Yu's attack was accurate and his command was decent, so Xiang Yu was definitely not brave and strategic; Xiang Yu's problems: first, the way of thinking is inappropriate, because the personal ability is too strong, and he does not pay attention to the cultivation and collection of talents; In fact, even Han Xin couldn't beat Xiang Yu with the same strength, but only Xiang Yu was effective on Xiang Yu's side, and he would lose immediately in the war zone without him, and Xiang Yu would be dragged down!

In fact, Xiang Yu was passed down after Liu Bang was scandalized, after all, he supported such a large army, and overthrew most of the Qin Dynasty army, he must have been brave and strategic.

I think Xiang Yu must have a strategy himself, otherwise he would not have developed into one of the biggest forces at that time. It's just that he is too conceited about himself, too confident in his own bravery, and disdainful of using those strategies, which ultimately leads to failure.

I think there's some truth to that. Because he was able to become the overlord of Western Chu, it shows that he has a certain amount of courage, but he lacks strategy and is too upright when fighting.

I think this point of view is very correct, Xiang Yu is a very brave and powerful person, but he does not have some strategy.

I agree with Xiang Yu's statement that he is brave and unscrupulous. He just blindly behaves like a puppet, does not use his brain when doing things, and has no long-term plan.

I don't agree with this statement, judging from the plot in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Xiang Yu is a very brave and resourceful person, and it is difficult to surpass him.

It is indeed brave and unstrategic, and he still doesn't believe in his strategists, so he easily believes in Liu Bang, and lets Liu Bang run away in the Hongmen banquet.

History is written with victors, but it is just a matter of winning and losing! Xiang Yu has dominated the world all his life, and he has won more with less, is this comparable to those who have courage and no strategy? In the battle of Qixia, Liu Bang and Han Xin surrounded Xiang Yu, who was only about 100,000 soldiers and horses, with a superior force of six or seven hundred thousand, and this was just a fluke to win the ultimate battle!

Becoming the overlord of Western Chu shows that he has a certain amount of courage, and judging from the plot in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Xiang Yu is a very brave and resourceful person.

I don't think so, Xiang Yu is only not very good at winning people's hearts, and he still has the strategy of leading troops to fight.

Xiang Yu is not completely brave and resourceless, he is mainly more arrogant, and then has a wrong judgment on the development of the situation.

No, it's just that in the later stage, because his personal strength is too strong to ignore his strategic aspect. His strategy may not be as good as Han Xin's, but as a marshal, how can he have no strategy. The destruction of the cauldron is enough to see its plan, but it is too arrogant in the future.

In fact, I don't think there's anything wrong with it, Xiang Yu is brave and unstrategic, which will lead to his failure.

Xiang Yu has the courage to be invincible, the military strategy of 10,000 enemies, and the master of tactics. But there is no big strategy, and the basic level of passers-by in the big picture politics is not the ability to settle the world. There are few major events, there is a lack of decision, and there is a lack of strategy, and it is difficult for the generals of an army to excel, and it is difficult for the king of a country not to destroy the country.

Xiaoyu is a rough man, he has a lot of courage to complete this thing, but without a good strategy to complete this thing, this thing will definitely fail.

He is brave and strategic, before he succeeds, he can still listen to his father, after he grows bigger, he is completely against his father, and he plays a good hand of cards and ends up killing himself. People, you can't be too narcissistic and persistent when the spring breeze is proud, listen to people's persuasion, and eat well.

Xiang Yu was defeated by pride and contempt for the enemy, and his ability to lead troops is indeed unique in the world.

Xiang Yu is a hero, superior in martial arts in all aspects of Liu Bang's advantage, the more such a person is more arrogant, he didn't take Liu Bang into his eyes at all, thinking that there is no opponent in the world, underestimating Liu Bang, and Liu Bang is weak but learning from each other's strengths and weaknesses to be vigilant.

If Xiang Yu is both wise and brave, how can he lose to a little Liu Bang when appointing talents?

He is an undeniable military genius, like Han Xin, he must win the battle and win the attack, but the same shortcoming is that he is politically naïve and confused, Liu Bang is a second-rate military player, but he has Han Xin, Peng Yue, and Di Bu to make up for it, he himself is a political master, a political hooligan, a combination of politics, and the military, Xiang Yu is naturally not an opponent!

Pure military ability, up and down for 5,000 years, there is almost no second stronger than him, but he lacks the strategic goal of unifying the world. As long as he is paired with a character like Zhang Liang, he can beat any opponent.

In my opinion, Xiang Yu still has a strong plan compared to Liu Bang.

Xiang Yu is too indecisive, in today's society, he belongs to the kind of person who attaches too much importance to feelings, and others will never shirk when they ask you to do something

Xiang Yu's character determines his failure, if Zhuge Liang and Sima Yi are his military advisors, he will also fail, because he will not accept other people's opinions and insist on going his own way.

Most people are defeated in no vision, carefully look at the military book strategy, except for the gossip array, need to understand astronomy and geography, the others are defeated in the good generals who use weapons, a little bit of intrigue and trickery after understanding the opponent, and the mastery of terrain and geographical location. There are so many awesome generals, why is there no color in modern warfare, and modern warfare is useless.

Fool's war, fight for ** equipment, no matter how much you read military books, you can't use it.

It took 7 years from the end of the Qin Dynasty to the White Snake Uprising to the establishment of the Western Han Dynasty, Liu Bang and Xiang Yu fought for almost 5 years, and in 5 years, they went from the good situation of dividing the princes to a kiss, not that there is no courage and no strategy.

If you become a king or lose, you will also die, and everything else is just bad luck.

It was all planned by Fan Zeng for him, otherwise how could there be so many wonderful battles, after Fan Zeng left, Xiang Yu fell very badly.

<>First of all, TV series are largely the product of the author's secondary processing, in order to attract people's attention, the plot must add a lot of conflicts, and it is necessary to create distinct characters, but real history is not like this. History is multifaceted, and each historical figure is three-dimensional and complex, but this is not an academic forum, so I will not cite historical materials, but simply combine the evaluation of Xiang Yu in history to give me some judgments of my own: Xiang Yu is a real man, a man who can stick to his inner morality, a man who is proud but also conceited, but a man who is bound to fail.

has outstanding personal talents, and is indeed inferior to Liu Bang in terms of being good at employing people, and does not listen to the words of the only strategist Fan Zeng. Han Xin once worshiped under Xiang Yu's door, and wanted to show his ambitions, but he was not taken seriously, and left angrily, throwing himself into Liu Bang's wave, like a fish in water, like a broken bamboo, and finally defeated Xiang Yu in the wall. And Liu Bang is good at knowing people, using Zhang Liang, Xiao He, and Han Xin....As a result, the strategic gap with Liu Bang became wider and wider, which in turn led to the final defeat.

Xiang Yu is a righteous gentleman, affectionate and righteous, very good at governing the army, leading troops to fight a very good set, he is a pioneer, and the combat effectiveness of the troops is extremely strong. His army was well-trained, strong and heroic. His troops were mobile and nimble, often able to win more with less and stronger with weak.

However, although Xiang Yu was an outstanding military strategist, his political ability was not strong. Although he is an outstanding tactician, he is not very strategic. In addition, its system is not good, not good at recognizing and using talents, many outstanding geniuses are not met (such as Han Xin, etc.), plus political mechanisms (such as rewards and punishments, atmosphere, employment, talent matching and matching, etc.) and logistics mechanisms (money and food) are not good, emotional intelligence is not high, and strategy is inferior.

Wait so that Xiang Yu's failure has become inevitable! From a literary point of view, Xiang Yu's image and story are tragic and heroic, and the ending is embarrassing, which is very in line with the aesthetic feelings of traditional heroic romanticism, so there is no shortage of praise for Xiang Yu in the world. However, from the perspective of history and politics, Xiang Yu is also the representative of the separatist forces of the princes, and he has always advocated the political concept of the restoration of the princes, and is the obstructor in the historical process of realizing the great unification of China, and the historical attributes of his political forces are incomparable with those of the Qin and Han dynasties.

I think this statement is very correct, because when setting up the Hongmen Banquet, Fan Zeng persuaded Xiang Yu to send troops to attack Liu Bang, but Xiang Yu did not listen and missed the best opportunity, and Xiang Yu attached great importance to righteousness and feelings, and it was precisely because of his feelings that he did not kill Liu Bang at the Hongmen Banquet.

I don't agree with that. I think he is a self-serving person, he doesn't know how to follow some good advice, he doesn't think things are particularly thorough, he can't protect some people, and he doesn't belong to a true gentleman.

My opinion is that Xiang Yu is really a very sincere person, he treats his friends with great respect, and he is also a very admirable person, he is really a very good hero.

I think this sentence is very accurate, Xiang Yu is a very conscientious person, he feels that he has no face to face some people, so he committed suicide, and he is a very responsible person.

In this regard, I think Xiang Yu is not stubborn and self-serving, Xiang Yu is actually brave and strategic, and the reason why he does not go to the river is because he wants to protect the villagers in Jiangdong.

Xiang Yu is a brave and unscrupulous horseman. Since he was a child, he has been strong and brave to pull mountains and rivers. But he has always only used brute force to solve problems.

He was self-serving, proud and arrogant in his heart, and never listened to the advice of others. In the last years of the Qin Dynasty, Liu Bang and Xiang Yu agreed that whoever captured Xianyang, the capital of the Qin Dynasty, would claim the throne in Guanzhong. And Xiang Yu, who killed the main force of the Qin State, later arrived in Guannei.

So Xiang Yu and Yafu Fan added a banquet and invited Liu Bang to participate. Liu Bang was invited, and at the banquet, Liu Bang showed weakness everywhere. Xiang Yu was a little fluttering because of Liu Bang's bowing, and felt that Liu Bang would not make a difference.

And Fan Zeng saw that Liu Bang was able to persuade Xiang Yu to kill Liu Bang, and thought that Liu Bang would be the biggest enemy in the future to seek the world's major affairs. However, the project changed its mind, thinking that Liu Bang, who was low and small, could not be on the stage and could not pose a threat, so he let Liu Bang go, because of his arrogance and ignorance, letting Liu Bang go was undoubtedly a tiger returning to the mountain. Later, in the Battle of Qixia, he died at the hands of Liu Bang.

Xiang Yu is very capable of fighting, in the war against Qin, he made a great contribution, but he did not have a plan, after entering the customs, he robbed women, robbed money, he set fire to the palace of the Qin Dynasty. It seems that he has won, he has obtained gold and silver money. But the moment he burned, killed, looted, he already lost.

He lost to the hearts of the people, he lost to his own hubris. Compared with Liu Bang, who also entered the customs, as soon as he entered the customs, he gave a large reward to stabilize the morale of the army, and Xiao He led the army to appease the people. Compared with the two teams in this way, how could Xiang Yu win, compared with Liu Bang, Xiang Yu can only be a general, not suitable for being an emperor who strategizes.

Such a person with only brute strength and no scheming can be a king of the world. He had many opportunities to kill his most powerful foe, but he missed them every time, believing that the other party could not pose a threat and died at the hands of the enemy. He is a brave and unscrupulous horseman. <>

Xiang Yu is the overlord of Western Chu, but he is not brave and resourceless. It's just that Xiang Yusheng was born at the wrong time, and the social conditions he encountered were not good. Otherwise, it will become a generation of hegemons.

Xiang Yu is a brave and unscrupulous horseman, Xiang Yu is very bold, and he will rush ahead in everything, but he will never think about the consequences of things, so the ancients would think so.

Yes. This is because many people think that Xiang Yu is a brave and resourceless person, his martial arts are very strong, and he can be said to be a very good general, but he is not particularly advantageous in terms of resourcefulness.

No, Xiang Yu is still a relatively good talent, and he is also a relatively smart person, that is because he is not as smart as Han Xin, and secondly, because he is not as smart as others, so he has such an idea.