What version of Dream of Red Mansions is good to read, and which version of Dream of Red Mansions sh

Updated on culture 2024-05-24
8 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-11

    One of the wonderful things about Dream of Red Mansions is that everyone's interpretation and feelings of Dream of Red Mansions are different, if they are adapted by others, they will lose their taste, and they may not be in line with their own taste, and if the level of the adaptor is not high, it will inevitably affect their understanding and even misreading of Dream of Red Mansions. So I recommend reading the original work, and most of the general 120 popular versions are thought to be written by Cao Xueqin and continued by Gao E. It starts like this.

    The first episode of Dream of Red Mansions, Zhen Shiyin's dream of knowing psychic, Jia Yucun's wind and dust, and her boudoirs.

    The first time this book opens, the author Ziyun: Because he has experienced a dream, he will be true.

    hidden, and wrote this book "Stone Records". Therefore, it is said that "Zhen Shiyin dreams and knows psychic". In the proviso.

    What do you remember? Why did you write a book? Ziyun: Today's wind and dust, nothing has been accomplished, and I suddenly thought about it.

    All the women of that day pushed it carefully one by one, and felt that their actions and insights were all above me, what a dignified.

    The eyebrows are not as good as the other dry skirt hairpin? If you are ashamed, you will have more than enough, and if you regret it, it will be useless, and there will be no end to it.

    Also. At this time, he wants to rely on what he has relied on in the past - relying on the grace of heaven, inheriting the ancestors, and wearing brocade clothes.

    At that time, on the day of gluttony and beauty, he betrayed the grace of his parents' education and the virtue of his brother's discipline, so as to today's incident.

    The sin of insuccess and half-life is compiled to tell the people of the world. Although my sins are inevitable, there are people in the boudoir who have been in the past, and they must not be wiped out because I am not good. Although today.

    The thatched rafters, the tile stove rope bed, its wind morning and moon and evening, the willow garden flowers, did not hurt my bosom.

    Pen and ink maker. Why don't you use the fake village dialect to perform a story to please people's ears and eyes? Hence the saying.

    Jia Yucun] "Wind and Dust and Lady Show" is the first time that the theme is justice. The opening of the book is the cloud, "the wind and dust."

    "Lady show", it is known that the author's original intention was to describe the girlfriends of the day, not the book when complaining about the world.

    Although it is involved in the state of the world for a while, it has to be narrated, but it is not its original purpose.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-10

    Elementary school students read the toddler version.

    Middle school students read the teen version.

    High school students read the vernacular version.

    Adults who read modern literature, especially those who have not read Dream of the Red Chamber.

    If you are a person who particularly likes to read this kind of tome, you can read the modern text first and then read the xx annotations, if you are engaged in research, then you should read the original work, and you must also get the original work!!

    I think the key is to read that publisher, that person made it!

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-09

    Looking at the original book, it is not a literary language, it is half-literate and half-white, I have read it several times, and there are few places that I can't read.

    The vernacular version will be somewhat tampered with, and the beauty of the language will be worn away.

    I read the original book and then read the vernacular version, so I was deeply touched.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    It is best to read the original work, and modern people can understand the words in Dream of Red Mansions, and there is no need to read the translation.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    It is recommended to find the version that has been commented on by Yan Zhai, which can deepen the understanding of **.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    It's best to read the vernacular, and the meaning is different.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Definitely. Only the original ones are the most interesting.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Dream of Red Mansions should be read by the People's Literature Publishing House, "Dream of Red Mansions" (120 volumes, two volumes).

    The 120-volume "Dream of Red Mansions" published by the People's Literature Publishing House, this two-volume book is based on the Gengchen version and compiled with various other lipotic editions as the reference text, because the Gengchen version is the earliest and most complete version of the Dream of Red Mansions.

    Those who have participated in the proofreading of this book are also well-known experts and scholars in the red academic circles, such as Li Xifan, Feng Qiyong, Liu Mengxi, Gu Pingdan, Hu Wenbin, Cai Yijiang and others, who can be said to have made great achievements in the field of Dream of Red Mansions.

    Summary

    This set of books has annotated many rare words and difficult sentences in the original book to make it easier for readers to understand, and some controversial places have also been annotated after each time to facilitate research and reference. It can be said to be an introductory book for reading Dream of Red Mansions, and it is also a must-have book.

    Whether it is a reader who is new to Dream of Red Mansions, a veteran red fan, or even a red scholar, this book is indispensable.

Related questions
16 answers2024-05-24

Well, I read it, I read it two or three times while reading Yu Pingbo's comments, but I think this book only needs to be read a few times and understand some of the truths in it, and there is no need to specialize in it, after all, we are not red scholars, we all have our own careers, and we don't need to be sentimental for the content in it. >>>More

3 answers2024-05-24

The evaluation and appreciation of Dream of Red Mansions is as follows: >>>More

9 answers2024-05-24

Take a look at Hu Shi's "Dream of Red Mansions" research, but I think it must be right, there is a mention of Emperor Taishang in the book, which should be the last years of Qianlong.

6 answers2024-05-24

It's a long story, give you the address of the Red Mansion, there are a lot of cattle in it, and it will definitely make you jaw-dropping.

7 answers2024-05-24

said that when He Shen Jin presented "Dream of Red Mansions", Qianlong said after reading it: "This cover is also a family affair for Mingzhu." This sentence connects "Dream of Red Mansions" with the Nalan family. Some people even believe that the Pearl Mansion is the Grand View Garden, and the Pearl, Nalan Xingde, and his son are Jia Zheng and Baoyu. >>>More