-
The lines are too thunderous, Zhuge , Wang Yun , Sun Quan , Zhao Yun , Guan Yu are in line with the image in my heart. I don't feel as good as "Kangxi Dynasty" and "Zhenguan Long Song".
-
The lines in the new Three Kingdoms are too vernacular, the characters are not obvious, the three lords lack the domineering spirit of the emperor, Guan Yu lacks arrogance, and Zhuge Liang does not have the stability to win thousands of miles away.
-
First of all, the egg hurts. It fundamentally undermined the connotation of the Three Kingdoms. The lines are too thunderous. The most unbearable thing is that the time of Taoyuan Sanjieyi is shorter than the time for Cao Cao to soak in urine...Ruins the feel of the original. Connotation. Significance.
-
Refuse to watch. Influenced the image of Zhuge Liang, Cao Cao and others as handsome guys in my heart.
-
Garbage is purely yy, which reality is like this, messy, the people who should be highlighted are not prominent, and the ones that should not be highlighted are written very divinely.
-
Shame and forbearance, yin, for the sake of power, he will not choose to break his hand, but this is also how he can achieve great achievements.
-
It feels like this is a time-traveling film.
Stars possessed the bodies of ancient people, burdened with the fate of historical figures...
Especially after Liu Bei said that Yuan Shao couldn't be supported, Adou and Dong Zhuo said that I can't think about it now.
I was even more convinced.
-
And aptly, political struggle, that's it, take the past to show the present...
-
It's thrilling and pitiful, it's boring and terrifying.
In short, when you don't know what's going on, the "Three Kingdoms" attract you.
Crazy Three Kingdoms!!
-
False, that's how history is tampered with.
-
"The New Three Kingdoms" and "The Old Three Kingdoms" are both film and television works set in the Three Kingdoms period, although they both tell the story of the Three Kingdoms, but there are great differences in the production style, storyline, and character portrayal of the two. Therefore, after watching "The New Three Kingdoms" and then watching "The Old Three Kingdoms", you will have the following feelings:
Easier to understand: "The New Three Kingdoms" is more modern and popular, the picture is clearer and clearer, and it is easier for ordinary audiences to understand and accept, while "The Old Three Kingdoms" pays more attention to historical restoration and character building, which may be a little difficult for audiences who are not very familiar with history.
Different character impressions: "The New Three Kingdoms" has reshaped some famous characters, such as Cao Cao, Lu Bu and others, making the audience's impression of these characters different from that of "The Old Three Kingdoms". In addition, the character creation of "New Three Kingdoms" is more three-dimensional, with more side descriptions, making the characters more vivid and interesting.
Different plot treatment: There are also differences in the plot treatment of the two works, for example, some new plots and characters will be added in "New Three Kingdoms" to make the story fuller. "The Old Three Kingdoms" pays more attention to historical authenticity, and the plot is closer to the original work.
In general, after watching "The New Three Kingdoms" and then "The Old Three Kingdoms", you can better understand and appreciate the history of the Three Kingdoms, but at the same time, you need to pay attention to the differences between the two to avoid misunderstanding and confusion about history.
-
After watching the new Three Kingdoms and then watching the old Three Kingdoms, you may have a different feeling, it mainly depends on the individual's views and preferences. Here are some possible feelings:
For viewers who are already familiar with the story of the new Three Kingdoms, re-re-entering the old Three Kingdoms may feel a bit monotonous and outdated. The narrative style, scene setting, and actors' performances of the old Three Kingdoms are very different from the production of modern TV dramas, which may make the audience feel uncomfortable.
For viewers who like historical themes and have a strong interest in ancient Chinese history, it may be more interesting to re-enter the Old Three Kingdoms. The old Three Kingdoms are more faithful to historical facts, and there are more explanations and displays of the historical figures, events and cultural backgrounds of the Three Kingdoms. This may give viewers a deeper understanding of the historical background and cultural connotations of the Three Kingdoms period.
For viewers who like certain characters more, re-settling the old Three Kingdoms may be more touching. Different versions of the Tale of the Three Kingdoms may portray and deal with the personalities, images, and fates of certain characters differently. Viewers may be satisfied or disappointed with the performance of certain characters, which can have an impact on the feeling of the story as a whole.
In short, after watching the new Three Kingdoms and then watching the old Three Kingdoms, you may have different feelings and experiences. But in any case, as an important part of ancient Chinese culture, the story of the Three Kingdoms has always attracted people's attention and love. Whether it is the new Three Kingdoms or the old Three Kingdoms, they are all precious legacies of traditional culture, which are worthy of our hearts to feel and appreciate.
-
The New Three Kingdoms is a TV series broadcast in 2009, adapted from Luo Guanzhong's ** "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", which injects freshness into an ancient story through modern interpretation techniques, costumes and prop design. The Old Three Kingdoms refers to the 1994 TV series "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", which is more faithful to the original story and shows a more serious historical color.
For lovers of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", whether they watch the new version or the old version, they will be given the answer. The New Three Kingdoms may make it easier for them to accept elements that are less realistic and have tried a lot to remove the shackles of history, while the Old Three Kingdoms are more in line with their historical view or cognitive information about the story. No matter which version it is, the story of the Three Kingdoms is still a classic that people can't forget, although it is an adaptation, it will tell the insignificant historical and legendary elements, and it is a good TV idol drama and historical learning material.
-
Except for the better clarity, the others don't have the taste of the old Three Kingdoms, it's more like an idol drama that criticized the Three Kingdoms skin, probably preconceived, I watched the old Three Kingdoms repeatedly, and I didn't even finish half of the new one.
-
The old version of the Three Kingdoms is closer to the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, and the new version of the Three Kingdoms is more like the Romance of the Three Kingdoms.
-
The old Three Kingdoms, the episode of the meeting of the ancient city, the gate of the ancient city opened, the drum car of the third master slowly went out of the city, and the ** of "This Worship" sounded, and the eyes of many viewers in front of the TV were red.
The New Three Kingdoms? Please really ask Kangkai, stop acting, really, thank you.
The old Three Kingdoms, in the episode of Wuzhangyuan, Jiang Wei led the soldiers of the three armies to kneel down and said that the prime minister took care, and the others didn't know, he was still a doll less than 10 years old, and he immediately turned off the TV and burst into tears.
The New Three Kingdoms? Lu Yi is right, don't pretend, please, thank you.
-
Brother, what you said is so right, I also feel the same way, the so-called New Three Kingdoms is just a costume film with the signboard of the Three Kingdoms, and it has nothing to do with history at all.
-
People who evaluate the new Three Kingdoms are bored and pretend to be very knowledgeable. Every work is a kind of art, and we must know how to appreciate it.
-
I think the New Three Kingdoms are very good, especially the portrayal of the characters of the Wei State (Cao Cao, Cao Pi, Sima, etc.) is vivid and vivid. What does it mean to be "faithful to the original"? Is it good to be "faithful to the original"?
Each work is the result of its author's creation, and no new things are allowed? Blindly seeking "loyalty" to talk about development, and besides, Roche's original work itself also has quite loopholes!
-
You watch the old Three Kingdoms first, after watching it, you all have that feeling, compare the actors, the old ones look comfortable.
On the costumes, the armor in the New Three Kingdoms is really fake, and there was no such transcendent equipment at the time, and I have a stomachache when I watch it, not to mention that it is more faithful to the original, in terms of artistry, the old Three Kingdoms is really good, and it's strange that the poor props were almost at the time.
-
I'm watching the New Three Kingdoms, and I think that Zhao Yun here is unreal in the martial arts scene of the Savior, my mother doesn't understand the Three Kingdoms, she said after watching the TV series, Liu Bei filmed here is very treacherous, especially Zhuge Liang is very cunning, and Sun Quan and Lu Su in Jiangdong are very loyal. This is what the director didn't pay attention to... Chen Hao, who plays Diao Chan, may also be the reason why everyone is not welcome, and some plots are too outrageous, I compare it with the original book, although the director can have his own speculation on history, but don't be too outrageous...
Besides, with the previous classics, there is already a standard in the audience's mind, which cannot be surpassed, just like Dream of Red Mansions.
-
The New Three Kingdoms is too tender and can't be heroic! It can only mislead the public!
-
It's pretty good. There are good parts of the old Three Kingdoms, especially the psychological aspect.
-
Fortunately, after all, on the basis of inheriting the old version of the Three Kingdoms, it has been given an innovative meaning, which further caters to the tastes of the majority of audiences ......
-
It depends on personal opinion, I think you don't necessarily feel good if it's good, you only know when you read it.
Most of the TV series are adapted from the original work, but the TV series are derived from the original book and are different from the original work, especially the new version of the Three Kingdoms, which deeply excavates the psychology of many characters in the original book and restores a lot of historical truths: like why Cao Cao's defeat in Chibi was able to escape from the pursuit of the Sun-Liu coalition army, in fact, the Sun-Liu coalition army has its own plans, and they all hope to kill Cao Cao by the other party's hand, as a result. >>>More
There is no deviation on the main line. There is no deviation from the old and new TV series or **. >>>More
Encyclopedia search New Romance of the Three Kingdoms and Romance of the Three Kingdoms.
A lot, there are too many fools, where did Zhuge Liang get his beard at that time?
There is Dong Zhuo (played by Lu Xiaohe) who is a giant traitor and is domineering; Outside, there was an uprising of the Yellow Turban Army, which shook the community. From time to time, Cao Cao (played by Chen Jianbin ) is obscure and wants to eliminate harm for the country. After escaping from the capital, Cao Cao and the princes Yuan Shao, Liu Bei (played by Yu Hewei), Sun Jian and other twenty heroes allied to jointly crusade against Dong Zhuo. >>>More