How do you think of Song Jiang s talent and ability, how should you evaluate Song Jiang

In terms of talent, Song Jiang is not outstanding, because he does not have a high degree such as lifting people and jinshi. In terms of ability, Song Jiang doesn't know martial arts, and without the support of the heroes of Liangshan, he has died a hundred times. However, Song Jiang was good at using small favors to win people's hearts, taking advantage of the righteousness of the heroes of Liangshan, and under the guise of doing the right thing for heaven, he used the blood and lives of his brothers to realize his ambition of serving the imperial court.

He is good at intrigue and disguise, and he has deceived many people. He never pays attention to righteousness, does not pay attention to feelings, he has already drunk the poisonous wine of the imperial court, and he wants to poison Li Kui to death, for fear of ruining his reputation. He used other people's money to help others, and used other people's lives to make way for his own despicable goals, and he was a complete hypocrite.

Judging historical figures cannot be separated from specific historical conditions. I remember when I was a child, I watched the Water Margin and resented Song Jiang, but in fact, I used the values of modern people and the current environmental conditions to ask the ancients, which can be a temporary emotional vent, and there is no serious value. Since then, it has been judged that Song Jiang is a capitulation faction, a villain who only wants to have private thoughts, and a trivial official who climbs up on other people's shoulders?

Song Jiang and his brothers could not be tolerated by the society at that time, embarked on the road of resistance, destroyed the normal social order at that time, and threatened the stable position of the rulers. In a turbulent society, a state of high energy is full of contradictions between members of society and between individual members and society as a whole, and the difference in interests leads to strong dissatisfaction and a desire for change, and the relationship between members of society cannot be stable for a long time. Then there must be changes and eliminate the high-energy state, so the end of the Song Jiang can only be two ways, one is to continue to rebel against the ruler, that is, to rebel against the ruling order at that time until the overthrow of the Song Dynasty and the establishment of a new imperial court, if it can succeed, it will be like Zhu Yuanzhang, Liu Bang, Liu Xiu, and if it can't succeed, it will be like Li Zicheng and Hong Xiuquan.

The other way is to reach a compromise with the rulers, merge into the existing system, and become the defender of the current ruling system, as the Song Jiang actually hoped. These two choices are seen by outsiders, and it cannot be said that Song Jiang at that time was able to see such a choice, but his ability to choose compromise is the manifestation of his strategic vision, with their strength, they simply cannot establish a huge force like Li Zicheng and Hong Xiuquan, and the vitality of the Song Dynasty at that time has not been exhausted, the economy of the Song Dynasty has not led to the bankruptcy of most members of society, and the time is not yet ripe to overthrow itThis in itself is the tragedy of Song Jiang, and it is at this level of understanding that Song Jiang has a more strategic vision than other uprising leaders and is more qualified to become a big brother. So compromise is not a manifestation of cowardice in Song Jiang's character, Song Jiang has never been a cowardly little official, he was coerced by others to go to Liangshan, if he is only confused by Song Jiang's compromise side and can't see his strategy, then the meaning of the Water Margin is much more superficial.

Although Song Jiang had such a strategic vision, the gap in his personal quality led to his inability to implement his strategy well, after all, he was only a small official, with limited level of understanding and political ability, although he was better than other rebel leaders, but he could not complete the role assigned to him by history, if he could reach the quality of politicians like Liu Bang and Cao Cao, I think Song history would really be rewritten. This is the second tragedy of Song Jiang.

Under the breath of loyalty, there is a hint of rebellious determination.

Song Jiang, the owner of Shuibo Liang cottage, this person understands the righteousness, fights righteousness and squanders wealth, and has won the praise and admiration of the majority of heroes. But his later recruitment was indeed a big fool and a weak mind, and the villain's opinion, although it was out of a good intention, it eventually made a big mistake and he couldn't regret it.

As a literati who was unwilling to do anything in feudal society, Song Jiang was full of retribution but had nowhere to show it.

He squandered money and fought righteousness, helped the weak and alleviated, and was filial to relatives and friends, which was the gentle and generous side of his character;

He was filial to the emperor and emphasized righteousness, which was the orthodox side of his character;

He does things for everyone in the open and makes friends with thieves in the dark, which is the hypocritical and cunning side of his character;

He gathered people to oppose the country and wrote poems and words, which is the rebellious side of his character.

The pedantic literati who open their mouths and close their mouths want to find a way out for 106 (no exceptions) brothers. In the end, he exchanged the lives of his brothers for an official and a half-position, and in the end, he did not have a good death. If his brothers had the spirit of heaven, they would have hated themselves for being blind in their previous lives.

A happy man who made a bunch of righteous brothers;

A mentally handicapped person will not find a good home for his brother;

A clever person has achieved a career in Shuibo;

A pathetic man who does not know the cruelty of the temple;

In short, he is a person who is admirable at the beginning and suffocates at the end!

Visionary, idealistic, and bold speculators.