Guan Yu, one of the Five Tiger Generals , and Zhang Liao, one of the Five Good Generals , which on

If you talk about the level of force, there is no doubt that Guan Yu is much stronger than Zhang LiaoAlthough Zhang Liao is also very brave, but Guan Yu is a super-first-class military general of the Three Kingdoms, except for Lu Bu, no one can win Guan Yu, if it is a heads-up, Guan Yu alone can deal with Zhang Liao and Xu Huang teamed up, but Guan Yu is inferior to Zhang Liao in terms of military ability, although Guan Yu is also an excellent military strategist, but he is too proud, so it is easy to underestimate the strength of the enemy, this is also the reason why Guan Yu will defeat Maicheng, Zhang Liao is much calmer.

Everyone knows that Guan Yu is a very important figure in the Three Kingdoms periodGuan Yu is not only strong in martial arts, but also values love and righteousness, so he is admired by many people, Guan Yu is not only an outstanding general, he is also a military strategist, and his art of war on the battlefield is also one of the best, and there is a very powerful military general in the Wei State, this person is called Zhang Liao, although he and Guan Yu are not in the same camp, but the private relationship is good, because the two have known each other for a long time, and when Guan Yu was helping Cao Cao behead Yan Liang and Wen Chou, Zhang Liao also saw it.

So which of the two of them is more capable? In fact, there is no comparison between thisIn terms of the level of martial arts, Guan Yu is definitely much stronger, although Zhang Liao is also a good general, but pure force, he can't enter the first-class generals, and it is similar to Xu Huang and Xiahoudun, Guan Yu is the head of the five tiger generals, not a level at all, and Zhang Liao's martial arts are not the highest in Cao Ying, there are also Xu Chu and Dian Wei above him.

But although Zhang Liao couldn't beat Guan Yu, his resourcefulness was no worse than Guan YuHe is also a wise and brave character, and he is a little much stronger than Guan Yu, he is calm and calm, never reckless, only Zhao Yun can be comparable to him in this regard, although Guan Yu is powerful, but his personality is too arrogant, and it is easy to be caught by the enemy, the reason why he defeated Mai Cheng,It is also because of his character.

Zhang Liao was brave and resolute, 7,000 people rejected Sun Quan's 100,000 army, and 800 people broke the Eastern Wu Dynasty, leaving a reputation for stopping crying.

Guan Yu was arrogant, although he regarded Dongwu as a rat, but he was captured by Dongwu.

By comparison, the judgment is made from the superior.

The facts have long been decided, and the Martial Saint Guan Yu must have a slight advantage. Guan Yu's record of the five good generals is almost unsurpassed.

The two of them are better than fame, Guan Yu is better, than martial arts, or Guan Yu is powerful, more than the battle record, Zhang Liao is powerful, even if Guan Yu is powerful in China, but he has experienced a big defeat, causing himself to be in a different place, losing the city and losing the land. However, Zhang Liao did not have such a defeat, but defeated the strong with the weak and preserved Hefei.

Personally, I feel that Guan Yu is more powerful, after all, he can make moves in Lu Bu's hands without being defeated, pass five levels and kill six generals, and his record is much stronger than Zhang Liao, and there is really no real comparison of combat power.

Compared with Guan Yu of the Five Tigers and Zhang Liao of the Five Tigers, Zhang Liao is a little smaller Guan Yu.

In history, Guan Yu and Zhang Liao are two famous generals, and many people like to compare them together, but from a comprehensive point of view in all aspects, Guan Yu is more powerful.

OneGuan Yu is respected by everyone as the "Martial Saint", whether it is in terms of reputation and ability to lead troops or other aspects are far higher than Zhang Liao, and in the real history, Guan Yu and Zhang Liao are not at the same level at all, Guan Yu wants to defeat Zhang Liao. First of all, in terms of reputation. It is recorded in history that Guan Yu has two adjectives, one is the enemy of ten thousand people and the other is the general of the bear and tiger, and he and Zhang Fei are the only two people who are called ten thousand enemies during the Three Kingdoms period, and they are also very eye-catching among the generals in the Three Kingdoms period.

There are also many people who evaluate Guan Yu as the champion of the three armies, it is obvious that these adjectives are very true and appropriate for Guan Yu, and the evaluation of Zhang Liao in the same period is much inferior, including Cao Pi's evaluation of Zhang Liao's "Ancient Calling Tiger", which is obviously much worse in name.

IIThe second aspect is from the aspect of martial arts. Guan Yu defeated Zhang Liao in this aspect, take the Battle of the White Horse as an example, Guan Yu and Zhang Liao are Cao Cao's forwards, and the two of them led troops to attack Yan Liang at the same time, but only Guan Yu beheaded Yan Liang alone, and this is also the first and only cooperation between the two people but Guan Yu directly robbed the great achievement, which shows that Guan Yu's martial arts are really powerful.

IIIThe third aspect is from the point of view of the ability to command troops. Guan Yu is strictly a general who guards one side, Guan Yu has never disappointed Liu Bei, and has completed all the tasks within his ability, and Guan Yu has always been a general in charge of Jingzhou alone, guarding Jingzhou alone for many years. Including Guan Yu is a northerner, when he came to Jingzhou, the sailors here were trained very well, especially when Liu Bei was defeated by Cao Cao when he was in Changsaka, it was because of the naval army led by Guan Yu that Liu Bei fled to Jiangxia, although Zhang Liao is also very powerful, but there is still a big difference.

is famous, Guan Yuda must be big, after all, he is one of the main characters of the protagonist group of the romance.

The status, Guan Yu is relatively high. The veteran of Shuhan Group and one of the core figures. And Zhang Liao is a demoted general in the Cao Wei group, just a magistrate.

In terms of martial arts, it should be Guan Yu, after all, he was used by Cao Cao as a special combat team.

In terms of IQ, Zhang Liao should be relatively high. After all, Zhang Liao could let the two Qincha who were dissatisfied with him fully cooperate with him to fight, but Guan Yu forced the emperor's brother-in-law to rebel against him.

In terms of the combat ability of commanding troops, judging from the facts, it should be Zhang Liao who is more powerful.

After all, Zhang Liao defeated Sun 100,000, and the generals under Sun Quan, such as Gan Ning, Lingtong, Lu Meng, and Zhou Tai, fled.

And Guan Yu lost to Sun 100,000.

Judging from the results, Zhang Liao is the one worthy of the title of God of War of the Three Kingdoms.

Although Guan Yu flooded the Seventh Army, was defeated by the ban, and shocked China, Guan Yu suffered many defeats in his life, such as in the Battle of Xiangfan, he lost to Xu Huang and Lu Meng one after another, and Zhang Liao rarely lost in his life, and his record was better than Guan Yu. But Zhang Liao, whether under Empress Lu or Cao Cao, he is always a general, Guan Yu is under Liu Bei, but he is the commander of the army, even if Guan Yu's record is not as good as Zhang Liao, but his status is above Zhang Liao, the two are not at the same level, and the two have their own abilities.

Personally, I think Guan Yu is more powerful, after all, Guan Yu's influence is very great, and about the description in **, he is nine feet tall. Body type is an advantage. I think these are based on the fact that in **, about nine feet tall, very huge, and very tall, such a person must be very powerful.

The head of the five good generals is General Cao Wei. He was experienced in a hundred battles and rarely suffered setbacks, so he was named the head of the five good generals. We all know that in the troubled times of the Three Kingdoms, fierce generals are like clouds, and some famous generals are still mentioned by us repeatedly. For example, the five tiger generals of Shu Han;

Cao Wei's five good generals are all generals who have been practicing the art of war for a long time and are both civil and military, which is enough to take charge of themselves. Especially the five good generals, although they are brave in martial arts, they are still lagging behind Guan Yu, Zhao Yun, Zhang Fei and others; However, in terms of the ability to march and fight, they are not far behind.

The five Ziliang generals are Yu Ban, Zhang Liao, Xu Huang, Zhang He, and Le Jin. According to the record of Emperor Wu of the Book of Wei in the Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms, "it is a famous general, and the five sons are the first". In terms of fame and status, it is indeed difficult to match the foreign surname generals in Cao Ying.

And the head of the five good generals is not Xu Huang, who once repelled Guan Yu head-on and rescued the siege of Fancheng;

is not Zhang Liao, who has rarely met opponents since his debut; It is a name that many Three Kingdoms fans hate: Yu Ban. That's right, Yu Ban was the general of Zuo at that time, and his official rank could be said to be below one person, above ten thousand people, and the five sons and others were not comparable to him.

Yu Ban followed Cao Cao Rongma all his life, and it can be said that he has experienced a hundred battles and rarely suffered defeats. In the battle of Puyang, Cao Cao's troops were defeated like a mountain, and Lu Bu sang and marched; It was Yu Ban who stepped forward, repelled Lu Bu and Gao Shun, and successfully made Cao's army retreat slowly; Later, in the Battle of Wancheng, Zhang Xiu rebelled, and the Qingzhou Army mutinied;

It was Yu Ban who suppressed the field, reduced Cao Cao's losses, and pressed the Qingzhou soldiers who were about to move at that time. Therefore, Cao Cao was lamented by the ban on "the wind of ancient generals". He has extremely rich combat experience and is a veritable "trump card" under Cao Cao, so Cao Cao will be in the battle of Xiangfan;

I am very relieved to hand over the most elite Seventh Army to him. It's a pity that we all know Yu Ban's later story: he was defeated by Guan Yu, and his evening was not guaranteed. The head of the five good generals has become a laughing stock!

The five sons of Wei will have Zhang Liao, Le Jin, Yu Ban, Zhang He, and Xu Huang. The most powerful of them, the head of the Five Good Generals, has not been mentioned in history, but I think it is the strongest in Yu Ban.

Yu Ban was the head of the five good generals of Wei, but later surrendered to Guan Yu for various reasons.

The first of the five good generals is Yu Ban, although his strength is the worst, but he is good at patting Cao Cao's sycophants, so he was liked by Cao Cao and ranked him first.

The first is undoubted. The most glorious battle in Guan Yu's life was the Battle of Fancheng. In this battle, he captured Yu Jin and beheaded Pang De.

Even Cao Cao almost escaped from the capital. It can be seen that Guan Yu is a person who attaches equal importance to loyalty and courage. It is because of his loyalty that people in later generations have also given his image to mythology.

There is no doubt about Guan Yu's first place, whether it is official history or romance, Guan Yu's military ability is super strong. Guan Yu commanded the army to fight, and there were few defeats, and in the early stage of the Battle of Xiangfan, he was also flooded by the Seventh Army, which shocked the world, and even Cao Cao was so frightened that he almost moved the capital. If it weren't for the sneak attack from behind Dongwu, Guan Yu would probably have a better record.

Because Guan Yu's military ability is really very strong, Guan Yu is still a very smart person.

Guan Yu and Zhang Fei are Liu Bei's sworn brothers, as if the two of them originally followed Liu Bei. After decades of fighting, he has lived to this age, and this honorary position should belong to Guan Yu. According to Guan Yu's work experience, he can be regarded as the number two person in Shu Han, the veteran of the veteran level, so it is not too much for him to be the first.

Except for Zhang Fei, other people's work experience cannot be compared with Guan Yu.

Since Guan Yu followed Liu Bei, he has always been loyal and has never had two hearts. At that time, Liu Bei's army was defeated, and Guan Yu "disarmed and surrendered" to Cao Cao in order to ensure the safety of the two sisters-in-law. In the end, after five levels and six generals, the second sister-in-law of the guard was reunited with her brother, and the affection was singing and crying, which was admirable and admirable.

Liu Bei asked Guan Yu to be the leader of the Five Tigers, in fact, he also used Guan Yu as a banner to show everyone.

Although Guan Yu's combat power is not the strongest among the five tigers, his combat power is not weak. beheading Yan Liang and punishing Wen ugly, its strong people have long been spread all over the world. Moreover, Guan Yu not only has a lot of combat effectiveness, but also has a very strong ability to command troops.

Guan Yu is a good general in the true sense, from the conquest of the Yellow Turban Army to the garrison in Jingzhou, the size of the decisive battle, Guan Yu has a wealth of practical combat experience. Liu Bei saw its ability to command the troops in battle, otherwise he would not let Guan Yu sit alone in Jingzhou. Although others also have a strong ability to command troops and fight, they can't compare to Liu Bei's recognition of Guan Yu.

Liu Bei asked Guan Yu to be the leader of the Five Tigers, and there was another purpose, that is, to enhance Guan Yu's prestige and strength. Guan Yu is sitting alone in Jingzhou, he will definitely be questioned and resisted by many people, the local camps in Jingzhou overlap, and there is no one with high prestige, it is difficult to suppress everyone. If Liu Bei does not allow Guan Yu to be the leader of the Five Tigers, then some people with ulterior motives will guess Sun Xiaoxiao's intentions for Liu Bei.

In Jingzhou, they will try their best to restrain Guan Yu, which is not conducive to the stability of Jingzhou.

As the pioneer of Cao Jun, Pang De and Guan Yu faced off hundreds of times in the first battle, and there was a stalemate; In the second battle, they flattered each other and fought for more than 50 times, and Pang De shot Guan Yu with an arrow, and finally Guan Yu had no way to take Pang De. Relying on the temperature factor, he excavated the water and soaked Cao Jun, and captured Yu Ban and Pang De alive. If you talk about single killing, Pound did not lose to Guan Yu back then, the two made a draw, and in the end, only Guan Zedraft and the second master defeated Pound by using the method of water attack, which shows that Guan Yu is just "out of reach, but in fact, it is difficult to deputy".

Based on the analysis of the above points, although Guan Yu's combat effectiveness is not the first of the five tigers, from the perspective of academic qualifications, Guan Yu is the right-hand man of the five tigers. Whether it is the combat strength of the commander of the army, or the work experience in the army, he is the first person of the Five Tigers.

It is indeed a return to the Qing Dynasty, I have to say that among the five tiger generals, Guan Yu is definitely the first among the five, Guan Yu's lethality is still relatively strong, and he is a particularly good general.

His strength cannot be called the first, and the so-called first is ranked according to comprehensive strength. His force value has always given people the impression that he is very powerful, but in the details of the ** banquet, we can briefly see some clues, such as the battle with Huang Zhong, in fact, the opponent's force value at that time was far above him, but because the other party took into account his camp and his own comprehensive strength to compare, in the end, he was merciful.