Why did Shi Da cross the Dadu River and be wiped out?

Updated on history 2024-05-01
9 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    Because his wife gave birth to a son, he held a three-day banquet and missed the best time to cross the river.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    At that time, the Dadu River suddenly broke out in a flash flood and other reasons, and Shi Dakai's troops finally fell into a desperate situation. In order to protect them, Shi Dakai went to the Qing army camp alone to discuss peace issues, was escorted to Chengdu, and finally executed.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Shi Dakai faced the only iron chain bridge on the Dadu River, there was no light artillery suppression, automatic ** assault, relying only on lightning guns, flintlock guns, it is impossible to climb the iron cable across the bridge. Therefore, Shi Dakai, who was intercepted in front and pursued in the back, was completely annihilated.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Even if Shi Dakai.

    The river crossing was successful at the beginning, but it was difficult to succeed in the end. From the moment he first ran away in a negative mood, he was doomed to fail, at most he was just surviving. <>

    Shi Dakai was a famous leader of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom in the late Qing Dynasty, and he himself was able to write and fight, and he was proficient in everything on the battlefield. Shi Dakai came out of the mountain at the age of 16, and three years later, he became the commander and led thousands of troops. At the age of 20, he was named the Wing King, which can be said to be the pinnacle of his life, but God did not give him more time to display his talents, and he led the army to cross the Dadu River.

    , because of negative anger, he fled aimlessly with an army of 100,000, and finally, he was broken and sunk in Anshun and died on the battlefield. <>

    Some people think that if Shi Dakai successfully crossed the Dadu River at that time, he might be reborn in Nirvana, but in fact, this can only make Shi Dakai survive for a longer period of time, and he will not succeed. One is because although Shi Dakai's military talent is high, as a general leader, he himself does not have a strong ability to make decisions, and he is indecisive in case of trouble. Secondly, the incident in Tianjing.

    Later, the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom revolted.

    The internal chain of the army has fallen apart, at this time Shi Dakai chose to lead the troops to escape, if he was more bold at this time, he could still escape, but he did not choose to stand on his own, and continued to play the "Taiping Heavenly Kingdom" signboard, falling into an embarrassing situation. <>

    After the Tianjing Incident, Hong Xiuquan.

    persuaded him to go back, but he was always unwilling, and when Anqing was besieged by the Qing army, Shi Dakai had no intention of wanting to rescue. This kind of rebellious behavior naturally made Dakai's troops lose moral support, and in the end, Shi Dakai had no one to help him on the battlefield.

    All in all, even if Shi Dakai crosses the Dadu River later, there is no way to turn things around, after all, his men and horses are getting fewer and fewer, coupled with his indecisive character, it is difficult for him to carry the banner, and in the face of the imposing Lunsui Qing army, it is destined to have no chance of winning. Target.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    In the end, there is a chance of success, because after crossing the river, there will be a lot of people who are willing to support him and are willing to follow him to make a comeback.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    From the perspective of the combat effectiveness of the Taiping Army, even if Shi Tuoda crossed the Dadu River, he would not be able to sue Chengdu. In a decisive battle with the army of the socks on the plains crisscrossed by the river, and to attack the fortified city, Shi Dakai simply could not do it. In this way, Shi Dakai will still be defeated and have no chance of winning.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    It's possible, after all, his ability is very strong, and he can make a comeback, but it will take a long time, but it's not like he doesn't have firewood.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Yes! It is quite possible to build a new Chinese empire!

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    The main reason for Shi Dakai's failure in the Dadu River: Li Yu.

    1. There is a lack of special institutions responsible for the food and grass of the large or early army, and food crises often occur in the army.

    2. The rush to expand the troop has increased the food burden, but the logistical supply has not been completely solved.

    3. Ignoring logistics work and not paying enough attention to the collection of food and grass for the enemy, leaving an opportunity for the enemy to take advantage of.

    Introduction:

    Shi Dakai (March 1831 - June 27, 1863), nicknamed Yada, nicknamed Shi Gandang, Guixian County, Guangxi (now Qishi Township, Gangbei District, Guigang City), ancestral hometown of Heping County, Guangdong Province. A famous general of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom, a modern Chinese military strategist, and a national hero. He was once named the "Wing King of the Holy Spirit Dentong Army" and was revered as the "Righteous King".

    Shi Dakai was one of the most legendary figures of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom, he was sympathetic to the people's livelihood, and his life deeds were praised by later generations, and he was considered "the most perfect image of the peasant uprisings in China in all dynasties". In May of the second year of Tongzhi (1863), he led the crowd deep into the Yuexi Mountain, reaching the south bank of the Dadu River, and finally the whole army was annihilated, and Shi Dakai was captured.

Related questions
9 answers2024-05-01

In the last years of the Qing Dynasty, the largest peasant uprising Taiping Heavenly Kingdom Movement, among the many generals, only Shi Dakai can be called a famous general. He made great contributions in the process of the establishment of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom, and beat Zeng Guofan several times to commit suicide by jumping into the river. Moreover, he was an upright person and managed the army well, and was deeply loved by the soldiers of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom. >>>More

9 answers2024-05-01

Where did the 100,000 elites come from, there was a problem within the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom, and Shi Dakai was also implicated (no longer trusted) and forced to leave. There are fewer and fewer people who follow Shi, and in the end there are only some cronies, in order to save the lives of these people, Shi Dakai surrendered to Qing ** with his wife and children, who knew that Cixi, the old woman, was untrustworthy and treacherous, not only broke the contract and killed the Shi family, but also killed all Shi's subordinates ......Heroes are born at the wrong time, if it is the era of Kangxi Yongzheng, Shi Dakai is very likely to be another Shi Lang ...... >>>More

9 answers2024-05-01

Because their own group simply does not have so many ships, plus there are too many people, they will fail.

27 answers2024-05-01

Because they are all people who are afraid of death, and they will think of all kinds of ways to keep themselves alive in the face of death.