Is Qin Shi Huang all to blame for Qin s demise?

The reason for Qin's demise was rooted in two people, one was Li Si and the other was Zhao Gao.

Why do you say Lis? In "On the Passage of Qin", it is said that it is because of the immutable law, after reading many books, I think it is not, if it is because the Qin law is too strict, then why did the people of the Qin State not rebel and not respond to the chaos at the time of the chaos? Outside is boiling, outside of Guanzhong is not owned by Qin, but Guanzhong is quiet, Xiang Yukeng killed 200,000, all of them are Qin people.

Therefore, the reason is not in the law, but because the Kwantung people and the Qin people at that time were not a family, that is to say, the Qin people are Qin people, and they are now Shaanxi people, and if you pull a province, such as Hebei people, you can't say that people are Qin people, but if you say that he is Han, he will definitely not object. Therefore, the most important reason why the anti-Qin cause at that time was so vigorous was that everyone did not think that they were Qin people, that is to say, there was no orthodox idea of governing the Qin Dynasty in their minds, and there would be the idea that Chu would be Chu even if the three households died in Qin. We know that the orthodoxy of the Chinese is very heavy, Wang Mang usurped the Han, and everyone helped him recover.

And the reason for this, the most important thing is that the Qin Dynasty did not implement the feudal system, and everyone may know the disadvantages of the feudal system, but the reason why he existed is also his value, as mentioned in Ma's "Treatise on the Monarch", when the kingdom conquers a region, there are two ways to occupy him permanently, one is to station a large number of troops, which is the top use, but it is not economical. The second is that the monarch lives directly in the newly occupied place. But there is only one monarch.

And the feudal system is actually to play the role of a monarch stand-in. Many things are not harmful or not beneficial or not harmful, but the important thing is to weigh it. And when the Qin Dynasty examined this issue, winning the government was not as good as some people thought, so I listened to Li Si, so when Chen Sheng rebelled, I didn't say anything else, just said that Xiang Yu and Liu Bang, who finally played a decisive role in the process of destroying Qin, Xiang Yu discussed with the Taishou in that place to fight together, and then killed the Taishou himself unexpectedly; Liu Bang discussed with the county magistrate to live together, but later the county magistrate saw that Liu Bang was afraid that it would not be easy to control and regret it, so he had to kill him, which shows the role played by the magistrate of Qin, who can say that Qin's demise has nothing to do with not dividing the seal

The reason for the demise of Qin can be directly traced back to the time of Qin Zhaowang, the grandfather of Qin Shi Huang. During the reign of King Zhao, the strength of the Qin State had reached the level of the ability to wipe out Liuhe. Wu has the god of war Bai Qi (a general who has not been defeated in history).

The text has Wei Ran and Fan Ju. But at this time, the crown prince of King Zhao died (King Zhao reigned 61 years). King Zhao's son died before he could succeed to the throne, and King Zhao had been subject to the Chu family of relatives because of his front half of his body, so all the family affairs arranged for his prince were women of the old Qin military nobles.

And the death of the crown prince directly led to the question of whether to make the grandson the emperor or the son the prince. If you don't have a grandson, then the background of this grandson is too terrifying. So the biggest storm on Daqin** began, Bai Qi was killed, and the three clans of Mengxi and Bai were imprisoned.

After that, the conflict between the old Qin warrior group and the Kwantung clan in the court never ended. After the unification of Qin Shi Huang, the old Qin warriors disappeared in the court. During the Unification War, Wang Jian and Wang Ben's father and son disappeared directly from the court.

Meng Tian, who drove the Xiongnu in the north, actually belonged to the Kwantung Shi group. After Li Si directed the sand dune scheme, the domestic contradictions broke out completely, but it is a pity that Li Si is not enough to suppress the old Qin people in Guanzhong, just imagine that the old Qin people who are the foundation of the Qin State have given up their own country, who else can save this devastated Great Qin? In the end, Liu Bang invaded Xianyang, but at this time, only the Kwantung clan in Xianyang was left to defect immediately, and the old Qin warrior group, which had made great achievements in the Great Qin Unification War, disappeared.

The demise of the Qin State lies in the contradiction between the old aristocratic group and the Great Qin military merit aristocratic system benefit group. It was not the fault of the First Emperor.

Qin unified China with Legalist thought, so it was natural that after unification, Legalist thought was also used to rule. However, it is wrong to govern the country with the idea of using Legalism, and to govern the country, we must use Taoist and benevolent thoughts. The error of consciousness was the root cause of the fall of the Qin Dynasty.

Not all, Qin Shi Huang's measures laid the foundation for the fall of the Qin Dynasty, the common people were too resentful, especially many students of other schools, and the exploitation of Qin II really led to the demise of the Qin Dynasty.

I think it's too much of a rush. There is no benevolent monarch, and if it weren't for Hu Hai, maybe history would be different.

Benevolence and righteousness are not applied, and the world is different!

To be precise, it should be the prince of Qin, Ziying is the eldest son of the prince of Qin, Fusu, after Zhao Gao killed Hu Hai, he found Ziying and let him succeed to the throne as emperor, it didn't take long for Liu Bang to hit Xianyang, and then Xiang Yu also arrived, Ziying dedicated the jade seal of the country to Xiang Yu, and the Qin State perished.

After the death of Qin Shi Huang, Zhao Gao colluded with Hu Hai and Li Si, forged a testament to establish Hu Hai as emperor, and gave Qin Shi Huang's eldest son Fu Su to die. Qin II Hu Hai was mediocre and did not have Qin Shi Huang's ability to control the resistance forces in various places. In July of the first year of the Second Dynasty (209 BC), Chen Sheng and Wu Guang were sentenced to death for dereliction of duty, so they took risks and led the soldiers to mutiny, which was huge and responded in various places.

Qin Shi Huang, II are responsible!! Qin Shi Huang did not appoint his eldest son, Fusu, as the crown prince. Zhao Gao is chaotic, Hu Hai is mediocre and incompetent! Li Si tampered with the edict.

Qin II Hu Hai was destroyed in his hands.