Han Xin has made an indispensable contribution to Liu Bang s career, if he establishes himself as th

I don't think necessarily, although some people are very good at leading troops to fight, but they are not suitable for being the king of a country, and some people are suitable for being emperors, but if you let him lead troops to fight, it is absolutely impossible, everyone will have their own strengths, their own shortcomings, we can't let them do things that they are not good at, so maybe things will become a mess, Han Xin is a good general, this is undoubted, but it may not be able to become a qualified king.

Isn't there a saying in modern times that there is a specialization in the art industry, which is probably what it means, Han Xin has always been praised by people because of his outstanding military talent, in the early years, he was humiliated by his crotch, and was regarded as timid, and then he has not been recognized by Xiang Yu, and has always been very unhappy, until he met Xiao He, he was finally reused by Liu Bang, and later Han Xin's performance also lived up to expectations, it can be said that Liu Bang achieved him.

Let's not talk about Liu Bang's imperial talent, but Han Xin really doesn't have the quality of being an emperor, he was not reused for a while, and he ran away later, and after being named a general, the whole army was even more surprised, it can be said that Han Xin really won't make friends and win people, but as an emperor, he won't win over people, how can he respond to others and stabilize the world if he lets others support him, and Han Xin himself may not have the courage to be an emperor.

There is also the fact that if Han Xin establishes himself as a king, it is actually unjustifiable, and there are not many people who support him, he wants to become an emperor, and it is difficult for him to become an emperor, and if he becomes an emperor, but he will not coordinate the forces of all parties, will not think from the overall situation, will not understand the suffering of the people, and will not be able to use people will make his emperor not last long, I think he is still more suitable to be a person who leads the army, and leading the army to fight is his strength.

An outstanding military strategist does not mean that he can dominate the world. In order to dominate the world, we must also have a strong ability to lead and manage, and we must have the heart to think about the people.

It is undeniable that Han Xin is an outstanding military strategist, but if you want to be a politician and a king, you must know how to use people, which Han Xin cannot do at all.

Probably not. Han Xin's ability to lead troops to fight is outstanding. But his ability to govern the country is not certain. If he doesn't know how to govern the country, and the people in the region he rules are unstable, he won't be able to dominate the world.

I don't think he can dominate the world, although he has good military talents, he is not cunning enough, he has no political acumen, and he is easily deceived.

I don't think so. Because to dominate the world, it is not only necessary to rely on military talent, but more importantly, to govern the country and secure the country.

I don't think so. If Han Xin establishes himself as king, he may become the next Xiang Yu. Leading a war is not the same as being a leader.

We all know that he is a very outstanding military talent, but it is impossible for him to establish himself as a king, what is needed is not only military affairs, but also the ability to know how to use people well.

No, because Han Xin has no political acumen, otherwise he would not be jealous of Liu Bang, and in the end there would be no good end.

In terms of military talent, it is theoretically possible, but if you want to succeed, you still need other help, and he didn't have anything when he first started, so it was difficult.

I don't think so, because Han Xin is a trickster, he can only play soldiers, but in terms of ruling the regime, or governing the country, many strategies are far inferior to Liu Bang.

No, Han Xin is a very successful military strategist, but he may not be able to become a leader like Liu Bang.

Han Shin's biggest defeat was that he did not establish himself as king. After the seizure of the state of Qi, his advisers once suggested that he establish himself as king and form a three-legged pattern with Chu and Han, but Han Xin thought that Liu Bang was not kind to him and could not bear to do so. As expected, after the Han Dynasty unified the world, Han Xin was killed by Empress Lü!

A person with such merit as Han Xin, no one who becomes an emperor will be at ease, if he chose to establish himself as the king and occupy the rich Qi State with his military methods, Liu Bang would not be able to deal with him at all. Even if it can't unify the world, it can continue to be divided and form a three-legged situation.

1, when Liu Bang, the king of Han, was in Guanzhong, there were few people, and Han Xin burned all over the country with such a little spark. Ming repaired the plank road, secretly crossed Chencang, returned to Sanqin, almost started from scratch, and helped Liu Bang to conquer the world. Therefore, as long as Han Xin is self-reliant, he can be at any time and has the ability to fight the world;

2, Han Xin started from the capture of Wei Wang Leopard, there were few generals, he only traveled around the entire north in three years, subdued Zhao, Dai, Yan, Qi and other places, and was also taken away by Liu Bang twice during the period of almost all the elite troops. Therefore, no force can resist Han Shin;

3, Han Xin will scatter beans into soldiers, he never asks Liu Bang for soldiers, Liu Bang secretly snatches his soldiers at every turn. He is not in a hurry, and he can still get soldiers. Soldiers are the foundation of war, and Han Xin's ability to recruit soldiers is the first in ancient and modern times;

4, Han Xin never needed Xiao He to provide food, Liu Bang did not have enough food, and Han Xin also supported Liu Bang. Besides, Han Xin's front is so long, and the food supply in the rear will definitely not be able to keep up. As long as Han Xin wins, he will have food.

5. Han Xinbing, the more the merrier. Except for the battle of Qixia, the others are all winning more with less, and they are all taking the initiative to attack. This ability is unique through the ages.

How can Liu Xiang stop it? There are too many soldiers, Liu and Xiang are not able to lead the troops, such as the battle of Pengcheng, Liu Bang's 560,000 was killed by Xiang Yu's 30,000. Xiang Yukeng Qin died 200,000.

In any case, Han Shin can be self-reliant at any time, and he can eventually win the world. A soldier immortal can explain the problem with a fairy word, he can see through others, and others can't understand him; He can subdue the other party with water, flags, letters, etc., and he is a god; Every time you fight, you don't fight hard, your own ** is not big, the other party ** is not big, and the other party will eventually belong to yourself, or disperse by itself. I think so, what about you?

Zhuge Kongming, with the strength of a Shu State, could not reach Guanzhong, and withdrew again and again; Kong Ming has always been trapped by grain and grass. Compared with Kong Ming, it can be seen that Han Xin's soldiers are like gods.

Yes, because Han Xin himself is a person who can write and martial arts, he is very smart, his strength is still relatively strong, and he is very caring.

I think at least there is a great success rate, and if he had listened to his subordinates calling himself king, it is very likely that the outcome would have been different.

Yes, because Han Xin himself is very smart, and his performance is very good, which is particularly surprising.

If Han Shin establishes himself as king, China may have to recalculate, and everything will have to change.

Han Xin was originally an ordinary soldier in Xiang Yu's army, but because he felt that there was nothing to do with Xiang Yu, he turned around and defected to Liu Bang. Although Liu Bang's strength is weak, he gave Han Xin the most room to show. Later, when Han Xin captured the seventy cities of Qi State, he directly named Han Xin as the king of Qi, and after the establishment of the Han Dynasty, he was named the king of Chu.

In fact, when Han Xin was the king of Qi, the strategist Kuaitong once persuaded Han Xin to break away from Liu Bang and go it alone. But Han Xin has always believed that Liu Bang has the grace of knowing him, and without Liu Bang, there would be no Han Xin today. Secondly, Han Xin's refusal to betray was also related to his strength at that time.

Although Han Shin occupies a lot of territory and has a lot of troops. But at that time, there were still many princes in the world, and if Liu Bang mobilized these people to attack together, he might not be an opponent. In addition, Han Xin was reluctant to do it alone, but he was still not pressed.

When Liu Bang demoted him to the Marquis of Huaiyin, Han Xin began to have resentment in his heart, and conspired with Chen Feng to rebel, but he was killed by Empress Lu before he could act.

1. I think that Liu Bang has the grace of knowing things

When Han Xin defected to Liu Bang, Liu Bang's strength was very weak. But for reasons of trust, all the troops were handed over to Han Shin under his command. It was precisely because of this kindness that Han Xin was reluctant to raise troops to betray Liu Bang when his territory became larger and larger, and his troops were more and more numerous.

The strategists Kuaitong and Zhong Liwu both persuaded Han Xin to rebel, but Han Xin did not agree.

2. The strength has not yet been reached

When the Han Dynasty was not established, Han Xin had already become the king of Qi, and the fief was the hometown of Qi. Although it seems that it has a country, in fact, the world was still in a state of fragmentation at that time. Even if Han Xin wanted to rebel, he would have to weigh Liu Bang's ability to call and soon be able to summon all the princes to attack him, so why take this risk.

3. I was not forced to do that

Anyone who does something needs to have a reason in their hearts. Han Xin was named the king of Chu after the establishment of the Han Dynasty, but not only because he was accused of rebellion and demoted to the marquis of Huaiyin, his power was not as great as before, but he had a little more resentment in his heart. So he decided to rebel against Chen Xuan, but unfortunately Chen Xuan was quickly defeated by Liu Bang, and Han Xin, the internal response, was also killed by Empress Lu.

Because Han Xin trusts Liu Bang very much, Liu Bang also trusts Han Xin very much, Han Xin once saved Liu Bang's life, and Liu Bang promised Han Xin a lot of benefits, so he will always follow.

The main reason is that he has no confidence, he has no real friends along the way, Fan Xu (many people may be aware of this) may be aware of this, but Fan Xu has a good relationship with Liu Bang, and Fan Xu has no ability. If he had a team like Liu Bang, it would be terrible.

He wants to repay Liu Bang for his kindness, he has no ambition to dominate one side, and he has no political acumen.

Mainly because Han Shin trusts him very much and has no ambition in this regard, so he will do this.

I think it's okay, because at that time, Han Xin held all the military power, and these military power was more than Sun Quan's entire army.

I don't think so, because Han Xin himself doesn't really want to be an emperor or a prince, and he may choose another monarch without Liu Bang.

I think it's okay, because Hanshin's strength is also very strong. And Han Shin likes to use some caution. Maybe a lot of people can't resist him

I don't think so. The basis is that Han Xin is just a reckless man, and there are not many people willing to help him, he only has himself by his side.

If Han Xin really chooses to support the army and stand on his own feet and stand in the hostile camp with Liu Bang from then on, then Han Xin will inevitably become a big stumbling block on the road to Liu Bang's hegemony, but this does not mean that Han Xin will definitely win the final victory. This is not because many Han Xin's ability to lead troops to fight is not good, but because Han Xin is really inferior to Liu Bang in other aspects except for leading troops to fight, and Ah Hanxin only has a soft spot for fighting and leading soldiers.

First of all, if the rebellion chills need prestige. Obviously, Han Shin has such prestige. Han Xin's military exploits are too great, even Liu Bang's brother-in-law Fan Xu is respectful, and people like Chen Xin are also convinced of Han Xin.

As long as Han Xin puts up the banner of rebellion, there will be many people who will follow him with all his heart. However, remember that although these people admire Han Xin, they are only limited to leading troops to fight, and it is obviously impossible for you to let them betray Liu Bang and follow Han Xin.

Moreover, Han Xin's political level is extremely clumsy, arrogant and unsophisticated. To put it simply, Han Xin is a war machine, and Mao doesn't understand anything else, you must know that even if he is cut to the Marquis of Huaiyin, Han Xin still puts on a posture with his nostrils facing the sky. Fan Xu treated him with princely courtesy, but Han Xin said, "I didn't expect that I can only be with people like Fan Xu now."

As you can see, he doesn't know how to judge the situation, he doesn't understand the world, and he doesn't have the ability to turn his face at any time, so it is destined that Han Xin will not be able to raise troops and stand on his own, and even if he rises on his own, he is doomed to failure.

The explanation for this in the history books is that Han Xin was just a cloth cloth at the beginning, with no power and no power, he couldn't be an official, he couldn't make money, and he didn't pay attention to Xiang Yu, and it was Liu Bang who made him the king and worship the prime minister, and glorify his ancestors, so Han Xin felt that Liu Bang treated him well, and he had no reason to betray Liu Bang. In fact, Han Xin was loyal to Liu Bang from beginning to end, but he just wanted to lead his troops to fight, but the confrontation of people's hearts was too weak.

It's impossible to say about this matter, after Han Xin sets up his own door, maybe Liu Bang will also be defeated, and it may not be, mainly depending on which of the two of them is more capable.

No, because success is also Xiao He, defeat is also Xiao He, a person's success is multifaceted, not relying on only one factor, so Liu Bang's success is doomed.

I don't think Liu Bang will win, because Han Xin is very smart, and he is very popular with the people, and he will definitely win if he sets up his own door.

There is still a problem, or because Han Xin has not been loyal to his soldiers and horses, I see that when Han Xin attacked Zhao State, and when he was preparing to attack Qi State, the soldiers and horses were all taken away by Liu Bang, or without Han Xin's own knowledge, it shows that Han Xin's soldiers still obey Liu Bang.

If Han Xin is self-reliant, there will indeed be a situation where he and Liu Bang and Xiang Yu are divided into three worlds. At that time, Liu Bang and Xiang Yu were extremely anxious, and neither could defeat the other. And Han Xin happened to have a large number of troops in his hands.

Plus his own genius military command ability. It can completely compete with Liu Bang and Xiang Yu.