When Liu Bang killed Han Xin, why didn t Han Xin s personal soldiers come to save him?

Because Liu Bang had already been proclaimed emperor at that time. That is, Liu Bang is the highest official. Han Xin is just one of his generals.

To save Han Xin is tantamount to rebellion. Again, it was Lu Pheasant and Xiao He who booby-trapped Han Xin, and it is unknown whether Liu Bang instructed it. It is a booby-trap, of course, prepared and acted quickly, and it is too late to save.

Because Han Shin's death was already doomed at that time. At that time, Liu Bang's strength was already very strong, and they actually wanted to save it, but they didn't have the strength to fight against it.

Han Xin was tricked to the palace by Empress Lu and Xiao He to kill him, Han Xin's personal soldiers were not around at the time, and this incident was very sudden, and everyone was not prepared, so there was no way to save him.

Because Han Xin's personal soldiers didn't know, since Liu Bang was Han Xin, Han Xin himself didn't know beforehand, and they didn't know about it.

Han Xin did not have personal soldiers, and even if he did, he was not around, Han Xin was originally the king of Qi, and later changed his title to the king of Chu, and then became the marquis of Huaiyin, in the process Han Xin's wings have long been cut off. Han Xin's last title was the Marquis of Huaiyin, and Huaiyin was also his hometown, but when he was the king of Chu, he was captured alive by the strong men sent by Liu Bang, and Han Xin has been living in Chang'an since then, so Han Xin did not really become the Marquis of Huaiyin for a day.

Han Xin has fought for so many years and made so many achievements, why doesn't he have a personal soldier? At the beginning of the Han Dynasty, Han Xin was ranked by his military exploits, Han Xin was the first, and the second was Cao Shen, Cao Shen followed Han Xinli's military exploits, followed by Guan Ying, Kong Ju, Chen He, etc., these generals were once directly commanded by Liu Bang, and later they were all assigned to Han Xin's command, that is, Han Xin's team was afraid that the main force was Liu Bang's old subordinates, which was also the reason why Liu Bang was able to directly rush into Han Xin's military camp to seize the Shuai Yin and take away the seal.

Because the speed of the booby-trap of Han Xin was too fast, this caused Han Xin's 30,000 relatives to stop Han Han and his soldiers to not know that Han Xin had died at that time. After they got the news, everything had already fallen to the dust, and naturally there would be a situation where Han Xin's personal soldiers did not come to save Han Xin. Bending and balancing width.

When Liu Bang booby-trapped Han Xin's Zhibu slip, Han Xin's personal soldiers did not go to save him, because they fully understood the truth of conforming to the general trend. After all, after the unification of the world has been completed, Han Xin's role is no longer large.

Liu Bang did not trap Han Xin, Xiao He and Lu Hou premeditated when they killed Han Xin, so it cannot be said that Liu Bang booby-trapped, and Han Xin's personal soldiers were in ** when he died?

First analyze why Han Xin was killed 1, arrogance.

Han Xin's arrogance is recorded in the history books, once Han Xin talked with Liu Bang, Liu Bang asked Han Xin, how many soldiers and horses do you think I can lead to fight with my ability? Han Xin said 100,000, and then he continued to ask Han Xin, what about you? Han Xin said that the more the merrier, you must know that the military power was in Han Xin's hands at that time, Liu Bang did not say anything, but he had already held a grudge.

It is difficult to say that Han Xin was killed without Liu Bang's instructions, but in the history books, Liu Bang was indeed in the field to quell the rebellion at that time, and after Han Xin was killed, Liu Bang also cried bitterly.

2. Repeatedly insulting Liu Bang's cronies.

Fan Xu is Liu Bang's childhood friend and has repeatedly helped Liu Bang get out of danger, and Han Xin, as a person who took refuge in Xiang Yu's camp, often insulted Fan Xu's birth and ability to lead troops to fight.

Liu Bang's intention was very simple, at that time, he really needed a talent like Han Xin to fight the world, so without Han Xin fighting Xiang Yu by himself, it would be tantamount to self-destruction.

3. Credulous others.

Xiao He is a good friend of Han Xin, and Xiao He has indeed shown outstanding talent in governing the country, so Han Xin has always believed in this person, but in order to survive, he betrayed Han Xin, tricked him into Changle Palace, and killed him.

Xiao He didn't want to kill Han Xin, but he was forced by Empress Lu's edict that if Han Xin didn't die, he would have to die, so he chose to betray Han Xin, but he was actually forced to believe Xiao He in vain.

The above three points are the reason why Han Xin must die, when Han Xin left the palace and entered the palace, the main hall was still calm, so these pro-soldiers thought that there was no big deal in entering the palace this time, so naturally there was no preparation for battle.

However, Empress Lu sent the Imperial Forest Army to directly kill all these government soldiers, so these people naturally could not rebel, and Han Xin could only die unjustly in Changle Palace.

Whether Liu Bang participated in this booby-trapped killing, the answer given in the history books is yes, it was he who issued a secret edict to kill Han Xin after he left, but this is not logical, since he had the idea of killing Han Xin early, why should he be given seven immortality?

If there are no seven immortals, how simple is it to directly send the Royal Forest Army to suppress them, and do you still use booby-traps? Why did Liu Bang scold Empress Lu and posthumously seal a series of titles of Han Xin after returning to the dynasty? So I came to the conclusion that Liu Bang was not involved in this booby trap at all. What do you think about this?

It is estimated that Liu Bang had already designed to deliberately arrange these cronies away, and deliberately set up a situation at that time to relax the vigilance of Han Xin and his cronies.

On the one hand, he also asked for himself, and Han Xin in the back became more and more arrogant and arrogant, causing everyone to betray his relatives, and even put Liu Bang in his eyes, so Liu Bang wanted to kill Han Xin, on the other hand, he also asked for it, and there were no cronies around him to save him.

Because no one dared to resist, they were all afraid that one day they would suffer the same fate as Han Xin.

Han Xin's killing was designed by Empress Lu, as for why his personal soldiers did not save him, mainly because Han Xin had been cut by Liu Bang when he was killed, and there were not many people available around him.

The main reason is because Han Xin is suspicious and doesn't trust anyone, so when Liu Bang wants to kill him, there is no one around him who can save her.

It is wrong to say that Liu Bang booby-trapped Han Xin, because Liu Bang did not want Han Xin to die. He died at the hands of a woman. Yes, it is Liu Bang's wife, Lu Pheasant.

Strictly speaking, this is an active wife. If the wife means that her husband inspired it, it shouldn't be. It is estimated that husbands and wives do not believe what they say.

Liu Bang's gangster background is not controversial. His father didn't like him, let alone the society of the time. It is difficult to find a daughter-in-law.

The main social ideas of the time would not have considered such people.

As for saying that there is an old man who will be angry. Seeing that this gangster had an extraordinary future and the image of the emperor, he had to marry his daughter and was willing to turn it upside down. This kind of talk is for fun.

As for saying that Liu Bang has a sense of responsibility or love, the girl cried and cried and wanted to be with him, but it is estimated that the ghost did not believe it. We can compare Zhou Yafu. Zhou Yafu was the prime minister, and his position was not low, but his son was noticed when he sent the bridge to buy armor.

The son said that he would bury his father when he died.

Therefore, the censor said, "Do you want to rebel underground?" "Won the empire in one fell swoop**. But he was told again, and the plan failed.

Later, Empress Lu and Xiao He lured Han Xin into the palace and executed nine families. This is consistent with the phrase "the rabbit is dead, the dog cooks, and the bird hides its bow". Liu Bang and Xiang Yu fought for the world.

At first, they were beaten and ran around. On the way, they met his two children and pushed them away several times.

Fortunately, a good driver, Xia Houying, was rescued again. This is the later Han Dynasty Hui King and Princess Lu Yuan. As for the suitable wife, Empress Lu and his father, Taigong, they were both arrested by Xiang Yu for more than two years.

It is estimated that Empress Lü also got used to it, because Liu Bang ran away and his wife and children could not stop him. The oil thief on the soles of his feet is fast. Does this scene feel familiar?

Yes, so is Liu Bei in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms". This seems to be genetic. Later, Empress Lü announced that Han Xin had been executed for a conspiracy and ordered the killing of three Yi people.

Therefore, even if Han Shin had his own soldiers and studied after he was killed, there was no need to save him. If Han Shin hadn't died, his own soldiers would have rescued him, and if he rebelled, he would have been killed as well. The cost was too high, so he was relieved to accompany Xiao He into the palace.

As soon as he entered the palace, Xiao He, who was trapped in the world, gave an order, and the guards in the palace arrested Han Xin. Lu Pheasant didn't wait for Liu Bang to come back at all. Liu Bang is still resisting.

First of all, he and Julu Sheriff Chen Chen teamed up to rebel outside. Then, Han Xin took advantage of Liu Bang's battle with Chen Chen to capture the capital. These two statements echo back and forth, making it impossible for Liu Bang to take care of both sides and win the world.

Han Xin's personal soldiers have long been gone, after all, Han Xin has been deprived of military power.

Han Xin's Qing soldiers all went to Jingzhou at that time, and his Qing soldiers were all transferred by the emperor at that time, and he did not save Han Xin in time.

His own soldiers were all injured by Liu Bang. Liu Bang is a sinister and cunning person, and he has long been prepared for everything.

Han Xin, Tai Shi Gong and Xiao He, Zhang Liang called him"Three heroes of the early Han Dynasty", is Liu Bang's first founding hero. Han Xin helped Liu Bang win several key battles between Chu and Han. For example, we are familiar with the secret of Chencang, the battle of Jingjing.

The most classic is that in the Battle of Qixia, Xiang Yu, the first military general in the history of Han Xinqiu, committed suicide. Liu Bangdu once said. "Husband's plot is better than thousands of miles away, I am not as good as an egg; Zhenguo, help the people, raise the ring, not the valley, I am not as good as Xiao He; A million soldiers will win over the attack.

I'm not as good as Han Shin. All three rejoiced"。

<> from this point of view, Han Xin's record is incomparable. Liu Bang also promised Han Xin:"Heaven does not kill Han Xin, the emperor does not kill Han Xin, and iron does not kill Han Xin"。

This sentence is not recorded in the official history, but it is clearly recorded in other historical books such as "Romance of the Western Han Dynasty"). This means that under no circumstances will he kill Han Shin. Sadly, Liu Bang did not keep his promise, and Han Xin was eventually killed.

However, Liu Bang did not directly hit Han Xin. Lu Ji killed Han Xin with a bamboo knife (not Junbu killed Han Xin). After learning that Han Xin had been killed, Liu Bang's reaction was"Joy and sorrow"(Sima Qian's "Historical Records"), which shows that Liu Bang was full of joy at Han Xin's death, rather than sadness and guilt.

Why did Liu Bang kill Han Xin? Han Shin is not one"Allies"。Han Xin has been under Xiang Yu.

After Chen Sheng and Wu Guang rebelled, Han Xin took refuge in Xiang Liang, but his identity is unknown. After Xiang Liang was defeated, he was assigned to Xiang Yu, and Xiang Yu made him a doctor. After Liu Bang entered Shu, he was recommended by Xiao He.

Han Xin left the state of Chu and returned to the state of Han. Liu Bang stamped him with the seal of a general. Therefore, Liu Bang has always held a grudge against Han Xin, fearing that he will rebel one day.

Han Shin's military talents. Liu Bang once said"It is difficult for a husband and a woman to cook without rice, and the decisive victory is thousands of miles away, I am not as good as eggs; The town of the country helps the people, there is no food for raising the environment, I am not as good as Xiao Heye; An army of millions will win the attack. I'm not as good as Han Shin.

All three rejoiced"。It can be seen that Han Xin's military genius is as high as 100% in Liu Bang's eyes. After the establishment of the state, it is unstable and can collapse at any time.

And the stability of the country depends on the army, and the collapse of the country is also related to the army, then Han Shin is in danger! "Han Xin said.

Han Xingong is the master. According to the record of "Romance of the Western Han Dynasty", Liu Bei said to Han Xin. "Heaven does not kill Han Xin, Jun does not kill Han Xin, and iron does not kill Han Xin"。

This sentence is more obvious, however, Han Xin reached the point of death, and finally Lu Zhi killed Han Xin with a bamboo knife. What will Liu Bang's expression be when he receives this news? Therefore, Han Xin died before he left the school, but he ended up like this, and only stayed"Rabbits and dead dogs are cooked, and birds are hidden"words to warn future generations.

Liu Bang was a very suspicious person, Han Xin had more credit at that time, and the power in his hands was relatively large, Liu Bang was afraid that Han Xin would rebel, so he found an excuse to kill Han Xin.

Because Liu Bang believed that Han Xin's existence threatened his position, Liu Bang believed that Han Xin might plot a rebellion, Han Xin's military ability was strong, and Han Xin's emotional intelligence was relatively low.

This is because of political competition, and Xiao He has an inseparable relationship, and Empress Lu is more afraid of Han Xin, so it led to the death of the other party.