Ming Dynasty or Qing Dynasty, which dynasty was stronger?

Of course it's the Ming Dynasty, otherwise why would so many people in the Qing Dynasty want to oppose the Qing Dynasty and restore the Ming Dynasty?

The Ming Dynasty in the Chongzhen era was not as strong as the Qing Dynasty in the Dolgon era.

The Ming Dynasty in the Chongzhen era was stronger than the Qing Dynasty in the Xuantong era.

The Ming Dynasty in the era of Zhu Yuanzhang was stronger than the Qing Dynasty in the Shunzhi era.

The Ming Dynasty in the Zhu Di era was stronger than the Qing Dynasty in the Kangxi era.

On the whole, the Ming Dynasty was still stronger than the Qing Dynasty.

Personally, I think it's the Ming Dynasty.

The reason is one sentence: the Ming people are heavy artillery, and the Qing people are heavy horses. Horses and cannons, you say?

If it were not for Chongzhen killing Yuan Chonghuan and destroying the Great Wall and the earth entering the Xiaoice River period at that time, the Ming Dynasty would not have been killed by Li Zicheng into Beijing.

Actually, Chongzhen is a good emperor.

The territory is that the Qing Dynasty is stronger, and the sea power is that the Ming Dynasty is stronger!

Ming dynasty! At the beginning, neither Nurhachi nor Huang Taiji thought that they would be able to enter the Central Plains. The Manchus entered the customs on the basis of the civil strife of the Ming Dynasty.

The peasant army led by Li Zicheng looted money and grain in Beijing and invaded Wu Sangui's family, making Wu think that Li Zicheng could not be relied on, so the Manchus surrendered.

The two dynasties lasted too long to compare the strongest period of one with the weakest period of the other. So we all compare them to their heyday. During the Yongle period of the Ming Dynasty and during the Qianlong period of the Qing Dynasty.

Ming Chengzu went to Mongolia five times, each time it was an army of 500,000, and the army food was endless, which was simply not possible in other dynasties. But then again, the population of the Qing Dynasty was also unprecedentedly large, and so many people did not starve to death on a large scale, which also shows that the grain production of the Qing Dynasty has been greatly improved. The Ming Dynasty emphasized literature and light military force, but the national strength was quite strong in the heyday, and if it was not for improper command at the end of the Ming Dynasty, the Qing army would have no chance to enter the customs.

But the descendants will always be better than the previous generations, and in general, the Qing Dynasty was stronger for a longer period of time, and the population was unprecedented, so the Qing Dynasty was stronger than the Ming Dynasty. Hope.

The Ming Dynasty can only be regarded as medium in Chinese dynasties, and in terms of comprehensive ability, it cannot be compared with the Han and Tang dynasties, but it is stronger than the Qing Dynasty.

Economy: The economy of the Ming Dynasty was not prominent among the previous dynasties, and it could not be compared with the Song Dynasty, but it was stronger than the Qing Dynasty.

Military, the Ming Dynasty was very strong in the early stage, especially in the Yongle period, the military force reached its peak, five northern expeditions to Mongolia, the pursuit of the remnants of Mongolia, Zheng He seven to the West, as long as a little historical knowledge of people know that the Ming Dynasty can take almost all the major things that can be taken are done by Zhu Di. The Qing Emperor Kangxi called Zhu Di's era "Yuanmai Han and Tang Dynasties".

However, the Ming Dynasty did not eliminate the Mongols in the end, and even in the middle and late periods, the emperor was captured by Wara, and in the war with the Later Jin, he was at a disadvantage and lost a large area of land in the northeast.

The Ming Dynasty should not belong to the best dynasty, in the history of the youngest feudal society in our country, I think the Tang Dynasty is still the best dynasty. Because the Tang Dynasty has reached its heyday. It is the pinnacle of unsocial politics, economy.

The Ming Dynasty was not the best dynasty, the best dynasty in Chinese history was the Tang Dynasty, and the economic and technological development of the Tang Dynasty at that time was the most advanced in the world.

Historically, the Ming Dynasty was not the best dynasty, many emperors of the Ming Dynasty were relatively incompetent, and the most prosperous dynasty in Chinese history was the Tang and Song dynasties.

There are several dynasties in Chinese history that are very good, the early and middle Ming Dynasty is very good for the development of a country, but not in the later period.

Of course, this Ming Dynasty is not the best dynasty, and the emperors of the Ming Dynasty are many mediocre and incompetent emperors, and many emperors who ignore the government. And the eunuch dictatorship is particularly powerful.

No, from an economic point of view, it should be the Tang Dynasty, the prosperous Chang'an, and the Ming Dynasty is the most backbone dynasty.

The Ming Dynasty was the last dynasty to be established by the Han Chinese, and its peculiarity lies in the fact that Zhu Yuanzhang, the founding emperor of the Ming Dynasty, was a figure at the bottom of society, and the Ming Dynasty was also a unified feudal dynasty.

It depends on what angle to evaluate, but in most evaluation dimensions, the Ming Dynasty may not be ranked the best. The Han and Tang dynasties were the most prosperous.

For the ancient Han people, it was indeed a good era and a good dynasty.

The Ming Dynasty did have a glorious history in ancient Chinese historical dynasties, such as not ceding land and paying indemnities, not paying tribute and relatives, not surrendering and bending the knees, and not signing humiliation.

No, the Great Sui Dynasty, especially the opening of Emperor Wen of Sui, was the greatest and greatest era in China for 5,000 years.