When did China start to be poor, wasn t it very rich in the Tang Dynasty?

Your question is too vague. The wealth created in a historical period is very uneven in its possession. In China, it is roughly divided into three types: the state, the (big landlord), and the yeoman (small farmer). Who are you asking?

From the perspective of yeoman farming, all Chinese dynasties were very poor; On the landlord side, each dynasty was poor at the beginning of the dynasty and later after the communist agrarian revolution; From the most important aspect, the Song Dynasty in history was the most abnormal, the people were rich and the country was poor; The so-called "prosperous" periods such as the Sui Dynasty and the early Qing Dynasty were all rich in the country and poor in the people.

But generally speaking, the more descendants are, the richer they are than their predecessors, which is the inevitable development of social productive forces; In the same way, every dynasty will be poorer in the early stage, richer in the middle and early stages, and poorer in the later period.

Now, both the country and the people are slowly getting rich.

Since the Kangqian event, the drawbacks of China's seclusion have gradually emerged. Britain and other Western countries began to import opium to China in order to change their ** deficit with China. Then there was the Opium War, and I think it was after the Opium War that China began to be poor.

That's an interesting question! Every dynasty in China had a time when it was poor, and there was a time when it was relatively rich! The Tang Dynasty was only relatively rich in Zhenguan and the early Kaiyuan period!

Before the Opium War of 1840.

China is the richest in the world.

When the West was trading with our country.

Not only because of the vast size of our country.

It is also due to the strong purchasing power of our people.

In fact, in the entire ancient history of our country.

All are on the rise.

Don't think that the Qing Dynasty is poor and weak because it was humiliated.

That was only after the Jiajin Dynasty.

The Song and Tang dynasties were the two peaks in history.

Of course. Song's military was a little weaker.

Liaojin, Western Xia, and Tubo can't be defeated by anyone.

China has been impoverished since the Opium War!

Things are robbed, of course poor!

Personally, I think it is not from the perspective of economy, politics, culture, diplomacy, military and so on. The Song Dynasty should be considered relatively powerful. But it's also relative. In addition, the Han Dynasty was also relatively powerful.

Relatively speaking. It may be that the poor become rich, causing the rich to become poor.

There are still a lot of poor people. Any system will also face the situation of disparity between the rich and the poor, and can only strive to narrow the gap or improve the level of security, but it cannot eliminate the gap between the rich and the poor. Because in any system, there will be no absolute fairness, and most of the resources will be in the hands of those in power.

Of course, on the other hand, if the resources are in the hands of the poor, first, they are not used well, and they are all wasted, and second, if they are used well, he will not be poor, he will become rich, and he will stand in the ranks of the rich to treat the poor. Just like the boy who killed the dragon, he will slowly turn into a new dragon in the face of the large amount of treasure left by the dragon.

1.At the beginning of the Tang Dynasty, he was poor and left his place. The people have no means of making a living. Refugees are in trouble. The rich are poor and extravagant, and they want to do evil and do things in violation of the law.

2.The rule of Zhenguan to the prosperous era of Kaiyuan. The poor work at sunrise and rest at sunset. The rich are full of poetry and songs. Go to the examination department to report the son of heaven. Rationally exploit the poor, appease the poor, and feel the glory of the prosperous world.

3.Anshi Rebellion. In the war-torn land, there is no distinction between the poor and the rich, and the displaced people are fleeing for their lives everywhere, and the day is precarious, and there are many casualties.

Non-war-torn land. The poor went hungry and evaded military service. Harsh government is fiercer than a tiger.

There are Du Fu - "Three Officials" ("Xin'an Officials", "Stone Trench Officials", "Tongguan Officials") and "Three Farewells" ("Farewell to the Newlyweds", "Farewell to the Elderly", "Farewell to the Homeless") as evidence. The rich have a conscience and worry about the country and the people. Heartless forcible seizure of wealth is difficult for the country.

4.After the Anshi Rebellion. The poor live the miserable life of "The Coal Seller". The rich have a conscience and worry about the country and the people. Heartless annexation of land, oppression of the poor, plundering of the poor.

5.At the end of the Tang Dynasty, the poor ** left the place. The people have no means of making a living. Refugees are in trouble. The rich are poor and extravagant, and they want to do evil and do things in violation of the law. Bandits abounded, and uprisings were frequent. Defection to feudal towns abounded.

Hello! You're talking about the last years of the Tang Dynasty, right? The Tang Dynasty was relatively prosperous, and only at the end of the period was there a large gap between the rich and the poor, and the contradictions between the people deepened, leading to its demise.

There are poor people in every period.

This thing can't be avoided, after all, there is so much wealth in society, and if you don't work hard, others are working hard.

Giving is not necessarily rewarding, but not paying must be rewarding.

There have been many poor people throughout the ages.

It's just that the king of the Tang Dynasty was considerate of the people's suffering, and always put the suffering of the peasants on the agenda. Go and work on it. So it gives people the feeling that there were many poor people in the Tang Dynasty.

However, the kings of most dynasties blindly enjoyed themselves and ignored the sufferings of the people. So it feels like a prosperous age.

Hello, in fact, in the early days of the Tang Dynasty, because of years of war and natural disasters, many people were killed, and the economy was basically on the verge of collapse.

Why were there so many poor people in the Tang Dynasty? I will answer this question as follows, not only the Tang Dynasty, but also other dynasties, the common people of the whole country have no access at all, and the industry is not developed at all by farming. How many people can be in business?

So it's good to be able to farm for a year to maintain food and clothing, can he not be poor?

At that time, the economic level was not high, and there were years of war, the country's financial resources were declining, taxes were high, and there was no cultivation technology.

The government military system, the means of production and land are all public, the common people have very little property, and there was an uprising in the south 2 years after the death of Li Shimin, the rule of Zhenguan, and the rich southerners were still forced to rebel.

At that time, the Tang Dynasty was thousands of years earlier, that people were not so developed, and various factors such as economic regulations were not allowed, but now it is different, all aspects are good, people's minds, science and technology, and so on! That's why there would have been so many poor people in the Tang Dynasty.

Because there was no other way out in those days, only to live on the land, and at the end of the year, there was not much income at all, living in a big collective, waiting for everyone to live and farm together, when they got it, they could only get food, and there was no other place to make money, and now it is different, you can make a lot of money in any line, and now you rely on brain power.

China has a long history, and the reason why there were so many poor people in the Tang Dynasty must be there, because the difference between the rich and the poor in that historical period was still very large.

When many so-called historians talk about the Tang Dynasty, they talk about how strong the Tang Dynasty was; When talking about the Song Dynasty, it is often belittled and said how weak the Song Dynasty is. There are even some ** and romances since the Ming and Qing dynasties

In fact, there are many poor people in every era.

Not to mention the Tang Dynasty.

The rich and the poor are divided. There are many rich people, and there are many poor people, and some people just don't want to work, so they can only suffer from poverty.

There were many poor people in the Tang Dynasty, which dynasty. The Tang Dynasty looked at it from the general direction, and there should be fewer poor people, what do you say?

Wasn't the Tang Dynasty a prosperous era.

It should be poor and okay.

If it's a fact. It is also the inequality between the rich and the poor.

In every era there is a gap between the rich and the poor.

There were many poor people in every dynasty, not just the Tang Dynasty

Every dynasty has poor people, not only the Tang Dynasty.

Are there no poor people now, there are poor people all the time?