Why did Wei Yan die? Was it just an internal struggle for interests?

Although Wei Yan is brave, he has a proud personality and a very bad temperament, so many people are dissatisfied with him. He was at odds with Yang Yi, and the contradictions continued to stir up, and he was finally killed by Ma Dai sent by Yang Yi.

Wei Yan was arrogant and arrogant, and once dreamed that he had horns on his head, which was a sign that he would oppose the Shu Kingdom. And on weekdays, Wei Yan was arrogant and domineering, and he didn't get along with other generals very well, and his relationship with others in the army began to deteriorate. and ruined Zhuge Kongming's decision-making many times, and finally killed himself.

Because of his personality, Wei Yan has a domineering personality, is arrogant, and is very easy to offend people, and he is at odds with Yang Yi, and was finally assassinated by Yang Yi.

As the saying goes, the frozen ruler is not a day's cold, and an internal battle team in the political struggle is not enough to kill him, not to mention that Wei Yan is public, and he constantly makes enemies on weekdays, and the big tricks of the tree are even more resentful for a long time.

In history, Wei Yan was a general with a certain strength, and he was guarded against by Zhuge Liang because he put forward his military opinions many times. In the world, he made too many enemies and fought for political interests, and was publicly enmitigated by Yang Yi and others for personal vendetta and framed to death.

Wei Yan was arrogant and very capable, blocking Yang Yi's way to rise, and Zhuge Liang was also afraid that no one would be able to control Wei Yan after his death, so he was finally killed.

He is a powerful talent, but he is rampant, blocking the way of others to rise, and finally being killed by others.

The historical truth of Wei Yan's death is that he was chased by Ma Dai and wiped out by the three clans.

When Liu Bei entered Sichuan, Wei Yan had military exploits and was promoted to general of Yamen. Liu Bei captured Hanzhong, promoted him to the general of Zhenyuan, the Taishou of Hanzhong, and became the general of the independent party, guarding Hanzhong for more than ten years. After Liu Bei ascended the throne, he worshiped General Zhenbei.

Wei Yan fought bravely, had an arrogant personality, and was at odds with Changshi Yang Yi. After Zhuge Liang's death, the contradiction between the two intensified, and the key judgment fought for power with each other, Wei Yan was defeated and fled, and was chased by Ma Dai and cut down, and was wiped out by the three clans.

Major achievements:

Zhuge Liang put forward the Meridian Valley conspiracy during the first Northern Expedition. The battle of Yangxi broke Guo Huai and Fei Yao. During Zhuge Liang's fourth Northern Expedition, under the command of Zhuge Liang, he and Gao Xiang, Wu Ban and others defeated Sima Yi in the Battle of Lucheng and achieved the results of the first 3,000.

Wei Yan has a very outstanding military talent, he followed Liu Bei to fight in the south and the north, and his Meridian Valley plot is also very practical, but unfortunately Wei Yan does not understand power and strategy, and was suppressed by Zhuge Liang all his life, and finally died in the hands of Yang Yi.

Wei Yan's military talent was first-class in Shu, and during Wei Yan's tenure as the Taishou of Hanzhong, he never let Wei take a step forward in Hanzhong. And after his successor, who served as the Taishou of Hanzhong, Hanzhong was soon lost.

Wei Yan's military talent is still very powerful, which can be seen from the fact that he has never had problems in guarding Han; Because his death caused Shu Han to lose a fierce general, and he died at the hands of his own people, so it is a pity.

And Wei Yan's death was actually not aggrieved, the first of the soldiers to launch the Northern Expedition, Wei Yan contributed a lot, broke Fei Yao and Guo Huai, and pursued them all the way to the hinterland of Wei. The duty is obedience, and Wei Yan, as the leader of the troops, not only failed to fulfill his duties, but also prevented the retreat of the troops. If it weren't for Wang Ping's stopping, I don't know how many people would have died, and such a reckless and irrational act could be regarded as a rebellion.

[Wei Luo said:

Zhuge Liang is ill, and he is said to wait for the clouds: "After my death, but be careful not to come back." "Let Yan Shi do his own thing, and hold on to mourning. If you delay and hide it, you will go to the mouth of praise, and it will be mourning. Liang Changshi Yang Yisu and Yan were at odds, see Yan Zhi marching.

matter, afraid of being harmed, Zhang Yanyan wanted to raise the people to the north, so he led his people to attack Yan. Yanben didn't have this intention, so he didn't go with the army, chased and killed him. This is the official history.

The Romance of the Three Kingdoms is recorded as killed by Ma Dai, and after Zhuge Liang's death, he handed over the military power to Yang Yi, but he refused to accept it and rebelled. Killed by Ma Dai.

What are the reasons for rebellion, arrogance, etc., in fact, they are all fabricated reasons in the romance, Wei Yan's real cause of death was because he and Yang Yi had never been in agreement, and Zhuge Liang left his last words after his death, saying that Wei Yan should be left behind when he withdrew the army, but Wei Yan thought that Zhuge Liang's death could not be used as a reason to withdraw the army and to continue the Northern Expedition, so he delayed retreating, Yang Yi used this to frame Wei Yan for rebellion, and was finally killed, Wei Yan did not have the motive to rebel, strength, and did not act, and finally died on the way back to Chengdu. Therefore, it is unrealistic to say that Wei Yan rebelled, that is, he failed in the internal struggle and died.

In the book, Lao Zhuge said that Wei Yan's goods had anti-bones, so he asked Ma Dai to cut him, and the book said that this goods had anti-bones. In fact, I don't think Wei Yan thought about rebelling, he was all forced.

Wei Yan never showed signs of rebellion, he just sometimes disobeyed Zhuge Liang. After the death of Guan Zhang Zhao Ma Huang, Wei Yan can be said to be the number one general in Shu, and his military power should also be the greatest, but Zhuge Liang is his top boss. Zhuge Liang cut Wei, cautious; But Wei Yan had to take a dangerous road.

Zhuge Liang definitely disagreed when he was alive, but if Zhuge Liang died, then Wei Yan would have the power alone, and if Wei Yan's method was followed, assuming that the defeat of Wei was successful, it would prove that Zhuge Liang's decades of efforts were wrong. From this point of view, Wei Yan must die.

In the official history, Wei Yan was the most capable general of Shu in the late Three Kingdoms period (note that it was not Zhao Yun who was Wei Yan). But his position in Liu Bei's group is very awkward, because he is Liu Bei's general when he was in Xichuan and Jingnan, and he can be regarded as a late general. At the same time, he and Yang Yi of the Yizhou faction, who was formerly Liu Zhang's subordinate, were mortal enemies.

While the two are fighting openly and secretly, they both point to the position of Zhuge Liang's heir, and they are therefore feared by Zhuge Liang. In other words, with Kong Ming's character, neither of these two people will be suitable to inherit him. Among them, Wei Yan's character is very upright, arrogant and impulsive, which makes him absolutely unwilling to obey when others order him to withdraw after Zhuge dies, and he is unwilling to give up interrupting the Northern Expedition because of a person's death, and even burn the plank road to prevent the army from returning.

This left enough truth for his nemesis Yang Yi to put him to death, and finally Wei Yan was killed by the Shu army on the charge of rebellion.

According to the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Zhuge Liang calculated that Wei Yan would rebel, so he installed a Ma Dai beside him, which is of course unreliable;

According to the records of the Three Kingdoms, it can be speculated that the real reason for Wei Yan's real death was that he was at odds with Yang Yi, and he didn't want to break off the queen for him, so he disobeyed Zhuge Liang's order, retreated, and destroyed the roads along the way, making Yang Yi limited to passivity, so Yang Yi and Wei Yan both wrote to the court to accuse the other party of rebellion; It is certain that Wei Yan did not rebel, if he wanted to rebel, he did not need to withdraw to Chengdu at all, and just surrendered to Cao Wei directly.

Because his credit is too great, Zhuge Liang is suspicious, and he is afraid that his merit will be overshadowed.

I feel that Wei Yan has a strong personality, is proud of his talents, unruly, and is not a good subordinate...

Wei Yan was arrogant and thought that Zhuge Liang was the smartest when he died, so he did something to be killed Zhuge Liang left a bag of tips before he died Beware of Wei Yan Anti There are in the Three Kingdoms.

To put it simply, Wei Yan usurped the throne.

He ate too much, and his boss didn't have the money to feed him, so he killed him.

<> TV was that Wei Yan was originally a subordinate of Liu Biao, and later took refuge in Changsha to guard Han Xuan, and because he was dissatisfied with Han Xuan, he led the crowd to surrender to Liu Bei. At that time, Zhuge Liang was about to behead Wei Yan, saying that Wei Yan was disloyal and difficult to last long. Later, Liu Bei dissuaded him before he gave up.

He didn't know Zhuge Liang's arrangement, so he would think that Zhuge Liang didn't arrange it, so after Zhuge Liang's death, he should be the second person in power and decide the next move, and finally Yang Yi took control of the military power, Wei Yan naturally thought that Yang Yi rebelled and seized power, so he burned the plank road to prevent Yang Yi from returning to Chengdu. This logically makes sense.

The analysis is not reliable at all, Zhuge Liang was afraid that Wei Yan's recklessness would harm the Shu Kingdom, so he did not hand over the military power to Wei Yan, but only temporarily used Yang Yi. Even Yang Yi can kill Wei Yan, how capable can Wei Yan be? Zhuge Liang knows Wei Yan too well, Wei Yan is just a general, if he is the commander, Shu will fall earlier.

Later, in the Shu Han era of the later lord Liu Chan, Wei Yan's aggressive combat style always clashed with Zhuge Liang's strategic thinking of steadily and steadily marching step by step, and the biggest contradiction was Wei Yan's "Meridian Valley Conspiracy" that Zhuge Liang completely vetoed.

Zhuge Liang is unclear and narrow-minded, more than cautious in military but not enough courage, six out of Qishan without an inch of work, waste money, food and people's power, mediocre political achievements in Shu but drive and grab too much ...... the peopleZhuge Liang should be re-understood and evaluated.

Zhuge Liang's description of him is "I see that Wei Yan has a backbone in the back of his head", that is, the brain is anti-bone, I know that this word is because of the wronged Wei Yan's classmates, and now it has become an anti-bone boy, in short, it is related to rebellion.

Personally, I think that Wei Yan died by himself, Zhuge Liang did his best, and spent all his energy on winning against the enemy, especially the link of lighting the seven-star lantern to continue his life, although it was made up, but it also fully showed that Wei Yan's behavior was substantial harm to Zhuge Liang, and he made Zhuge Liang discouraged. From this point of view, in fact, he died unjustly, because he consumed Zhuge Liang's heart.

Because Wei Yan had ill intentions at that time, he was thinking about how to harm others, and he and Shi Yangyi became more and more conflicted, and later Wei Yan was framed and later brutally killed, so he was killed by others.

The real cause of Wei Yan's death was a conflict with Yang Yi. Wei Yan and Yang Yi have always been at odds. When Zhuge Liang was alive, he was usually a peacemaker between two people.

Before Zhuge Liang died, he told Jiang Wei, Yang Yi and others that he would arrange for Wei Yan to break off. For the sake of Shu Han's future, Zhuge Liang did not hesitate to kill Wei Yan.

Wei Yan finally died in Ma Dai's pursuit, and although his military exploits were prominent, he believed that he could not use his talents, and he was at odds with Yang Yi, and died in the battle between the two sides.

Wei Yan was killed. In true history, Wei Yan rebelled and was eventually killed by soldiers.

In 234 A.D. (the twelfth year of Jianxing), Zhuge Liang's fifth Northern Expedition, Wei Yan was appointed as the striker, dreamed that he had horns on his head, and asked Zhao Zhi, the dreamer, Zhao Zhi said: "The husband Qilin has horns and does not use it, and this is the elephant of a thief who wants to destroy himself without fighting." But he stepped back and said to men

The horn is the word, and the knife is also used; With a knife on the head, it is very fierce. ”

In the autumn of the same year, Zhuge Liang's illness worsened, and he secretly retired from the army after the death of Changshi Yang Yi, Sima Feiyi, and Jiang Wei, etc., so that after Wei Yan was broken, if he delayed or did not obey his orders, he would do as he pleased. Zhuge Liang died, and he was not mourned, Yang Yi ordered Fei Yi to figure out Wei Yan's intentions. Wei Yandao:

Although the prime minister is dead, but there is still me, how can the world's major affairs be wasted because of the death of one person? Besides, who am I, Wei Yan, and how can I be at the mercy of Yang Yi and be a general after the break? ”

The army slowly retreated with Yang Yi, Wei Yan was furious, day and night, rushed in front of Yang Yi's army, and burned the pavilion everywhere he walked. Yang Yi and Wei Yan both went to each other to say that the other party had rebelled, and Liu Chan asked Dong Yun and Shi Jiangwan, the governor of the palace, who wanted to rebel, and Dong Jiang and Jiang both guaranteed that Yang Yi suspected Wei Yan. Wei Yan first occupied the mouth of the Nangu and led his army to attack Yang Yi's army, and Yang Yi ordered Wang Ping to defend against Wei Yan in front.

Wang Ping scolded Wei Yan's vanguard: "Zhuge Gong died, and the bones are not cold, how dare you people do this!" "Wei Yan's army knew that Wei Yan was at fault, and they didn't listen to Wei Yan's orders, so they all dispersed.

Only Wei Yan and his sons fled to Hanzhong, Yang Yi sent Ma Dai to catch up with Wei Yan and behead him, and dedicated his head to Yang Yi, Yang Yi trampled Wei Yan's head with his feet, and scolded: "Yongnu! Can you do evil again?

So they exterminated the three tribes of Wei and Yan.

The Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms recorded: "The original Yanyi did not descend to Wei in the north and returned to the south, but wanted to eliminate the killing instrument and so on." Hao Jing of the Yuan Dynasty believed that Yang Yi "killed the general with personal anger, and the crime was floating".

The above is the record of the biography of Chen Shou, the author of "Three Kingdoms", but according to Pei's note citing "Wei Luo", it was Wei Yan who was entrusted by Zhuge Liang with military power, and Yang Yi was afraid that Wei Yan would take the opportunity to harm him, so he spread rumors that Wei Yan was going north to join the enemy and sent troops to attack him, but Wei Yan, who was framed, was afraid that the war would be innocent, so he only fled without fighting, and was finally hunted down. Pei Songzhi believes that this statement is a rumor from Cao Wei, and the "Three Kingdoms" of Chen Shou of Shu Han is more credible.

After Zhuge Liang's death, Wei Yan led the army to kill Yang Yi, and when Yang Yi asked Wei Yan to say "Who dares to kill me" three times, Wei Yan laughed and said: Don't say three times, what does it matter if you call 30,000 sounds? If the prime minister was there, I still had some concerns, and now that the prime minister is dead, who can still kill me, so I began to say the earth-shattering but not crying ghosts and gods three times, "Who dares to kill me".

When he shouted, he was hacked to death by Ma Dai from behind.

Wei Yan during the Three Kingdoms period was not eliminated by Zhuge Liang's secret order in the official history, but he took the blame himself. At that time, Wei Yan and Yang Yi had a feud, and after Zhuge Liang's death, Wei Yan was dissatisfied because Yang Yi took over power. Wei Yan therefore set fire to the plank road, and played the other party's rebellion at the same time as Yang Yi.

As a result, the queen lord believed in Yang Yi and wiped out the three clans of Wei Yan.