Is the Warring States million strong army reliable? Did 450,000 people really kill Bai Qi in the Bat

Bai Qi was known as the God of War at that time, and his military talent was a top-notch existence at that time. The army of millions is still quite reliable, and Bai Qi is worthy of its name, and 450,000 people is nothing in his eyes.

The Battle of Changping lasted for three years, and in the end, Zhao was defeated because he was unable to support the army's grain and grass, and in the face of the enemy's surrendered 400,000 troops, Qin had no way to provide grain and grass, so Bai Qi could only order to be killed.

As the most famous general of the Warring States, Bai Qi was brave and good at fighting, and he was very capable of commanding. The wars during the Warring States period were all large-scale, so the million-strong army was still very reliable, combining two factors, so it is still very possible that Bai Qi killed forty-five people in the Battle of Changping.

We can't judge the values of the ancients by the current value standards, the ancients were already very difficult to live at that time, and the population was very small, and basically the men at home either served as soldiers or went to farm.

Bai Qi did not kill so many people, but only exaggerated to show that Bai Qi had won a big battle to show his merits.

According to historical records, Bai Qikeng killed more than 250,000 soldiers, not the 400,000 people we now say. In the Battle of Changping, as many as 150,000 Zhao troops were killed in the battle.

There were not so many, and many of the armies at that time were imaginary in number. From the productive forces, the productive forces were low at that time, how could it be possible to raise such a huge army.

I think it should be fake, 400,000 people should be an exaggeration, maybe the number of soldiers who participated in the war is less than 400,000.

In history, the fierce general of the Qin State killed 400,000 Zhao troops in the Battle of Changping for three reasons: First, he thought that the Zhao army was capricious, and he was worried that the 400,000 troops would be unwilling to rebel again. In order to eliminate the trouble, he ordered all the pits to be killed.

Second, it not only deterred the rest of the countries, but also established the strong authority of the Qin State, and also saved its own military rations. Sankeng killed Zhao State's 400,000 big ambush army, causing Zhao Yuanqi to be seriously injured and severely injured in the judgment hall, and then digging cherry blossoms was unable to compete with Qin State.

People are killed, but more than 400,000 is impossible. History books have a hobby of exaggeration, more than 100,000 people can be written with a million armor, and hundreds of cars can be called an army of 10,000 people. It's just a spectacular picture.

Don't keep saying what historical records are recorded, you have to think about some problems yourself, according to the population density of Zhao State and the size of the Qin army at that time, a few of our teachers think that at most 200,000 people will be killed, or overestimated. The Battle of Changping did not go all out to fight (there were Xiongnu in the north, and there were many troops), and when the outcome of the war was undecided, the Zhao army had been wiped out by half, and if the so-called 400,000 troops were added, the standing strength of Zhao exceeded one million!? During the Spring and Autumn and Warring States periods, the entire Chinese population was basically less than 100 million for a long time, and no matter how desperate the army was, it was impossible for the combat readiness personnel to exceed 5 percent of the population (people were needed to ensure reserve production), so it was better to have no books than to have no books.

It is very valuable that the landlord can doubt the seemingly conclusive records in these historical books.

Reliable, at that time, except for the fierce tiger and wolf division Qin Jun, no one in the armies of other countries would do this...

Kill is kill, but there is certainly not 400,000, this number is too exaggerated, ancient China liked to exaggerate the number of wars the most! Surely not 400,000!

Kill is definitely kill! However, the method of killing has been controversial in historical historiography. Some history books say that it was killed in a pit (buried alive), and some history books record that it was beheaded, and as for the result, we have to wait for historians to continue to research.

But one thing is for sure, Bai Qi did kill more than 400,000 Zhao troops at that time, so that Zhao Guo's vitality was greatly damaged and collapsed.

It was to kill a lot of people, but it is estimated that there are at least 200,000, not 400,000.

That's pretty much what the annals say.

At that time, Zhao Kuo took 400,000 people out to fight, and almost tens of thousands were killed in the battle, less than 10,000 fled back to Zhao, and Qin let go of a few hundred. Since then, Zhao has changed from a strong country to a weak country, and it took more than ten years to recover.

Bai Qi is really a murderer, and he finally got retribution.

Yes, kill is kill, but there is absolutely no 400,000.

Because in ancient China, the population of a country was very small.

If you want to kill 400,000, isn't it slaughtering the country?

More than 400,000 people? Unlikely.

Reliable, for the following reasons:

On the one hand, the Qin army was defeating the Zhao army at that time, and the Zhao army lost the ability to resist, and the second was that the Zhao army had been hungry for many days because of lack of food. At that time, the main force of the Qin army, together with the requisitioned and transferred troops, totaled more than 500,000 people, and the combat power and manpower were enough.

On the other hand, Bai Qibai is a butcher, before the First Battle of Changping, that guy had already killed hundreds of thousands of Chu troops and Wei troops in the war, and with his murderous character, he would not keep these Zhao troops. Moreover, at that time, Bai Qi was ready to destroy Zhao in one fell swoop, so he would not leave Zhao Jun strong and put it back.

Third, the Qin army's reward and punishment system, the merits of the Qin army's officers and soldiers are assessed by the number of enemies eliminated by their heads, so killing hundreds of thousands of people can also bring huge benefits to participating in the war, so this thing is reliable.

Moreover, this was also in favor of the Qin State at that time, and the only one who could confront the Qin State militarily at that time was the Zhao State, and the Qin State seized the opportunity to completely weaken the Zhao State, so Bai Qi's behavior at that time was also praised by King Qin Zhao.