As Sun Quan s younger sister, is Sun Shangxiang indeed a person or a posterity?

Updated on history 2024-06-19
15 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-12

    Whether it is recorded in history books, folklore, or in some ** stories, and even some games up to now, there is a setting, that is, Sun Shangxiang is Sun Quan's sister. But if you are familiar with history, you will find that the age gap between the two people is very strange, because when Sun Jian died, Sun Quan was only 9 years old, but Sun Shangxiang was 11 years younger than Sun Quan. So Sun Shangxiang is probably not Sun Quan's sister.

    At the beginning, in order to consolidate the alliance between Liu Bei and Sun Quan, Mrs. Sun married Liu Bei. Later, he returned to the state of Wu, and there is no detailed record of Sun Shangxiang after that. Sun Shangxiang married Liu Bei after the Battle of Chibi, and it is said that he had more than 100 slaves and maids with him at that time.

    Each one of them was guarding him with knives, and even if Liu Bei entered his room, his heart would be wavy. Therefore, in history, the relationship between Liu Bei and Sun Shangxiang was not very close. <>

    Even later, Liu Bei built a city specifically for Sun Shangxiang, called Mrs. Sun, and some people said that it was because Sun Shangxiang was jealous of Liu Bei and unwilling to live with Liu Bei. In 211, Sun Shangxiang went home to visit relatives, Sun Quan sent a warship to pick up his sister home, originally wanted to take Liu Chan away, but was stopped by Zhuge Liang in time, and Sun Shangxiang never returned. This is also why there are so few records about Sun Shangxiang.

    But it can be seen that Sun Shangxiang must have a certain relationship with Sun Quan, otherwise Sun Quan would not have done this. <>

    In fact, on the question of whether Sun Shangxiang exists, his age is the biggest key to solving the problem. In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, there is basically no mention of the character of Sun Shangxiang, and only Mrs. Sun appears in it. In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, it is recorded that Sun Jian had a total of 5 sons and a daughter, one of whom was named Sun Ren.

    But everyone rummaged through the ancient books and found that Sun Ren was actually an alias for Sun Lang. And Sun Lang is the name of one of Sun Jian's sons. Therefore, in the historical records, it is very likely that there is no Sun Shangxiang, and it is only because of the feminine name Sun Ren that everyone sees her as Sun Jian's daughter.

    So Sun Shangxiang probably doesn't exist, and it can't be Sun Quan's sister.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-11

    Sun Shangxiang is indeed a person, and there are relevant records in many historical documents or related books, which can prove that there is really such a person.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-10

    I think he has a descendant, because his sister is a cowardly person, so it's not worth it.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-09

    Sun Quan's younger sister is called Sun Shangxiang, and it is indicated in the formal historical records that there is such a person, and it is not a character made up by later generations.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    1, Liu Bei. The combination with Sun Shangxiang is Zhou Yu.

    used a beauty trick, but I didn't expect Zhuge Liang.

    The skill is high, and the raw rice is cooked into mature rice. Zhou Yu saw that he had no choice, and gave Sun Quan another idea, and took advantage of the newlywed reason to put Liu Bei under house arrest in Eastern Wu. If Zhuge Liang comes to ask for someone, he will exchange Jingzhou for it.

    2, Sun Quan agreed to Zhou Yu's strategy, built a luxurious villa, fine clothes and jade food every day, singing and dancing banquets, Liu Bei was really confused, and Sun Shangxiang and Wushan clouds and rain every day.

    3, all this is expected by Zhuge Liang. He used a clever plan to let Liu Bei return to Jingzhou with Sun Shangxiang. Sun Quan was furious, Liu Bei fled back, and Jingzhou was not going back.

    Even if he kills his sister, he must chase Liu Bei back. This is the reason why Sun Quan wants to kill his own sister.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    It may have something to do with her status at the time, or it may have something to do with Sun Quan, so it makes sense to call it and it won't cause losses.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Mainly because Liu Bei lost three wives at that time, if each lady was called Mrs. Liu, it might not be clear.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Because Sun Shangxiang is also a very capable person and is respected by many people, she is called Mrs. Sun.

  9. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Maybe it's because the relationship between two people is particularly bad, so they call each other in this way.

  10. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    Because Liu Bei has a lot of wives, such a title can better distinguish them and respect them.

  11. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Sun Shangxiang is Sun Quan's half-sister.

    The first thing to know is that there is no record in the history books what Sun Quan's sister is called, and the so-called "Sun Shangxiang" is a name made up by later generations in the drama.

    According to the official history, Sun Jian's wife, Wu, gave birth to Sun Ce, Sun Quan, Sun Yi, Sun Kuang, and a daughter. And Sun Jian's other concubine gave birth to Sun Lang and two daughters.

    And this Sun Shangxiang is most likely born to Sun Jian's concubine. In other words, Sun Shangxiang and Sun Quan are half-brothers and sisters, and they will naturally be worse emotionally, so it is no wonder that Sun Quan married Sun Shangxiang to Liu Bei.

  12. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Sun Shangxiang was the sister of Sun Quan, a general who was captured in the late Eastern Han Dynasty, and was the wife of Liu Bei, the general of Zuo. The historical book "Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms" calls it Mrs. Sun, and the folk drama calls it Sun Shangxiang. In order to consolidate the Sun-Liu alliance, Mrs. Sun married Liu Bei for three years, and later returned to Wu.

    Sandwiched between the two countries, she has an unruly personality that is completely different from traditional women, and she is a famous chivalrous woman.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Sun Shangxiang is Sun Quan's half-sister.

    Sun Quan's sister is Sun Shangxiang, Shangxiang is the character, and his real name is Sun Ren. Sun Jian's daughter, Sun Ce, Sun Quan's half-sister. Later, she married Liu Bei and was Liu Bei's third lady.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    According to the history of the TV presentation, yes, but the facts are not known.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Sun Quan considered the overall situation first, so he made the decision to kill his sister.

    At that time, Liu Bei was about to return to Jingzhou, and as soon as Liu Bei returned to Jingzhou, then Dongwu's goal of putting Liu Bei under house arrest and consuming his will failed. Therefore, Sun Quan must intercept Liu Bei. But Sun Xiaomei has married Liu Bei, with Sun Xiaomei as a shield, the generals of Eastern Wu did not dare to stop Liu Bei, seeing that Liu Bei was about to get out of control, the matter was already very urgent, Sun Quan was afraid that his subordinates would hinder Sun Xiaomei and dare not do it, so he ordered "Mention my sister and Liu Bei's head". Resistant.

Related questions
11 answers2024-06-19

Sun Shangxiang: Sun Shangxiang is the name of a person in the drama "Ganlu Temple", and its historical prototype is the sister of Sun Quan, the lord of Wu during the Three Kingdoms period of China, and later married Liu Bei. There is also a description of Sun Shangxiang in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", her name is written as "Sun Ren" in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", and Sun An in the opera "Two Army Divisions Fight Wisdom Across the River". >>>More

35 answers2024-06-19

Lu Zhen, a historical figure, is based on Lu Lingxuan, the wife of Luo Chao, the general of Gao Huan's department, who was matched into the court because of her husband's rebellion, and became the nurse of the queen Gao Wei, who is good at greeting, shrewd and witty, and later has the world's rights with his son Mu Tiva. It had a certain impact on the fall of the Northern Qi Dynasty. In 2013, Yu Zheng's studio work "The Legend of Lu Zhen" became popular, but the TV series changed a lot of characters. >>>More

2 answers2024-06-19

Zou Ji: A Qi man during the Warring States Period, he was once a Qi minister. (There is a discernment, good at drumming and piano.) In the twenty-first year of King Qi Wei, he saw King Wei with a drum and a piano, saw him for three days, and worshiped him as a face). >>>More

4 answers2024-06-19

"Romance of the Three Kingdoms".Sun Shangxiang ended up throwing himself into the river and died. >>>More

13 answers2024-06-19

Sun Shangxiang (Yehenara Uka).

Tsang Pei Tzu as Sun Shangxiang (Yehenala Yuxiang). >>>More