Why was Xu Shiyou removed from command after the Vietnam War?

After the Vietnam War, Xu Shiyou was not removed as a commander, but was also the commander and deputy chief of the general staff of the Guangzhou Military Region. Before the self-defense counterattack against Vietnam, there was a saying that Xu Shiyou wanted to be promoted to become the chief of the general staff, but unfortunately the level of this gentleman was not good, and he blindly fought hard in the self-defense counterattack against Vietnam, and the troops were extremely heavy, and the results were not good.

Yang Dezhi, who was not as good as Yang Dezhi on the Western Front, performed well, which fully showed that Xu Shiyou was not suitable for modern warfare, and as a result, Yang Dezhi became the chief of the General Staff.

Xu Shiyou (February 28, 1905 - October 22, 1985) was born in Xu Jiawa, Hepu Village, Tianpu Township, Xinyang County, Xinyang City, Henan Province. In 1955, General Xu Shiyou was awarded the rank of general, and served as deputy chief of general staff of the Chinese People's Liberation Army, commander of the Nanjing Military Region, commander of the Guangzhou Military Region, vice minister of national defense, and member of the Standing Committee of the Communist Party of China's Military Commission.

He is the first. Member of the 1st, 2nd and 3rd National Defense Commission, Alternate Member of the 8th CPC National Defense Committee.

Member of the 9th, 10th and 11th ** Politburo. At the first plenary meeting of the Communist Party of China, he was elected as a standing member and deputy director of the Advisory Committee.

The tomb of Xu Shiyou is located in Xujiawa, Hepu Village, Tianpu Township, Xinxian County, Henan Province, 31 kilometers away from the county seat. The cemetery is halfway up a hill with its back to the saddle where the two mountains meet. The tomb bag is 200 cm high and 350 cm in diameter.

The whole tomb is round in front and back, simple and solemn, 1150 cm long, 850 cm wide, covering an area of about 98 square meters. The cemetery is condescending and has a great view.

It should be a flat tone, and then when I got older, I retired for the elderly.

Soldiers are not expensive for long", Commander Xu's Eastern Front fought fiercely and steadily, and the battle ended victoriously in 28 days. The scale of the battle is greater than that of the Western Front, the effect of the war is greater than that of the Western Front, and the ratio of exchange between friend and foe is greater than that of the Western Front. Stop hearsay, half-understood, irresponsible misunderstanding, and smearing General Xu.

He was not removed as a commander, but was still the commander and deputy chief of the general staff of the Guangzhou Military Region, and was later transferred to the Nanjing Military Region as commander and deputy chief of the general staff.

Then he complied with the call of the younger cadres and retired from class to retire.

Before the self-defense counterattack against Vietnam, there was a saying that Xu Shiyou wanted to be promoted to become the chief of the general staff, but unfortunately the level of this gentleman was not good, and he blindly fought hard in the self-defense counterattack against Vietnam, and the troops were extremely heavy, and the results were not good.

Not as good as Yang Dezhi on the Western Front.

It fully shows that Monk Xu is not adapted to modern warfare.

As a result, the chief of the General Staff was Yang Dezhi.

was not withdrawn, in fact in 79 he was the commander of the Guangzhou Military Region and commanded the self-defense counterattack against Vietnam, which was a great achievement, and then in 80 he was elected as a member of the Standing Committee of the Military Commission.

** Too big, old-fashioned tactics, not adapted to modern warfare, marginalized after the Sino-Vietnamese War.

He was not dismissed, but was transferred to the post of commander of the Nanjing Military Region. Xu Shiyou was 75 years old at that time, and in the eyes of the leader at the time, the younger Yang Dezhi was more suitable to continue to defend the country.

1. The use of outdated strategies in the Vietnam War caused a large number of **.

2. Too old, 74 years old.

3. After 7-8 years as the commander of the Guangzhou Army, the district division, it is time to change the position!

Xu Shiyou was dismissed as a god and demon

There is no sentence. After the Vietnam War, he came back and went up.

After the founding of the People's Republic of China in 1949, he served as the commander of the Shandong Military Region. In February 1954, he was appointed second deputy commander of the East China Military Region, and in October 1954, he was appointed deputy chief of the general staff of the Chinese People's Liberation Army.

In March 1955, he was appointed commander of the Nanjing Military Region. In September 1959, Xu Shiyou was appointed Vice Minister of National Defense, Commander of the Nanjing Military Region, and Second Secretary of the Party Committee.

In November 1966, he was criticized by the rebels in Nanjing, who raided Xu Shiyou's home and smashed his general's dress.

In August 1967, Nanjing borrowed the "Dongfeng" of Chen Zaidao, commander of the Wuhan Military Region, and was preparing to criticize Xu Shiyou, which was protected by ***.

Coming back on the 1967 National Day, Xu Shiyou was invited to the Tiananmen Tower, talked for half an hour, and publicly appeared in the newspaper. After that, Xu Shiyou lived in Zhongnanhai for more than 40 days.

On March 20, 1968, ** approved the report of the Party Committee of the Nanjing Military Region on the establishment of a revolutionary committee in Jiangsu Province, and agreed to Xu Shiyou as the director of the revolutionary committee.

At the end of 1973, Xu Shiyou was appointed commander of the Guangzhou Military Region and first secretary of the party committee.

In January 1974, he was appointed commander of the Guangzhou Military Region. Participated in and commanded the Xisha self-defense counterattack.

In 1980, he was appointed as a member of the Standing Committee of the Military Commission.

In September 1982, at the 12th National Congress of the Communist Party of China, Xu Shiyou was elected as a member of the ** Advisory Committee, Standing Committee Member and Deputy Director.

In 1978, in the self-defense counterattack against Vietnam, the People's Liberation Army took the 41st Army, the 42nd Army, the 43rd Army, the 54th Army, the 55th Army and the 50th Army (lacking the 149th Division) as the Eastern Front Corps, commanded by Xu Shiyou.

Who told you you were sentenced? Zhou Gong?

When the counterattack against Vietnam began in 1979, the marshals and generals at that time were old, dead, and miserable, so they could only select Xu Shiyou, who was relatively "young", from among the generals, to sit.

Because Xu Shiyou was at the rank of general, and he was the commander of the Guangzhou Military Region at that time, the Guangzhou Military Region was also the front-line commander of a military region closest to Vietnam.

To fight Vietnam, it is necessary to use a large number of troops in Guangdong, Guangxi, and Yunnan, which are closest to Vietnam, and Xu Shiyou happens to be the commander of the Guangzhou Military Region, so Xu Shiyou can only go into battle, and Xu Shiyou also fought from the war years and has good command skills, so it is natural that he has won Deng's trust.

After the catastrophe of the "Cultural Revolution" for 10 years, the army has become a hard-hit area, military training has almost come to a standstill, and it cannot keep up with advanced international military thinking, and even the ranks and establishment of the army are chaotic. In terms of momentum, among the founding generals, Xu Shiyou dared to be the first.

The self-defense counterattack war against Vietnam was fought in 1979, when the marshals and generals were old, dead, and miserable, and they could only select Xu Shiyou, who was relatively "young", from among the generals, to sit on the front line to command. Why don't you choose Su Yu, who is more famous, to tell you the truth, Su Yu has no position in the army at this time!! In 1958, at the enlarged meeting of the Military Commission, Su and others were beaten by Mr. Peng, demoted, and had no real power, and in 1972, he went to serve as the first political commissar of the Academy of Military Sciences.

So Su Yu definitely didn't have the authority to command this battle. To fight Vietnam, it is necessary to use a large number of troops in Guangdong, Guangxi, and Yunnan, which are closest to Vietnam, and Xu Shiyou happens to be the commander of the Guangzhou Military Region, so Xu Shiyou can only go into battle, and Xu Shiyou also fought from the war years and has good command skills, so it is natural that he has won Deng's trust.

Because Xu Shiyou was at the rank of general, and he was the commander of the Guangzhou Military Region at that time, the Guangzhou Military Region was also the closest military region to Vietnam......Hehe.

First of all, it must be the principle of proximity The Guangzhou Military Region has been around recently Secondly, they are all old and no one wants to fight anymore In fact, Su Yu is more suitable, but because he has overstepped Mao's authority several times, he has been suppressed by *** and cannot be reused for the rest of his life He can only choose a younger one.

More than loyalty, not enough resourcefulness!

The Eastern Front of the self-defense counterattack against Vietnam was commanded by General Xu Shiyou, although Lang Son was conquered, but due to tactical mistakes, it did not keep up with the tide of modern military command, and the rich experience accumulated in dealing with Vietnam for decades of actual combat led to our side being too large, and paid a heavy price in exchange for victory, compared with the Western Front, the gap is large, so the self-defense counterattack war against Vietnam is the failure of General Xu Shiyou's life.

In the course of the war in the new period, because the firepower and organizational mode have undergone relatively big changes, and because Vietnam has been in a state of war for a long time, the tactical quality of the soldiers is relatively high, and we have adopted the tactics of crowd and caused relatively large losses.

Title... To give a comprehensive analysis, it is not very clear about this period of history It is really difficult to say about Commander Xu, in a broad sense, no one can avoid making mistakes, and Xu is the same. The question is that as far as the 79 self-defense counterattack is concerned, what kind of command mistakes Xu made and to what extent, it should not be as easy to talk about it in detail as some articles impassionedly depreciating a few sentences.

About Xu, all I know is the news of "second-hand" or above, and the only news that is relatively close is that Xu is very detached and can afford to put it down, but it has nothing to do with Xu's specific operational command.

The words of dissatisfaction with Xu are not available now, and the troops are withdrawn.

Xu Shiyou's guiding ideology is a bit outdated, which led to the beginning of the army suffered a lot of defeats, what era was it? Xu also engaged in crowd tactics.

What is a failure? There is also a saying that Xu Shiyou is outdated, and all the tactics of the crowd are mentally retarded, do you understand? Xu Shiyou's initial suggestion, did the above approve it?

Use your brains well, Xu Shiyou has fought all his life, can he fight so badly? Do you know the shallow, close and deep, do you fight steadily, do you agree with the above, force Xu Shiyou to follow their path, and then why you want to fight this battle, and when the reform will start, think about it yourself.