When the Shu Kingdom fell, why were Zhuge Liang s descendants protected?

Because Zhuge Liang was very famous, if Zhuge Liang's descendants were killed, the ruling class would be affected, so his descendants were protected.

Because Zhuge Liang helped Liu Bei establish the Shu Kingdom, it has a very important position in the Shu Kingdom, and when Zhuge Liang dies, his descendants will also be protected from harm.

Because there were people in the Zhuge family who were officials in Cao Wei, no one in Zhuge Liang's descendants dared to move when Shu was destroyed.

Because the people of Shu have special respect for Zhuge Liang and are deeply impressed by his noble qualities, they will actively protect his descendants.

There are not many shortcomings in Ge Liang's family, he does not have many heirs, in order to leave him a descendant, Zhuge Liang's character and reputation are very good, and he can't bear to hurt his family.

This is Cao Wei's means of oak posture and Sima Zhao, who holds real power, which can reflect Sima Zhao's brilliant Liang and let him firmly sit in Cao Wei's position of covering the sky with one hand.

Through such means, Sima Zhao can hold great power. This will give you a good reputation. Able to win the hearts and minds of the people.

Zhuge Liang's son Zhuge Zhan's ability is mediocre, not as outstanding as Zhuge Liang's ability, with Zhuge Liang in the imperial court, married a princess, the people because he is Zhuge Liang's son, and also respect him, hesitate when fighting, only talk on paper, no actual strategic ability, resulting in Deng Ai's success in attacking Shu and accelerating the demise of Shu.

This is because Zhuge Liang's son is not as smart as his father and does not have good military talents, although he holds an important position in the court, Deng Ai did not make the correct command when he attacked Mianzhu, because of his own personal grudges, he did not ask for help like Jiang Wei, and finally lost his advantage, causing the destruction of Shu.

Because before the war, Zhuge Zhan did not listen to the advice of others and occupied the dangerous terrain in advance, so that the Shu army missed the best opportunity to annihilate the enemy, so that Shu Han automatically surrendered the city.

Because many people have high expectations for Zhuge Liang's son, but the result is not a big deal, because this judgment has brought a crisis to Shu.

Because many people had high hopes for Zhuge Liang's son, but it didn't work out. Because of this judgment, it brought a crisis to Shu.

Zhuge Liang is the best person in Shu, but he single-handedly destroyed Shu. During Zhuge Liang's reign, he always made peace with Wu in the main number of Xiang Zhang, and then raised the country with war and killed Cao Wei. As a berserker who once held Shu to a state of collapse, after Zhuge Liang's death, who affected the political situation of Shu and who personally lit the fuse of Shu's demise?

Why did Zhuge Liang single-handedly destroy Shu?

Before talking about the above questions, let's first compare the strength of each of the three countries horizontally, and to be honest, who is strong and who is weak.

In ancient China, before there was any advanced production technology, an important indicator of a country's strength and weakness was its population. As long as there are enough people, even a million beggars are enough to fend off the enemy's tourist traps. According to historical records, Shu had the smallest population during the Three Kingdoms period, with only 940,000 people.

Wu Luosheng, 2.3 million; Wei had the largest number, about 4.43 million.

This is a comparison of the population, and it can also be compared to the consumption of war. There are two sets of data on the population of Shu recorded in the historical books: 200,000 households in the early period, with a total population of 900,000, and 280,000 households in the later period, with a total population of 940,000, 100,000 soldiers, and 40,000 officials.

That is to say, in the continuous war, the population consumption base of Shu was quite large, with 620,000, accounting for 69% of the total population. In other words, on average, seven out of ten Shu people died in the war, which is simply terrifying.

However, the population of Wu did not change much before and after. According to historical records, in 242, there were 120,000 households with a population of 2.4 million. In the fall, the population did not change much, almost the same as the data for 242, and it is likely that the previous data was reported directly without re-counting the population.

From this aspect, it can be seen that Wu's population loss is basically zero.

Due to limited information, it is impossible to verify the population consumption data of Wei. But in the later wars, the reason why Wei was so powerful was because he was outnumbered.

From the above data, it can be seen why the Shu State was defeated first, then the Wu State was defeated, and finally the Sima family took over the world. After all, in that era when labor and production depended entirely on manpower, the size of the population meant the strength of the country. Shu has the smallest population and the weakest strength.

Due to a birth defect, Shu has been in a dilemma. During Zhuge Liang's reign, he adhered to two principles, that is, to unite Wu and attack Wei.

After Zhuge Liang's death, his successor, Jiang Wei, took over the baton and vowed to revive Shu. He was even more powerful than his teacher Zhuge Liang, and sent troops more frequently. But at this time, Shu was basically in a state of poverty, the population had plummeted, there were no soldiers in the army, there was no food on the account, and the situation was embarrassing.

The truth can be seen from the consumption of the population of Shu, but Jiang Wei just turned a deaf ear and continued to use force. It wasn't until he really lost all his money in Shu that he suddenly realized, but it was too late!

Because Zhuge Liang's elder brother Zhuge Jin was an official in the Cao Wei regime. He also achieved a great official position. So Zhuge Liang's descendants were all protected, all thanks to his elder brother.

Because Zhuge Liang's family is a big family, and he also has brothers who are officials in Wei and Wu, Zhuge Liang's descendants are protected.

Because Zhuge Liang was loved by the people, and his spirit of dedicating himself to the country and dying touched the people, so the people wanted to protect his descendants.

This is because Wei considered Zhuge Liang's name of virtue, and if he killed his descendants, he would be condemned by the whole world, so Wei chose to settle Zhuge Liang's descendants in order to buy people's hearts.

Because Zhuge Liang's contribution to the country was very large, and Zhuge Liang's influence on that time was still relatively large.

This is because Zhuge Liang originally had great merits to Shu Han, so his descendants were not raided, but protected.

Because Zhuge Liang's descendants are very talented, and they know how to use their position to resolve their embarrassment.

Concern. Personally, I think that because of Zhuge Liang's character and spirit, even his opponents admire and admire him, and his name is a household name, so after the demise of Shu Han, a large number of ** were raided, but Zhuge Liang's descendants were protected. It must be known that "do your best, and then die" is the most accurate praise for Zhuge Liang, the prime minister of the Shu Han Dynasty.

There were many reasons for the demise of Shu, but among these reasons, the interference from Adou was the least; Just imagine, what dynasty of monarchs can trust Zhuge so much like the Liu family's father and son?

Personally, I believe that there were the following reasons for the demise of Shu:

1, Zhuge Liang's employment is too harsh, he wants talents with both ability and political integrity, so there is a risk of "no general in Shu";

2. Zhuge Liang's reckless military force, waging wars for many years, made the Chengdu Plain, known as the country of abundance, unable to bear the economic recession caused by the war, which can be seen from Li Yan's inability to prepare military rations;

3. From the perspective of the general social law, it must be together for a long time, which is also the trend of history、、、 after the teacher table was written by Zhuge Liang! I don't know anyone who would question that!!

Yes, Sima Yan did not kill Zhuge Liang's descendants.

Wasn't there a big news in the first two years? It is said that the descendants of Shu were reunited during the Three Kingdoms period, and when Zhuge Liang's descendants saw Liu Bei's descendants, they immediately shouted: Lord. We will know without descendants.

The fall of Shu was not done by one person, and the decline and fall of an empire was often caused by many aspects. Throughout the history of Shu, there are many sages, and the national territory is not large but has a strong combat effectiveness. Most of us attribute it to the Shu Han Dynasty and Zhuge Liang.

Zhuge Liang's life can be described as wonderful, and it seems to us that he is a perfect person. But we can't one-sidedly completely link Zhuge Liang with the peril of Shu. Zhuge Liang's son is not as talented as everyone thinks, but Zhuge Liang's son is not talented but has too much power, and there are many factors.

First of all, Zhuge Liang had great prestige in Shu Han at that time, and after his death, all the Shu people wept bitterly. For the Shu Kingdom, the collapse of a country's pillars is fatal to the entire country. The rulers of Shu must once again erect an image like Zhuge Liang.

Zhuge Liang's son Zhuge Zhan is undoubtedly the best candidate. The country has a spiritual leader who can reassure the people, which can stabilize the people's hearts, and only then can Shu have room for development.

Secondly, Zhuge Zhan is not talentless, Zhuge Liang sent a letter to Zhuge Jin when he was eight years old, the letter said that Zhuge Zhan was young, smart and cute, and he thought he was an early success, and he was afraid that he would not be a heavy weapon. As the letter says, Zhuge Zhan is talented when he is young, and he is not a useless person. And after Deng Ai Vashu, Zhuge Zhan angrily beheaded Ai Envoy, and Gan Bao said:

Although Zhuge Zhan's wisdom is not enough to help the danger, and his courage is not enough to resist the enemy, he can live up to the country outside, and he will not change his father's will at home, and he will be loyal and filial. Although his talent is insufficient, he has a strong patriotic heart and unyielding will, and he has the name of the son of Zhuge Liang, so he is fully qualified for his position.

Finally, there are many elements to the demise of Shu that cannot be attributed to one person. In the late Shu Kingdom, there were Huang Hao's rebellion, there were strong rivals such as the Sima clan outside, and Jiang Wei was not appointed, etc., so many unfavorable factors led to the decline of an empire.

Zhuge family has done their best since Zhuge Liang died. and then to Zhuge Zhan, Zhuge Shang's father and son sacrificed their lives for the country. Zhuge Yimai did everything for Shu, how could Zhuge Zhan be blamed as a sinner of Shu, there is no single factor in the demise of Shu, even Huang Hao cannot be said to be the source of the demise of Shu, so we must objectively examine history and correctly look at Zhuge Zhan's image.

No, it can't all be blamed on Liu Chan, although his reasons are very big, but Shu itself is already riddled with holes, weak strength, and easy to be destroyed.

Shu was originally riddled with holes, and with Yizhou, it was impossible to confront Wei at all, and there was also a mentally handicapped child, Liu Chan, who had nothing to do with Zhuge Liang's son.

There is this reason, but this is not the source, after Zhuge Liang died, others wanted to reshape a Zhuge Liang, so they identified Zhuge Liang's son, but his son's talent was not high, and it was because others had too high expectations for him.

This is impossible, the success or failure of a country cannot be just one person's merits and demerits, and the destruction of Shu at that time was inevitable, not because of Zhuge Liang's son.

No, the fall of Shu was affected by many factors, and the source was not Zhuge Liang's son.

No, the demise of a country cannot be the responsibility of one person, it can only mean that the country's strength has been exhausted, and the people's will and strength cannot keep up.

How can the demise of a country be because of a person, Zhuge Liang is highly respected in Shu, what a talented, cultivated and moral person he is, then his son will not be too incompetent after his education.

To be honest, I don't think it's Zhuge Liang's son, a country is destroyed because of various factors, not because of a person.

I think there is a reason for this, but it definitely won't be the source. The demise of a nation cannot be brought to death by one person.

I don't think it should be, there are many reasons for the demise of a dynasty, how can it be that the reason is Zhuge Liang's son.