Guan Yu s Northern Expedition was defeated and died, was the timing wrong?

It must be that the timing is wrong, if the timing is right, he will definitely beat the other party away with his own personal strength, and it is impossible to defeat at all.

I think he really chose the wrong time, because Shu Han at that time was obviously weaker than the other two countries, and he should have Taoguang and obscurity first.

Personally, I think it was indeed the wrong timing, which led to the defeat of the Northern Expedition, and I think it was really not good this time.

Yes, because he didn't choose the right time at that time, and he didn't occupy the right time and place at that time, so he failed.

Cao Cao's subordinates thought that Guan Yu was too rude and wanted to kill Guan Yu several times, but Cao Cao stopped them. Guan Yu protected the two sisters-in-law to come to Dongling Pass, and the guard Kong Xiu said that he didn't see Cao Cao's paperwork and blocked Guan Yu from passing the pass, so he was killed by Guan Yu.

Luoyang guarded Han Fu and blocked Guan Yu again, the tooth general Meng Tan challenged Guan Yu, and was cut into two pieces by Guan Yu, Han Fu shot Guan Yu's left arm with a dark arrow, Guan Yu pulled out the arrow with his mouth, and Pegasus beheaded Han Fu.

When Guan Yu arrived at Bishui Pass, the guard general Bian Xi ambushed 200 knife and axe men in Zhenguo Temple, and agreed to kill Guan Yu by smashing the cup. The monk Pujing, who presided over the temple, was Guan Yu's fellow villager and told Guan Yu about Bian Xi's conspiracy, and Guan Yu was furious and beheaded Bian Xi.

Guan Yu arrived in Xingyang, Xingyang Taishou Wang Zhi was a relative of Han Fu, and wanted to kill Guan Yu to avenge Han Fu, so he secretly prepared to set fire to Guan Yu. Wang Zhi's subordinate Hu Ban told Guan Yu about Wang Zhi's conspiracy, Guan Yu hurriedly went on the road, Wang Zhi led his troops to chase after him, and was killed by Guan Yu.

When Guan Yu arrived at the mouth of the Yellow River, the guard general Qin Qi did not let Guan Yu cross the river, and was killed by Guan Yu again. After crossing the Yellow River, it was Yuan Shao's territory, and he met Sun Qian there. Sun Qian told Guan Yu that Liu Bei had gone to Runan and asked Guan Yu and his two wives to meet in Runan.

Guan Yu and Sun Qian re-crossed the Yellow River and set off for Runan, and Cao Cao's troops chased Xiahoudun and fought with Guan Yu. At this time, Zhang Liao arrived to convey Cao Cao's order, and only then did he let Guan Yu and his party go. Guan Yu continued to move forward, and received a fierce general Zhou Cang halfway.

When he walked to the ancient city, Zhang Fei, who occupied the city, thought that Guan Yu had surrendered to Cao Cao, refused to recognize him, and stabbed Guan Yu with a gun.

At this time, Cao Cao's troops killed Cai Yang to avenge his nephew Qin Qi. Zhang Fei asked Guan Yu to behead Cai Yang behind the three-way drum before he was willing to recognize him. Guan Yu beheaded Cai Yang before the drum was finished. Only then did Zhang Fei understand Guan Yu's hard work, so he cried loudly and knelt in front of Guan Yu to apologize.

The recommended answer is basically okay, but there are a few points that I still need to suggest.

1. Longzhong said very clearly that it is necessary to "change in the world" and attack in two ways, so that the enemy can succeed only if the enemy loses one or the other; At that time, the situation was: Liu Bei forced Cao Cao away with a defensive battle in Hanzhong, and his own losses were not small and he had to rest; Although Guan Yu broke the Forbidden Seventh Army with the help of heavy rain, he was alone in the depths, and the defeat was sooner or later, which obviously did not meet the conditions of the Longzhong pair (at that time, Cao Wei only had a few small rebellions, and they were quickly quelled, far from the extent that "the world has changed").

2. Guan Yu does not have a superstitious alliance. If you look at Lu Daichuan, you can know that after Xiangshui, Guan Yu fell out with Eastern Wu and secretly instigated a rebellion in Changsha in Eastern Wu. Guan Yu belongs to "tactical underestimation, strategic attention", even if Lu Xun acted as a sycophant, he also left hundreds of beacons to guard.

It's a pity that he met Lu Meng, the most outstanding general of Eastern Wu at that time, who crossed the river in white and quietly held the beacon tower, and Lu Xun captured Yiling at the same time, blocking Jingzhou's passage to Xichuan for help, which is one of the reasons why Xichuan has not had reinforcements coming.

3, Liu Bei never reached the strongest in the Three Kingdoms. Liu Bei was at least equal to Dongwu in his heyday, and the overwhelming thing was that he held Jingzhou, one of the lifelines of the Yangtze River, and could go down the river to take Jianye, which was also the reason why he was feared by Dongwu. Since ancient times, the Jiangnan regime did not protect Jingzhou (Eastern Jin Dynasty and Southern Song Dynasty), and Eastern Wu was bound to take Jingzhou at any cost.

First of all, after the Battle of Chibi, Cao Wei's forces were frustrated, Sun Quan's general Zhou Yu died of illness, and the strength of both sides was damaged, while Liu Bei took advantage of the situation to capture Jing and Yierzhou, and defeated Cao Wei in Hanzhong with his own strength.

Secondly, after the Battle of Hanzhong, Liu Bei's forces became the strongest of the three forces, which made Sun Quan's original policy of joining Liu against Cao waver, and he favored Lian Cao against Liu. and began to plan an attack on the Jingzhou region. Due to the death of Zhou Yu and Lu Su, Sun Quan's two previous governors, Sun Quanfang's talents suffered great losses, so Guan Yu despised the power of Sun Quanfang.

And Sun Quan's co-starring Lu Meng and Lu Xun's deception made Guan Yu lose his vigilance against Sun Quan.

Again, Cao Wei, although the Battle of Chibi and the Battle of Hanzhong were damaged, there were still Xu Huang, Cao Ren and other generals in charge, Guan Yu besieged Fancheng, flooded the Seventh Army and captured Yu Ban thinking that Cao Jun had no one, but he did not know that Yu Ban had not fought for many years, and he had long since lost the courage of the year, and Cao Ren stuck to Fancheng, although it seemed that he would be defeated, the military spirit was not shaken, coupled with the reinforcements brought by Xu Huang, echoing with Lü Meng's capture of Jingzhou, and finally successfully repelled Guan Yu.

In the end, Guan Yu was too arrogant on weekdays, and he was at odds with Meng Da and Liu Feng, resulting in Shangyong's soldiers and horses not being dispatched although they were asked for help, and Liu Bei's main force had already returned to Shuzhong, and the news was inconvenient, coupled with Guan Yu's previous good news, Liu Bei couldn't imagine that Guan Yu would be defeated so quickly, let alone send reinforcements. Moreover, even if reinforcements are sent, it may be difficult to sustain the difficulties of Shu Dao.

Guan Yu was killed, it should be said that it was the inevitable result of the balance of strength of the three parties when the three legs were established.

Tens of millions of male soldiers dare not be, and they single-handedly behead Yan Liang. It was only because of Yun Chang's strong martial arts that the fierce general was tied to death. Guan Yu's heroic deeds are familiar to everyone, but not here? Aluminum juggling? 绱松袢舜蠓绱約約級約 came, how did the army end up defeated?

This also starts from Longzhong, when Liu Bei finally saw Zhuge Liang in the thatched house, Zhuge Liang analyzed the current trend and set the guidelines and policies for the next few decades: seize Jingyi Erzhou as the basis for hegemony; Lianwu resisted Cao, and sent troops from Jing and Yi Prefectures, so that the hegemony could be achieved. I have to say that they were quite smooth sailing in the early stage, and it was not until the defeat of Cao Cao in the Battle of Chibi that there was a complete turnaround, and a pattern of Cao being weak and Shu strong temporarily appeared.

I have to say that people are cheap, and once they have a little capital, they will start to "float". At this time, the alliance is also in vain, Guan Yu insulted the envoy and refused to marry, Sun Quan is not stupid, you Liu Bei is now strong and strong and destroys Cao thief and then comes to cut me, what can I bear with you? So he took advantage of Guan Yu's attack on Cao Cao, and the emptiness of Jingzhou took the opportunity to sneak attack.

There was Cao Cao in front of him and Sun Quan in the back, Guan Yu suffered from the enemy on his back, and there was a lack of soldiers and major generals, at this time Cao Wu had an absolute advantage in the gang, and Cao Cao, Lu Meng, and Lu Xun were all outstanding military strategists, and it was difficult for Guan Yu not to lose.

In fact, Guan Yu's killing was caused by a series of accidental factors. First of all, Liao Li, the guard of Changsha, surrendered without a fight because of a letter from Lu Meng, where is Changsha? Changsha is the granary of Jingzhou, how can such an important person be guarded by such a nest of waste?

This is inseparable from Zhuge Liang, when Kong Ming recommended Pang Tong to Liu Bei, Liu Bei believed it, and it turned out that he was indeed the dragon and phoenix among the people, and recommended Liao Li, Liu Bei was even more convinced, so that he put it in such an important position without any combat experience. Even if Liao Li insists on waiting for Liu Bei's reinforcements, it won't be like this, as a soldier, who doesn't know the importance of Changsha, and the loss of Changsha laid a hidden danger for Guan Yu's death later. Coupled with the rebellion of Mi Fang, Mi Fang has not been treated by Guan Yu as a relative of the emperor, and when Guan Yu besieged Fancheng, he ordered Mi Fang to be responsible for the supply of grain and grass, but Mi Fang did not complete the task, Guan Yu was furious and put down the cruel words:

Wait for Lao Tzu to clean you up after the battle. The unexpected rebellion of Mi Fang became a direct factor in Guan Yu's killing.

Another point is that Zhuge Liang's guidelines and policies are a little flawed! Longzhong said to the middle "When the world changes, then order a general to take the soldiers of Jingzhou to Wanluo, and the general will be the commander of the people of Yizhou, so that the great cause can be achieved." They did this in the end, and the only drawback was that their forces were scattered, so that after Guan Yu's defeat, there were no troops to save them.

In short, there are many reasons, and in the end, they were gathered together and Guan Yu lacked a little luck to lead to the defeat and killing, it is a pity that a generation of heroes is really a pity!

The important reason is that Guan Yu's own character is too "proud", and after all, the word arrogant has ruined a generation of heroes.

Arrogance and contempt for the enemy are the main and subjective reasons.

The first Chi and the first, superstitious Sun and Liu Alliance. Liu Bei began to unite with Sun Quan according to what Longzhong said, but he was too superstitious about this alliance. Cao Cao was defeated in the Battle of Chibi, and then lost most of Jingzhou, and was defeated by Liu Bei in Hanzhong.

Second, the dispersion of forces. Longzhong has "When the world changes, then order a general to Jingzhou's troops, to Wanluo, the general himself led the people of Yizhou, in order to get out of Qinchuan, then the great cause can be answered." Later development is also as mentioned in it, Guan Yu led Jingzhou troops to attack Xiangfan in the north, and Liu Bei's troops were stationed in Hanzhong to get out of Qinchuan.

The direct consequence of this remorse was that the troops were scattered, so that after Guan Yu failed, there were no soldiers nearby to save him.

The direct cause of Guan Yu's defeat was the failure to conquer Xiangfan and the loss of Jingzhou, both of which caused Guan Yu to be besieged by the enemy on his back and back, and was finally captured and beheaded by Eastern Wu.

Other reasons for Guan Yu's failure are:

1, Guan Yu's achievements and influence have overwhelmed the mind of this fierce general, and he is suspected of underestimating the enemy as the coach;

2, Sun Quan and Guan Yu joined forces with Ying to marry to consolidate the union of Sun and Liu, but Guan Yu sternly refused, so he held a grudge;

3. During his reign, Lu Su actively advocated the rejection of Cao Cao, but Lü Meng implemented the original policy of the governor of Zhou Gongjin;

4. Zhuge Liang was anxious to help Liu Bei occupy the territory of Yizhou due to the death of Pang Tong and the Yizhou Mutiny, and was unable to assist General Guan to consolidate the original good situation in Jingzhou;

5. Liu Bei was anxious to become emperor as soon as he occupied Hanzhong, and he had no time to look east to Jingzhou;

6. Liu Bei's victory in Hanzhong stimulated Guan Sou Youyu's pride and increased Sun Quan's fear, that is, it accelerated the rupture of Sun Liu's alliance;

7. Zhuge Liang did not suggest that Liu Bei send troops to support within the effective time when the situation was more critical.