Guan Yu s Northern Expedition, why did Zhuge Liang choose to remain silent without direct advice or

Guan Yu's Northern Expedition, Zhuge Liang chose to remain silent without direct advice or advice, mainly because the Northern Expedition was Guan Yu's self-asserted behavior, and secondly, Zhuge Liang did not have the ability to draw troops to assist Guan Yu.

Because Zhuge Liang wanted to take this opportunity to hit Guan Yu's excessive self-confidence at that time, Zhuge Liang chose to remain silent.

The main reason is that Guan Yu is too conceited and doesn't listen to Zhuge Liang's opinion at all, so Zhuge Liang chooses to be silent.

Because Cao Cao had just failed in Hanzhong at that time, there were not many soldiers and horses to resist Guan Yu, and Zhuge Liang naturally acquiesced to this behavior.

It is estimated that it will succeed. If Guan Yu hadn't lost Jingzhou, Liu Bei wouldn't have died, Zhuge Liang wouldn't have died of hard work, and everyone would have gone according to the established strategy, then Cao Wei would sooner or later be wiped out by Shu Han, and finally clean up Sun Quan, so as to achieve the great dream of unifying the Central Plains.

First of all, the most regrettable thing in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is that Guan Yu defeated Maicheng and was killed by Lu Meng. Guan Yu never thought that Sun Quan would harm him, he felt that the two sides were cooperative partners, and they should be in one camp, but Guan Yu forgot that the two sides were only temporarily united by interests.

Secondly, Sun Quan was not stupid, knowing that if Shu Han destroyed the Cao Wei regime, then Shu Han's next object would be himself, so Sun Quan turned his back on Liu Bei and betrayed Guan Yu. Guan Yu was fighting Cao Wei in front, but he didn't expect Sun Quan to release arrows in his back, and the final result was that Guan Yu carelessly lost Jingzhou and gave away his life.

Then, some friends wanted to ask, if Guan Yu had not lost Jingzhou, the Northern Expedition was estimated to be successful. Therefore, we have to look at Guan Yu in this way that he did not fail and was killed, which means that Guan Yu successfully took Xiangyang, and Liu Bei will not act impulsively to avenge Guan Yu, and it will become Liu Bei who can take the opportunity to seize Cao Wei's power, and Zhuge Liang will not have to work so hard in the Northern Expedition later, nor will he work hard, and finally gave his life for the Northern Expedition.

And after Liu Bei took Cao Wei's country, they could choose to rest and turn around to clean up Sun Quan, you must know that Sun Quan's strength is not as powerful as Cao Wei, Shu Han wants to eat Sun Quan, it is very easy, and the final outcome is that Shu Han dominates the world, and the world is no longer a three-game situation.

In the end, the above is all speculation, and it can't be done accurately, but it is certain that Guan Yu carelessly lost Jingzhou, which really reduced the strength of the entire Shu Han by half. It's a pity that Guan Yu was still careless and gave Sun Quan a chance, which greatly damaged Shu Han's vitality, even if Zhuge Liang desperately wanted to make up for it in the future, there was no magic to return to the sky

After Guan Yu carelessly lost Jingzhou, if he successfully returned to Yizhou, what would be the outcome.

Not necessarily, the loss of Jingzhou did not cause great military losses to Shu Han, but there was one less place for Cao Cao to remember, which did not have much impact on the later Northern Expedition.

I think Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition will still not succeed in the future, because history will not change, and Guan Yu is getting older later.

If Guan Yu had not lost Jingzhou, Zhang Fei would not have died, Liu Bei would not have gone on the Northern Expedition, there would have been no so-called Battle of Yiling, the 50,000 Yizhou army would not have been wiped out, Huang Quan's 10,000 troops would not have surrendered, and Liu Bei's army would not have lost a large number of backbones and middle- and lower-level officers.

Several Northern Expeditions had few results, but Zhuge Liang could only persevere, not only because of his desire to support the Han Dynasty, but also because of Liu Bei's expectations, which accompanied him until the last Northern Expedition, and finally died of illness in Wuqing Souzhangyuan at the age of 54. For Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition, the destination was mainly in the Longyou region, rather than Guanzhong, where soldiers must fight.

Because there are a lot of rivers and mountains in Guanzhong, it is difficult to break through, and if you use it as a destination, it will lead to the failure of the Northern Expedition.

Guan Yu is arrogant by nature, and there will definitely be problems in the Northern Expedition. Guan Yu is arrogant by nature and does not listen to the opinions of others in the decision of many things, so Zhuge Liang chose to remain silent about Guan Yu's Northern Expedition and let Guan Yu deal with it himself.

Because Guan Yu was Liu Bei's most trusted general at that time, and Guan Yu's Northern Expedition was also supported by Liu Bei, Zhuge Liang could not refute it, so he had to remain silent.

Because Zhuge Liang thought that the form at that time was more favorable to Shu Han, but he didn't expect Guan Yu to fail later.

Because he was unable to change Guan Yu's decision on the Northern Expedition at that time, he could only choose to accept it silently.

"Romance of the Three Kingdoms" commented on Zhang Fei and Guan Yu: "Yu is kind to the soldiers and is proud of the scholars, and Fei loves and respects the gentleman but does not care for the villain." It can be seen from this that Guan Yu's attitude towards Zhuge Liang is not friendly, and during the Battle of Chibi, Guan Yu once questioned Zhuge Liang:

Guan has been fighting with his brother on the Long March, and for many years, he has not lagged behind. Today, when there is a great enemy, the military adviser is not commissioned, what does this mean? ”。

Guan Yu thinks that he has won every battle, so he should be reused, and Zhuge Liang is a military advisor who formulates tactics for the battle, if the soldiers in his hands do not listen to his own dispatch, then the military adviser will become a useless person.

The launch of the Xiangfan War was Guan Yu's own initiative, although it was inconsistent with the Longzhong countermeasures at that time, but Liu Bei let it go and did not oppose it, so Zhuge Liang had no position to oppose it. And probably in order to rectify Guan Yu's arrogance, when Guan Yu attacked Xiangfan, he did not increase troops or send generals, making Guan Yu difficult to take care of. Zhuge Liang may have taken the opportunity to make Liu Bei recognize Guan Yu's weaknesses and make him trust himself more.

We can't help but suspect that Zhuge Liang had the subjective intention of getting rid of Guan Yu by the hands of Cao and Sun.

Because Zhuge Liang knew that Guan Yu's character was very arrogant, even if Zhuge Liang opposed Guan Yu's Northern Expedition, Guan Yu might not listen to Zhuge Liang's opinion, and with the victory in the Battle of Hanzhong, Zhuge Liang might have been carried away by the victory.

This is because Zhuge Liang at that time still had a trace of luck and thought that Guan Yu might win the victory, so he still instigated him to go to Cao, but in the end he failed.

Because Guan Yu has always looked down on Zhuge Liang and still doesn't listen to Zhuge Liang's advice, Zhuge Liang instigated him just to let Liu Bei see Guan Yu's true face.

First of all, Guan Yu's decision to kill Cao was definitely not decided by him alone, it was probably under Liu Bei's instructions, so Zhuge Liang did not dissuade him. Secondly, Guan Yu has a strong personality, and dissuasion may make him rebellious, so it is better to let him go.

Guan Yu obviously didn't think Zhuge Liang was talented, but he looked down on Zhuge Liang because he felt that Zhuge Liang was too young, had no beard, and was a little white face, which was useless.

Guan Yu is a military general, but he is familiar with "Spring and Autumn", has literati feelings, and his self-esteem is very strong. Everything likes to be stuffed in his heart and resentment over time, Guan Yu is a doer, he thinks that real heroes should go to the battlefield instead of watching from behind, plus Zhuge Liang is not from a high mountain and wild village, Zhuge Liang has replaced his position in Liu Bei's heart, and naturally looks down on Zhuge Liang.

Guan Yu believes that personal martial arts strength is the most important, so he can't look down on Zhuge Liang, who can only give advice.

Because he is a very talented person, but Zhuge Liang is very smart, he just doesn't show it.