Why did Zhuge Liang let Liu Bei kill Liu Feng after Guan Yu s defeat?

At the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty, the world was in turmoil, and the heroes were divided, and finally formed a three-kingdom trend headed by Cao Cao, Liu Bei, and Sun Quan. However, with the death of these three people, the Three Kingdoms gradually declined, especially Liu Bei died of illness in the White Emperor City, and before his death, he entrusted Gu Zhuge Liang to assist Liu Chan, and brought Shu into a land of no return. For people who love the history of the Three Kingdoms, is Liu Bei only one son, Liu Chan?

I have to pass the throne to this Adou who can't be supported.

In fact, Liu Bei has a total of four sons, in addition to Liu Chan, the other three are Liu Yong, Liu Feng, and Liu Li. There are relatively few records about Liu Yong and Liu Li in history, and they are both mediocre people. But this Liu Feng is different, he is not only a hundred generations higher than Liu Chan in terms of ability, but also quite prestigious in the Shu army.

But in the end, Liu Bei executed this eldest son at the suggestion of Zhuge Liang, why is this?

Liu Feng was originally the son of Luohou Kou, after Liu Bei took refuge in Liu Biao, he met Kou Feng in Jingzhou, Kou Feng has a strong personality and extraordinary strength, and is a rare member of Liu Biao's command. At that time, Liu Bei was forty-one years old but still had no heirs, in order to continue the incense, and at the same time to win over such a fierce general, Liu Bei accepted Kou Feng as a righteous son and changed his name to Liu Feng.

Liu Feng did not disappoint Liu Bei, after Liu Bei entered Shu, Liu Feng followed Zhao Yun, Zhang Fei, Zhuge Liang and others to attack Yizhou, invincible everywhere he passed, Liu Feng became a rising star in the Three Kingdoms generals, after Liu Bei occupied Hanzhong, Liu Feng and Meng Da successfully broke through Shangyong, Liu Feng was appointed as the deputy army general. At this time, Liu Feng reached the pinnacle of his life both in terms of position and prestige.

It can be said that if it weren't for Liu Chan's sudden appearance, then he would be the one who would be in charge of Shu in the future. After Liu Chan was born, Liu Bei was very spoiled for this son. But at the same time, he was afraid that after his death, Liu Feng would seize the throne, so Liu Bei transferred Liu Feng from Yizhou to guard Shangyong.

Liu Bei's approach was nothing more than the fear that Liu Feng would cultivate his own power in the army, which would be detrimental to Liu Chan's accession to the throne in the future.

At this time, Liu Feng was already unwilling to inherit Liu Bei's position, but it would be fine if he honestly levied Shangyong, but we all know that Guan Yu trapped the beast Maicheng and asked Liu Feng for help, but Liu Feng could not raise his troops, which shows Liu Feng's resentment towards Liu Bei. After Guan Yu defeated Maicheng, Zhuge Liang immediately suggested to Liu Bei that he should give this adopted son to death. After hearing this, Liu Bei also decided to get rid of the troubles as soon as possible, so he ordered Liu Feng to be killed on the grounds that Liu Feng did not send troops to rescue Guan Yu.

Because at that time, Liu Feng was likely to pose a certain threat to Shu. It is precisely because of this that Liu Bei was allowed to die.

Because Liu Feng did not send troops to rescue Guan Yu when he was besieged, Zhuge Liang judged that Liu Feng had already rebelled, and if he continued to stay, it would make the political situation of Shu unstable, so he let Liu Bei kill Liu Feng.

Because he knew that Liu Bei would be the emperor after Guan Yu's death, he needed to determine the heir, so he had to kill Liu Feng.

Zhuge Liang thinks that Liu Feng is particularly strong, and Zhuge Liang thinks long-term, because Liu Feng may drag his feet, so he will let Liu Bei die.

Because of Liu Feng's relationship, Guan Yu was gradually killed and Jingzhou was captured.

This is because his existence is a scourge, and if he is not dealt with in time, it is likely to threaten their future situation, which is particularly dangerous, and the only way to do it is to strike first.

In fact, it was not Guan Yu who should be blamed, but Zhuge Liang, who said at that time that "Feng is strong, and it will be difficult to control after the change of world". This sentence means that Liu Feng is too strong, if Liu Chan ascends the throne after Liu Bei dies, according to Liu Chan's character, Liu Feng will not be able to suppress him. And Liu Feng was just the righteous son recognized by Liu Bei, Liu Bei naturally didn't want to make the hard-working country cheap outsiders, so he listened to Zhuge Liang's words and killed Liu Feng.

The cause of this incident is Guan Yu, Guan Yu is good at everything, but he has an arrogance, except for Liu Bei, he will not back down half a point to Zhang Fei. And Guan Yu's favorite thing is to listen to Liu Bei praise him, if Liu Bei says that anyone is better than him, this will cause Guan Yu's dissatisfaction. I think that when Ma Chao first returned to Shun, Guan Yu wrote a letter to ask Liu Bei, and Liu Bei praised Ma Chao for being a good person, but he was still not as good as Guan Yu.

This made Guan Yu talk about it whenever he met people, and he was very satisfied with Liu Bei's attitude. It is also Guan Yu's arrogance that has offended many people, although he is good at fighting, but he is not as good as Liu Bei in dealing with people, such as treating the veteran Huang Zhong, Guan Yu does not take the other party in his eyes. It was also because of this that Guan Yu lost Jingzhou later, and ran to Maicheng for help, Mi Fang and they took refuge in Sun Quan, resulting in Guan Yu dying in the end.

After he died, Liu Bei was held responsible, but these people all took refuge in Sun Quan, but one Liu Feng did not take refuge, so Liu Bei and they attributed the responsibility to Liu Feng. Liu Bei didn't plan to execute Liu Feng, after all, he was his adopted son, but Zhuge Liang felt that if Liu Feng didn't die, he would threaten Liu Chan in the future. As soon as Liu Bei heard Zhuge Liang's words, he executed Liu Feng, and poor Liu Feng was still talking about his father-son relationship with Liu Bei before he died.

Liu Feng is not only brave, but also has a very upright personality, and after Liu Beixian dies in the future, I am afraid that no one will be able to control him. Woke up the dreamer with a word again, Liu Bei made a decision after hearing it, and gave Liu Feng to cut himself.

Two reasons. One is because Guan Yu was defeated and killed, but Liu Feng shrank and did not move, not to save Guan Yu, Liu Bei had to kill him to calm the army's anger, and secondly, Liu Feng was just the righteous son that Liu Bei thought he couldn't give birth to his own son and accepted it, and now he is quite fledgling, in order not to make it difficult for his own son to ascend the throne, so get rid of him!

Liu Bei still held a grudge against Guan Yu's death, and at the same time, in order to pave the way for his own son Liu Chan and prevent Liu Feng from supporting his own army, he gave Liu Feng death under Zhuge Liang's strong advice, but regretted it afterwards.

"Feng is fierce and fierce, and it will be difficult to control after the change of world" These are the eleven words that Zhuge Liang said, Liu Bei didn't want his country to flow to outsiders, so he would die.

Guan Yu died in frustration, and when the news of his murder came, Liu Bei cried bitterly and vowed to avenge his younger brother, plus Zhuge Liang said that Liu Feng would not be easy to control in the future, so Liu Bei gave Liu Feng death.

The answer is: Liu Feng is a threat to Liu Chan's succession, and Liu Bei believes that Liu Fengfeng should not save Guan Yu because of his selfish desires and be disloyal to Sichuan Shu. So kill him.

This is because Liu Bei wants to keep his country, and he didn't trust Liu Feng at that time, he wanted his son to inherit the throne.

Liu Feng was useless and abandoned his righteous friend, which made Liu Bei very angry, so he let Liu Feng die.

The first is to pave the way for his son Liu Chan to ascend to the throne, and secondly, because Liu Feng is an unstable factor, Liu Bei does not want Shu to affect the great cause of Kuangfu Han due to internal friction.

First of all, because Guan Yu was defeated and killed, and Liu Feng and Meng Da did not save Guan Yu, Liu Bei was very angry, and secondly, Zhuge Liang thought that Liu Feng was too violent, and it would be difficult to restrain him in the future, and he was afraid of future troubles.

Because in the process of Guan Yu's escape, he once asked Liu Feng for help, but he did not come to the rescue. This is also part of the reason why Guan Yu was killed.

Because Zhuge Liang didn't believe him, Zhuge Liang felt that his existence would cause a great hidden danger to himself.

Because this person's temper is particularly irritable, and it is difficult to take on a big job, Guan Yu has asked him to send troops to help him many times, but he refused, if such a person is allowed to serve as the Datong of Shu, it will definitely make Shu face a great crisis, so he will be ordered to be killed.

Liu Feng's death, Guan Yu is just a reason, although it is related, but it is not the main reasonThe main reason is that Liu Feng is Liu Bei's son, but he is not his own son.

Liu Feng, a native of Changsha in the late Eastern Han Dynasty, was originally surnamed Kou, because Liu Bei had a good relationship with Liu Feng's biological father when he lived in Jingzhou, Liu Bei had no biological children at that time, and saw that Liu Feng was a very promising general, so he discussed with Liu Feng's biological father and adopted Liu Feng as an adopted son. In the sixteenth year of Jian'an (211), Liu Bei had already gained a firm foothold in Jingzhou, and took advantage of the discord between Liu Zhang and Zhang Lu of Hanzhong to send troops to Yizhou, and actually started the battle of Sichuan under the pretext of helping Liu Zhang. In this process, the young Liu Feng began to emerge and slowly made a name for himself in the army with his bravery.

After occupying Yizhou, Liu Bei made Liu Feng the deputy lieutenant general.

Next, Liu Bei began to continue to go north, launching the battle for Hanzhong, which lasted for nearly two years, and finally ended with Cao Cao's defender Xiahou Yuan who stayed in Hanzhong and Cao Wei withdrawing from Hanzhong, and Liu Bei completely occupied Hanzhong and Yizhou. Liu Feng was arranged by Liu Bei to capture Shangyong with Meng DaLiu Feng once again fulfilled his mission and successfully won the territory of Shangyong, and was therefore promoted to deputy general by Liu Bei.

After Guan Yu was defeated in Jingzhou, he sent people to Shangyong to ask for help, but Liu Feng refused to send troops on the grounds that the people were not attached to the people's mind, which eventually indirectly led to Guan Yu being captured and killed. After this incident, Liu Bei was furious and wanted to arrest Liu Feng and Meng Da for questioning, Meng Da was very clever, and after hearing the news, he defected to Cao Wei. And Liu Feng thought that he was Liu Bei's righteous son and would be fine, but he didn't expect that he would be killed by Liu Bei in the end.

Liu Feng's death, not saving Guan Yu is one thing, on the other hand, both Zhuge Liang and Liu Bei know their names: although Liu Feng is nominally Liu Bei's son, he has no blood relationship with Liu Bei, and Liu Bei has his own flesh and blood Liu Chan after receiving Liu Feng, if Liu Bei dies,According to the rules, it should be passed on to the eldest son, but can Liu Bei pass the throne to Liu Feng? It's impossible, but Liu Feng is the eldest son, and it's not easy to explain it

In case Liu Feng is unfavorable to Liu Chan after Liu Bei, Zhuge Liang and others die, who can control Liu Feng?

So,Even if there is no reason for Guan Yu's incident, Liu Feng's ending may not be too good

Because Liu Feng is Liu Bei's godson, he will definitely compete with Liu Chan for the throne, Liu Bei's foundation was unstable at that time, and in order to stabilize internal affairs, Liu Feng was killed.

Liu Feng died not because he knew anything, but because Liu Feng refused Liu Bei's request to send troops at that time, which indirectly led to Guan Yu's death, Liu Feng dared to do this when Liu Bei was still there, if Liu Bei died, it would pose a great threat to Liu Chan who succeeded to the throne, so he would suggest that Liu Bei give Liu Feng death.

Zhuge Liang felt that Liu Feng was not easy to manage, and if Liu Bei died, no one could suppress him, so he suggested that Liu Bei execute Liu Feng. Zhuge Liang thought that Liu Feng wanted to succeed to the throne.

The reason why Zhuge Liang must Liu Bei give Liu Feng to death is because Zhuge Liang thinks that Liu Feng is a treacherous person and a villain, and if he does not stab him to death, it will inevitably cause great trouble in the future, and Zhuge Liang's true face is really good for Shu Han.

Zhuge Liang asked Liu Bei to kill Liu Feng, and the reason for supporting Adou was very simple: orthodoxy.

Because Adou is Liu Bei's flesh and blood relative, he is an orthodox descendant of the Han family. And Liu Feng is not Liu Bei's biological son, but he was adopted by Liu Bei, he was from a low background, and during the Three Kingdoms period, which focused on origin and bloodline, they were not qualified to control power at all.

Because Liu Feng was too good and had already threatened Liu Chan's position as the heir, Zhuge Liang persuaded Liu Bei like this; Zhuge Liang's real purpose was to ensure the stability of the Shu Han regime and avoid a situation like that of Eastern Wu.

Liu Bei, who lives in Jingzhou, is nearly 40 years old and has no children. Someone persuaded Liu Bei to adopt a godson, so Liu Bei adopted Liu Bi's nephew and changed his name to Liu Feng. Liu Feng followed Liu Bei's Northern Expedition and fought in Yizhou and Hanzhong.

He was everywhere and made a huge contribution. Liu Bei relied on him and promoted him to the deputy lieutenant general. This young man has a bright future.

There is a lack of talents in Shu and a lack of successors. Later, Zhang Fei Guan Yu died, Ma Chao died of illness, Huang Zhong died, Zhao Yun was old, and there were not many of the first generation, and the second generation was almost none except for Wei Yan, Zhang Bao, Guan Xing, and Liu Feng. Guan's death made Liu Feng infamous for his own destruction, but he only had 10,000 troops, which was a drop in the bucket and not enough to save the overall situation.

You must know that Guan Yu fought two powerful enemies of Ran Zheng, Cao Cao and Sun Quan. Even if Liu Bei came to fight in person, he would definitely not be able to win. The highlight of Liu Feng's life was Liu Bei's decision to seize the river.

At that time, although Liu Feng was only twenty years old, he was known for his use of force.

In the process of conquering Yizhou, he made great contributions, so he was awarded the position of deputy army lieutenant general by Liu Bei. Regarding Liu Feng's combat effectiveness, Zhuge Liang once had this evaluation: "Feng Gang is fierce, after the world changes, it is difficult to control Pi Yingsong."

It can be seen that Liu Feng's fighting level, even Zhuge Liang admires it. Especially later, Liu Feng and Meng Da won Shang Yong together, which was also Liu Feng's glorious moment. Liu Feng and Meng Da occupied Shangyong together, but in 219 AD, when Guan Yu threatened China, Monroe led his army to attack Jingzhou.

Guan Yu besieged Xiangfan at this time, and Guan Yu, who had nowhere to go, hoped that Liu Feng could send troops to help, but Liu Feng refused at this time. After Guan Yu was defeated and killed, Meng Da had a bad relationship with Liu Feng, and Meng Da was oppressed by Liu Feng because of the Guan Yu incident. Turned around and took refuge in Cao Wei, which led to Shang Yong's loss, and Liu Feng returned to Chengdu.

Liu Feng is Liu Bei's eldest son, so when Liu Bei becomes emperor in the future. Although he is the righteous son, he is the eldest son of the Han Dynasty. Therefore, for his son Liu Chan, there is naturally no way to inherit Liu Bei's mantle.

Liu Feng had already read twenty at this time, and his strength was extraordinary. If he can train well in the future, he can become Shu Han's right-hand man. The root cause of Liu Feng's killing was the contradiction between him and Liu Chan.

In addition to his special identity and powerful personality, Zhuge Liang also believed that he would not be able to control himself after Liu Bei's death, so he became a victim of political struggle in a confused way.