What do you think of geographical determinism ?

GeographyDeterminismThat is to say, the geographical environment determines the person as well as the wholeNational economyThis is the way of development, which highlights the factors of geography and culture. Topography, climate, hydrology, soil, rivers, water sources, etc., can affect the entire tribe and the way civilization develops, and even affects its rise and fall. <>

The so-called geographical determinism is made up of. It was proposed to be in the Roman Empire.

The history of the period between 400 and 500 years is an example of the drought in most parts of the Roman Empire, which affected the normal cultivation of the land, and the value of agricultural production decreased, and the society became more tense and gradually unstable, and then the political situation collapsed, and finally the Roman Empire gradually disappeared, of course, this is an individual case.

I feel that the development of a country will be affected by many factors, and the fact that you can find one example does not mean that this is the case for all. <>

Because in addition to geographical factors, that can also be developed by itself, a personal determinism and a good leader can determine the history of a dynasty. Although this view of history.

It's not right, but if I just want to find an example, it's not difficult, it's not difficult, so many prosperous dynasties in history are hard to find, so many, because of the mediocrity of an emperor, there are no examples of such rulers who have collapsed and collapsed due to the gradual disappearance of the court?There are many more than one, and I can give 10 8 examplesBut personal determinism is certainly not right, and the development of history is not determined by individuals, and certainly not by geographical circumstances. <>

The development of a place is affected by geographical factors, by human factors, by social factors, and by many factors. It's like your body, whether your body is healthy or not, to say that your heart must be healthy, the human body can be healthy, is this sentence true?I think it's right, but if you're healthy, say you're in good healthAs long as your heart is healthy, of course it's not right, if there is a problem with your kidneys, your body is still not healthy.

The core concept of "geographical determinism" is that the geographical environment plays a decisive role in the development of human society. The impact of geography on human beings is very large.

If this theory exists, there must be a reason for it. This determinism is recognized by many scientists, and at the same time resisted by many scientists, and whether it exists remains to be tested.

This theory is still very realistic, and we have now been affected by some factors, and we should pay attention to some things in order to develop steadily.

Geographical determinism, abbreviated as "determinism", is a school of thought that affirms that natural conditions (i.e., geographical environment) are the decisive factors in the development of human society, that is, the process of social and economic development is explained by the role of natural processes, so that the geographical environment determines the political system.

This argument originated in ancient Greece, when Hippocrates believed that human characteristics arise from climate, and was widely used in sociology, philosophy, geography, and history.

Geographical determinism was part of the popular naturalistic trend of the century. This trend of thought has played a certain historical role in opposing religious theology and exploring the objectivity of social development. However, it exaggerates the role of the natural environment in social life and social development, and it is wrong to replace social laws with natural laws.

Geographical environment is a constant and necessary external condition for the existence and development of society, which has an impact on social development, but it is not a determining factor in social development and the state system, and cannot determine the nature of society and the replacement of social system. Moreover, its role and influence are also constrained by the level of production and social system of society.

Geography cannot play a decisive role in the development of society

1. Geographical environment cannot determine the nature of social systems. The nature of a social system is determined by the mode of production of the material means of this society;

2. The geographical environment cannot determine the change of the social system;

3. The role of geographical environment in social development is restricted by the society, and the bright hall is closely related to the level of social productivity and scientific and technological development.

The town of the town laughs at environmental determinism, referred to as determinism. That is, the process of social and economic development is explained by the role of natural processes, so that the political system is determined by the rational environment of the earth.

To put it simply, geography is everything, and humans can only succumb to the environment.

This theory was formed in the early days of the development of geography, when the level of human productivity was low, so the ability to transform nature was very weak, and they could only live with water and grass. If there is enough food and water, people will migrate.

I wonder if you're satisfied?

Geographical determinism, abbreviated as "determinism". That is, the process of social and economic development is explained by the role of natural processes, so that the geographical environment determines the political system. This argument has been widely used in the study of sociology, philosophy, geography, and history.

It is not geographical determinism, which believes that the natural environment has a decisive influence and role on the existence and development of human beings.

The first time I saw geographical determinism was in the history class in the first year of high school, when the teacher analyzed the geographical environment of Greece, which determined the characteristics of Greece's developed industry and commerce and developed navigation, so the Greeks formed the quality of fairness and integrity, and finally Greece formed a more democratic political environment. Geographical determinism means that everything is determined by geography, and such an extreme thing should not be desirable. On the one hand, geography can be said to be very important, but it cannot be regarded as a decisive factor.

This is largely caused by the geographical environment, why China's south is more developed than the north, the geographical environment is still very large, you go to the middle and lower reaches of the Yangtze River to see very clearly, and the northwest is very different. Another example is the development of the United Kingdom, which also has a lot to do with the geographical environment. Because it is separated from the European continent by the English Channel, it is relatively less affected by the mainland, and you can do whatever you want.

At the beginning, the religious problems on the European continent were complicated, but the religion in Britain was relatively tolerant, and various sects could even live in harmony. When the royal power on the European continent began to be centralized, the English aristocracy began to contradict the king, and the Magna Carta came into being. It is also interesting that the Hundred Years' War between Britain and France was fought on French soil.

So can we say that Britain can become a world hegemon because of geography? The answer is, of course, no, for example, Japan, which is also an island country, has developed two or three hundred years later than Britain, and this is due to the cultural differences between the two sides. So when you analyze the development of the UK, the geography is an important factor, and there are other reasons such as politics, economics, culture, etc., so that the whole perspective can be expanded.

Sometimes we don't have to stick to a decisive factor, the world is so complex, and the reasons for this complex world are probably also complex.

So I think for geographically determinists, that's very, very important, but not the determinant.

Geography has an important impact on administrative organization, but this must not be deterministic with geography.

Confused. Geographical determinism is a political theory that emerged in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. This theory holds that man is a product of the earth, and therefore geography determines all aspects of man. From the economic system, political system, cultural values.

Even people's personalities are determined by the geographical environment. Apparently. Geographical determinism puts people in a position of passive adaptation, ignores the subjective role of human beings, and is a kind of mechanical materialism.

point of view. In fact, the natural geographical environment only provides conditions and opportunities for people to meet their needs, and how to make use of these conditions and opportunities depends on people's subjective initiative.

Therefore, our view of the role of geography is that of influence rather than determinism, of contingency rather than necessity. Of course, as the material basis for the survival and development of human society, the geographical environment will have an eternal impact on the administrative organization, and the human society will never be able to violate the laws of nature, and the administrative organization must conform to the laws of nature in order to survive and develop.