Is Liu Bang really like Sima Qian said, is he a god descending from heaven, and is there any basis?

Updated on history 2024-07-31
10 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-15

    He was just a pavilion chief at the beginning, but because of his great ambition and his hard work, he eventually became the founding emperor and established the great dynasty of the Han Dynasty.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-14

    I don't think so, Liu Bang is the founding emperor of the Western Han Dynasty, and Sima Qian wrote history books for the Western Han Dynasty, so I have to exaggerate him and praise him more.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-13

    It was a tradition of ancient historians to find a plausible account for imperial power. Although Sima Qian is an upright historian, he is still a traditional historian, and he is not exempt from vulgarity.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-12

    No, Liu Bang is just an ordinary person, but he is more capable than ordinary people.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-11

    No, it's just that people are mythologizing Liu Bang, in fact, Liu Bang is not so powerful at all.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-10

    Definitely not. Sima Qianzhi said this mainly to deify Liu Bang, so he wrote like this.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-09

    Son of the Red Emperor. In fact, it is not a folklore, but a record in the "Historical Records":

    First, when Liu Bang was born, he said that his mother dreamed of having sex with God, and his father saw a dragon attached to his mother's body, and later became pregnant and gave birth to Liu Bang.

    Second, Liu Bang was a good drinker when he was young, but he had no money, so he often drank and slept there every time he was drunk. The two wine sellers found that Liu Bang was faintly covered with a dragon, and the account book was broken at the end of the year, so they didn't ask him for accounts.

    Third, Liu Bang beheaded the White Snake and rebelled, and later someone saw a woman crying about the White Snake, and others asked him why, she said that his son was the son of the White Emperor and was killed by the son of the Red Emperor. In other words, Liu Bang is the son of the Red Emperor.

    Fourth, he was later wanted by the Qin Dynasty and hid in Mangdang Mountain, and his wife could find him every time, saying that there were colorful clouds in the place where Liu Bang was hiding.

    Fifth, Fan Zeng said that Liu Bang has a genius.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    Folklore has it that the son of the Red Emperor descended to earth, but it was under this banner that Liu Bang's great cause in the later period was paved.

  9. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    The gods descended to earth by himself. In order to deceive people.

  10. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    To analyze the reasons why Liu Bang won the world, it depends on who he was the opponent with at that time, what kind of person the opponent was, and what advantages Liu Bang had compared with him.

    Xiang Yu, a hero, but it is difficult to become a generation of kings, he attaches too much importance to affection, while Liu Bang, a villain, has just achieved his unique advantages. He can do whatever it takes, he can have no worries, he can even watch his father being killed, or push his son off the carriage with his own hands in order to escape for his own life.

    Secondly, Liu Bang is ambitious to win the world, as said in the Hongmen banquet, in the past, he was greedy for money and was so beautiful, and after the garrison was on the throne, there was nothing to take from the property, and women had nothing to do.

Related questions
8 answers2024-07-31

Sima Qian is a descendant of the Qin general Sima Cuo, who can be said to be the first person of the Han nationality to run Sichuan. When he persuaded King Qin Hui to attack Shu, he put forward the economic strategy of "pulling out a country and the world does not think it is violent, and the West Sea (that is, Qinghai, referring to the area of Chengdu) is not greedy". After Sima Cuo, what people can know now is Sima Cuo's grandson Sima Qi, who was a subordinate of Bai Qi, the general of the Qin State who had killed 400,000 soldiers of Zhao State in the Battle of Changping, and he also participated in the Battle of Changping. >>>More

14 answers2024-07-31

Because this can reflect the greatness of Liu Bang, he once won more with less, and defeated Xiang Yu under such a difficult situation at the beginning, which can better confirm the power of the founding emperor of the Han Dynasty, so Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty will not punish him.

11 answers2024-07-31

The Records of the Historian was created independently by Sima Qian, but Sima Tan had accumulated materials before, as well as Wang Guowei, and Gu Jiegang believed that "The Biography of the Assassins", "The Biography of Fan Liteng", and "The Biography of Lisheng and Lu Jialie" were all written by Sima Tan. >>>More

17 answers2024-07-31

I think Sima Qian may indeed be missing this battle, but now historians have not given an answer, after all, most of Liu Bei's history is defeatedTherefore, everyone thinks that Liu Bang did not win the battle of Pengcheng, but I think it is very credible, and there is indeed a thousand-mile defense line. >>>More

6 answers2024-07-31

Sima Qian adheres to the heart of a historian, dares to disobey the dragon's face, writes down the past facts with the pen of justice, although he is punished, but his pride is eternal, he does not stick to one pattern and writes the annals of history, regardless of day and night, travels in the long river of history, examines the traces of the past, and discovers the true knowledge of history. The cold comes and the summer comes, the dripping water pierces the stone, and the love silk is gorgeous, and it finally becomes a swan song.