Who is the real hypocrite in the Water Margin, why is it not Song Jiangwu Yong, but someone else?

Personally, I think this person should be Li Kui. In order to save face for himself, Li Kui took the initiative to go back to take his wife back. As a result, the road has not been taken care of.

In the end, the old lady was eaten by the tiger. Although Li Kui killed the Four Tigers in the end, the old age was finally eaten. If Li Kui didn't pick up the old lady, then the old lady would definitely be alive normally.

And the old lady was also carried away secretly. Since ancient times, our country has paid attention to loyalty and filial piety, and filial piety is the first great good in the world.

Therefore, there are many heroes in Liangshan, in fact, many of them are indiscriminate and full of numbers, and they are serious thieves. It's just that the idea of this book is to resist the unfair rule of the imperial court and express the idea of official coercion and rebellion. That's why there is the story of one hundred and eight generals in Liangshan.

Personally, I think that Li Kui is not a good man, at most he is a reckless man who likes to kill. Starting from Dai Zong and Song Jiang in the robbery field, Li Kui didn't care about the people next to him at all when he was killing. Killing and slashing along the way, in fact, killing many innocent people.

As a good man, when you think that the court is unjust, you should resist. But the people are not at fault, right? Why harm the people?

When the law was robbed, those people were lively, and they didn't want to intercept this group of Liangshan heroes. Compared with the practices of other heroes, Li Kui obviously did nothing.

And above Liangshan, there are almost no people who really have a good relationship with Li Kui. Except for one Bao Xu, the rest are Dai Zong and Song Jiang. Song Jiang just wants to use Li Kui, and Song Jiang's relationship with anyone is actually not bad.

And Dai Zong was the person Li Kui got along with the most when he was in Jiangzhou. Nominally, both of them are Li Kui's eldest brothers. And Bao Xu is because he and Li Kui have a common language - murder.

Bao Xu is nicknamed the god of mourning, and the evaluation of him in the Water Margin is: "I have to kill people in my life". So Bao Xu can play with Li Kui.

And others, basically, don't like this reckless man who only likes to kill.

There are few people who really make me feel like a hero, and the first one is Lu Zhishen, chivalrous and courageous. In fact, on Liangshan, Lu Zhishen is one of the people who hates Song Jiang the most. Lu Zhishen punched Zheng Tu to fight for others, and later escorted Lin Chong to fight for his brother.

So Lu Zhishen can be called a good man. Characters like Bai Sheng, who are similar to Bai Sheng, are at most a headless and faceless thief.

The second one that makes me feel that he is a hero should be Wu Song, because in the Water Margin, Wu Song acted chivalrous and righteous, and did it righteously. So it's one of the heroes. Although Wu Song also likes to kill, most of the people who die in his hands are still thieves.

killed a lot of servants when he was splashed with blood in the Mandarin Duck Tower, which can be regarded as Wu Song's only stain. So later, when they came to Liangshan, only Wu Song and Lu Zhishen had the best play.

When I was a child, I watched "Water Margin" and felt that the characters in it were informal and carefree. thinks they may be heroes and heroes on the rivers and lakes, but now it seems that the characters in them are not a bunch of chickens and dogs?

This is properly said by your big brother Li Kui. As one of the most hypocritical generals in the Water Margin, Li Kui can be said to be a combination of disloyalty, filial piety, benevolence and injustice, and truly achieved the realm of a real villain. Of course, Song Jiang and Wu Yong are also hypocritical, so to speak, at least more than 30 of the 108 heroes in Liangshan are hypocrites, and only those who were forced to go to Liangshan are still a few people who are loyal and brave and have true temperament.

At least in Song Jiang's faction, there are few good people.

One. Li Kui, the king of hypocrisy, and even more so Song Jiang Wu If he did a sample survey among the readers of the Water Margin, I believe that at least 9 out of 10 people would say that they hated Song Jiang the most, for no other reason, Song Jiang was not only a villain who was good at tricks, but also contributed to the tragic situation of Liang Shan after he was recruited in one fell swoop.

And Wu Yong, as the so-called first person in strategy in the Water Margin, really can't afford this title. Its so-called strategy is nothing more than forcing the family to ruin if it wants to get someone. When it was time to conquer Fang La, it was also possible to see the uselessness of Wu Yong.

Liangshan 108 heroes were stunned to let half of the eight heavenly kings of the family play to death, of which Wu Yong's responsibility should account for at least 70%.

However, even so, Song Jiang and Wu Yong are still relatively kind compared to Li Kui. To give a few simple examples, everyone in the world thinks that Li Kui is honest and honest, but only Song Jiang is the first to look forwardBut he didn't know that Li Kui was murderous by nature, and he liked to kill people at every turn. Not only that, everyone must know the allusion that Li Kui's mother was eaten by a tiger.

However, Li Kui at that time was not grieving for his mother, he simply felt that he had carried his mother for thousands of miles, and he was eaten by a tiger like this, and he just carried it in vain.

In addition to this, as a loyal fan of Song Jiang,Do you think Li Kui was deceived by Song Jiang's benevolence and righteousness? No, the reason why he supports Song Jiang so much is entirely because Brother Song gave him money, Li Kui likes to gamble on this stubble, and many people must not have understood it carefully, right? Therefore, it is not wrong to call Li Kui the real hypocrite in the Water Margin.

Two. How to look at the Water Margin dialectically, many people think that the Water Margin is a surrealist way to satirize the social oppression of the poor. However, in fact, most of the characters portrayed in Water Margin are far from being good people.

Perhaps only Yang Zhi who was forced to go to Liangshan like this can be called a typical example of our understanding. As for Song Jiang, Wu Yong, Li Kui and others, they themselves have already stepped into the ranks of the wicked with one foot, after all, which good person have you ever seen, in order to let people go to Liangshan, they will force people to ruin their families at every turn?

Let's talk about the most important turning point in the Water Margin - Zhao'an. This plot written by Shi Nai'an is actually more ironic, so much so that after reading this paragraph,One of the thoughts that lingered in my mind was that the protagonist of the Water Margin was actually Song Jiang, and Shi Nai'an just wanted to portray the life of a person like Song Jiang, so that the world could see how hateful this kind of person's face was. And Li Kui is probably equivalent to a loyal imp beside the king of Hades.

Song Jiang is a positive character, that is, a good person. In the process of fleeing, the generous Song Jiang met many heroes and heroes with the names of Hu Baoyi and Timely Rain, including the walker Wu Song.

At the beginning, he helped friends in the rivers and lakes, but he only developed contacts for himself, and in the future, if there were any mountains and rivers in the rivers and lakes, it would be easy to do things. But if you want to say that he really went to Liangshan to be the king of the mountain, then he never thought about it at that time. Even in his heart, he felt that he was an official, and he looked down on those people in the green forest.

Song Jiang, the chief priest of Yuncheng County, Shandong, has his own class superiority.

And even if it were, it wouldn't. Having said that, Song can't be said to be absolutely good or bad, at first he was a good man who helped the poor, then an unscrupulous underworld boss, and finally a hero who did the right thing for heaven. In the end, it's a plus, and it's not appropriate for good or bad.

Brief introduction. Song Jiang was originally the director of Yuncheng County, Shandong, and his correspondence with Chao Gai was discovered by Yan Poxi, so he killed Yan Poxi in anger and fled home to hide. Later, he went to Qingfeng Village to seek refuge in Huarong, but was framed and imprisoned by Liu Gao's wife when he was watching the lights in Qingfeng Village.

On the way to Qingzhou, he was rescued by Yan Shun and others. On the way to Liangshan, he learned that his father had died of illness, and when he went home to mourn, he was caught and sent to Jiangzhou.

He was sentenced to death for writing anti-poems in Xunyang Building, Jiangzhou, but on the day of execution, he was rescued by the people of Liangshan and defected to Liangshan. After being shot dead in the attack on Chao Gai in Zengtou City, Song Jiang sat in the first place, and won two victories over Tong Guan and three victories over Gao Yu. After accepting Zhao'an, he led the Liangshan men and horses to attack the Liao State and pacify Tianhu and Fang La.

After being crowned an official by the imperial court, he was framed by Cai Jing, Tong Guan, and Gao Yu, poisoned, and buried in Tateerwa.

Song Jiang in "Water Margin" is not a good person, the heroes of Liangshan are evil, and the heroes of fighting the underworld are a group of righteous bandits, because Song Jiang's stubbornness has ruined everything for them, including their lives, so I don't think Song Jiang is a good person in this story.

Song Jiang in "Water Margin", he is a good person, because he never does anything hurtful to nature, but he has a big temper and speaks very irritablely, so it is easy for people to mistake him for a bad person.

Song Jiang was one of the heroes of Liangshan, so he was considered a good man, but most people didn't like him because he had always been the main subordinate among the heroes of Liangshan, and eventually led to the tragic fate of the rebel army and himself.

"Water Margin" describes a lot of images that are deeply rooted in the hearts of the people, but everyone has different opinions and opinions on the characters in the book. In the minds of some people, Song Jiang is a hero; But in the minds of some people in Lianghe, Song Jiang is a villain. Therefore, for different characters, the benevolent and the wise have their own opinions, which fully shows that the author is relatively successful in shaping the role of this task.

1. Some people say that Song Jiang is a hypocrite. Song Jiang is a person who likes to fight grievances, but he often uses his character characteristics to do some hurtful things, often robbing some states and counties. Not only these daily trivial things in ordinary times, we all know that the final outcome of the heroes of Liangshan is to be recruited by the imperial court, so why did Song Jiang take his brothers to be recruited by the imperial court, you must know that everyone's ability is not the same, and the ending may be different, many people think that this is a manifestation of Song Jiang's hypocrite, after all, Song Jiang only thinks about his own future.

But if you talk about hypocrites, Song Jiang can only rank second.

2. Li Kui advocates violence. In fact, in the book "Water Margin", there is not much introduction to Li Kui. Li Kui is a person who advocates violence, is accustomed to using force to solve some things, is rude, and does not use his brains to do things, but he does not dare to take responsibility for doing wrong things, but says that it is the fault of others.

When he was in Jiangzhou Dharma, he didn't listen to Chao Gai's orders and killed a lot of people.

The three respectful defeated factions and Li Kui did something wrong but framed it was Song Jiang's order. Song Jiang is a relatively benevolent person, when he was in Zhujiazhuang, Song Jiang promised not to kill innocent people, but Li Kui did whatever it took for the sake of the end, even the prefect's youngest son and some unreasonable Yanei did not let go, but when others formed a bond with Li Kui because of this matter, Li Kui did not dare to admit that he did it, but said that it was Song Jiang's order, which led to innocent people being implicated.

The phoenix does not inhabit the sycamore, and the good tree chooses the bird to perch. Wu Yong himself is pretentious, he is unwilling to only live the life of a hero in the rivers and lakes with Chao Gai, and when he meets Song Jiang, who is ambitious, ambitious and idealistic, Wu Yong has no way to refuse.

Wu Yong is a scholar, and his family is too poor to participate in the scientific examination, so he can only work as a teacher in the village. How can Wu Yongxue be willing to only be a teacher? He saw the opportunity and co-opted Chao Gai, Liu Tang and others to organize the robbery of the Birth Gang.

Wu Yong succeeded, but he also paid the price for it, he became a good man in Liangshanbo and became a wanted officer of the government, Wu Yong originally wanted to do a great career to glorify his ancestors, but he became a wanted person, he was unwillingHe wanted to use his ability to lead his brothers to do another big job, but Chao Gai was too comfortable, he didn't want to toss, he just wanted to eat and drink on Liangshan with his brothers, don't make trouble, just fine.

Wu Yong was distressed in his heart, staying in Liangshan like this for a lifetime, this is not Wu Yong's ideal life, Wu Yong doesn't like it. But when Song Jiang came to Liangshan, Wu Yong saw hope, he found his way to pursue his dreams, and he began to snub Chao Gai step by step and walked towards Song Jiang.

Wu Yong is a scholar, he wants to do a career, he wants to be glorious and wealthy, and he is glorifying his ancestors, while Song Jiang's ideal is to glorify his ancestors and be promoted, and the ideals of the two of them can be said to be essentially the same.

Song Jiang is unwilling to be a hero in Liangshan, and Wu Yong is not willing to be a hero in LiangshanThey all wanted to desperately break free from the cage of Liangshanbo's heroes, and they all wanted to counterattack fate, and it was natural for the two of them to come together.

Chao Gai is short-sighted, and Song Jiang is ambitious; Chao Gai likes a stable and comfortable life, while Song Jiang likes to struggle and struggle; Chao Gai is rude, Corporal Song Jiang Lixian. Wu Yong is a Zhiduoxing, he chooses Liangmu to live and Song Jiang.

Finally: "Water Margin" seems to be the protagonist of Song Jiang on the surface, but in fact, everything is provoked by Wu Yong, Wu Yong instigated Chao Gai and others to rob the birthday gang, instigated Chao Gai to be the boss of Liangshan, instigated Song Jiang to be the boss of Liangshan, and instigated and framed this framer, everything was caused by Wu Yong.

Because Wu Yong later went against Chao Gai's idea, he switched to Song Jiang and finally helped Song Jiang complete the great cause.

Because they saw the right eye, Wu Yong and Song Jiang were all the way, and they both longed for fame and fortune.