Wei Yan in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms was finally killed for rebellion, is there really a rec

In history, Wei Yan did not rebel, he was just dissatisfied with Yang Yi and led his troops to break away from the army, and complained to Liu Chan, the purpose was to seize the leadership of the army, nothing more. Of course, it was indeed wrong for him to do so, but it was not a rebellion.

No, Wei Yan's killing is the end of **, and it is recorded in the official history that Wei Yan was stripped of his power and was not allowed to lead troops to fight again, and finally died of illness.

It is recorded that Wei Yan in the official history was not convinced by Yang Yi and led his army to attack Yang Yi's troops, and was later beheaded by Ma Dai.

<> Romance, Wei Yan was killed in the end for rebellion, is this really the case in history? Wei Yan did not rebel. Neither the "Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms" nor the "Wei Luo" recorded the text of Wei Yan's rebellion.

"Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is only written for the needs of the storyline, and Zhuge Liang suspects that Wei Yan may rebel in the future. Therefore, it has the meaning of removal. Since Wei Yan did not rebel, why was he framed as a rebel?

There are mainly the following reasons: Wei Yan has an arrogant personality, although he is not as good as Guan Yu and Zhang Fei, but Wei Yan is obviously inferior to the other three of the Five Tiger Generals. Such a character offended many generals in the late Shu period.

Among them, the relationship with Yang Yi has reached the point of incompatibility. It was also Yang Yi who wiped out his three clans. Killing the Savior and defecting to Liu Bei, the era of only loyalty in ancient times, made Zhuge Liang very concerned, Zhuge Liang could be said to have been wary of Wei Yan when he was in power, and basically did not give him great military power.

Compared with Huang Zhong, who defected together, the difference is not ordinary. Of course, Liu Bei still admired Wei Yan very much and asked him to be the Taishou of Hanzhong.

insisted on the Northern Expedition to destroy Cao Wei, this view may also be influenced by Liu Bei Kuang's support for the Han Dynasty. But in the later period, Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition was more about diverting the contradictions in Shu, and Zhuge Liang should know that it was difficult to support the Han family in the later period of Shu, so it was more just to transfer the contradictions within Shu through the Northern Expedition, and at the same time to fight for as much peace time as possible for future generations of generals. Wei Yan didn't understand this.

Even when Zhuge Liang died, he asked to withdraw the army, but Wei Yan insisted on not withdrawing. Even said that the death of the prime minister alone should affect the country's plans, which is easily slandered by people with ulterior motives and turned into conspiracy. Wei Yan's life can be said to be tragic, as a fierce general with the highest ability, he was not killed in battle but was wiped out by the country's internal political struggle.

But throughout the Three Kingdoms era, which hero is comedy?

Shu State has no general Liao Hua as a vanguard, talking about the withering of talents in the late Shu Kingdom, Zhuge Liang is a very good national management talent, but in military strategy, is not particularly flexible and fickle, after Zhuge Liang died of illness, can be called the commander of Wei Yan is mainly Wei Yan, but I didn't expect Wei Yan to die in the internal power struggle, after more than ten years Shu did not launch any military action, Jiang Wei was also in power after the death of Prime Minister Jiang Wanfei Yi, and the subsequent military operations were also victorious and defeated, With the withering of talents in all aspects, the Shu State gradually declined, and the civil official group in power in Shu also tended to the unified culture of the Central Plains, so after Chengdu was only besieged by Deng Ai, the civil official group headed by Yu Zhou persuaded Liu Chan to surrender.

This is not the case in history, he was not killed because of **. Instead, he was killed by Ma Dai because of a personal vendetta.

This is really the case in history, because Wei Yan did rebel in history and was finally killed, which is recorded in history.

This is really the case in history, because the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is actually telling history, and the difference between history and history will not be particularly big.

In "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", it was Ma Dai who killed Wei Yan.

In the twelfth year of Jianxing (234), the army retreated slowly with Yang Yi, Wei Yan was furious, day and night, rushed in front of Yang Yi's army, and burned the pavilion road everywhere he walked. Yang Yi and Wei Yan both went to each other to say that the other party had rebelled, and Liu Chan asked Dong Yun and Shi Jiangwan, the governor of the palace, who wanted to rebel, and Dong Jiang and Jiang both guaranteed that Yang Yi suspected Wei Yan.

Wei Yan first occupied the mouth of the Nangu and led his army to attack Yang Yi's army, and Yang Yi ordered Wang Ping to defend against Wei Yan in front. Wang Ping scolded Wei Yan's vanguard: "Prime Minister Zhuge has just died, and his bones are not cold, you dare to do this!"

The army knew that Wei Yan was at fault, and if they didn't listen to Wei Yan's orders, they all scattered. Only Wei Yan and his sons fled to Hanzhong.

Yang Yi sent Ma Dai to catch up with Wei Yan and behead him, offering his head to Yang Yi. Yang Yi trampled on Wei Yan's head with his foot and scolded: "Yong slave! Can you do evil again? So he exterminated the three tribes of Wei Yan.

Ma Dai is just the killer, and Yang Yi is the real murderer. Wei Yan is not a thief. He is only against Yang Yi alone. The so-called "rebellion" is just an internal strife between Yang and Wei for power. Zhu Geliang has to pay some responsibility for his will...

The mastermind is Zhuge Liang, ** is Yang Yi, and the executor is Ma Dai.

The one hundred and fifteenth chapter of Wuhou's pre-ambush plan Lord Wei dismantled the Chenglu plate, the original text is as follows:

The one who beheaded Wei Yan was Ma Daiye. It turned out that when Kong Ming was dying, he gave Ma Dai a secret plan, and when Wei Yan shouted, he was killed by surprise; On the same day, Yang Yi read the plan and knew that Ma Dai was there, so he acted according to the plan and killed Wei Yan.

Ma Dai slew it. Here's a brief summary of the incident in my own words. Zhuge Liang said in the foreword that Wei Yan would rebel after his death, so he entrusted the plan to Yang Yi and instructed him to wait for Wei Yan to rebel before he could disassemble it, and there was a plan to kill Wei Yan.

When Wei Yan and Ma Dai were about to take refuge in the Wei army, they would lead their troops to take Nanzheng first, at this time, Yang Yi opened the bag and asked Wei Yan if he dared to shout three times on the horse according to the method on the bag: "Who dares to kill me." Wei Yan laughed, why didn't he dare, as soon as the words fell, a person behind him raised a knife and beheaded Wei Yan under the horse.

It turned out that Zhuge Liang clearly judged Wei Yan's motives after his death, and he had already taught this secret technique to Ma Dai, but in fact, he had asked Ma Dai to be an "undercover agent", and he could only do it when Wei Yan shouted the "signal" of "who dares to kill me".