The teacher asked us to watch the Dream of Red Mansions. The old version is better or the new versio

Support the first floor,I also recommend that it's best to watch the original.,If it's a TV, it's up to personal preference.,The shooting effect of the new version must be better than the old version.,But I personally like the old version and think it's a classic.,It can never be surpassed.。 As far as the final ending is concerned, the new version continues Gao E's sequel, which greatly distorts the theme of Dream of Red Mansions, while the old version discards Gao E's sequel based on years of exploration and insists on making a Red Chamber that is most in line with Cao Gong's original intention. Finally, to sum up, I support the old version, but if you look at the original work, it is recommended to read the first 80 times separately from the last 40 times.

Pure handmade, asking).

Read the original book to get a more comprehensive understanding of the characters and the wonderful plot.

It's best to watch the original book, and the remakes of the TV series are all steamed buns that have been chewed by others. The directors' understanding is not necessarily correct, you look at the new version of "Dream of Red Mansions" Director Li Shaohong has made this drama more reorganized. It completely distorts the image of classical literature in our hearts and the truth it interprets!

So, don't go to the TV series. It's best not to read a book about Dream of Red Mansions. If you really want to read it, go to the original book first (remember:

It's not a children's version, it's a hundred and twenty original works) The "Red School" can't be called an expert. Only your own understanding is always best.

The new version is closer to the original.,Basically nothing has changed.,It's recommended to see the new version!

And the new version is clear, much better than the old one!

Old version, but you can read the book Dream of Red Mansions.

It's best to look at some of the more complete.,It's the kind of collection or a book.。

Compared with the new version, the old version will be more comprehensive.

The new version is closer to the original.,Basically nothing has changed.,It's recommended to watch the new version.。

Go to see the original book first, and then look at the old version, the old version is very classic.

87 Old Edition Dream of Red Mansions:

1.From the point of view of guidance, it was filmed under the guidance of Zhou Ruchang and other red experts, and the first 80 episodes of the plot were completely filmed according to Cao Xueqin's version, and the last 40 episodes were reconstructed according to Cao Xueqin's foreshadowing.

2.From the perspective of the actors, the selection of actors is very in line with the original prototype, and they have undergone all-round training such as piano, chess, calligraphy and painting performances. It is very consistent with the temperament of the person who was conceived when he was studying.

3.It was filmed at an era when art was still being pursued, and the elite of the whole country was concentrated. The artistic standard is extremely high. From the perspective of stage art and all aspects, it has reached its peak.

The new version of Dream of Red Mansions:

Director Li's Dream of Red Mansions is the same as her "Orange is Red", full of weird ** and scenes. The presentation of the storyline is mainly narration, rather than performance, almost a recitation version of Dream of Red Mansions.

In terms of actor selection, although the draft was also selected for a year, they were all just beautiful, and their personality characteristics were not obvious. No matter how much people speak, act, or behave, they are almost the same mold, and if they don't distinguish carefully, they won't be able to recognize who is who.

The stage and ** and other aspects are very different from the old version, but it doesn't feel very consistent with the identity of the characters.

In short, Dream of Red Mansions is not impossible to remake, but it must be filmed in a more calm and stable era.

The old version is the Dream of Red Mansions, the new version is the Dream of the Green Mansion, this dream is not the other dream, the two are very different, support the old version!

I saw the knowledge of the head of the Red Mansion and the dream of the Qinglou.

The old version is good-looking, and the new version is a ghost movie,

I think the old version is more classic, and the new version is a bit out of line.

I think it's still good-looking in the new version, the new version has added many elements that were not in the old version, the scene is very dreamy, which can fully show the domineering and extravagance of the mansion in Jiafu, and the inner world of people in the background of people's cautious and confused life in the context of the graceful and luxurious life of the big family. Although the actors are all young, the performance still injects a lot of thought into the performance, and it also has its fresh side. Overall it's pretty good.

Of course it's different!

The first 29 episodes of the 87 version of Dream of Red Mansions are based on the 80 episodes of the ancient Dream of Red Mansions, which are faithful to Cao Xueqin's original work, and the next 7 episodes do not use Gao E's sequel, but according to the foreshadowing of the first 80 episodes, combined with years of research results in red studies, to reconstruct the ending of this tragic story. This version is very experimental**, at that time, everyone in the red academic circles like Wang Kunlun Shen Congwen Mr. Qigong Wu Shichang Zhou Yang Zhou Ruchang Yang Cao Yu Dai Linfeng Jiang Hesen Wu Lengxi Lin Chenfu Cheng Yin Zhu Jiajun Wang Chaowen and so on are all consultants of this TV series, which can be said to be several elites in the Chinese red academic circles at that time, and many old gentlemen have passed away now.

The 2010 version of Dream of Red Mansions is based on Gao He and Cheng Weiyuan's adaptation and continuation of Dream of Red Mansions, and the narration and dialogue in the TV series are basically unchanged and interpreted in the original text of the book, completely faithful to the fake book written by Gao E, Gao E's continuation of the book made a lot of changes to Cao Xueqin's first 80 times, and then used his imagination to write the last 40 times.

The former of the two TV series is based on the 80 ancient books of Dream of Red Mansions and the research results of Red Studies, and the latter is based on Gao E's sequel, of course, there is a big difference, and it would be strange if there was no difference. 87 version, if you look carefully, you will find that the ending behind is actually very sloppy, and the fate of many characters has not been explained, which is also a limitation of Hongxue, because until now, before the discovery of a new ancient book Dream of Red Mansions, Hongxue has basically encountered a bottleneck, and the fate of many characters is difficult to be clear, and the academic community has not yet reached an agreement, which is also the reason for the hasty ending, which is somewhat a pity. As for the 2010 version of the film, which is completely based on Gao E's fake book, anyway, I think Gao E's sequel is very outrageous, and the writing level after 80 and before 80 times has changed a lot, and the tone of writing has changed greatly, which is really not a clever continuation, and the effect of filming makes people feel that the last 40 times are a bit inexplicable.

Well, yes, the old version is that Baoyu is a monk, and the new version is that he went to catch the exam and was admitted to a friend, don't you think the boss is very good-looking, and the ending is also very fake Baoyu is a song How can a person who hates career economy go to study - Brother will not continue to ask me Adopt it.

I think the most important points are: the technique is good, the age of the actor is similar to the character, and it feels real.

The suggested question can be more specific, for example, does the comparison between the old and new Dream of Red Mansions refer to the comparison of the film and television version of Dream of Red Mansions, or the comparison of multiple versions of Dream of Red Mansions? Wait a minute.

Personally, I still prefer the old version of the Red Mansion, since it is a classical masterpiece.

It has to have a classical charm. It is said that the new Red Mansion spent 100 million to shoot, and the TV effect is good, but it does not have the breath of the Red Mansion.

The new version of the Red Mansion is more terrifying.

There is no best, only the best for yourself. Each version has its own uniqueness.

Generally speaking, the Dream of Red Mansions Gengchen version is suitable for junior and intermediate red fans. Because its content is relatively complete, there are relatively many criticisms of the fat inkstone.

If you are a beginner, look at the 82nd edition of the People's Literature Publishing House. Gengchen proofreading version. There are annotations and it is relatively easy to learn.

If you want to collect, there is a photocopy of the Shanghai Ancient Books Publishing House, it seems to be five or six hundred, which is not very cost-effective. There are thousands of thread-bound books, and it's too dark.

If you look at it and collect it, there is a traditional vertical photocopy of Gengchen edition of Tianjin Ancient Books Publishing House, I think it's good, cost-effective, and there is no typo problem in photocopying. **Around 70 per set. However, it is not suitable for people who do not have a background in ancient Chinese, and the traditional Chinese characters of the brush are not so easy to recognize.

For research purposes, of course, the more editions you have, the better, and there are about 14 kinds of manuscripts to add a piece.