History records that Hua Tuo died in 208 AD, but Guan Yu scraped his bones to heal his wounds in 219

In Luo Guanzhong's "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", there is a description of Hua Tuo scraping Guan Yu's bones to cure poison, which tells the story of Guan Yu's right arm being hit by the Wei army's poisonous arrow during the Battle of Xiangyang. Later, the wound gradually swollen and painful, and he could not move. Hua Tuo scraped the bones for Guan Yu's arm to remove the poison on the bones, but Guan Yu's expression remained unchanged, and he was still playing chess with others.

This story was originally a celebration of Guan Yu's bravery, perseverance, and patience, and it also illustrated the medical skills of the divine doctor Hua Tuo. Won people's praise and admiration. He is the originator of our surgical medicine.

This is a fictional story based on facts recorded in the "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" and the "Xiangyang Mansion Chronicles" in Hubei Province, which is widely circulated among the people. Although Guan Yu had scraped his bones to heal his wounds, Hua Tuo had already died a few years ago.

The Romance of the Three Kingdoms is not a historical fact Although some of what is said is true But after all, it is just a ** It can only be entertained as a story Don't confuse it with real history I also like the Romance of the Three Kingdoms I have watched it several times Recently, I have been playing the Three Kingdoms of Heroes There are also some characters in wild history Such as Zhao Yunlu's daughter-in-law Ma Yunlu If I don't play this game, I never knew that Zhao Yun and Ma Chao were in-laws Whether you raise this question from the game or the romance or the folktales and legends or something else Just one point: when the story Don't take it too seriously (I don't read historical biographies, if you see it in the official historical record, then I'm talking nonsense in front of me, but there shouldn't be such a contradictory record).

There are a lot of stories that are fake.

When Hua Tuo scraped Guan Yu's bones to heal his injuries, Guan Yu played chess with Ma Liang

"Romance of the Three Kingdoms" describes the entire ** process of scraping bones and healing wounds, which is similar to what is written in the history books, but there is an additional plot of Guan Yu and Ma Liang playing chess. When Hua Tuo came to see Guan Yu, Ma Liang was playing chess with Guan Yu. When Hua Tuo treated Guan Yu, Guan Yu set up a banquet to treat each other, and while eating wine, he continued to play the unfinished game of chess with Ma Liang.

Since there is a chess game, then there will be a winner and a loser, and judging from the description in the book, this game of chess should not be finished. Because as soon as Hua Tuo finished giving Guan Yu a good time, Guan Yu laughed and said to his generals that his arms were stretched out as before, and he praised Hua Tuo for being a miracle doctor.

Guan Yu doesn't care about the reasons for winning or losing the chess game

Guan Yu's most concerned thing when he scraped his bones to heal his injuries was to heal his arm injury as soon as possible, so that he could continue the Northern Expedition. As he said, "I take Fancheng, only for the present; took Fancheng, that is, when the long drive into the capital, went to Xudu, exterminated the Cao thief, and used the Han room to settle down. After he finished his stay in Huatuo, he quickly explained to the generals that his injuries were okay and strengthened everyone's confidence.

Then the outcome of the chess game is not something Guan Yu cares about, he is eager to launch an attack on Fancheng again, and he is also eager to express his gratitude to Hua Tuo, so naturally this game of chess will end everywhere. This game of chess has nothing to do, and naturally there will be no winners and losers. However, it is conceivable that Guan Yu has the upper hand in this game of chess, and if it is finished, Guan Yu will undoubtedly win.

Fake, when Guan Yu scraped his bones to heal his wounds, Hua Tuo was no longer alive.

When Guan Yu attacked Fancheng, he was shot in the right arm by a poisoned arrow. The soldiers took out the arrows and saw that the poison had seeped into the bones, and persuaded Guan Yu to return to Jingzhou**. Guan Yu was determined to capture Fancheng and refused to retreat. When the soldiers saw that Guan Yu's arrow wound was gradually getting worse, they sent people around to inquire about the famous doctor.

One day, someone drove a boat from the river to the front of the village, reported his surname Hua Mingtuo, and came to treat Guan Yu's injuries. Guan Yu asked Hua Tuo how to treat the law, and Hua Tuo said: "I'm afraid that you will be afraid, set up a pillar, hang a ring on the pillar, put your arm into the ring, tie it with a rope, and then cover your eyes, and give you a knife."

Guan Yu smiled and said, "No need to tie up." Then he ordered a banquet to be held to entertain Hua Tuo.

Guan Yu drank a few glasses of wine and played chess with others, and at the same time stretched out his right arm to Hua Tuo, and said, "Whatever you want, I'm not afraid." Hua Tuo cut open the skin of the flesh and scraped the bones with a knife.

Those present were so frightened that they covered their eyes with their hands. Look at Guan Yu again, while drinking, playing chess, talking and laughing. After a while, the blood flowed and the poison on the bones was scraped, Guan Yu stood up with a smile and said to the generals

My arms stretched out as if they had been before. Mr. Hua Tuo, you are really a miracle doctor! Hua Tuo said

Since I have been practicing medicine, I have never seen a man as great as you, and the general is a man of God. ”

It's fake.

However, Hua Tuo in history did not treat Guan Gong's arrow wounds, and the two did not even have a chance to meet. Because Hua Tuo died in the 13th year of Jian'an (208 AD), and Guan Yu's poisoned arrow was in the 24th year of Jian'an (219 AD), there was an interval of 11 years, how can the dead heal the living?

However, Guan Yu was killed by an arrow to scrape poison, which has been recorded in "Three Kingdoms: Guan Yu's Biography", and its details are similar to those described in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", but unfortunately the name of the doctor is not recorded in the book.

The reason why Luo Guanzhong wrote the doctor as Hua Tuo was probably because Hua Tuo was a famous doctor at that time and was good at surgery, and it was not a problem to treat arrow injuries. is so "well-founded", coupled with the author's brilliant pen, the story is written vividly and vividly, who doesn't believe in the authenticity of "scraping bones to cure poison"?

The Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms, Guan Zhang Ma Huang Zhao Biography records: Yu taste for the flow of arrows, through his left arm, although the wound is healed, every time it rains, the bone often hurts, the doctor said: "The arrow is poisonous, poison into the bone, when the arm is broken to make a wound, cut the bone to detoxify, and then this problem is to remove the ear."

Yu stretched out his arm and ordered the doctor to split it. Shi Yu Shi invited the generals to eat and drink, and the blood in his arms flowed away from the plate, while Yu cut and drank, laughing and laughing.

Not really.

It is recorded in the Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms that after Hua Tuo became Cao Cao's "imperial doctor", he was "always around." Taizu suffers from the wind, every hair, his heart is dizzy, he is acupuncture, and he is handy. Obviously, with Cao Aman's health condition that he may have a "head wind" disease at any time, coupled with his personality in the world, it is impossible for Hua Tuo to move around to treat others.

However, he was a scholar, and he always regretted himself" also confirmed that Hua Tuo had no freedom of movement at that time, and it was even more impossible for him to go to the "enemy's" account to treat his opponent's illness.

From the analysis of time, according to historical data, "scraping bones and healing" occurred in the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an in the Eastern Han Dynasty, that is, in 219 AD. However, it is recorded in the "Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms" that Hua Tuo was homesick and went home to visit relatives, and after returning home, he excused his wife from illness and did not return. He can be anorexic and still can't get on the road.

Taizu ,.. furiouslyannoyed Cao Cao, so he said: "Don't worry, there should be no such rats in the world?"

He was sentenced to death. Hua Tuo was killed in the thirteenth year of Jian'an (208 AD), which is more than ten years different from Guan Yu's arrow. No matter how "miracle doctor" he is, the dead Hua Tuo can't heal the living Guan Yu.

But because Hua Tuo is a famous doctor, the author is purely exaggerating the atmosphere.

The plot in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is purely fictional, and Hua Tuo has been dead for two years at this time, so it is not Hua Tuo's doing, but just an ordinary military doctor. The Nine Cities web game Bloody Warriors describes this in detail.

Folklore is a story that has been passed down by word of mouth among ordinary people.

One day, someone drove a boat from the river to the front of the village, reported his surname Hua Mingtuo, and came to treat Guan Yu's injuries. Guan Yu asked Hua Tuo how to treat the law? Hua Tuo said

I'm afraid that you will be afraid, so I will crack a pillar, hang a ring on the pillar, put your arm into the ring, tie it with a rope, cover your eyes again, and cut you **. "Guan Yu said with a smile"No need to bundle.

Then he ordered a banquet to entertain Hua Tuo.

Guan Yu drank a few glasses of wine and played chess with someone, and at the same time stretched out his right arm to Hua Tuo, and said:"Whatever you want, I'm not afraid. "Hua Tuo cut open the skin of the flesh and scraped the bones with a knife.

Those present were so frightened that they covered their eyes with their hands. Look at Guan Yu again, drinking and playing chess at the same time. After a while, a basin of blood flowed, and the poison on the bones scraped Sen Hui, Guan Yu stood up with a smile and said to the generals

My arms stretched out as if they had been before. Mr. Hua Tuo, you are really a miracle doctor! "Hua Tuo said

Since I have been practicing medicine, I have never seen such a great man as you, and the general is here to answer the man of God. "

The above is all the content of Hua Tuo's bone scraping and healing for Guan Yu, you are welcome to share the story with your relatives and friends!

There are 16 cases in the Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms (including 7 in the Book of the Later Han Dynasty), 5 in the Biography of Hua Tuo, and 5 in other literature, for a total of 26 cases.

Among Hua Tuo's medical deeds, Guan Yu's "scraping bones to cure poison" is the most popular, but in fact it is a fictional story derived from "Romance of the Three Kingdoms". It mainly describes Guan Yu being wounded by a poisoned arrow when he fought with Cao Cao's general, and Hua Tuo scraped off the poison that penetrated into the bone with a knife.

In the Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms, there is indeed a record of Yu being shot in the arm and scraping the bones to cure the poison [7], but in the historical facts, Hua Tuo had already been killed by Cao Cao at that time, and the person who held the knife and scraped the bones was not Hua Tuo but another unknown military doctor.

Scraping bones and healing is a typical plot in **, with many fictional components, not enough to be convinced, it is just a means to shape the image of the character, and it is not true.

Hua Tuo was killed by Cao Cao during the Battle of Chibi, and it is said that there are historical materials to be examined, but it is more credible.

It's fake. 1. Hua Tuo in history did not treat Guan Gong's arrow wounds, Hua Tuo died in Jian'an 13 years, and Guan Yu was poisoned by arrows in Jian'an 24 years;

2, Guan Yu's arrow scraping poison is indeed a thing, which has been recorded in "Three Kingdoms: Guan Yu's Biography", and the details are similar to those described in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms";

3. The reason why Luo Guanzhong wrote the doctor as Hua Tuo is probably because Hua Tuo was a famous doctor at that time and was good at surgery.

"Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is very different from "Romance of the Three Kingdoms". The former is **, with an element of fiction. The latter is a historical document with high credibility. So if you want to study this reality, it's best to watch "Three Kingdoms". Hope! Thank you!

The Romance of the Three Kingdoms is **, and the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is a history book, which do you think is more in line with history.

In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, the person who scraped Guan Yu's bones and healed his wounds was indeed Hua Tuo. Of course, I also said that it was just **, in the real historical frontage, Hua Tuo died long before Guan Yu scraped his bones and healed his injuries.

We are familiar with the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, but it has been inherited as one of the four famous works of our country. Every character in the book is brought to life and left a very deep impression on us. In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, especially Guan Yu's unparalleled quality of loyalty and righteousness is worth learning from all of us.

If anyone who has really studied the history of the Three Kingdoms understands that Guan Yu scrapes his bones and heals his wounds, it is pure nonsense. After all, it has been clearly recorded in the Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms that Hua Tuo had died a few years before Guan Yu attacked Fancheng. So the dead can't come back from the dead to scrape the bones for Guan Yu to heal his wounds, which is also just made up in **.

There are many similar episodes of ** selling models, such as the ugly Zhang Fei, who is actually a beautiful man in real history. <>

In fact, it cannot be said that the Romance of the Three Kingdoms falsifies history, after all, the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is just a film, and the fundamental purpose of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is to please readers. And the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is described from the perspective of the Shu camp as the protagonist, and the heroic image of the generals of the Shu camp is excessively described, which is also in line with the theme of this **. Here we have also fallen into a misunderstanding, we can't treat the Romance of the Three Kingdoms as a history book.

**There is a fundamental gap between the two and the history books. <>

The reason why Luo Guanzhong did this was to highlight the legitimacy of the camp of the Shu State. As the power of the Han Dynasty, the Han Dynasty still has a sense of belonging to the people of the whole world. Therefore, writing in this way can arouse the reader's sense of identity, and the use of Huagu to heal the wound here is also to highlight Guan Yu's character quality.

It adds another ink to Guan Yu's unparalleled quality, which is why later kings respect Guan Yu very much. <>

It's not Hua Tuo, the transportation at that time was very underdeveloped, and Guan Yu was injured by a poisoned arrow while marching and fighting, so it was done by a military doctor in the army.

No, it's not Hua Tuo, it's someone else, maybe Hua Tuo's apprentice.

It was not Hua Tuo who healed his bones but someone else, because at that time, Hua Tuo had already died and had been killed by Cao Cao.

Although Hua Tuo died, he still had medical works and apprentices, among which Wu Chu and Fan A were also very famous at that time, because Guan Yu was injured, so it is very likely that it was Fan A who scraped his bones and healed his injuries.

Guan Yu is a well-known figure in the Three Kingdoms period, he is not only very strong in combat, but also very loyal. He was loyal to Liu Bei and vowed to follow him. He was a great historical hero.

However, our heroes also made mistakes. When Guan Erye was in his fifties, he also led his troops to attack Cao Cao. He killed many famous generals, and there was awe everywhere.

However, when he attacked Fancheng, his self-esteem was even stronger, as he felt that he would soon succeed and the morale of the soldiers was high. But who knew that at this time, a dark arrow hit Guan Erye's arm, and he fell off the horse at that time, everyone was in a hurry, in order to prevent the deterioration of Guan Yu's wounds, everyone was looking for a way to poison the wound.