The ancient generals, will they be alone in front of the battle?

Under normal circumstances, there was no single-handedness in ancient wars, but there were very few phenomena. For example, in the Three Kingdoms period, there were indeed heads-up situations, such as Lu Bu singled out Guo Yan, Tai Shici also singled out Sun Ce, these are actually based on the content recorded in historical dramas. Of course, in most cases, there will be no plot of the elephant going head-to-head when the two armies face each other, and these plots are basically made up in some ** or TV series.

Although it is said that there were relatively few heads-up links in ancient wars, there are also a very few people who particularly like heads-up. The most typical should be Wang Yanzhang, the iron gun general of the fifth generation, this guy can be said to be addicted to heads-up, every time he leads the army to fight, he is thinking about separating the victory or defeat with the enemy's general. Of course, in addition to this guy, Xiang Yu actually likes to single you out, for example, when Xiang Yu was confronting Liu Bang, he had already proposed that two people come out to fight each other, and the winner or loser would be decided by the two main generals heads-up, I have to say that Xiang Yu's idea is indeed relatively naïve, and Liu Bang naturally did not agree to his request in the end.

If Liu Bang really goes head-to-head with Xiang Yu, I'm afraid he won't be able to go through three rounds in Xiang Yu's hands. <>

In the era of cold weapons, it is actually people who fight and fight. As we all know, in ancient times, wars relied on some cold weapons, and they did not have some of the current high-tech. In the era of cold weapons, fighting a war is actually to fight manpower, that is to say, if the number of people on which side is relatively large, it is basically a foregone conclusion.

Of course, when fighting, it must still depend on the commander's commanding ability, so the commander is very important when the two armies are facing each other. And in some ** or TV series, the reason why there is such a description is actually for the sake of art, in order to let more people be interested in their works.

There is a risk in going head-to-head, even if you are strong in martial arts, you may also be injured by secret calculations, such as shooting with a hidden arrow, Guan Yu is not an example. Unless your own forces are too inferior, and your own strength is strong, it makes sense to go head-to-head.

That's true, it's called a fighter. To put it bluntly, after the official start of the fight, each side will send a fierce general to fight heads-up, and the morale of those who win will naturally rise, and the desire to go to war will increase if they lose.

No, it won't. First of all, the generals have a sense of the overall situation, they will not fight alone before the war for the sake of personal righteousness, they will not joke about the survival of an army or even a country, and every battle is planned.

No, because it does not conform to the logic of war, if one side has absolute strength, it will not go head-to-head at all, and if it loses the war, there is no way to explain it to the emperor

Definitely yes. The generals of the two sides, in front of the armies of the two sides, must have singled out before the battle. Then the two armies will fight each other.

The scene of heads-up often appears in storytelling and romance, but when the two armies are at war in real history, the supreme commander of the army will not personally go into battle, otherwise the entire army will be in danger. But it's not that there is no heads-up, I have written a discussion about the heads-up of military generals in history before, and the following paragraphs of the Three Kingdoms martial arts, I hope to provide you with a reference.

In the real battlefield of the Three Kingdoms in history, there are not many one-on-one battles between the generals of the two sides, and they are not as exciting as in the romance. There are several martial arts dramas of the Three Kingdoms recorded in history, such as when Lu Bu was fighting against Dong Zhuo's subordinate Guo Yan, the two agreed to fight alone to decide the winner, but Guo Yan was stabbed by Lu Bu with a spear. Then there is Sun Ce and Tai Shi Ci's "Shenting War", Sun Ce is brave, known as the little overlord, and Tai Shi Ci's martial arts are also very strong, and later with Sun Ce when he attacked the city, there was a general in the city who used his left hand to hold the wooden beam of the city tower and pointed at Sun Cejun and scolded, Tai Shi Ci said in the formation:

Watch me shoot his left hand! As a result, an arrow pierced the man's left hand and nailed it to the wooden beam, and the three armies applauded. There is another one that Guan Yu beheaded Yan Liang, "Yu Wang saw Liang and spurred Liang to ...... among the ten thousand armies."The armies dare not be enemies.

This is the real head of the general among the hosts. The rest of the wonderful martial arts dramas are difficult to see in the official history, Hua Xiong was killed by Sun Jian, Wen Chou was defeated by Cao Cao and died in the chaos, Xu Chu did not fight Ma Chao naked, but just glared at Ma Chao and Ma Chao did not dare to move....As for Zhao Yun, there is no wonderful performance in the official history, and his courage and strategy are not as good as Guan Yu and Zhang Fei.

When the two armies fought, the soldiers lined up in formation. The generals of both sides, riding on white or red horses, armed with spears or broadswords, and wearing silver helmets or gold armor, rode out on horseback, rushed to the most dangerous front line, and shouted: "Wait for the rats! Who would dare to fight me? ”

At this time, in the opponent's camp, there was no need to shoot him with arrows, nor to beat him in groups, but it was the same, flashing a strong general, rushing to the most dangerous front line, shouting: "Who are you?" Quickly report the name, I will not die under the gun! ”

Then, it's a heads-up between two people.

The result of heads-up: not one, or three-five, or dozens, one side of the general was picked off the horse. And the soldiers did not make any counterattack, and immediately surrendered to the defeat, and the war ended.

It gives the impression that as long as the Lord will prevail, the whole army will win; As long as the main general loses, the whole army loses. The outcome of the entire war depends entirely on the martial arts of the two main generals. The soldiers were merely ornaments and had no real value.

When you think about it, it's a little incredible. If that's the case, what do you need those soldiers for? Did the soldiers just stand aside and watch the excitement go head-to-head? Wouldn't the soldiers rush up and catch the enemy generals alone?

As a result, some people said that on the real battlefield, military generals are completely non-existent, because this does not conform to the basic laws of war at all. The reason why there is a situation where the generals are heads-up in the romance is completely wishful thinking on the part of the **family, and its purpose is just to write a wonderful and beautiful look to attract readers.

Actually, it's not necessarily true, in the battles in history, there are still things where the generals go head-to-head, but it's not as dramatic as in **, and the number of occurrences is much less.

In addition, the heads-up recorded in the official history is often not a "war" in the real sense, at most it is just a "duel".

There were very few in the national dynasty, but it was said that it was very popular in Japan until the Sengoku period in the 15th and 16th centuries (of course, if you think that Japan is not a war, it is a hooligan fight, so I don't say it).

Yes, it's a way to boost morale.