-
Assuming that Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition was successful,The next thing he must have done was to perishSoochowUnify the Central Plains, and then if he lives long enough, probably withLiu ChanThere will be a battle for power, because "high merit and shaking the master" will inevitably lead to a political purge.
When Zhuge Liang took the Northern Expedition as his appointment in the "Longzhong Division", Zhuge Liang had already been with Liu Bei.
said that the way to recover the Han Dynasty is because of Guan Yu.
's death, this plan became an unrealistic copywriting, and it made Liu Bei die in the White Emperor City, and he had to put Liu Chan and Shu Han.
The restoration of the Han Dynasty and so on were entrusted to Zhuge Liang. Since then, the power of Shu Han has been in the hands of Zhuge Liang, and in order to live up to Liu Bei's kindness, after many years of preparation, he was afraid that his time was short, and he frequently went out of Qishan to the north to attack Cao Wei.
With his immortal talent, with the weak to defeat the strong,It can be said that his life, since Liu Bei's "three visits to the thatched house", has been related to the rise and fall of the Shu Han Dynasty, and the Northern Expedition was unsuccessful in the end, and he died in Wuzhangyuan due to illness.
If Zhuge Liang didn't die and the Northern Expedition succeeded, assuming that Zhuge Liang succeeded in borrowing his life at that time, he didn't die, and Cao Wei didn't have Sima Yi.
If Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition was successful, half of the Central Plains was in handAfter the rectification, it will naturally come out of the Eastern Wu, at that time it was estimated that it would be difficult for the Eastern Wu to fight back, Zhuge Liang must be captured, and the mission of the Han Dynasty will be completed by the time. Zhuge Liang may retire successfully, but at that time, it is no longer what Zhuge Liang can do if he wants to, Liu Chan is wise and foolish, if one day the king will come to the world and become the lord of the world, Zhuge Liang will also grow up during the time of Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition and the expedition to Wu, "high merit and shock the master" will make him have a sense of crisis, Zhuge Liang may not want to oppose him, but in order to save his life, he has to have a political struggle with Liu Chan.
Of course, these are all assumptionsAfter all, Zhuge Liang's repeated Northern Expeditions are also because of Liu Chan's trust in him, and if the Northern Expedition is really successful, it is not certain whether there will be this political struggle, but there is a possibility that there will be people in Cao Wei's original territory who will continue to resist, and whether Shu Han can be stable is a question, if Liu Chan has been mediocre, will he go to Qin II.
What about the road?
-
If Zhuge Liang succeeds in destroying Wei, he will definitely continue his crusade against Eastern Wu, because Zhuge Liang has been pursuing the merit of restoring the Han family all his life, but Zhuge Liang's successful Northern Expedition will attract the emperor's suspicion.
-
If Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition succeeded in defeating Cao Wei, then he would definitely choose to go south to attack Eastern Wu, and finally complete the act of unifying the world and reviving the Han Dynasty.
-
<> "Zhuge Liang's most promising Northern Expedition was successful, but because of this, he was forced to withdraw his troops.
Zhuge Liang's most promising Northern Expedition is the First Northern Expedition between 228 and 234 AD.
This Northern Expedition can be described as a major military operation with full preparations, careful operational planning, strong troops, and a small gap between the forces of the two sides. Although Zhuge Liang achieved some victories in this Northern Expedition, he ultimately failed to capture Chang'an, and there were many reasons for the defeat, the main of which was sabotage by Sima Yi of Cao Wei.
First of all, let's take a look at Zhuge Liang's preparations in this Northern Expedition. In 227 AD, Zhuge Liang asked for another northern expedition and personally led the troops. He put forward a detailed plan to move violently, including dividing troops to attack Hanzhong, making a detour to attack Longyou, and besieging Chang'an.
He also paid special attention to the equipment and rest of the soldiers, and ordered the soldiers to make winter clothes, trying to reduce the burden on the army by all means. In short, it can be said that Zhuge Liang made full preparations before the operation, taking into account the life and combat effectiveness of the soldiers from all aspects.
Second, let's take a look at the strategy adopted by Zhuge Liang in action. He first attacked Hanzhong with elite troops and lightly armed, forcing Cao Wei to send a large number of reinforcements to reinforce him. Then, taking advantage of the surging Han water, he went down the river and fought with Cao Wei's army in the Liangshan area, and achieved a certain victory.
Then, he mobilized his army again to march to Chang'an, planning to seize Cao Wei's base in one fell swoop.
However, it was at this time that Sima Yi appeared. He was appointed as a general by the Cao Wei court to lead Cao Wei's army against the Northern Expedition. Although Cao Wei's strength was stronger than Shu Han at that time, Sima Yi was very cautious, and he adopted more conservative tactics in an effort to drain Shu Han's strength.
At the same time, he also managed to sow discord between Li and Shuhan and Wu Guo, making the relationship between Liu Bei and Sun Quan more and more strained.
In the end, the Northern Expedition failed. Although Zhuge Liang achieved some victories in this Northern Expedition, he did not really capture Chang'an, and the sphere of influence of Shu Han's Zhengjiao Bridge was not substantially expanded. And the main reason for the failure of this Northern Expedition was that it was destroyed by Sima Yi.
To sum up, Zhuge Liang's most promising Northern Expedition should refer to the first Northern Expedition that took place between 228 and 234 AD. Although the Northern Expedition was well prepared, well-planned, strong, and the gap between the forces of the two sides was small, it ultimately failed to capture Chang'an, and the reasons for the failure were many, the most important of which was that it was sabotaged by Cao Wei's Sima Yi.
-
Correctly, the significance of the Northern Expedition lies in two aspects: first, to unite the people and unite foreign countries; The second is Zhuge Liang's political ideal: to restore the Han Dynasty and return to the old capital. Let's talk about bringing people together. Liu Bei, Zhuge Liang and others entered Sichuan and belonged"Foreign regimes"。
<> Liu Bei was a northerner, and his subordinates belonged to the northern group. Zhuge Liang has lived in Jingzhou for many years and belongs to the Jingzhou Group. These two groups broke into Sichuan, overthrew Liu Yan, and seized power in Sichuan.
The local ** and landlords in Sichuan were intimidated by the force of Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang and were forced to submit. Zhuge Liang is the representative of the Jingzhou Group, while Zhao Yun, Wei Yan and others are the representatives of the Northern Group. Qiaozhou is the representative of Yizhou Group.
But the Sichuan group was actually not satisfied, although Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang also tried to show favor to the Sichuan group, such as appointing many people as officials.
Contradictions are irreconcilable. Liu Bei's Northern Group and Zhuge Liang's Jingzhou Group entered Shu and occupied a dominant position and obtained a large amount of material resources, which originally belonged to the Sichuan Group. In the eyes of the Sichuan Group, they occupy or occupy the resources that originally belonged to the Sichuan Group, so they are not satisfied.
There are deep contradictions between foreign blocs (Northern Group, Jingzhou Group) and Sichuan Group.
In order to reconcile this contradiction, Zhuge Liang could only turn the internal contradiction to the external one, that is, the Northern Expedition and the Northern Wei Dynasty, which could gather the manpower of Shu and let the three groups focus on the affairs of the Northern Expedition, reduce the intensity of internal strife, and maintain the legitimacy of the external group and the internal stability of Shu, which has achieved the goal of long-term governance. In addition, Zhuge Liang's political ideal was to revive the Han dynasty and return to the old capital. Shu was originally a dove occupying a magpie's nest and snatching it from Liu Zhang.
Therefore, it is difficult for the foreign Jingzhou people and the Bashu aborigines to be of one heart and one mind. Once the external situation eases, it is easy to create internal confrontation. War is undoubtedly a means of diverting contradictions, diverting attention, internal and external disasters.
-
It is unlikely to succeed, or it is too risky.
First, the strength of Shu is limited, and the ability is limited, it is divided into three ways to attack, Zhuge Liang can only lead one way, and the other two roads no matter how good your strategy is, someone must implement it, Wei Yan may be capable, but Wei Yan is too risky, and his prestige is not enough, so he may not be able to make his generals obey unconditionally, especially in case the war is unfavorable. As for the third way, it is even more difficult to find a general who is in command alone.
Second, the risk is too great, Shu is too weak, the three-way division of troops, the environment at that time lacks overall cooperation and command, as long as the failure or failure of the road may affect the overall situation, Shu can not afford to lose, and the three-way for the logistics grain and grass supply these put forward higher requirements, Shu is difficult to bear.
The attitude of the third state of Wu, in a word, if the three roads are really smooth, the state of Wu will not sit back and watch the state of Shu hit hard or even destroy the state of Wei, the reason is very simple, the goal of the state of Shu is to recover the Han family, and the state of Wu is also among the recovered, if Wei is destroyed, it will be the turn of Wu, and only if the state of Wu cannot be held can it take profit. Therefore, even if the three roads ahead are smooth, the national strength of Shu is already empty, and once Wei is in danger, Wu will not sit idly by.
Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Romance of the Three Kingdoms, any action depends on a third party, not just a matter of two parties.
-
It can only be said that if it is in a short period of time, Shu will occupy a certain advantage...
But, one, when did Shu have no generals who could stand alone!
Second, the internal instability of Shu State, Zhuge Liang is in charge of Shu State, although he is doing his best, but for those who have a heart, Zhuge Liang may want to establish himself as a king! And then blow the wind in Liu Chan's ears!
Third, to be honest, entering the Wei region, it is bound to be unable to supply well, once the back road is cut, the game is over!
Fourth, Sima Zhixin, if Zhuge Liang launches such an attack, there are only two situations... First, Sima took advantage of the situation to stand on his own, and second, Sima was forced to fight against Lao Zhuge with Cao (so that Sima's military power is likely to be taken back somewhat, Cao Zhen is not a fool) However, Sima chooses the first type, and he is bound to be difficult to last!
Fifth, if such a large-scale troop transfer is detected by the enemy, then it will be a failure for the sake of the mountain.
-
Hello: Cao Wei in history is far stronger than Shu, and Shu can't beat Cao Wei no matter how he fights.
-
I don't understand your strategy, but I know that Zhuge Liang lost because his immediate boss made a wrong decision.
-
Cao Wei didn't eat dry rice.
-
LS is right, Sima Yi is not so stupid, he will definitely be under heavy troops in all the places of Wei, unless he is not "invited" back by the emperor of Wei.
-
Could it be that you think you are better than Zhuge Liang?
-
No matter what you do, you won't succeed. There is too much difference in overall national strength.
1.The gap in population and high-end talent is too great, and this problem cannot be solved in one generation.
2.At that time, northern China was the absolute economic core, and the cultivated land area exploded in the south, and many places in the south were undeveloped and wild, and Dujiangyan was too little in southern China at that time. And Cao Wei occupied the north at that time, and the total land area was about the sum of Shu Han + Sun Wu multiplied by 2.
Among the above, 1 and 2 formed an irreconcilable contradiction in the time span, so no matter what Zhuge Liang did, it was impossible for the Northern Expedition to succeed, and the advantage of drag-Cao Wei was getting bigger and bigger, and the rapid battle-population and talent were not Cao Wei's opponents for the time being. If you want to write**, then unless you add some gold fingers to Zhuge Liang.
1 Zhuge Liang's character Kong Ming, a native of Yangdu, Langya County, Shu Han of the Three Kingdoms (now Yishui County, Shandong Province). When he was a teenager, his parents died, and he followed his uncle to avoid chaos in Jingzhou, and lived in seclusion in Longzhong, Nanyang, known as Wolong. Married the daughter of Huang Chengyan. >>>More
Zhuge Liang is a very wise figure in the Three Kingdoms period, since the Jin Dynasty, there are a lot of fans, and he has died after doing his best all his life; In the poet Du Fu's "Shu Xiang", it is said that the hero dies before leaving the school, which makes the hero full of tears. " >>>More
I hope it will help you The tomb of Marquis Wu, that is, the tomb of Zhuge Liang, is at the foot of Dingjun Mountain in Mian County. Zhuge Liang (181 A.D. - 234 A.D.), the word Kongming, Langya Yangdu (now Yinan, Shandong) people, at the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty, lived in seclusion in Longzhong, Deng County (now Xiangyang, Hubei), paid attention to the world, and was called "Wolong". In the twelfth year of Jian'an (207 AD), Liu Bei visited the thatched house three times and asked him to help. >>>More
Many people are interested in Zhuge Liang.
It shouldn't be too unfamiliar, Zhuge Liang's achievements in history are very high, and many people know that Zhuge Liang is also a particularly talented person. For Zhuge Liang, in fact, the biggest achievement is to help Liu Bei. >>>More
There are many reasons for the failure of this Northern Expedition, on the one hand, there is a shortage of food and grass, and on the other hand, there are not enough talents under his command to make this Northern Expedition successful.