After looking at the experts Three Kingdoms rankings, Yan Liang was in front of Guan Yu

If Guan Yu and Yan Liang are allowed to fight fairly, the strength of the two should be almost the same, the reason why Guan Yu was able to kill Yan Liang was because he occupied the component of the sneak attack, and he was still riding a red rabbit horse under his feet, even if he had the upper hand, the other party could retreat with his whole body, and it would not be easier than Guan Yu's battle against Huang Zhong. Of course, Guan Yu also has a trick, that is, the knife dragging strategy, in view of Yan Liang's careless character, it is very likely to be implemented, so the overall lack of burning Qi is slightly greater than that of Kuling Guan Yu, and he can even kill the other party, but it will take a lot of effort.

First, under Yuan Shao's account, the rankings of Yan Liang and Wen Chou are in order, that is to say, Yan Liang's strength is above Wen Chou, and Wen Chou once had a confrontation with Zhao Yun, at that time Zhao Yun was still under the account of Gongsun Zhan, and it was already very good for the fledgling to be able to tie with Wen Chou, Duan Wei This is not that Zhao Yun's strength is not high but his experience is lacking, and when he met Guan Yu in the later stage, Guan Yu also admired his martial arts very much. This situation is just like when the Tiger Prison Pass Sanying fought against Lu Bu, Lu Bu's combat effectiveness must be the highest, but he may not be able to defeat Liu Guanzhang and the three of them, relying on the speed of the red rabbit horse to fight with the three of them before they fought a draw, at that time Lu Bu was already a famous general in the world, with extremely rich experience, so combat experience also occupies one factor.

Second, Zhang Liao and Wen Chou had a battle, and the two fought inseparably, and later the other party released a cold arrow, and Zhang Liao was not an opponent. And Zhang Liao is also a person that Guan Yu admires very much, when he was in Xuzhou, Zhang Liao was a general under Lu Bu, and he had contact with Guan Yu, and he could be looked down upon by Guan Yu, which means that his martial arts are also extraordinary, which also indirectly shows that Wen Chou's martial arts are between Guan Yu and Zhang Liao, and Yan Liang's martial arts value is about equal to Guan Yu.

Third, Guan Yu at his peak relied on the red rabbit horse, and was able to exert his strength and speed to the extreme, plus he repaid Cao Cao and did his best, so when he fought with Yan Liang, Guan Yu was still able to win, but it would take considerable strength, of course, because of the weakness of the opponent's character, if Guan Yu pretended to be defeated, Yan Chat was likely to chase and fall into Guan Yu's drag knife plan.

I think Guan Yu's strength is stronger, because Guan Yu's strength is relatively large, and he also has the title of God of War, except for the last battle to disturb Hong, he has not lost the battle against Li Xi.

Guan Yu's strength is stronger. Guan Yu is a brave and resourceful cherry tenant, his ability is very strong, his martial arts are very strong, and he has had the exploits of killing Yan Liang on a white horse before.

Guan Yu's strength is stronger and more balanced. This is because Guan Yu's martial arts are very strong, he has had a duel with Yan Liang before, and there is a very famous story of the white horse beheading Yan Liang.

In "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", Yan Liang died in an accident. Guan Yu is a famous general, and his martial arts are very superb, he will be very brilliant at his peak.

The truth of killing Yan Liang is that he saw Yan Liang's banner and station from a distance, so he rode in, but at that time, no one in Yuan Shao's army could arrive; Guan Yu was very powerful when he was at his peak, and the impact on others was also very serious, and the shadow brought by his force value at that time also made many people avoid it.

Guan Yu at his peak was particularly powerful, basically one person could fight ten.

Then you have to see whether it is the official history of the Three Kingdoms or the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. If the two of them really go head-to-head, Guan Yu is slightly better; On the march and fighting, of course, it was Yan Liangsheng, how to say that Yan Liang was also a famous general in Hebei at that time, and he shocked Hebei.

Guan Yu Baimapo beheaded Yan Liang, and the ugly women and children by the Yellow River are all known. Because of this, whether in the literature of later generations; Or in everyone's after-dinner discussions, the two generals are ranked outside the first-class. After all, a person who is killed by a knife cannot be considered first-class.

However, Yan Liang singled out Zhang Liao and Xu Huang, and Wen Chou singled out Zhao Zilong.

Before Guan Yu and Yan Liang fought, the last person to fight with Yan Liang was Xu Huang Xiaoxiao, Xu Huang was a fierce general, and everyone knew it. According to the Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms, Xu Huang lost to Yan Liang in 17 rounds; Erection of the beam and Romance of the Three Kingdoms said that Xu Huang lost in 20 rounds. Although there are slight differences between the two books, at least they illustrate the problem, that is, Yan Liang can defeat Xu Huang within 20 rounds.

Guan Yu is not the first general of the Three Kingdoms, the first general in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms will be Lu Bu, the battle of the Tiger Prison Pass Lu Bu fought Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Liu Bei, 4 people fought for a long time, and finally because of lack of strength to retreat, Cao Cao faced Lu Bu to send six fierce generals to fight with Lu Bu, which shows Lu Bu's strength, and Guan Yu is also very brave, and the most outstanding record is to quickly defeat Yan Liang and Wen Chou.

Guan Yu is definitely at the top in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, but it is a little difficult to rank first, Guan Yu's best record is to defeat Yan Liang in a few rounds, and kill Wen Chou in a few rounds. Yan Liang is definitely a first-class general, his strength is not weaker than Guan Yu, Yan Liang can defeat Xu Huang in 20 rounds, and Xu Huang can fight with Xu Chu for 50 rounds, Yan Liang lost to Guan Yu because he underestimated the enemy, and Guan Yu's red rabbit horse is in the prime of life. Wen Chou is also a first-class general, he can be as famous as Yan Liang, and his strength must be almost the same, Wen Chou once fought with Zhao Yun for more than 60 rounds, and was defeated by Guan Yu because he was afraid, after all, Guan Yu had just defeated Yan Liang, whose strength might be a little stronger than him, and Guan Yu's horse was fast.

With these records alone, Guan Yu has no way to win the first place, after all, Guan Yu has not defeated Pang De.

Zhang Fei's strength is also very strong, definitely not weaker than Guan Yu, there is also a good reference between the two, that is, Yuan Shu's general Ji Ling, Guan Yu once fought with Ji Ling, the two fought for 30 rounds, and there was no winner or loser, and Zhang Fei only stabbed Ji Ling to death in just over 10 rounds, although Zhang Fei did not have a record of defeating first-class generals, but Zhang Fei's strength can also be seen from his repeated battles with Lu Bu.

Lu Bu is undoubtedly the first general of the Three Kingdoms, fighting Guan Yu and Zhang Fei alone, Cao Cao is very clear about the ability of his generals, and in the face of Lu Bu's suspicion, he has to send out 6 at a time, and no one among Cao Cao's generals wants to fight Lu Bu alone, these people all recognize Lu Bu's strength, and there are not many rounds of the battle between Xu Chu and Lu Bu, and the rest of them come up to help, most of them are Xu Chu can not resist.

Guan Yu can be regarded as the Three Kingdoms, the first fighting general, and he can kill the leader in seconds among the ten thousand armies, which is particularly powerful.

I think so. Although Guan Yu was not very famous at that time, he successfully fought a bloody way for himself with this incident.

I don't think so, I personally think that Lu Bu is the first god of war, and the title of Red Rabbit among Lu Bu and Ma is not for nothing.

Yan Liang should be more powerful than Guan Yu, before his death, Lu Bu of Baimenlou ordered Zhang Liao to lead troops to surround Xiaopei, Zhang Liao was scolded away by Zhang Fei, Guan Yu said to Zhang Fei: This person's martial arts are not below you and me. But after Zhang Liao surrendered to Cao, the white horse was defeated by Yan Liangwen in the first battle, recalling what Guan Yu said to Zhang Fei, it is very clear that Guan Yu's force is not as good as Yan Liang, no matter which version of the romance, it is emphasized that Guan Yu's horse is quick and urgent, and the opponent is caught off guard and killed!

Especially Yan Liang, when he stepped forward to question, he was stabbed under the horse by Guan Yu's knife, why do you use stabbing characters here? The knives are all chopped over, decapitated, beheaded, split, the author uses the word stab, the intention is obviously hinted at taking advantage of the unpreparedness of the sneak attack, Xu Huang and Zhang Liao are not opponents, do not sneak attack, he walked thousands of miles and rode alone, and was finally blocked on the road by Xiahou Dun and fought without winning or losing, how could he kill Yan Liang, who was not even an opponent of Xu Huang and Zhang Liao and other famous generals? Watching the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is not just looking at Mao Ben (Mao Zonggang, early Qing Dynasty, Mao Ben) combined with Jiajing Ben (Ming, Luo Ben) to read together, we now see that the current Romance of the Three Kingdoms has been greatly modified by Mao's father and son, the ornamentality has been improved, and the modification is relatively large, among which Guan Yu beheaded Yan Liang Jiajing Ben Yuquan Mountain Manifestation, Pujing Zen Master Dialogue It is not difficult for us to see that the author said through the Zen master Yan Liang was killed process:

Let's say that Guan Gong's soul is not gone, wandering leisurely, flying on the clouds. Suddenly, there is a mountain in Dangyang County, Jingmen Prefecture, named Yuquan Mountain. A monk on the mountain, whose legal name is Pujing, was originally an elder of the National Temple in Bishui Guanzhen.

When you travel the world, you come to this mountain, see the mountains and rivers are beautiful, and the grass is a nunnery, and you sit in meditation every day. There is only a small walker, who often goes down the mountain to eat and spends his days. When the night moon is white and the wind is clear, it is the time of the third watch, the pure Zen master is sitting in the nunnery, and suddenly he hears someone shouting in the air

Where is the master? ”

The Zen master ordered the walker to look at it, and saw a person in the air, riding a red rabbit horse, carrying a green dragon knife, and following the two generals left and right, and the mouth was like a preface. The practitioner returns to the Zen master, and the Zen master knows that it is Guan Gong, Guan Ping, and Zhou Cang. When the cloud head flew to the front of the nunnery, the Zen master hit his seat with the tail in his hand and said:

Where is Yan Liang'an? ”

When Guan Gong heard this, the heroic soul had an epiphany, that is, he fell off the horse and stood in front of the nunnery with his crossed hands and said, "Who is my teacher?" May I ask for a clear number. ”

The Zen master said: "In the past in the Zhenguo Temple in front of the Bishui Pass, I met with the prince, why don't you know Pujing today?" ”

Gong said: "Although a certain person is foolish, he is willing to listen to the teachings." ”

The Zen master said: "The past is not the present, everything is not discussed, only in the words of the public: to the sun and the white horse pass, Yan Liang does not wait to fight with the public, and suddenly stabs him, this person is under the nine springs, and he is safe and does not hate?" Today, Lu Meng harms the public with tricks, and he is more safe? Why should the public be confused? ”

borrowed the mouth of the Zen master to say that Yan Liang's death, only looking at Mao Ben and not looking at Jiajing Ben is at best half a bottle wrong.

[Jian'an 5th year] 200 AD.

Yan Liang and Guo Tu and Chun Yuqiong attacked Dongjun Taishou Liu Yanyu in Baima, Yuan Shao was his own backup, Cao Cao rescued in the north, crossed the river with Xun You's troops, led Yuan Shao to the west, and led his light troops to cover the white horse, so that Zhang Liao and Guan Yu ascended first, and Yan Liangcang suddenly fought against him, and was beheaded by Guan Yu.

This is where the state comes in. Guan 2 is obviously in better condition than Yan.

In fact, I think Yan Liang is very aggrieved, he should be the first person under Lu Bu, because judging from the description of Kanto Huaxiong, Yuan Shao is very unconfident that Yan Liang is playing with Lu Bu, and he said that Yan Liang is not as good as Lu Bu.

Put Yan Liang's force a little lower, then his defeat to Lu Bu in 20 rounds is obviously a super long play and extraordinary consumption, and he is bored when he plays with Guan Yu.

And Yan Liang is in the army, there are soldiers on all sides, when Guan Yu came, the soldiers were cracked, Yan Liang wanted to ask, Guan Yu was a red rabbit and a horse, and he had already stabbed it...

There is also a game called Race to the Deer, which is equivalent to the map of Warcraft. In the later stage, Yan Liang was invincible 、、、 alone

It must be Yan Liang is powerful, if Guan Yu doesn't sneak attack, he will lose at most 25 combinations, Guan Yu is only a little stronger than Xu Huang, under normal circumstances, Guan Yu vs. Xu Huang 100 combinations is a tie, and Xu Huang defeated Guan Yu in the later stage without 80 combinations. You can't suspect that Yan Liang's strength is inferior to Guan Yu just because Guan Yu attacked and killed Yan Liang, which Ma Zhong captured and killed Guan Yu, does it mean that Guan Yu's strength is far inferior to Ma Zhong.

Guan Yu rode into the enemy camp alone to kill Yan Liang, some people say that it was because the horse was fast, could it be that the time from Guan Yu slapping the horse to killing the enemy was not enough for Yan Liang to react? Yan Liang didn't have a problem with his head, besides, were the guards around Yan Liang wooden? Think about it again, Guan Yu is one person and one ride, and how many people are there on Yan Liang's side, what else can you say?

As for Guan Yu's military talent, that's not to say. Guan Yu attacked Fancheng and defeated Cao Ren. The frightened Cao Cao discussed moving the capital to avoid its edge.

Later, Cao Cao sent Yu Ban, Pang De went, but Guan Yu surrendered, Pang De was beheaded, Cao Cao intimidated, and sent Wu Ziliang to Xu Huang, and then he felt uneasy, so he sent Zhang Liao, who had beaten Dongwu and was shocked, and then felt uneasy. Cao Cao has fought countless battles in his life, and this time he raised the whole country's army to resist Guan Yu, let me ask, what does this mean?

As for Guan Yu's loyalty, I think, if you are still a Chinese, you should know, I don't know if it?

According to the analysis of talented people.

Yan Liang had been confessed by Liu Bei earlier, saying that his second brother had been separated from him and wanted to help him find it.

As a result, Yan Liang thought... Then Guan Yu killed him. Then everyone was shocked, and before they came back to their senses, Guan Yu ran away.

。。。This has nothing to do with equipment, maybe it's a character problem.

Yan Liang is the first general in Hebei. In the battle of Guandu in the fifth year of Jian'an, in order to break through Cao Cao's defense line, Yuan Shao sent Yan Liang to lead an army to besiege Baima. Liu Yan, who was stationed in Baima, hurriedly reported to Cao Cao that once the White Horse was breached, Yuan Shao's army would cut Cao Cao's defense line, which was extremely unfavorable to Cao's army, so Cao Cao hurriedly led the army to help, and Zhang Liao and Guan Yu were the vanguard.

Zhang Liao and Guan Yu came to the front line and confronted Yan Liangjun. Then came one of the most famous killings in history. Generally speaking, in ancient times, when the two armies faced each other, there was no one-on-one confrontation between military generals.

In the official history, there are few such records. But Guan Yu broke this case, after he saw Yan Liang's cover, he calculated the situation of both the enemy and us, and suddenly rushed towards Yan Liang, the result was also very unexpected, he not only successfully stabbed Yan Liang to death, but also cut Yan Liang's head back. Guan Yu's killing this time is not only famous in the Three Kingdoms, but also very famous in history.

So some people have questions, in the Three Kingdoms, in terms of force alone, not to mention higher than Guan Yu, but there should be a lot of fierce generals who are comparable to Guan Yu's strength. Other countries don't talk about it, just Shu Kingdom, there should be at least three:

First, Zhang Fei, Zhou Yu and Guo Jia have said that Guan Yu and Zhang Fei are the generals of the bear and tiger and the enemy of 10,000 people, so it means that Zhang Fei's force is also very brave, and to a certain extent, Zhang Fei is more fierce than Guan Yu. Especially when he was in Changbanpo, Liu Bei fled for his life in a hurry, Zhang Fei only led dozens of horses, and when Cao Jun chased after him, Zhang Fei stood at the head of the bridge single-handedly to block Cao Jun. Zhang Fei shouted, "Who dares to fight to the death with me", Cao Jun had several generals at that time, but none of them went out to fight alone, which shows Zhang Fei's fierceness and his deterrent.

So if in Baima, Guan Yu is replaced by Zhang Fei, if Zhang Fei rushes into battle to kill Yan Liang, can he succeed as smoothly as Guan Erye?

The second is Zhao Yun, Zhao touches Qinyun's fierceness, which is also recognized, the first to recognize Zhao Yun's fierceness is Liu Bei, Zhao Yun Changbanpo bravely rescued Liu Chan, and met Cao Jun in Hanzhong, and was praised by Liu Bei for his courage. The second to admit Zhao Yun's fierceness was Zhuge Liang. So according to Zhao Yun's might, if in Baima, if Guan Yu replaces Zhao Yun to rush to kill Yan Liang, can he succeed as smoothly as Guan Yu?

The third is Ma Chao, Ma Chao is the first fierce general in Xiliang, and he drew with Zhang Fei, so it shows his fierceness. Later, Guan Yu challenged Ma Chao, but was stopped by Zhuge Liang with a tactful letter. But Ma Chao's force is also recognized, so in Baima, Guan Yu is replaced by Ma Chao, can Ma Chao kill Yan Liang in the army like Guan Yu?

Judging from force alone, whether it is in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" or in the records of "Three Kingdoms", Zhang Fei, Zhao Yun, and Ma Chao are no less brave than Guan Yu, so can these three people achieve Guan Erye's achievements? This is not only a test of a person's bravery, but also a test of a person's courage and wisdom. Therefore, it is not an easy task to kill Yan Liang, and it is not necessarily possible to kill Yan Liang by force alone.

What do you think of Zhang Fei, Zhao Yun, and Ma Chao whether they can achieve Guan Yu's record of killing Yan Liang?