Did Wei Yan betray Shu Han in history?

Wei Yan in history did not betray Shu Han, his purpose should still be to disobey Yang Yi, but he was too impulsive, and as a result, he gave his own life.

Before his death, Zhuge Liang ordered Yang Yi to preside over the retreat of the Shu army, and Wei Yan broke off. However, Wei Yan and Yang Yi did not have a good relationship, and he claimed to be the first person in the army, so he refused to obey orders after Zhuge Liang's death, and tried to seize military power. In the end, Wei Yan was defeated and killed, but although Wei Yan disobeyed his orders and led his troops to attack friendly troops, it was really not because he planned to rebel, but because his personality was too impatient.

Wei Yan is brave and brave, and now some people on the Internet think that he proposed the "Meridian Valley Scheme" and think that he is both wise and brave, which is not correct. Meridian Valley is only found in "Wei Luo", and the record of "Three Kingdoms" is:

Yan every time he goes out, he wants to invite 10,000 soldiers, and he will meet in Tongguan with Liang Yidao, such as Han Xin's story, and Liang is not allowed.

From here, we can see that every time Wei Yan goes on an expedition, he asks himself to do it alone, so he just wants to master more military power, which is not so much that he is wise and brave, but that he does not understand human feelings and sophistication, and every time he goes against the leader, it is also a loss that Zhuge Liang does not care about him. <>

But this is secondary, the key Wei Yan has always been very impatient, when discussing military affairs together, once there is a dispute with Yang Yi, he will often directly pull out a knife and threaten to kill the other party, "Every time I sit and argue, Yan or raise the blade to imitate the instrument." At a meeting to discuss military affairs, he directly drew a knife in front of the leader to kill someone, even if he didn't really do it, he could imagine what kind of character Wei Yan was. <>

Such a person, you say, will be thoughtful, weigh the pros and cons, and then launch a rebellion ......That's really thinking too much, Wei Yan is purely muscle movements faster than his brain, and after the failure to seize military power, he habitually went berserk, but this time there was no Zhuge Liang to restrain him, so he made a big fuss, and eventually led to his own death. <>

Wei Yan did not betray Shu Han, it was just a crime fabricated by the author Luo Guanzhong out of thin air for the development of the plot.

No, Wei Yan did not betray Chu Han, relatively speaking, Wei Yan was just more active in the Northern Expedition. I think Wei Yan is just making meritorious contributions.

No. Wei Yan had conflicts with others at that time, he was unwilling to go back, and wanted to continue the Northern Expedition, but was framed to death.

No, he just lost in the struggle for power with Yang Yi, so he would kneel Yang Yi in front of his tomb after his death.

In fact, Wei Yan's main contradiction is because Zhuge Liang gave military power to Yang Yi, strictly speaking, this is a contradiction between him and Yang Yi. Wei Yan is also a very arrogant person, in the Shu Han Group, not many people can enter his eyes, and he is usually high, so many generals in the Shu Han Group also let Wei Yan. But Yang Yi didn't take Wei Yan seriously, these two people didn't obey anyone, when Wei Yan knew that Zhuge Liang handed over the military power to Yang Yi, his heart was also very angry, at this time he was naturally unwilling, so he forced Yang Yi to hand over the military power, but at this time he didn't think about rebellion at all, so naturally he would not take refuge in Cao Wei.

Wei Yan had already become the general of the expedition to the west during the Northern Expedition of Zhuge Liang of the Shu Han Dynasty, and he was the Taishou of Hanzhong. In the entire Shuhan Group, except for Zhuge Liang, he should already be a veritable second-in-command. If a person like Wei Yan rejoins Cao Wei Group, it will be difficult for him to obtain so many rights and interests, and he naturally knows this in his heart, so it is impossible for Wei Yan to take the initiative to join Cao Wei at all.

Wei Yan also made a lot of contributions to the Shu Han group, in the battle of Changsha, Wei Yan killed the Taishou Han Xuan, and later saved Huang Zhong, and also sacrificed the city. Later, when Liu Bei entered Sichuan, Wei Yan made great achievements, and after that, he became the Taishou of Hanzhong, so if emotionally speaking, Wei Yan would not rebel. <>

During the battle of Hanzhong, Cao Cao once persuaded Wei Yan to surrender with Mingfeng, but at that time, Wei Yan not only scolded Cao Cao, but also directly pulled a bow and shot an arrow at Cao Cao's two front teeth when Cao Cao's two armies were fighting. So if you want to surrender with such a resume, there is a high probability that it will not be reused.

And there was no rebellion. Judging from the treatment Wei Yan received, he had no reason to rebel. At that time, the trust he gained in Shu Han and the status he gained were incomparable to very few people.

If Wei Yan was resented by many readers, it was because Wei Yan accidentally knocked down the seven-star lamp that Zhuge Liang used to continue his life because of his report on the military situation before Zhuge Liang's death. After all, many readers belong to Zhuge Liang's loyal fans, and they can't bear all kinds of practices that hurt Zhuge Liang.

No, Wei Yan has no backbone in the back of his head at all, that's just Lao Luo's description. There is no record of it in the official history. Then why was Wei Yan looked down on by Zhuge Liang?

Just because he first did Liu Biao and Liu Brown, then Han Xuan, and then Xuande. Of course, Zhuge Liang disagreed, he was worried that he didn't know which day he would be killed by Wei Yan. Determined to behead the public.

Fortunately, he was rescued by Liu Bei, and later helped Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang to kill Zhou Yu, capture Xichuan, shoot Cao Cao in Hanzhong, capture Meng Shu seven times, and sacrifice the Meridian Valley and kill Wang Shuang. Wei Yan's contributions are not something that Zhuge Liang can erase if he wants to. His status in Shu is second only to that of the Five Tigers, but Zhuge Liang is still not worried about Wei Yan, otherwise how could Zhuge Liang not adopt the strategy of entering the Meridian Valley.

Later, after Zhuge Liang's death, Yang Yi escorted Zhuge Liang's coffin back to Chengdu. Wei Yan disagreed and was ready to lead the army to capture the Central Plains with Jiang Wei, but Yang Yi brought the whole army back to Shuzhong, which annoyed Wei Yan and forced him to burn the plank road. However, Yang Yi was later arrogant and said something that Liu Chan was dissatisfied with, and was reported by Fei Yi, but Yang Yi was ashamed and committed suicide.

Wei Yan is not rebelling, but relying on the wrong person, if he votes for Wei, he will definitely be reused with his martial arts and strategy.