Han Xin can get out of Sichuan, but Zhuge Liang can t get out of Sichuan, what is the reason?

Han Xin was able to go out of Sichuan, it was because he did a good job of secrecy and did not attract Xiang Yu's attention, but Zhuge Liang's exit from the mountain was blatant and spread all over the world, so how could it be successful.

Because the strength behind them is different, Han Xin's ability to go out of Sichuan is not only Sichuan and Shu as the strength of the **.

At that time, Han Xin went out of Sichuan, so he planned in advance, burned the plank road, and pretended that Liu Bang did not want to return to the Central Plains. However, Zhuge Liang's Longzhong policy is a long-term plan, and maybe this policy has been spread all over again.

Wei Chigong Xuanwumen has made great contributions, and Qin Shubao is Li Shimin's benefactor, so Li Shimin can only fight sloppily on both sides. The two were loyal to Li Shimin, during Li Shimin's serious illness, the two stood day and night outside the door to guard, Li Shimin couldn't bear the two of them so hard, and asked the painter to put the portrait of the two outside the door to replace the two Wei Chi Jingde in the "Xuanwumen" incident to make immortal contributions, save Li Shimin and lay Li Shimin's throne. After several comparisons, the two are almost comparable, but in the "Xuanwumen Change", Qin Qiongshi couldn't bear to kill each other, but Wei Chigong was loyal to Li Shimin, protected Li Shimin and shot Li Yuanji with his own hands.

<> was thus awarded the title of Shangzhu State. This shows that Qin Qiong's status was obtained because Qin Qiong caught Wei Chigong. Since he was able to capture Wei Chi Gong alive, then the two must have fought each other, and Qin Qiong was definitely the winning side.

Let's talk about Guan Yu first, right? Under the Tiger Prison Pass, Wenjiu beheaded Huaxiong, passed five passes and beheaded six generals, met with Zhang Fei and beheaded Cai Yang, solved the siege of the White Horse and beheaded Yan Liang and Wen Chou, the Battle of Xiangyang flooded the Seventh Army, beheaded Pang De and captured the ban, and shocked Huaxia, which achieved Guan Yu's lifelong fame. Those who died under Guan Yu on the battlefield should be Hua Xiong, Yan Liang, and Wen Chou.

But where did the term "Five Tiger Admirals" come from? Tracing back to the roots, we have to go back to the Three Kingdoms period, Liu Bei's five generals, including the sworn brothers Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Zhao Yun, and Ma Chao and Huang Zhong who later surrendered. The five of them bravely crowned the three armies and were invincible on the battlefield, so they were called the "Five Tiger Generals".

However! Among the many generals killed by the Five Tiger Generals, the relatively powerful ones should be Yan Liang, Wen Chou, Gao Lan, Hua Xiong, and Xiahou Yuan. Others, such as Li Tong, Han De, Zhang Hu, Xing Daorong or something, are more than one grade worse in comparison.

The winning general Zhao Zilong killed the most powerful general, is Gao Ran under Yuan Shao, Gao Ran was also a famous general in Hebei at that time, and Cao Cao's general Xu Chu battled, but did not fall behind, it can be seen that its power is abnormal, when Gao Ran wanted to capture Liu Bei, but was picked by Zhao Yun under the horse with a shot, not even a round of support, it seems that the general under Yuan Shao is really "fierce and abnormal".

Because Han Xin's ability to lead troops to fight is very strong, and there are many generals with particularly superb martial arts under his hands, but there are very few soldiers under Zhuge Liang.

Because Zhuge Liang has a lot of burdens, he needs to stick to the country, and many national affairs are handled by him.

The reality of the two main people is very different. Han Xin's opponent is Zhang Han, he is just a very ordinary one among the princes, Xiang Yu can't get out of the war of Qi, Han Xin only needs to deal with Zhang Han wholeheartedly. Zhang Han had never heard of Han Xin before, so he looked down on Han Xin very much, and Zhang Han committed a taboo in the soldiers.

Han Xin grasped Zhang Han's weakness and used the strategy of Ming Xiu plank road to darken Chen Cang, Han Xin took the other party by surprise, Zhang Han was quickly defeated, and Liu Bang also opened up the main road out of Xichuan, and he could smoothly send troops from Xichuan.

Zhuge Liang's situation was much more severe than Han Xin's. The national strength of Shu was originally inferior to Wei, Zhuge Liang attacked Wei just with the idea of trying, he knew that it was very difficult for him to defeat Wei, even if he couldn't defeat Wei, he couldn't let Wei develop well. The military strength of Wei was stronger than that of Zhang Han, and Zhuge Liang faced an opponent who was stronger than himself, so Liuchu Qishan did not defeat Wei.

There is also the fact that Han Xin is a military strategist in the true sense. He knows how to make use of the enemy's psychology, how to arrange troops, can make correct judgments on the situation on the battlefield, and can seize fleeting fighters in the war, and finally win the war.

Zhuge Liang can't be said to be a military strategist in the strict sense. But a far-sighted strategist, Zhuge Liang had to make adequate preparations every time he attacked Wei, and after he was ready, Wei also had a lot of defense. It is very difficult for Zhuge Liang to defeat the Wei State, which is stronger than himself, and if the leader of this army is not Zhuge Liang, he may be destroyed by the Wei State in the process of attacking the Wei State.

The trend of the war and the fighters slipped away because of too many preparations, which made Wei's defense impeccable.

There is no comparison. Zhuge Liang is good at governance and is a talent in internal affairs. If you start from the historical data, putting aside the romance, Zhuge Liang's military talent is not very prominent.

Han Shin's military talent is not surpassed, and there are few top military talents in history. If Han Xin invades Wei, he will expand his territory, and his national strength can change from weak to strong. Grain transportation and talent shortage are easily solved.

With territory, food, and talents, it is proportional. Those who are capable can change from weak to strong, and they can all be changed. At that time, after all, there was no unification, Wei had border troubles, and there were political changes inside, even though Wei was strong, but there were not many troops that could be used to deal with Shu.

Any founding monarch can start from scratch, not to mention that there are people in Shu who have land. Although Zhuge Liang is not a gentleman, Liu Chan is also obedient.

In the early years of the Western Han Dynasty, the water of the Western Han Dynasty was connected to the Han River, and grain could be transported by water. In 186 B.C., Wudu Da**, the water of the Western Han Dynasty was changed to the Jialing River, and the grain transportation during the Three Kingdoms period relied on wheelbarrows. Crossing the Qinling Mountains to transport grain? It's too hard. The kingdom of Shu is exhausted.

Because their enemies are different, Han Xin's enemy is Xiang Yu, and Zhuge Liang's enemy is Wei State, and Liu Bang's army at that time was relatively strong, and there were also strategists, Han Xin only needed to lead the army, but Zhuge Liang could only coordinate the overall situation by himself.

It can be seen from Xiao He Yue's pursuit of Han Xin that Han Xin is also a rare talent, he can play Xichuan to prove that he is capable, and Zhuge Liang can't beat Hanzhong, maybe he doesn't want to leave this place in his heart.

During the Three Kingdoms, Cao Wei has been entrenched in the Central Plains for many years, and his efforts have won the hearts of the people. Those who have won the world since ancient times, relying on the hearts of the people, the original Cao Wei has not lost the hearts of the people, what does Zhuge Liang take to fight for the world with others, so Zhuge Liang's legendary life is destined to end in failure.

No, because the strength behind them is not the same, if Shu Han's strength is also as strong as Liu Bang's, Zhuge Liang will win.

No. Because the comprehensive strength of Shu after the Battle of Yiling is far inferior to the other two countries; Han Shin Izukawa did not encounter such stubborn resistance as the Wei state.

It's not that Zhuge Liang is inferior to Han Xin, but that Han Xin's enemies are not as strong as Zhuge Liang's enemies. Both of them are very powerful people, and they have no way to judge if they don't fight.

There is a gap between the two of them, the difference between themselves and their opponents, and their own strength and influence, so Zhuge Liang can't get out of Sichuan.

The historical environment differs, as well as the military talents of the opponents. Han Xin faced the three generals of the original Qin Dynasty, and he was mediocre. And Zhuge Liang faced famous generals of the Wei State, such as Sima Yi and others.

Han Xin is a military wizard, and Zhuge Liang is a top military advisor! The two people are not good at the same thing, just whether they can kill Hanzhong or not, this is something that a military strategist can do, and a politician can only strategize, but it is much worse to lead troops to fight. When Han Xin led Liu Bang out of Hanzhong, it coincided with the chaos in the world, and Xiang Yu at that time was the overlord of Western Chu, and he was the most influential person in the world.

Zhuge Liang is different, when Zhuge Liang came out of Hanzhong, the world was already divided into three parts, and the international environment at that time was also quite stable, and Wei was also very peaceful and stable.

First of all, Han Xin and Zhuge Liang are both top-notch people for a while, but they are different in terms of their strengths.

1.In the era of cold weapons, if the defending side has stronger comprehensive national strength + the emperor is wise + the general is cautious in using troops + implements the tactics of defending against danger from top to bottom, then the attacking side with smaller national strength basically has no chance.

2.Han Xin's Northern Expedition was indeed successful in hell difficulty, but after a ** terrain change, the difficulty of Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition became almost impossible.

3.Zhuge Liang's five Northern Expeditions, in fact, there is no problem with the strategy, but the talents in Shuzhong are withering, and the military and government are grasping it, which is really difficult for Zhuge Liang. In the first Northern Expedition, Ma Tan died.

The fourth time had already beaten Sima Yi, and when Cao Wei's morale was low, he happened to take the Yongliang region in one fell swoop, and Li Yan dragged his feet. The first line is like five times of preparation, and the result is not a holiday. It can be said that Ge Liang, who is only responsible for a certain aspect of the military and internal affairs stalls, and on the other hand, there is a person of middle and upper level, and the Northern Expedition can be successful.

4.One thing about the success of Han Shin's Northern Expedition is that the north is not a unit, but fights separately.

Speaking of the first military division in ancient China, I believe that Zhuge Liang is definitely the eternal C position in the hearts of most people, but Zhuge Liang is not invincible, for example, he once went out of the Northern Sichuan Expedition five times but all ended in failure, with hatred. But what you may not know is that there is a person in history who led the army to successfully go out of Sichuan, and then defeated Xiang Yu to help Liu Bang conquer the Han Dynasty, he is Han Xin.

In ancient times, Hanzhong became the best defensive position by virtue of its unique geographical advantages, but it was also because of the terrain limitations of the basin that it was difficult for the army itself to take the initiative to expand its territory, which Zhuge Liang had proved with practical actions, so how did Han Xin hit Sichuan and go to the whole country?

In fact, when it comes to the reason, it may be unexpected by many people, when Liu Bang was suppressed by Xiang Yu when he was merged, he had no choice but to garrison Hanzhong, and later at Zhang Liang's suggestion, he burned the only route out of Sichuan, and put on a look that he just wanted to be the king of Hanzhong. But in fact, all of what they did was to pave the way for Han Xin's surprise attack.

On the other hand, Zhuge Liang, at the beginning of Liu Bei's three visits to the thatched house, Zhuge Liang had already indicated his intention to use Shuzhong as a base and then expand to the north, but at that time, such a strategy can be said to be well known, and under the premise that the enemy was prepared in advance, it was naturally more difficult to achieve this goal.

But Han Xin is different, the reason why Han Xin was able to go to Guanzhong was because he was able to hide his location under the cover of the Ming Xiu plank road. So when Han Xin came to the city, Zhang Han still didn't believe the soldiers who reported it, and even thought that the soldiers were lying for a while. Zhuge Liang's approach is completely opposite, his entire attack seems to be even, which troops are in the front, which troops are responsible for grain and grass escort, and which troops are responsible for countermeasures, all of which are clearly distributed and clear at a glance.

It is by virtue of this hand"The plank road is repaired in the light, and the warehouse is in the dark"In the final analysis, Zhuge Liang was defeated in only seeking stability, while Han Xin believed in wealth and danger.

To sum up, it is precisely because the battle fought by Han Xin is too classic, so such a strategy has become impossible to replicate, and the military strength of Shu at that time was not strong, which led to the Wei State having long been prepared, in the situation that the enemy is strong and I am weak, the tactics of steady and steady fighting are obviously not wise, and in the end, Zhuge Liang can only sleep in Wuzhangyuan.

Therefore, it is impossible for any war to turn the situation around by one person, and more importantly, the time and place are favorable"The Han family is not prosperous"of reality.

To sum up, it is precisely because Han Xin's battle is too classic, so such a strategy has become impossible to replicate, coupled with the fact that the military strength of Shu was not strong at that time, which led to the Wei State having long been prepared, in the situation that the enemy is strong and I am weak, the tactics of steady fighting are obviously not stuffy and wise, and in the end, Zhuge Liang can only sleep in Wuzhangyuan.

Therefore, it is impossible for any war to turn the situation around by one person, and more importantly, the time and place are favorable"The Han family is not prosperous"The reality of the brother Huai.

Because when the latter was on the Northern Expedition, he made a perfect observation of this place, allowing him to know the shortcomings of this place.

Because the enemy that Zhuge Liang faced was much stronger than the enemy that Han Xin faced, it was not so easy to eliminate.