Was Zhou Yu still alive when Guan Yu let Cao Cao go in the Three Kingdoms?

Alive, this is the case in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Guan Yu Huarong Dao let Cao Cao go privately, Zhuge Liang is not angry with Zhou Yu, so he is still alive. Historically, Guan Yu did not go to Huarong to stop him, but Liu Bei, but it was too late to go, and Cao Cao had already left. Zhou Yu died of illness on the journey, and he was not angry.

Alive, Zhou Yu died only after Zhuge Liang 3 Qi Zhou Yu. The specific time analysis is as follows: Zhou Yu died in 210 AD, and Guan Yu let Cao Cao go in the Battle of Chibi (208 AD), on Huarong Road.

Yes, this is the case in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Guan Yu Huarong Dao privately released Cao Cao, and Zhuge Liang is not angry with Zhou Yu, so he is still alive. Historically, Guan Yu did not go to Huarong to stop him, but Liu Bei, but it was too late, and Cao Cao had already passed. Of course, Zhou Yu died of illness on the journey, and he was not angry.

In the battle of Chibi, the Sun-Liu Alliance, the burning chain was jointly set by Kong Ming and Zhou Yu, but the specific implementation was Zhou Yu, which included the bitter meat plan, the anti-intermittent plan, the fraud plan, the chain plan, after everything is in place, only the east wind is owed, Kong Ming, who knows the astronomical earth, calculated the time when the wind blew, so as to defeat Cao Cao's chain in one fell swoop, but also let Zhou Yu decide to get rid of Kong Ming, a strategist who is more clever than himself! Zhou Yu was killed by Kong Ming's three qi Zhou Yu, so Zhou Yu was still alive at this time!!

Not dead. When Guan Yu let Cao Cao go, it was when Cao Cao Chibi was defeated, and Zhou Yu was still alive and well.

Alive, whether it is the Romance of the Three Kingdoms or written in "The Romance of the Three Kingdoms", Zhou Yu did not die after entering Nanjun, and probably died in the fifteenth year of Jian'an. i.e. 210

Of course alive, this happened during the Battle of Red Cliffs. It is a section after Cao Cao's defeat in Chibi, and he walked after Huarong Road

Alive, because it was still the Battle of Chibi.

didn't die, Zhuge Liang's three qi Zhou Yu's last breath didn't happen at this time.

He's not dead, he's alive and well, and he'll die after a long time!!

Alive, you go and see the new Three Kingdoms.

At the time of the Battle of Chibi, Zhou Yu was 34 years old, and Cao Cao's defeat of Huarong Road was the end of the Battle of Chibi, and Zhou Yu was no more than 35 years old at this time.

At that time, the Battle of Chibi was coming to an end, and it was still early for Zhou Yu to die.

The Battle of Chibi is not Guan Yu's business at all.

1. The reason why Guan Yu let Cao Cao go was because he thanked Cao Cao for his promotion and reuse when Guan Yu was in Cao Ying. At that time, Cao Cao already knew that Guan Yu had made up his mind, but he also sent his staff member Zhang Liao to inquire about Guan Yu's intentions. Guan Yu told Zhang Liao that as long as he helped Cao Cao make great contributions, he would leave to join Liu Bei.

After Cao Cao found out, he still used a heavy reward to keep Guan Yu, but Guan Yu still returned to Liu Bei's tent after five levels and six generals. Someone once advised Cao Cao to kill Guan Yu, but Cao Cao thought that Guan Yu was his own master, so he did not kill him.

2. In addition, Guan Yu let Cao Cao go for another reason, that is, not to let Sun Quan dominate the world. At that time, Liu Bei's power was not strong enough, and if Cao Cao was killed, Sun Quan would become the real overlord.

3. When the time comes, Sun Quan will send an army to attack Liu Bei, and Liu Bei's forces are defeated by Sun Quan, so Liu Bei will definitely be defeated. In this way, Sun Quan can sit on the world. If Cao Cao is released in Huarong Dao, Liu Bei can first use Cao Cao's power to suppress Sun Quan's forces, which will be of great benefit to Liu Bei in the short term.

Therefore, Guan Yu let Cao Cao go, firstly, to repay Cao Cao's kindness, and secondly, to consolidate Liu Bei's power.

Guan Yu's life

Guan Yu fled his hometown in his early years due to crimes and went to Zhuo County, Youzhou. In the first year of Zhongping (184), the Yellow Turban Rebellion broke out, and Liu Bei organized a volunteer army in Zhuo County. Guan Yu and Zhang Fei all joined them, and traveled around with Liu Bei to participate in the war to extinguish the Yellow Turban Army.

In the first year of Xingping (194), Cao Cao was angry with Tao Qian because Cao Song was killed, so he sent troops to attack Xuzhou. Tao Qian begged Liu Bei for help, and Liu Bei and Guan Yu led more than 1,000 people to the rescue. Cao Cao's soldiers retreated, Tao Qian said that Liu Bei was the assassin of Yuzhou, and Guan Yu and Liu Bei were stationed in Xiaopei.

Then, under the repeated concessions of Tao Qian and others, Liu Bei led Xuzhou Mu.

In the third year of Jian'an (198), Liu Beijun captured the ** of Lü Bu's army, and Lü Bu sent Gao Shun to lead the army to attack Liu Bei. Cao Cao sent Xiahoudun to help Liu Bei, but was defeated by Gao Shun. In September of the same year, Gao Shun defeated Liu Bei.

So, Cao Cao personally led his troops east to conquer Lü Bu. Liu Bei and Cao Cao captured Lü Bu in Xiapi and captured Xuzhou. Liu Bei, Guan Yu, Zhang Fei and others followed Cao Cao's class back to Xuchang.

Guan yu. Letting Cao Cao go is not real history, it is pure fiction. "Zhuge Liang.

Wisdom and Huarong, Guan Yunchang's interpretation of Cao Cao" is "Romance of the Three Kingdoms".

The focus of the chapter is Zhixi, in fact, this paragraph is fictional, just to highlight Guan Yu's character.

After the Battle of Chibi, Cao Cao fled from Huarong Dao in a hurry. Zhuge Liang sent Guan Yu to ambush here. Cao Cao's people were sleepy and lacking horses, and they lost their troops and could not fight again. Guan Yunian thought that Brother Tan went to Cao Cao to treat him well, and ignored the military order to capture Cao Cao alive, and let him go.

In recent days, a "Why did Guan Yu let Cao Cao go during the Three Kingdoms period?" The question has become a hot topic, and I will give you my opinion. First of all, Guan Yu wanted to repay Cao Cao's kindness, which allowed Cao Cao to leave from his encirclement.

Secondly, Guan Yu also wanted to use Cao Cao's power to restrain Sun Quan, and he couldn't let Sun Quan's family dominate. Finally, Guan Yu's temperament is also a very righteous person, and it is expected to let him go. So what's going on?

Let me share my thoughts with you.

One. First of all, Guan Yu wanted to repay Cao Cao's kindness, which allowed Cao Cao to leave from his encirclement. Previously, Guan Yu was also caught by Cao Cao, but instead of killing Guan Yu, Cao Cao also treated Guan Yu well, and finally let Guan Yu return to Liu Bei because Guan Yu learned that Liu Bei was still fine.

Two. borrowed Cao Cao's power to suppress Sun Quan Secondly, Guan Yu also wanted to use Cao Cao's power to suppress Sun Quan, and he couldn't let Sun Quan's family dominate. If Cao Cao is killed, then Wu is stronger than Shu, then Sun Quan will fight against Shu alone, which will not do them any good.

Three. Guan Yu's temperament Finally, Guan Yu's temperament is also a very righteous person, and it is expected to let him go. It's not just Cao Cao who is playing the emotional card with him, but also his old friend Zhang Liao is also working for Cao Jun and also came to intercede.

Therefore, under such circumstances, Guan Yu, who was angry, sighed and let them go. <

The above is my opinion on this issue, which is purely personal and for reference only. If you have any different opinions, you can leave a message in the comment area and discuss it together. After reading it, remember to like and follow.

Guan Yu let Cao Cao go in order to save his sister-in-law, which was also a decision made in desperation at that time, and he could only do this in order to save his family.

Mainly because Guan Yu admires Cao Cao very much, and also thinks that Cao Cao is a particularly powerful character, and he should not lose his life again, so he will let him go.

Because he knew some things, and he felt that Cao Cao was also a very kind person, he let Cao Cao go at the most critical time.

It was because of his gratitude to Guan Yu for his promotion and reuse of him when he was under Cao Cao.

Original translation: In the fifth year of Jian'an, Cao Cao went on an eastward expedition, and Liu Bei defected to Yuan Shao. Cao Cao captured Guan Yu alive and returned, appointed Guan Yu as a partial general, and treated him very politely.

Yuan Shao sent the general Yan Liang to Bai Xiyu to attack Liu Yan, the Taishou of Dongjun, and Cao Cao made Zhang Liao and Guan Yu the vanguard to meet Yan Liang. Guan Yu saw Yan Liang's banner and car cover from afar, so he rode his horse into the thousands of troops and horses to assassinate Yan Liang, cut off Yan Liang's head and returned to the camp. Cao Cao immediately went to the table and asked the court to seal Guan Yu as the Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion.

At the beginning, Cao Cao admired Guan Yu's personality, and observed his mood and demeanor without the intention of staying for a long time, and said to Zhang Liao: "You try to ask him with your personal feelings." Soon Zhang Liao asked Guan Yu, and Guan Yu sighed and said:

I know very well that Cao Gong treats me with deep affection, but I am deeply gracious to General Liu, and I swear to live and die with him and not to turn my back on him. I will not be able to stay, and I will only leave after I repay Cao Gong with meritorious service. Zhang Liao reported Guan Yu's words to Cao Cao, who thought he was a righteous man.

After Guan Yu killed Yan Liang, Cao Cao knew that he would definitely leave, so he rewarded him heavily. Guan Yu sealed all the rewards given to him by Cao Cao, and left the town in a book with his eyes open, and went to Liu Bei in Yuan Shao's army. The people around Cao Cao wanted to chase Guan Yu, Cao Cao said:

Each man is for his own master, and there is no need to chase him. ”