Is it reasonable to pronounce a judgment in the case of 28 years of wrongful life and award more tha

I think it's unreasonable, I changed my life for 28 years, ** it can be ended with 760,000, this incident hurts two families, and separates the two families, what a sad thing.

The verdict in the case of 28 years of wrongful life was announced, and the final award was more than 760,000 yuan in compensation. There is a certain amount of plausibility. Because 28 years of life have been exchanged, of course, there is no way to measure it in money, but according to the current situation, it can only give so much compensation to the victim.

I don't think it's very reasonable, after all, there are several 28 years in life, and no amount of money can make up for these 28 years, and the changes in my family in 28 years have changed my life.

I don't think it's reasonable. After all, 28 years have removed one-third of their lives, and the wrong 28 years can not be made up for with 760,000 yuan, and they have caused great pain to the two families.

Plausible. Because I personally think that the probability of serious illness in this society is still quite large, even if there was no mistake at the beginning, then you are not going to be sick now, and it takes time to pay high compensation, and patients may not have time to wait for the next compensation result.

If it's financial compensation, it's already reasonable. But it is a pity that the life that was wrongly exchanged has not come back.

The award of 760,000 yuan is reasonable, and there is a law to refer to in terms of compensation for wrongful judgment and misjudgment, and 760,000 yuan is calculated according to the circumstances.

Irrationality. Because these 28 years are not something that can be made up with 760,000 yuan, they have caused a lot of pain to the two families.

I think it's a good loss of 760,000. Because some hospitals don't even have compensation, they will shirk their responsibilities. So it's good, although the money can't make up for the lost 28 years, but it can improve the current living conditions a little.

I don't think it's reasonable, after all, 28 years is already half of a person's life, and the best years are lost, and it can't be made up for no matter what.

Irrationality. Because of 28 years of youth, the best years to get along with my parents are far more than this price. And as soon as they recognize each other, they face cancer, and the mental pain cannot be measured.

I don't think it's a lot to lose 760,000 yuan, because it has a really big impact on one person, and it's not something that can be made up for with money.

What if it's unreasonable? 28 years of life have passed, and no one can go back to the past, so 760,000 is just a spiritual comfort.

It's not like there's no way to make up for these things.

The "Wrong Life Case" has been determined, and this case will be officially tried on September 18, 2022I believe that this case will soon be settled, this is also the only expectation of Yao Ce's mother, the case of "28 years of wrong life" has attracted everyone's attention since **, at first this case was just to find the responsible party, and later exposed the nature of many people, this matter has gone through many twists and turns and finally has to **, Yao Ce's adoptive mother believes that the hospital and biological parents have a certain responsibility, so there will be such a situation, anyway, this is a very painful blow to both families, Although Yao Ce has passed away, this case has not yet come to an end, and I hope that this matter can be brought to an end through this **.

I believe that many people have paid attention to the case of 28 years of wrong life, I have to say that this case is really incredible, how happy the family has become like this at the beginning, it is really embarrassing, and after Yao Ce's death, the adoptive mother and Yao Ce's wife have all kinds of mutual pinching and real estate disputes are very sad, Yao Ce himself is a victim of this matter, but now he doesn't know who to ask for an explanation, the "28 years of wrong life" incident has been a long time, and the final result has not been announcedIn May, during the trial, Xu Min had to be suspended because Xu Min changed the lawsuit in court and added Du Xinzhi as a defendant.

The "Wrong Life Case" has been determined

It has been a long time since the wrong life case, and everyone wants to know what the final result is, we can understand the mood of Yao Ce's adoptive parents, so I also hope that this matter can be concluded as soon as possible.

Yao Ce's biological mother wants to end this as soon as possible

Over the years, their family has suffered from all kinds of online violence, and every move of the two families has attracted everyone's attention, Yao Ce's biological mother hopes that this can be ended as soon as possible, so that everything can be calmed down and they can continue to live a normal life.

The latest development, the case has been clarified, and the victim has also been given a certain amount of compensation and losses, and the theft has also been requested.

The latest development is: It has been carried out in September 2021**, but the verdict has not yet been pronounced, and the verdict will be announced at a later date.

There is nothing unclear about this case at present, because the court has pronounced the final verdict and ruled that the plaintiff's lawsuit is not established, that is, Yao Ce's adoptive mother Xu Min's accusation against his biological mother Du Xinzhi for stealing the child is not established. Because after the investigation, it was found that what Yao Ce's adoptive mother said was basically true, so the plaintiff Xu Min's accusation was not established. Although the dust has settled on this matter, there are still many viewers who feel that it is not worth it for Xu Min's family.

Specifically, there are several reasons for this.

1. The property that Xu Min bought for his adopted son could not be returned in the end.

According to the history of the case, we can learn that Xu Min bought the property in Yao Ce's name after Yao Ce became an adult, and after the judgment of the case, Xu Min failed to get back the original property, and the suite ultimately belonged to Yao Ce's daughter-in-law. On the other hand, the house where Xu Min's own son Guo Ranzhi Xikuan lives was not purchased in Guo Xikuan's name, which made many netizens feel that Xu Min's efforts were not worth it.

Second, Xu Min's effort to raise his adopted son is more than Du Xinzhi.

Everyone knows that Yao Ce was found to have liver disease at the age of 2, Xu Min has paid a lot for Yao Ce over the years, and has taken him around to seek medical treatment since he was a child, not only spending a lot of money, but also carefully cultivating Yao Ce to go to a good university, arranging a good job for him, etc., I didn't expect to be empty of people and money in his later years, the only thing I am glad about is that I have a biological son. On the other hand, Xu Min's own son Guo Wei only studied secondary school and came out early to work to support his family, if the lives of the two children had not changed, everything about Yao Ce should have been Guo Wei's, but because of holding the wrong child, it caused the tragedy of Xu Min's family.

3. Xu Min and his wife are very sad in their old age.

The biological son himself did not spend a little effort to raise him, the relationship is not necessarily very deep, and the adopted son has also passed away, Xu Min and his wife are now empty, and the evening scene can be said to be very bleak.

To sum up, we can understand that although Du Xinzhi's family won the lawsuit in law, in terms of social feelings, people may be more sympathetic to Xu Min's family. I don't know what you think about this? Feel free to leave a comment below.

The property that Xu Min bought for his adopted son could not be returned in the end. Based on the course of the case, we can learn that Xu Min bought the property in Yao Ce's name after Yao Ce became an adult, and after the verdict of the case, Xu Min failed to get back the original property, and the house ultimately belonged to Yao Ce's daughter-in-law. On the other hand, Xu Min's own son Guo Xi imitated Hu Kuan's house, but it was not purchased in Guo Xikuan's name, which made many netizens feel that Xu Min's efforts were not worth it.

These uncertainties are, why the two children were held wrongly in the first place, whether such a thing was artificial, how Gao Shiran and the two were treated, whether the hospital had the responsibility to return to the state, and whether the hospital concealed this matter.

Everyone looks for their own mother, and the same should be true for real estate, and it is unfair to let others have nothing to rely on.

28 years of wrong life" case tomorrow**, I think the probability of reversal is very small.

1.It's been too long, it's hard to find evidence, it's hard to have a reversal;

2.Yao Ce has left us, and now it has become a grudge between two families, no evidence has been found before, and now it is even more difficult;

3.The case has a lot of attention, and I hope it can surprise us, and I hope it can be reversed.

There is really a lot of helplessness in life, many things are not as perfect as we imagined, Yao Ce has been away from us for more than a year, his case has not been closed, everyone is very psychologically complicated in the face of this kind of thing, as a parent, it really makes people feel sad and desperate. I think the probability of reversal is very small, the main reason is that China was relatively backward at that time, many things were not recorded, and it was really difficult to achieve a reversal in the absence of evidence.

First, it is difficult to find evidence after too long of time

28 years of wrong life" case Ming Cong Li suspicion day**, the attention is very high, I think this matter is too difficult to reverse, the main reason is that things have passed too long, it is too difficult to find evidence at this time, the conditions in China at that time are also relatively difficult, many things have not disturbed the chain There is a complete record, the court is talking about evidence, not human feelings, so from the perspective of evidence, I think it is more difficult to reverse.

Second, Yao Ce has left us, and now it has become a grudge between two families

Yao Ce's departure surprised everyone, and his departure also completely intensified the contradictions between the two families, without Yao Ce, and no one mediated in the middle, the relationship between the two families was completely broken.

3. I hope the court can give us a perfect answer

28 years of wrong life" case is very high, the court is also the focus of our attention, I hope the court can give us a reasonable explanation, a satisfactory answer, in the future, there will be a better solution.

Probably not, things have come to this point, and if there can be a reversal, it should have been reversed a long time ago, and it will not wait until now.

I think it's hard to reverse, and the evidence collected is all collected, and it's impossible for new evidence to emerge.

There will be a big reversal, that is, we can't accept that we are too old to check, and we hope that the two sides will settle out of court.

I think everything is not a foregone conclusion, everything is possible, and the facts speak for themselves.

28 years of wrong exchange, if it is not a stealing change, the most tragic is Du Ma.

The contradiction between the two parties in this matter is still in a lawsuit, due to the poor supervision of the hospital where Yao Ce was born, which has led to a huge change in his life, and it can be said that he was raised by his adoptive parents for 28 years of his life. According to him, he was not well protected against hepatitis B because he was born with the wrong hug, which also led to his current symptoms of liver cancer. Adding up the two, he and his biological parents went to the hospitalThe total amount of claims is $2.73 million.

But after this happenedThe negotiations between the two sides did not go as smoothly as expected。The person in charge of the Huaihe Hospital of Henan University did not attend the first trial between the two parties, or that the hospital was suspected of delaying time. But we can also understand that Yao Ce suffered from liver cancer, and his time cannot be delayed.

As a result of this, the hospital will now only make the patient's condition worse. Yao Ce himself also said that because he learned such a news during his serious illness, his mood has been very depressed, and then his ownThe condition is also gradually deteriorating

Lawyer Zhou Zhaocheng, who fought for Yao Ce, is very confident in winning the judgment in this case. He felt that the fault was entirely on this hospital, so he was confident that he would win the case. We also heard from Yao Ce himself that his illness was hopeless to put it bluntly, and he said that he was not even qualified for surgery, that is to sayThe time of his life can only face shorter and shorter results

And now the most uncontrollable thing in this case is time, because the hospital has not made any moves to actively solve the problem, it has been delaying, so we don't know, whether Yao Ce can win the case in the end, and it can even be said that Yao Ce's body can still hold on when he wins the case?

In the end, we look at this issue from a multifaceted perspective, that isIt doesn't turn out the way we think。Because the client could not prove that the fact that he was not vaccinated against hepatitis B at that time had any direct impact on his condition, and the causal relationship between these conditions was difficult to clarify, the outcome of the trial will have to wait for some time.

Huaihe Hospital of Henan University compensated Xu Min and Yao Shibing for mental damages, medical expenses, lost work expenses, transportation and accommodation expenses, appraisal fees and other expenses totaling yuan; Compensate Guo Zi Dongwei for mental damages of 200,000 yuan, reject Xu Min, Yao Shibing, and Guo Wei's other litigation claims against Huaihe Hospital of Henan University, and reject Xu Min and Yao Lishu's litigation claims against Du Xinzhi.