Who did Guan Yu lose to in Maicheng? Who killed Guan Yu when he defeated Maicheng?

It was Lu Meng who was more precisely defeated by himself.

In the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an, Guan Yu attacked Fancheng, and was flooded in the forbidden Seventh Army, and the military power was greatly boosted, and Cao Cao had proposed to move the capital to avoid its edge. In October of the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an (219), Jiangdong general Lü Meng took advantage of the confrontation between Guan Yu and Cao Ren, the defender of Fancheng, to attack Jingzhou and capture Guan Yu's base camp Jiangling. Guan Yu was attacked on both sides, and hurriedly withdrew his troops from Fancheng to the west and stationed in Maicheng.

Lü Meng adopted a strategy of division and disintegration, so that Guan Yu's soldiers had no intention of fighting and gradually dispersed. Guan Yu was isolated and helpless, and held on to Maicheng. Sun Quan sent someone to lure Guan Yu to surrender, Guan Yu pretended to surrender, set up a banner at the head of the city, pretending to be a sergeant, but he fled, only more than ten horsemen followed.

Sun Quan sent Zhu Ran and Pan Zhang to cut off Guan Yu's various ways, captured Guan Yu and his son Guan Ping in Linfu, and immediately executed them.

Above is a historical allusion.

It is said that when he was arrogant, he looked at no one and despised the place, so he was defeated, so he was defeated by himself.

Well, it's Lu Meng. Actually, I think it was Guan Yu who lost to himself. He won the battle because he basically fought the battle, and was later appreciated by Cao Cao, after Liu Bei got the land of Sichuan and Shu, he became the commander of the generals, Liu Bei has repeatedly won military exploits abroad, and he himself has not been able to get the opportunity to make meritorious contributions, so that he has been guarding Jingzhou is inevitably a little boring, plus he is proud of the enemy, confident that Dongwu will not dare to sneak attack his Jingzhou, so the commander of the army went out, and finally caused the abdomen to suffer from the enemy.

And Lu Meng himself was single-handedly promoted by Zhou Yu, and he was later influenced by Lu Su, so he was very good in both fighting and strategy, and it was inevitable to kill Guan Yu in the end.

was defeated by Lu Meng's scheme, and was caught by Ma Zhong and Pan Zhang in Maicheng.

After Guan Yu broke through from Maicheng, he was ambushed by Ma Zhong, the general of Pan Zhang's department, in Zhangxiang, the governor Zhao Lei was captured, and Guan Yu was killed together with his son Guan Ping.

When Guan Yu defeated Maicheng, it was Sun Quan who killed him. Guan Yu's army was defeated in Maicheng and captured by the Eastern Wu generals, Guan Yu refused to surrender, and Sun Quan was angry and killed him.

When Guan Yu defeated Maicheng, it was Lü Meng who killed him, and after breaking through, he was caught and killed by Lü Meng's ambush.

Lv Meng. Guan Yu once dreamed that he was bitten by a pig before he went on the expedition, and knew that he might not be able to come back, and he was finally beheaded in frustration.

Guan yu. In Maicheng, he was defeated by the Eastern Wu generals Pan Zhang, Zhu Ran and others.

The Battle of Maicheng was a battle in the late Eastern Han Dynasty, in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms

is depicted in thick ink. At that time, Guan Yu had already lost Jingzhou and suffered heavy losses. Only 300 people came to Maicheng (now Lianghe Town, Dangyang City, Yichang, Hubei). Guan Yu went far away to destroy Liu Bei in Sichuan (present-day Sichuan) in the west.

and Liu Fengye and Meng Da of Shangyong (now Zhushan County, Hubei) asked for help.

However, Liu Bei was far away in Xichuan, and the rescuers could not arrive in time, while Liu Feng and Meng Da did not save them when they saw death. Guan Yu had no choice but to break through, but was ambushed by the Eastern Wu generals Pan Zhang, Zhu Ran and others. Guan Yu was captured by Eastern Wu, and would rather die than give in, and was beheaded by Sun Quan.

The story of the Battle of Wheat City was later famous all over the world by the success or failure of Romance.

How did Guan Yu die? It was when Fancheng was not conquered, Jiangling behind it was attacked by Eastern Wu, and in the process of returning to the army, the army soldiers fled, Guan Yu and his son Guan Ping retreated to Linfang, and were killed after the defeat. There is no doubt about Guan Yu's death, but there does not seem to be a clear statement in historical sources about who killed Guan Yu.

In "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", it was the following people who led to Guan Yu's capture and killing: Lü Meng attacked Jiangling, Guan Yu's subordinates Mi Zhu and Fu Shiren surrendered to Eastern Wu, and Lü Meng was successful; Guan Yu withdrew his troops from Fancheng, most of the soldiers fled, so they had to temporarily leave Maicheng, Sun Quan ordered Pan Zhang and Zhu Ran to cut off Guan Yu's retreat, and Pan Zhang's subordinate Ma Zhong captured Guan Yu and sacrificed it to Sun Quan; Sun Quan wanted to recruit Guan Yu and let him defend against Liu Bei and Cao Cao. Some of his subordinates said that Cao Cao did not kill him back then, so that he left a big trouble, and even talked about moving the capital.

How can he be allowed to live now? Sun Quan then killed Guan Yu.

Guan Yu was defeated by Lu Meng's scheme in Maicheng, and was caught by Ma Zhong and Pan Zhang.

The reason for Guan Yu's defeat in Maicheng: Sun Quan took the initiative to ask Cao Cao to attack Guan Yu's rear. Lü Meng was once again ordered to attack Jingzhou, and the Jingzhou guards Elfang and Shiren surrendered without a fight, so that Guan Yu only knew that there was a change in the rear, and did not know that Jingzhou had easily fallen.

At the same time, Guan Yu and Xu Huang, who came to the rescue, lost the battle and lifted the encirclement of Fancheng and retreated south, but the naval army still controlled Hanshui. Guan Yu tried to peacefully resolve the dispute with his former ally Sun Quan, but the envoy's anti-service tour was used by Lü Meng to shake the heart of Guan Yu's army, and Guan Yu's army gradually disbanded, and had to retreat to Maicheng.