After Zhuge Liang s death, it was better to go on a Northern Expedition like Jiang Wei or Fei Yi s s

Updated on history 2024-04-09
37 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    In a sense, Jiang Wanfeiyi's strategy of recuperation and Jiang Wei's active attack strategy were both desirable at that point in time, the former rested with the people after Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition for many years, and the national strength was consumed hugely, and it was appropriate to re-accumulate national wealth, and the latter used the accumulated wealth to continue to implement Zhuge Liang's initiative after a break of about ten years, and it was also advisable to attack instead of defend the policy, and it should be said that both sides did the right thing in their own historical periods. The two are in different periods and have different national financial resources, so there is no conflict. However, none of them can change the path of Shu Han's eventual demise.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Fei Yi must wait until there is a change in the world, or a big change, so that Cao Wei will go out of the Northern Expedition in civil strife, Fei Yi's later once swallowed troops in Hanzhong shows that Fei Yi does not want the Northern Expedition at all, but he thinks that the Northern Expedition without favorable conditions is better than not the Northern Expedition. Zhuge Liang began with the policy of encroachment step by step, striving not to engage in a frontal field duel with the main force of the Wei army to obtain Cao Wei's land, and after turning the soldiers into elites in the later period, he tried to annihilate the main force of the Wei army's western front, and occupied the dangerous points before the Cao Wei ** army rescued the enemy, and refused the enemy outside Liangzhou. Jiang Wei began to collect information through the Northern Expedition, and look for fighters, if he can win, he will fight, and if he can't win, he will avoid it, and try to be small and big, after Fei Yi's death, although there are more troops dispatched, but there are also more domestic containments, he urgently needs the right to speak, so he can only use his military exploits to block the mouths of the anti-war faction, but some people are unhappy after cutting Xu and breaking the King Sutra, so it is not accidental that Hu Ji missed the deadline.

    And the Northern Expedition of 262 was another war of desperation.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Wei Yanhao If Wuzhang Yuan is replaced by Wei Yan, it will not be Jiang Wei who led 1,000 soldiers and horses to sing red songs, but 1,000 crossbowmen shot Sima Yi, who finally came out of the nest, into the second Zhang He.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Anyway, no matter what strategy is used, the outcome of the destruction of Shu cannot be changed, after all, there are many people in Shu and the land of a state, and Cao Weibi, who can catch a lot of civil and military all-rounders, is too far behind. But the policy of sweet ginger allowed Shu to live for an additional 40 years.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    It turns out that Jiang Wei is good, after all, he has persisted for more than 30 years.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    After the Battle of Xingshi, if Fei Yi hadn't stopped Jiang Wei from sending troops to the Northern Expedition, Shu Han would have had a good chance to take Yongzhou and Liangzhou.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Half of each, the Northern Expedition once in a few years.

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Stabilize the country first, and then go on the Northern Expedition.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Didn't the state of Wu also be destroyed, and the large-scale wars he launched were not frequent.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    If the end is destruction, why not bother.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    Why would anyone compare Wei Yan to Jiang Wei? Do you dare to compare their records?

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    There is still Wei Yan? Isn't it time for me to summon Han Shin.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    Jiang Wei is my favorite character in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. I like Jiang Wei for only one reason, because I believe that Jiang Wei in history is just like Jiang Wei in **. **It's not like history, it's not true, and the same is true for the Romance of the Three Kingdoms.

    But in my opinion, Jiang Wei in ** wrote Jiang Wei alive: flesh and blood, rich in emotion, and both long and short. So much so that people forget the difference between history and **.

    Jiang Wei is obviously different from Zhuge Liang in **. The Romance of the Three Kingdoms is a popular style that records the history of the late Eastern Han Dynasty with the Shu Kingdom as the center. If you want to say that it is different from Shu Zhi, I think it is just a few more ** plots.

    Zhuge Liang, as the core figure of Shu, has rightly become the focus of the book. This is a legendary figure, and is also regarded by later generations as the embodiment of wisdom; But it's so perfectly written that even the slightest thoughtful reader will clearly feel that it's fiction. Lin Daiyu still has strengths and weaknesses, shouldn't Zhuge Liang?

    It is true that Luo Guanzhong is difficult to match Cao Xueqin, which is why Dream of Red Mansions can be recognized as the first of the four famous novels. A character without flaws will never be a real character. Jiang Wei is different.

    He is flesh and blood, long and short. Personally, I think that the final demise of Shu has something to do with Jiang Wei. But if it weren't for Jiang Wei, maybe Shu would have perished.

    Return. Hu no return? Fate always likes to play jokes with people.

    Throughout the whole time, this character has been hovering, struggling, and suffering between loyalty and filial piety - loyalty and filial piety. Since ancient times, loyalty and filial piety have been difficult to achieve both, and Jiang Wei is the same. Jiang Wei was a filial son, and of course, filial sons in the Wei and Jin dynasties have always emerged in an endless stream - Li Mi's Chen Qing table came into being in this era.

    He is a standard filial son, but in the end he has to turn his back on this filial piety; He chose loyalty, regardless of the old mother's shouting in the hall, he still refused, just to repay the prime minister's kindness. No return. Mother please forgive the child.

    Loyalty and filial piety have been difficult to achieve since ancient times. Perhaps we take this for granted now. In fact, we can never look at the ancients through the eyes of today.

    Different times, different backgrounds, and different thinking compositions are naturally different. Maybe it's a stupid idea when you take things for granted. Let's ask how many people will be moved to tears of pain when they look at the table today, but can we say that we are not filial because of this? Adopt it.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    Wei Yan's interpersonal relations in Shu are not very good, and many people will not accept it if he hands over power. In addition to the so-called professional ability, the number one leader must also have a mass base.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    Wei Yan! If it is given to him, it means that Zhuge Liang trusts him. But he will not kill Jiang Wei, Ma Dai, Wang Ping, and the late Shu Han generals.

    And it is estimated that he is in his 50s at this time. He can remain in power for more than 20 years. And his bravery and resourcefulness are outstanding.

    According to the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, his intelligence will be regarded as a person of the Zhang Fei type) If the military power is handed over to him, Shu Han will have one more fierce general. This is more conducive to the Northern Expedition, so that I will not think about the future Liao Hua Chong Pioneer (I don't underestimate Liao Hua). Isn't it?

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    Wei Yan is okay as a general, but not handsome. Jiang Weitong's art of war, but unfortunately it was too weak, and the opponent was Sima Yi, so there was no way.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", after all, is **, and some of the plots are unreal. As for whether Wei Yan is anti-minded, it is unknown from "Romance of the Three Kingdoms". I heard from my classmates that it was Zhuge who didn't like Wei Yan, so Wei Yan was destroyed.

    No matter who it is, the key is to have a good monarch!!

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    Choosing an army leader in Shu at that time could not only look at military talent, but of course Jiang Wei was considered in all aspects.

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-20

    Wei Yan, Jiang Wei is a cup in history.

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-19

    Felt??? Zhuge Liang himself has no military talent, and he should give military power to others when he is in power.

  21. Anonymous users2024-01-18

    Wei Yan is talented, but his interpersonal relationship is not good.

    It's better to be forced to rebel and be killed, it's a pity.

  22. Anonymous users2024-01-17

    From a tactical point of view, this is undoubtedly wrong, it is a taboo for soldiers to go deep alone, the chance of victory is very small, and one carelessness will wipe out the whole army, or even lose the whole army. However, judging from the current situation and the specific events at that time, Zhuge Liang and Jiang Wei's long-term Northern Expedition was undoubtedly a last resort. From a strategic point of view, this is a choice that a strategist should make.

    At that time, the world was divided into three, Cao Wei lived in the north, coerced the Son of Heaven to order the princes, the most powerful, they were the most likely to unify the world, and Sun Wu had Jiangdong has gone through three generations, the country is dangerous and the people are rich, and they can attack and retreat. Shu Han is caught in it, and the power is undoubtedly the weakest, and when it is unlawful, the 5 tiger generals have also gone to their 4If you slack off a little and show weakness, you are likely to become a fish under the knife.

    The first was wiped out. And that's exactly what happened. Zhuge Liang could only choose to attack and defend with the stool at this time.

    I have no choice but to do it, and the so-called attack still has a glimmer of life. If you don't attack, you can only die. Some people say that Zhuge Liang is bent on doing it.

    Cut off Shu Han in advance,Such a statement is unfair. Combining the above reasons.

    There is also the weight of the first emperor's excuse, Zhuge Liang can't guard Sichuan and sit still. When Longzhong was right, Zhuge Liang said yes"Three-legged, waiting for the world to change,"It's a pity that Liu Bei went first, and Zhuge Liang couldn't afford to wait. There has been no dramatic change in the world.

    Zhuge Liang was even more helpless. The so-called Han Gaozu Liu Bang achieved the imperial industry because of Sichuan, and it was also because of the changes in the world at the end of the Qin Dynasty and the time of heaven. So in the words of Mr. Mirror Water, it is:

    Although Zhuge Kongming met his master, it was not the right time to dig potatoes, which was sad and pathetic. "

  23. Anonymous users2024-01-16

    Wrong, that's three points of the world, and the second Shu Han is the weakest, why hit the stone with an egg? What's more, the road to Shu is difficult, and the gains outweigh the losses when they travel thousands of miles to attack Wei.

  24. Anonymous users2024-01-15

    Yes, a weak country should try to be strong, and the best defense is to attack.

  25. Anonymous users2024-01-14

    Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition was actually a loss of money and was doomed to failure, while Jiang Wei was a heavy peasant Qing soldier, who did not intend to be developed militarily, and was inferior to Sima Yi in terms of strategy, so he was doomed to failure.

  26. Anonymous users2024-01-13

    Zhuge Liang was at odds with Wei Yan.

    Jiang Wei is because Sima Yi is old and spicy, and Sima Yi's city mansion is deeper than Zhuge Liang.

  27. Anonymous users2024-01-12

    I remember that some time ago, there was a post saying that Jiang Wei had 11 Northern Expeditions, and many bar friends quoted this number. However, the younger brother only found 8 times in "The Biography of Jiang Wei", and found 1 time in other legends, a total of nine times, and the statement of romance is reliable.

  28. Anonymous users2024-01-11

    Zhuge Liang went out of Qishan six times, and Jiang Wei attacked the Central Plains nine times.

  29. Anonymous users2024-01-10

    3 times, the third time the Shu Kingdom was completely destroyed.

  30. Anonymous users2024-01-09

    Zhuge Liang went out of Qishan six times, and Jiang Wei attacked the Central Plains nine times.

  31. Anonymous users2024-01-08

    In the twelfth year of Jianxing (234), Zhuge Liang died in Wuzhangyuan after "dying before leaving the division", Liu Chan, the queen of Shu, added Jiang Wei to the right supervising army and the general of the auxiliary Han Dynasty, commanded the armies, and entered the Pingxiang Marquis. Subsequently, he successively served as Sima, General Zhenxi, and concurrently served as Liangzhou Assassin Shi, General Wei, and General, and was awarded Fu Jie by the imperial court. According to the Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms, between 238 and 262 AD, Jiang Wei carried out a total of 11 Northern Expeditions.

    First, in the first year of the Later Lord Yanxi (238), Jiang Wei and Jiang Wan led their divisions out of Longyou, and they were unable to hold on to the Wei army in Nan'an.

    Second, in the seventh year of Yanxi (244), Jiang Wei and Fei Yi sent troops to assist Wang Pingxing, the governor of Hanzhong, to build a strong position with the Shu army in Hanzhong, and Cao Shuang was defeated.

    Third, in the tenth year of Yanxi (247), he went out of Longxi and fought with Wei generals Guo Huai and Xiahou Ba against Taoxi.

    Fourth, in the twelfth year of Yanxi (249), Jiang Wei sent Liao Hua to Taocheng, at this time it was already "no general in Shu, Liao Hua became a pioneer", Jiang Wei fought with many generals of Wei alone, and the two sides won and lost each other.

    Fifth, in the thirteenth year of Yanxi (250), Jiang Wei was supplemented by Qianghu and fought with Guo Huai in Taoxi, and the two sides were tied.

    Sixth, after Fei Yi was assassinated and killed in the sixteenth year of Yanxi (253), Jiang Wei sent troops to surround Nan'an, and retreated after running out of food.

    Seventh, in the seventeenth year of Yanxi (254), he went out of Longxi Di Dao and beheaded Wei general Xu Qian.

    Eighth, in the eighteenth year of Yanxi (255 years), he and Xiahou Ba went out of Di Dao, broke the king through Taoxi, Wang Jing retreated to Di Dao City, and Chen Tai sent troops to relieve the siege.

    Nine, in 256, Jiang Wei sent troops again, and the Shu general Hu Ji did not arrive at the deadline, and was broken in Duangu for Deng Ai, with heavy casualties.

    Ten, in 257, taking advantage of the Wei general Zhuge Festival rebellion, Jiang Wei sent troops to Qinchuan, and the Wei army held on without fighting, and in the first year of Yong'an (258), Zhuge was defeated and began to retreat.

    Eleventh, in the fifth year of Jingyao (262), Jiang Wei sent troops again, fought with Deng Ai in Houhe, was broken by Deng Ai, and lived in the middle of the river.

    Jiang Wei's previous Northern Expedition achievements have won and lost each other, and the army has reached Huayin and Pucheng. Two of them were big wins; three small wins; Tie four times; One big defeat, one small defeat. Over the years, historians have depreciated Jiang Wei's Northern Expedition and praised it too much, and he fought for many years, which consumed a huge amount of national strength.

    During the last Northern Expedition, Liao Hua persuaded Jiang Wei to rest and reorganize the army, believing that "the army and the people are restless after years of expeditions, and Wei has Deng Ai, resourceful, and not an idle person", and suggested not to "force yourself to do difficult things".

  32. Anonymous users2024-01-07

    Although Jiang Wei is a descendant of Zhuge Liang, he is subject to Fei Wei's nine expeditions to the Central Plains, and he will give a maximum of 10,000 or 20,000 troops each time. To no avail at all.

  33. Anonymous users2024-01-06

    It depends on the reasons for the demise of the Three Kingdoms. The rulers of the three kingdoms were all "meritocracy", which violated the interests of the scholar class, and it was only because the three founders at that time were brilliant and strategic that these scholars were temporarily suppressed. I think that politically, Jiang Wei should reuse the "Shaozhuang faction", and at the same time, he can use the "scholar faction" in an appropriate amount to increase the sense of belonging of the scholar clan, and influence Adou in this way.

    As for the military situation, Jiang Wei of Shu at that time should not let the Wei army pass through Hanzhong, and strive to "keep the enemy outside the country". Zhuge Liang's train of thought obviously doesn't work, so why not try Wei Yan's "Meridian Valley Surprise Attack".

  34. Anonymous users2024-01-05

    Jiang Wei is good for offense and defense, but it is not advisable to consume national strength due to the fatigue of the saddle horse; Even Wu to resist Wei is an expedient measure, unite with the southwest and assimilate it, you can report to Shuchuan, and it is not too late to wait for the drastic changes in the Central Plains, but unfortunately I didn't live at that time.

  35. Anonymous users2024-01-04

    Jiang Wei is actually quite powerful, Zhuge Liang Pang Tong, Jiang Wei, Sima Yi and the four of them are called Wolong and Phoenix Chicks and Young Qizuka Tiger.

  36. Anonymous users2024-01-03

    Jiang Wei still stopped. It's because of Liu Adou.

  37. Anonymous users2024-01-02

    The edifice will fall Jiang Wei has done his best.

Related questions
20 answers2024-04-09

After Zhuge Liang's death, Shu also had to go through a period of pain, and some bulls, ghosts, snakes, and gods took the opportunity to jump out, so Jiang Wei needed to deal with the internal problems of Shu, so that he could rest assured of the Northern Expedition.

8 answers2024-04-09

Zhuge Liang should be Sima Yi's lifelong enemy, but in fact they are also real confidants, and they are all excellent. They are also very similar in many ways. Sima Yi has been in a weak position in the years of confrontation, because Sima Yi cannot compete with Zhuge Liang in terms of military ability. >>>More

4 answers2024-04-09

Mr. Hina Pang Tong died on the road to Xichuan, and it is said that the name of that place was Luofengpo. In other words, his death was planned by God a long time ago. At the time of the crime, Mr. Pang was riding Liu Bei's mount. >>>More

13 answers2024-04-09

Because Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition plan and strategy were seen through by Jiang Wei, Zhuge Liang felt that he was a manufacturable material, so he cultivated him.

17 answers2024-04-09

Speaking of the general trend of the world, it will be together for a long time, and it will be divided for a long time. "From the unification of the Seven Kingdoms by the Qin Dynasty, to the struggle between Chu and Han at the end of Qin, and then to the end of the Han Dynasty. And "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" uses vivid images to tell the history of the Three Kingdoms Wei, Shu and Wu in this period. >>>More