Did Song Zhiwen really kill Liu Xiyi in order to get Generational Sorrow Pulsatilla ?

Well, it's true, and that's been documented in history. It was indeed for an ancient poem that my uncle killed his nephew. This may seem a little incomprehensible to us, but if you want to change the dynasty, you can find that there is a certain reason why he did this.

In the Tang Dynasty or in ancient times, what scholars wanted was not fame and being an official.

At that time, Song Zhiwen was a petty official, but he didn't get the work he sold, so he happened to see his nephew make this ancient poem, and he thought if I could take this poem for myself. So he invited Liu Xiyi to his home, and he asked Liu Xiyi. He said, isn't it a waste of your great talent to be such a good writer but not to be an official?

If you don't want to go, how about you give this to your uncle?

Liu Xiyi is an authentic poet, he disdains this kind of behavior, and he categorically rejected his uncle Song Zhiwen's proposal without even thinking about it. And also despised it. At this time, Song Zhiwen's face couldn't be stopped.

He thought that I was your uncle, and that you dared to talk to me like this, and his poor pride was greatly affected by typhoid fever. He was in a state of annoyance. So he ordered his disciples to trick his nephew Liu Xiyi to a place, and then stoned him to death.

It's a pity that Liu Xiyi, who became famous at a young age, died in an unknown place, just because of a poem, which is unimaginable. Song Zhiwen This kind of person is extremely spurned by us. I didn't expect Song Zhiwen to be so frustrated, nor did I think of the ancients' pursuit and desire for fame, which is actually sad, abandoning your relatives for the so-called fame, even if you get everything, what's the point?

This kind of thing generally has two sides, because Song Zhiwen's identity as a writer will indeed covet better works, but accordingly, he will also cherish his feathers more.

I think he will, because his character is not a person who particularly relies on family affection, and he can't get what he wants, so he can only be a killer.

There should be something else hidden, not what we see on the surface, as for the real situation, we don't know.

Yes, Song Zhiwen was a famous poet at that time, and his nephew was still an unknown person, Song Zhiwen saw that this poem was written very well, just like he wrote it, and wanted to include it in his own name, and later his nephew Liu Xiyi regretted giving it to his uncle a little, and wanted to get it back, so he was killed!

It is possible, after all, everyone wants to be famous, and then in order to become famous, he killed his nephew to win this poem, so that the literati revered him even more.

It should be, he took a fancy to this poem, because it will definitely be passed down through the ages, and there is every reason to do it for the sake of his own reputation, but it is too inhumane for him to do so.

The authors of the historical records of the Pulsatilla are not the same, one is Song Zhiwen, and the other is Liu Xiyi, Song Zhiwen's reputation is not good, and it is not impossible to be blamed.

This is possible, after all, human greed is infinite, and sometimes it is not impossible to kill him in order to satisfy his greed.

It is very likely that he wanted to get this work and become famous, and killed the author for such selfishness.

It is very likely that some people will have a lot of evil intentions in order to be famous and for status and power.

The flowers are similar every year, and the people are different every year", but the author of such a beautiful poem was killed by his uncle!

There is such a small answer to the story: "Why did Song Zhiwen kill Liu Xiyi".

In the Tang Dynasty, a very famous poet named Song Zhiwen had a nephew named Liu Xiyi, who was also very talented.

One day, Liu Xiyi wrote a poem "Dai Baitou Yin", and asked his uncle Song Zhi for guidance, when Liu Xiyi recited it:

The ancients did not recover Luoyangdong, and today's people are still facing the falling flowers.

Song Zhi asked again: "In your poem, the flowers are similar every year, and the people are different every year, which is really lovely, if others have not seen it, you can let me do it!" ”

After Liu Xiyi heard this, he was puzzled and said casually: "These two sentences are the eyes of my poem, if you go to them, they will be completely tasteless, and you must not do it." ”

Song Zhiwen was very angry after hearing this.

That night, Song Ziwen couldn't fall asleep after tossing and turning, reciting these two lines of poetry repeatedly, and thought that this poem would be a swan song for the ages in the future, and it would be famous all over the world. Thinking about it, he thought that he must take it for himself, so he had bad intentions and ordered his subordinates to kill Liu Xiyi.

Later, Song Zhiwen was convicted and exiled to Qinzhou, and then ordered by the emperor to commit suicide, leaving behind a notorious reputation. As Liu Yuxi said: "Song Zhiwen should be damned, this is the retribution of heaven." ”

When the story was over, he told us:

1. Life insights.

1. Fame cannot be greater than talent.

A person's reputation should not be greater than his own strength, once his reputation is greater than his strength, it is not worthy of his name, deceiving the world, and there will be disasters;

2. Wealth cannot be greater than merit.

A person's wealth should not be greater than his own merits, once his wealth is greater than his own merits, he is opportunistic, that is, he gets something for nothing, and opportunism will invite disaster.

3. A person's life is in a vanity fair, and the society is not enough to move forward without interests, and if there is too much desire, it will hurt itself! The key here is: a gentleman loves money and takes it in a proper way; How can those who get rich first help those who are not rich to become prosperous together?

2. Wisdom practice.

1, Song Zhiwen was originally a successful person, but he was not greedy enough to swallow elephants. Therefore, people should be temperate and self-sufficient, and their expectations should not be too high. Otherwise, it will end up with a tragic end of laughter and generosity;

2. Everyone wants to pursue utilitarianism! Objectively speaking, it is not a bad thing, in the face of utilitarianism, the pursuit of profit cannot tarnish one's reputation, and seeking merit is sometimes too much;

3. Life pays attention to both ability and political integrity, in order to rise high and go far. If you have a low education, you can study hard, but if you lack virtue, it will be fatal. Roosevelt once said:

Learned but immoral, like a wicked man; Moral and unlearned, like a contemptuous husband. "So try to have both ability and integrity!

Do you like that? Please leave your valuable comments.

Most later generations believed that Song Zhiwen killed his nephew Liu Xiyi.

Since ancient times, "literati have been light". People who study academics and read poetry often have a little bit of frivolity and narcissism in their hearts, which is easy to cause conflicts when interacting with others.

Historically, two scholars who don't like each other ignore each other when they meet, and there are those who scold when they open their mouths, and they kill people because of a poem, and the person who is killed is still their nephew, I'm afraid that there will be no second person except Song Zhiwen.

The poets Liu Xiyi and Song Zhiwen both included the same poem "Generations of Sorrowful Pulsatilla", which contains two catchy sentences: the flowers are similar every year, and the people are different every year.

Historical records: Uncle Song Zhi asked bitter love after a couplet, knowing that it had not been passed on to others, begging for it, but he did not agree. The question was angry with him, so that the slave was crushed and killed in the other house with a soil bag, and before he was thirty, people took pity on him.

It turned out that after Song Zhiwen saw the poem written by his nephew Liu Xiyi, he was full of praise, and before it was announced, he wanted to take it for himself, Liu Xiyi said that it was difficult to cut love, Song Zhiwen was annoyed and ashamed, and crushed his nephew to death with a dirt bag, poor Liu Xiyi was not yet 30 years old when he died.

Most people in later generations think that Song Zhiwen died his nephew Liu Xiyi.

Song Zhi, a great poet in the early Tang Dynasty, asked, with only one sentence, "I am more timid about my hometown, and I dare not ask the person who came", which made many passers-by who returned to their hometown burst into tears. However, due to the vague records of historical materials, Song Zhiwen was suspected of killing his nephew Liu Xiyi, so as a typical object of criticism of literati jealousy, he was marked with a striking steel seal of "despicable villain" and has been tied to the black stake of literary history.

Mr. Li Guowen said in the essay "The Jealousy of Poets - Looking at an Unsolved Case in the History of Literature" that when Song Zhiwen saw his nephew Liu Xiyi's poem "Generations of Sorrowful Pulsatilla", he was jealous and wanted to take it as he already had, but Liu Xiyi refused, so Song Zhiwen killed him. The direct evidence of this incident comes from "All Tang Poems" and "The Biography of Tang Caizi".

In "All Tang Poems", Song Zhiwen's "Thoughtful" and Liu Xiyi's "Generations of Sorrowful Pulsatilla" are only one sentence different, to be precise, there are only three words different, Song poems are "the daughter of the boudoir cherishes the color", and Liu poem is "the daughter of Luoyang has a good color".

In fact, under strict research, in fact, the possibility is not great.

1. Song Zhiwen was born in the first year of Emperor Gaozong of the Tang Dynasty (656), and Liu Xiyi (about 651), that is, Liu was a few years older than Song.

2, Song Zhiwen is a person with a halo from his background, who has been smart and studious since he was a child. The poems written by Song Zhiwen are no worse than Liu's. Song Quan ascended to the position by virtue of his own ability, and he didn't need to grab other people's poems at all.

His tomb. In the Fengxue Temple in Ruzhou City, Henan.